AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Video Download Services & Hardware › Netflix streaming quality
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Netflix streaming quality - Page 54

post #1591 of 2670
I'm ranting. I'm also searching for an answer that I'd like to hear. Now that that's out of the way, and in the hope that any answers will to my liking (to the point and not just personal crap about my attitude) I'll rant a little more.

Netflix will not take any responsibility for delivery to my door once it's left theirs. Fair enough... almost. They say that if the issue is with the servers/service in the hands of my device manufacturer then it is not their responsibility. Beyond my initial purchase of the device, I have no contract (billing) with samsung to deliver content. "that's good for you" said a netflix supervisor "you're getting that service for free". (love it whenever anyone tells you something's free)

But, I point out to her, if that "free" service is interrupted for any length, you have already indicated to me a willingness to refund me for the loss. So which is it? Are you taking responsibilty for deliver to my door, or not?.

She said that Netflix offer of refund was only in good faith to the consumer, but under no obligation. I suggested to her that since I'm not paying Samsung, and obviously some service is being rendered on netflix behalf at samsung to get the content to my door, then samsung is their partner in this exchange and not mine. She disagreed and said that the companies work together in this delivery, but disclaimed any sort of partnership. I asked if any portion of my bill (some knucklehead here is bound to say 'hey, it's eight bucks... this guy just likes to rant. good for you) goes toward the upkeep of this working relationship with samsung. Obviously seeing where this was headed, she said not a penny.

I called Samsung again and talked to level two support. He managed to explain it very very well. Samsung does not stream anything, but, as was suggested here, runs the ap. Yes running that ap on their servers is necessary for me to access netflix. Yes, when those servers are down, I can't get netflix streams. When I offered him the analogy of buying, with cash, a new Toshiba laptop, getting connected through your ISP, and then being told that the world wide web was down and unavailable to you because of a problem at Toshiba's servers... wouldn't you have a problem with that? He said he saw exactly what I was saying but that's just the way it is right now between me, samsung, and netflix.

Then he went on to describe the most interesting angle. He said to note that the "netflix" ap, when it comes up in the setup menu is not an automatically installed application from Samsung. He said this is significant in that it is a NETFLIX app that samsung has contracted with neflix to provide with the device. He told me that neflix pays samsung to include their connectivity ap on devices. That's not some form of partnership? That's not a partnership, some part of which, my check to neflix supports? Since netflix is the sole recipient of my bill, shouldn't they be responsible for troubleshooting and servicing the delivery of that content to my door (or specifically to my ISP, who I'm paying to take it from there)?

In other words, and most to the point of my dissatisfaction here. I'm paying a bill to netflix. If netflix service to my ISP is down for whatever reason, shouldn't netflix be calling samsung to address this problem with thier application, and not simply telling a customer to spend the next two hours contacting samsung on his own?

Yeah, it's a rant. If this were a 200 dollar a month bill it would be less bewildering to some of the mincing handwringers here with what they see as an aimless obsession. If that's your take, just ignore it and move on. Nothing here for you to see. But if part of this just doesn't sit right with you either, or if you can make it clearer to me without being insulting, then please comment.
post #1592 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by frascati View Post
mincing handwringers here with what they see as an aimless obsession.
rotfl ..
post #1593 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by frascati View Post
Netflix will not take any responsibility for delivery to my door once it's left theirs.

But if part of this just doesn't sit right with you either, or if you can make it clearer to me without being insulting, then please comment.
Do you expect the grocery store, bank, department store and whatnot to take responsibility for the roads between your house and them? Realistically there is very little difference with Netflix having no more control than the others. Recently there was a road closed because of flooding and I got two flat tires (at once) via a small pothole... however I didn't lay the blame for either on the places I was trying to visit.
post #1594 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charles R View Post
Do you expect the grocery store, bank, department store and whatnot to take responsibility for the roads between your house and them? Realistically there is very little difference with Netflix having no more control than the others. Recently there was road closed because of flooding and I got two flat tires (at once) via a small pothole... however I didn't lay the blame for either on the places I was trying to visit.
Nicely put .. very clear and not insulting at all .. and it sits right .. I give it a 9 out of a possible 10
post #1595 of 2670
Netflix recently did a complete overhaul of the netflix interface on the iPad. Unfortunately the new version is a massive downgrade. 90% of functionality has been removed and it is ridiculously laggy. All clicks take at least three seconds to register. Scrolling looks like a jerky slideshow.

