AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Blu-ray Software › Red Box
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Red Box - Page 3

post #61 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

just sharing my obsevations which have been corroborated by some other members.

But you see - you weren't "just" sharing your observations, you were concocting (and sharing over multiple threads) ridiculous (and more than a little idiotic) theories like "seems like their {Redbox} buying their brs from the chinese counterfeit market." You also keep repeating nonsense like Redbox is using overly-compressed discs that no other rental or retail chain is using, despite having no evidence.

All of this, while knowing full well that your firmware on your BD player hadn't been updated in 2.5 years...

Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

doesn't explain why dragon tattoo and ghost protocol were below average transfers.

Where are all of the other posters who rented these titles from Redbox and are dissatisfied with the quality? Why aren't there others up in arms over this if it's really as you say?

The fact that you're the only one reporting that their Redbox rentals of those titles contained "below average transfers" strongly suggests that the problem is on your end (or that you were watching DVD copies of the films.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

i'm with netflix now and no issues so don't think its my equipment.

Are you claiming that you've compared Netflix copies of the titles in question with the Redbox discs and the issues have disappeared? Including the title that wouldn't play at all? I find that extremely hard to believe, in no small part because your credibility when it comes to properly troubleshooting appears to be severely lacking.

The fact that you didn't even consider that your woefully outdated firmware could be the culprit, even after having multiple copies of the same title all pop up as unreadable, is enough to suggest you should probably ask more questions and jump to far fewer conclusions in the future...
post #62 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by Steeb View Post

But you see - you weren't "just" sharing your observations, you were concocting (and sharing over multiple threads) ridiculous (and more than a little idiotic) theories like "seems like their {Redbox} buying their brs from the chinese counterfeit market." You also keep repeating nonsense like Redbox is using overly-compressed discs that no other rental or retail chain is using, despite having no evidence.

All of this, while knowing full well that your firmware on your BD player hadn't been updated in 2.5 years...


Where are all of the other posters who rented these titles from Redbox and are dissatisfied with the quality? Why aren't there others up in arms over this if it's really as you say?

The fact that you're the only one reporting that their Redbox rentals of those titles contained "below average transfers" strongly suggests that the problem is on your end (or that you were watching DVD copies of the films.)

Are you claiming that you've compared Netflix copies of the titles in question with the Redbox discs and the issues have disappeared? Including the title that wouldn't play at all? I find that extremely hard to believe, in no small part because your credibility when it comes to properly troubleshooting appears to be severely lacking.

The fact that you didn't even consider that your woefully outdated firmware could be the culprit, even after having multiple copies of the same title all pop up as unreadable, is enough to suggest you should probably ask more questions and jump to far fewer conclusions in the future...


don't want to get in a flaming war. i agree firmware update was the issue with tinker tailor. there are apparentely some flawed copies of ghost protocol out there. read that thread. not just from redbox but some who have bought it and some rented from bb. so not just a redbox issue.

and yeah when i re-rented ghost protocol and dragon tattoo from netflix i did
not observe the issues i had with the redbox rentals. so i chose to use a different vendor who so far has provided me with copies that are better than the ones i got from redbox. i speculated that maybe redbox uses knockoffs, but i certainly didn't say it as fact.

each person here can choose whatever source they want. redbox disappointed me, bb service is terrible, so now i'm with nf and happy so far with the bd rentals i've gotten from them.

also check out post 56 on this thread which indicates issues with another title rented from rb.

if your happy with rb, good for yo
post #63 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

if your happy with rb, good for yo

It's not about a preference for one rental company over another. It's about separating facts from inane, baseless conjecture. It's not your observations that I have a problem with, it's the ridiculous, illogical conclusions that you immediately jump to (and then repeat as if they're facts.)

As long as you continue to post BS claims like the one about Redbox renting bootleg discs from China, expect to be called on it.
post #64 of 120
Try some more. The strawberries taste like strawberries, and the snozzberries taste like snozzberries.

Which makes about as much sense as anything ..
post #65 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

Try some more. The strawberries taste like strawberries, and the snozzberries taste like snozzberries.

Which makes about as much sense as anything ..

That line always makes me think of the opening scene from Super Troopers. No matter how many times I watch that movie, I always laugh when that kid says that...
post #66 of 120
After a half dozen rentals, I had my first Redbox issue. I put Haywire on hold on Tuesday, but the machine was locked up that night when I went to pick it up. I called up the 800 number on the kiosk and they guy apologized and sent me 3 promo codes. I asked him about the hold, and he said that I would get billed the next day at 9pm, but that is why he was giving me the promo codes.

