AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Flat Panel General & New FP Tech › 46" screen for PC and movies
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

46" screen for PC and movies

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I'm planning on getting a 46" TV in the $2000 range around mid-Semptember.

I currently have my desk with 3x 20" LCDs and a 32" 720p LCD TV next to the desk. I want to eventually get rid of the monitors, get rid of the desk, and just have two 46" TVs. I'll sit about 6 feet from the screen. Initially I'll just have the 46" screen and the the 32" screen, but eventually I'll get a matching 46".

Half the time both screens will be for the PC, but half the time one of the screens will have TV or a movie on it.

I was thinking the Samsung LN46A650 would probably be the way to go. My thinking is that:

- it's new enough that I'll probably be able to find a matching one pretty easily early next year
- the 120hz display will probably look better for a PC, and 5:5 pulldown is nice
- I'm partly colorblind and I'd prefer a sharper picture to more natural colors
- the power consumption of a plasma could actually be an issue when you've got two every evening

But I was also looking at the 480hz Panazonic 50PZ80U, because I could get a 50" plasma for the same price as the 46" LCD, and probably squeeze two of them in the room (the width of two 50" screens is pushing it, though).

My concern with the LCD is the viewing angle mostly. Sitting directly in front of one screen at 6' away, that puts you at a 31-degree viewing angle from the other one. I have a TV stand that pivots, and I would probably have both screens facing my chair most of the time, but still, this is a setup where I'd want both screens to look decent from up to a 35-degree angle.

But using plasma for a computer screen seems pretty ridiculous, because I would think no matter what TV you have, eventually the Windows task bar is going to burn in.

Just seeing if anyone had any insight for me. Thanks!
post #2 of 4
In my personal opinion, I think you should start investigating once you are reasy to buy. Prices will have changed substantially in that period of time, and may open new doors.

One thing I will say, don't be deterred from plasmas because of burn in. I can assure you that there is no such thing if the set has been properly broken in, and the orbiter is running. That being said, I am not saying that you should choose plasma, but don't shut the door on either technology, keep an open mind.
post #3 of 4
Thread Starter 
Currently those panels are a bit over $2000, and in three months they'll probably be closer to the $1500 to $1600 range you're seeing other ones that size, but I doubt anything's going to change drastically.

Not that I'm terrified of burn-in, but I don't think an orbiter is going to prevent the 34-pixel tall Windows taskbar from burning in eventually.

I forgot to mention that the room is usually pretty dark, and the screen will probably be up high enough that you'd often be at eye level with the bottom edge of it. I'm just thinking the viewing angle concerns aren't enough to outweigh the downsides of plasma.
post #4 of 4
You know, everyone constantly insists that burn-in is no longer an issue, but they always add something to it like the person who responded, like so.

"Oh burn-in? Oh that's no longer an issue.......of COURSE as long as you are doing this that and the other"....

To me, buying a plasma for a computer set is not even a choice. There are too many static things on a computer, and I might want to leave my computer on for half a day, I don't want to forget I left it on and have a plasma with a static image burned into it. I also don't feel like running programs to get rid of IR, and i don't want to have to deal with IR. FURTHERMORE, if you do get burn-in, plasma display warranties don't cover it.

I think your better off with the LCD's. Why not just figure out where you are going to sit, and adjust the LCD's so they are all positioned in a way that you don't have to look at the LCD off-axis.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Flat Panel General & New FP Tech › 46" screen for PC and movies