Quote:
Originally Posted by ccotenj 
@jimmy...
in a proper test, I think it's highly unlikely that you could differentiate the 2 units..,
the only "performance advantage" the sc has is the amplification section... and since the great majority of users don't require nearly as much power as they think they do, you need to decide if you need it.
imnsho, buying a sc and adding an external amp to it is of questionable:
- benefit
- value for dollar
|
I would tend to disagree with that as a general statement
while the majority of users..as you say don't require nearly as much power as they think they do..if that is the case then I agree
But to those others...that I guess are not in the majority..an external amp can make all the difference in the world
I just demoed 4 different receivers with a set of Vienna acoustics speakers....4ohm and very difficult to drive
Denon 4310, Yamaha Z7, Onkyo 875 and a Pioneer VSX47TX(a $225 E bay purchase)
driving those speakers I liked them in that order....which also happens to be their ranking lowest to highest in actual bench test power ratings
It was very clear that the Denon and the Yamaha sounded harsh at sound levels that the Onkyo and the Pioneer, to a greater extent, did very well
Even with its lack of HDMI..the old Pioneer elite shined
I also ran the same test with a Parasound preamp( 7100) and an old Harman Kardon amp I had stored as well....again....a huge difference in dynamics and ability to play at reference levels without any audible harshness
I didn't run the same test with my SC07...as it would have been a lot of work to remove and replace it in the cabinet that it is in...but I have a feeling it would have performed at about the same level as the Yamaha Z7
On another note..the weight of the receivers was also in the same order as my preference to their sounds with the Vienna's
Warren