So, the next day I went to the same kiosk and it was working again, so I picked up my hold, watched it, and returned it just before 9pm, so I was able to use the original hold, and I suppose I shouldn't feel guilty about the promo code since I had to make more trips that planned and wasn't able to watch the movie on Tuesday.

But, overall, I'm pretty thrilled with Redbox. What is funny is that with Blockbuster Online or Netflix, I would turn around so many movies, that I would watch almost anything that was released on blu-ray. Now that I have to pay $1.50 for the rental, I have a slightly higher quality cut-off and make decision not to rent some of the titles that Redbox is stocking.

I am disappointed that Redbox will not stock the blu-ray version of an occasional mid-major release. I usually have my filter on Blu-ray only, but once in a while I'll select DVD and Blu-ray and notice the missing titles (Dangerous Method, Martha Marcy..., Carnage, My Week with Marilyn, J Edgar, etc).
post #67 of 120
Yeah, the BD selection is not the greatest, but until the general populace adopts it as the de facto standard, it is what it is ..

This whole bit from mr. wally about PQ differences and what not just makes no sense to me ..
post #68 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

Yeah, the BD selection is not the greatest, but until the general populace adopts it as the de facto standard, it is what it is ..

This whole bit from mr. wally about PQ differences and what not just makes no sense to me ..

UNLESS...MAYBE there are certain titles on Blu-ray that are now signaling the players to output lower resolution signals over the HD analog outputs????

I doubt it, since I have not heard of them doing that yet. However that could be a possible reason.
post #69 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

UNLESS...MAYBE there are certain titles on Blu-ray that are now signaling the players to output lower resolution signals over the HD analog outputs????

I doubt it, since I have not heard of them doing that yet. However that could be a possible reason.

What earthly reason would there be for that .. ??
post #70 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

What earthly reason would there be for that .. ??

Because it's part of the Blu-ray standards designed for copywrite protection. The studios can implement it anytime they want. So far they haven't (as far as I know.) If (and when) they do implement it, it will only effect older HDTVs without HDMI (digital) connections.
post #71 of 120
As promised. Lets try this again.


http://www.dailyfinance.com/2013/02/08/coinstar-profit-drops-redbox-earning-stocks/


Any thoughts are welcome.



Ian
post #72 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mailiang View Post

As promised. Lets try this again.


http://www.dailyfinance.com/2013/02/08/coinstar-profit-drops-redbox-earning-stocks/


Any thoughts are welcome.



Ian

That'll teach 'em to try and sell coffee at a kiosk .. biggrin.gif

Seriously though, the numbers really don't look that bad ..
post #73 of 120
glad to see the kiosk biz is profitable.

given bb's floundering and nf's disinterest in rentals, vis a vis, streaming,
redbox is pretty much the primary source for my bd rentals.
post #74 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

glad to see the kiosk biz is profitable.

given bb's floundering and nf's disinterest in rentals, vis a vis, streaming,
redbox is pretty much the primary source for my bd rentals.


So that's why I'm getting all these new BD releases from Netflix. Everybody's going to Redbox and jumping ship!



Bye Bye!



Ian biggrin.gif
post #75 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mailiang View Post

So that's why I'm getting all these new BD releases from Netflix. Everybody's going to Redbox and jumping ship!

Could very well be. Netflix only has themselves to blame!


Redbox Market Share Hits 45%; Kiosks to Hold More Discs

Quote:
Redbox ended 2012 with a 45.3% share of the physical disc rental market, up 7.5 points from the fourth quarter of 2011 and nearly double the market share of online and by-mail disc providers.

Blu-ray accounted for 12.5% of Redbox revenue for the fourth quarter (ended Dec. 31) of 2012, nearly double the Blu-ray revenue from Q4 2011. For both Disney’s The Avengers and Sony’s The Amazing Spider-Man, more than 20% of kiosk rentals were Blu-ray, the company reported. Warner’s Dark Shadows and Disney’s Brave saw Blu-ray rentals at more than 18%.

“We are uniquely positioned to take advantage of the increased acceptance of Blu-ray given our value price point and marketing assets, which we plan to further leverage to help consumers discover and explore the format,” Davis said.
post #76 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mailiang View Post

As promised. Lets try this again.


http://www.dailyfinance.com/2013/02/08/coinstar-profit-drops-redbox-earning-stocks/


Any thoughts are welcome.



Ian

It seems to me they took a hit only because of the other things they invested in.
post #77 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

It seems to me they took a hit only because of the other things they invested in.

That is correct
Quote:
Coinstar made the announcements while reporting fourth-quarter and full-year 2012 results. The company posted a profit of $22.9 million for the fourth quarter of 2012 a drop of more than 27% from the same quarter in 2011 ($31.5 million).

The drop came despite an 8.4% jump in revenue year-over-year ($564 million vs. $520 million). Coinstar said the drop in profit was due to operating results from kiosks acquired as part of its $100 million acquisition of NCR Corp.’s entertainment division, which included 10,000 kiosks previously operating under the Blockbuster Express brand.

In the fourth quarter Coinstar replaced 500 NCR kiosks with Redbox kiosks, and removed an additional 800 NCR kiosks outright. Since the acquisition, Coinstar has replaced 2,700 NCR kiosks and removed 1,600 others. Coinstar expects to complete the replacement and removal of NCR kiosks by May.

Coinstar also announced that many Redbox kiosks will increase disc capacity by more than 80 discs in 2013. New kiosks in the second half of 2012 were manufactured with the increased capacity, and “a significant percentage” of existing kiosks will be upgraded in 2013.

Redbox revenue for the fourth quarter grew 9.6% to $488.3 million, and during the fourth quarter, Redbox same-kiosk rentals were up approximately 6% year-over-year. There were a total of 188 million rentals during the quarter, compared with 174.8 million rentals during the fourth quarter of 2011. Video games accounted for 3% of rentals and nearly 7% of revenue for the quarter.
post #78 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wendell R. Breland View Post

Could very well be. Netflix only has themselves to blame!


Redbox Market Share Hits 45%; Kiosks to Hold More Discs
Quote:
Coinstar made the announcements while reporting fourth-quarter and full-year 2012 results. The company posted a profit of $22.9 million for the fourth quarter of 2012 a drop of more than 27% from the same quarter in 2011 ($31.5 million).

The drop came despite an 8.4% jump in revenue year-over-year ($564 million vs. $520 million). Coinstar said the drop in profit was due to operating results from kiosks acquired as part of its $100 million acquisition of NCR Corp.’s entertainment division, which included 10,000 kiosks previously operating under the Blockbuster Express brand.

In the fourth quarter Coinstar replaced 500 NCR kiosks with Redbox kiosks, and removed an additional 800 NCR kiosks outright. Since the acquisition, Coinstar has replaced 2,700 NCR kiosks and removed 1,600 others. Coinstar expects to complete the replacement and removal of NCR kiosks by May.

Coinstar also announced that many Redbox kiosks will increase disc capacity by more than 80 discs in 2013. New kiosks in the second half of 2012 were manufactured with the increased capacity, and “a significant percentage” of existing kiosks will be upgraded in 2013.

Redbox revenue for the fourth quarter grew 9.6% to $488.3 million, and during the fourth quarter, Redbox same-kiosk rentals were up approximately 6% year-over-year. There were a total of 188 million rentals during the quarter, compared with 174.8 million rentals during the fourth quarter of 2011. Video games accounted for 3% of rentals and nearly 7% of revenue for the quarter.




The biggest problem I have with Red Box, at least in my area, is that there aren't enough titles in BD. At this point I have no issues getting rentals from Netflix, and it's convenient. So for now, at least for me, sticking with their service is a fete de compli.




Ian
Edited by mailiang - 2/9/13 at 3:20pm
post #79 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wendell R. Breland View Post

Could very well be. Netflix only has themselves to blame!
Same for Blockbuster.
post #80 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by rezzy View Post

Same for Blockbuster.


Netflix isn't close to having the issues that BB has. If you keep on top of your Que and do returns by Monday, in most cases you're good to go when it comes to getting a new release. With BB it's turned into a crap shoot these days.


Ian
post #81 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mailiang View Post

Netflix isn't close to having the issues that BB has. If you keep on top of your Que and do returns by Monday, in most cases you're good to go when it comes to getting a new release. With BB it's turned into a crap shoot these days.


Ian

True .. timing is key .. if you miss that Monday, in many cases it does go to Long Wait at least in my experience ..
post #82 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mailiang View Post


The biggest problem I have with Red Box, at least in my area, is that there aren't enough titles in BD. At this point I have no issues getting rentals from Netflix, and it's convenient. So for now, at least for me, sticking with their service is a fete de compli.




Ian


to each their own. i like being able to pick up a br and watch it the same day. impulse renting if you want to call it that.

with nf i have to wait 2-3 days to get a title. not unreasonable, but it doesn't fit my impulsive nature.

also i only rent 4-5 br a month so a nf plan is really unnecessary for me.

only thing i do miss is not getting old titles.
post #83 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

to each their own. i like being able to pick up a br and watch it the same day. impulse renting if you want to call it that.

with nf i have to wait 2-3 days to get a title. not unreasonable, but it doesn't fit my impulsive nature.

also i only rent 4-5 br a month so a nf plan is really unnecessary for me.

only thing i do miss is not getting old titles.


Many of the older titles are available for streaming.



Ian
post #84 of 120
But then I miss my only source of 1080p content.

Funny thing is my wife has nf streaming set up on her hd set (we share very few movie/tv favorites so we rarely watch stuff together), but she's always complaining that there's
Nothing to watch!
Edited by mr. wally - 2/12/13 at 2:03pm
post #85 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

You need to edit your post. Your comments are quotes. Not sure what you mean by 1080p content.



Ian
post #86 of 120
br and pc content is what i consider 1080p.

don't want to go down the road where we argue whether streaming at 1080p is equal to bd as i know opinions vary on that topic.

if your satisfied with you nf streaming quality, then good for you.
post #87 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

br and pc content is what i consider 1080p.

don't want to go down the road where we argue whether streaming at 1080p is equal to bd as i know opinions vary on that topic.

if your satisfied with you nf streaming quality, then good for you.


If you read my BD posts you will find that I'm a BIG advocate of BD, so you won't get that argument from me. However, for 8 bucks a month Netflix streaming quality is hard to beat. So for the latest releases I turn to Blu-Ray, but for older titles and Indies, I usually go to satellite or streaming.


Ian wink.gif
Edited by mailiang - 2/12/13 at 3:28pm
post #88 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mailiang View Post

If you read my BD posts you will find that I'm a BIG advocate of BD, so you won't get that argument from me. However, for 8 bucks a month Netflix streaming quality is hard to beat. So for the latest releases I turn to Blu-Ray, but for older titles and Indies, I usually go to satellite or streaming.


Ian wink.gif

yeah there was that discussion about nf streaming and (i think) vudu being equal or nearly equal to bd.

i've seen my wife's nf 1080p streaming, and while it is very high quality for a stream, it didn't look like br quality to me.
post #89 of 120
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

yeah there was that discussion about nf streaming and (i think) vudu being equal or nearly equal to bd.

i've seen my wife's nf 1080p streaming, and while it is very high quality for a stream, it didn't look like br quality to me.

No doubt, but I'm kind of torn on having the service mainly because Netflix has a lot of anime available for streaming and that looks perfectly good viewing it that way. It also helps that I'm not a purist when it comes to listening to the Japanese soundtracks. The problem with a lot of anime series is there are often silly, over the top characters that can easily ruin a very dark and dramatic story, so it's nice to be able to check out a couple of episodes before I commit to a disc.

Stuff like that, I tend to watch on various TVs rather that like movies where I only watch them on the bigger home theater system. Therefore, streaming is plenty good enough for that.
post #90 of 120
I use Redbox plus the library. Who need's Netflix? Good thing they added new content.

Redbox gets every new release. I pick it up release week without issue. There's literally 15 (!) different kiosks on the way home from work. There's ample supply of Blu-rays if I want it. (A comedy often I pick up DVD.) Also, nearly weekly deals means I pay about 60-70% regular price on average. They are sucking all the money out of the rental movie business... it's over. Their profits and market share going up is the end of margins and local selection.

No one wants to see old movies at my library. Just like the DVDs, the majority of the Criterion Blu-rays languish on the shelf. People want new movies, tv, horror, comedy, and catalog favorites. Anything R-rated, black & white, or older than 1980 (really) sits and literally collects dust on Blu-ray. All the old folks who remember the movies don't own Blu-ray, and all the young people want either kids flicks to babysit their little rugrats or modern laughs or scares or thrills. I wonder everytime I'm there why I own so many movies. There is an embarrassment of riches on the row of shelves at all three of my closest branches.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Blu-ray Software
AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Blu-ray Software › Red Box