It is hard to imagine what kind of idiocy is going on in the group at Netflix that is responsible for their browsing UI. It really does take an idiot to remove all the information from the library browsing interface. These devices and our Internet connections can handle downloading an entire page of text when viewing movie info. Yet they removed all that information for what reason? Their programmers couldn't make a page of text download in an acceptable time frame?

I'm not joking. They actually removed all movie info except for a couple sentence description, year, star rating, movie rating, duration, and the top 2 or 3 actor's names. The other 90% of the screen is now blank. No more reviews, no similar titles, no genre info, no "this movie is" info, no aspect ratio, no subtitle info, no sound info, no average rating vs your suggested rating, and I probably missed a few more on this list of removed features. None of the remaining info are links either. They even made the movie cover picture smaller for no reason.

If I was in charge at Netflix, the lead of the interface team would be fired immediately. They really thought it was a good idea to remove all the movie info and have us stare at a 90% empty/white screen? Seriously? Why not just make their website a bunch of blank pages too?

Edit:

Here are examples of what the interface used to look like and what it looks like now. The old example had to be taken from the website but it is nearly identical to what the native iPad app used to show.
LL
LL
post #1596 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by frascati View Post

I'm ranting. I'm also searching for an answer that I'd like to hear. Now that that's out of the way, and in the hope that any answers will to my liking (to the point and not just personal crap about my attitude) I'll rant a little more.

Netflix will not take any responsibility for delivery to my door once it's left theirs. Fair enough... almost. They say that if the issue is with the servers/service in the hands of my device manufacturer then it is not their responsibility. Beyond my initial purchase of the device, I have no contract (billing) with samsung to deliver content. "that's good for you" said a netflix supervisor "you're getting that service for free". (love it whenever anyone tells you something's free)

But, I point out to her, if that "free" service is interrupted for any length, you have already indicated to me a willingness to refund me for the loss. So which is it? Are you taking responsibilty for deliver to my door, or not?.

She said that Netflix offer of refund was only in good faith to the consumer, but under no obligation. I suggested to her that since I'm not paying Samsung, and obviously some service is being rendered on netflix behalf at samsung to get the content to my door, then samsung is their partner in this exchange and not mine. She disagreed and said that the companies work together in this delivery, but disclaimed any sort of partnership. I asked if any portion of my bill (some knucklehead here is bound to say 'hey, it's eight bucks... this guy just likes to rant. good for you) goes toward the upkeep of this working relationship with samsung. Obviously seeing where this was headed, she said not a penny.

I called Samsung again and talked to level two support. He managed to explain it very very well. Samsung does not stream anything, but, as was suggested here, runs the ap. Yes running that ap on their servers is necessary for me to access netflix. Yes, when those servers are down, I can't get netflix streams. When I offered him the analogy of buying, with cash, a new Toshiba laptop, getting connected through your ISP, and then being told that the world wide web was down and unavailable to you because of a problem at Toshiba's servers... wouldn't you have a problem with that? He said he saw exactly what I was saying but that's just the way it is right now between me, samsung, and netflix.

Then he went on to describe the most interesting angle. He said to note that the "netflix" ap, when it comes up in the setup menu is not an automatically installed application from Samsung. He said this is significant in that it is a NETFLIX app that samsung has contracted with neflix to provide with the device. He told me that neflix pays samsung to include their connectivity ap on devices. That's not some form of partnership? That's not a partnership, some part of which, my check to neflix supports? Since netflix is the sole recipient of my bill, shouldn't they be responsible for troubleshooting and servicing the delivery of that content to my door (or specifically to my ISP, who I'm paying to take it from there)?

In other words, and most to the point of my dissatisfaction here. I'm paying a bill to netflix. If netflix service to my ISP is down for whatever reason, shouldn't netflix be calling samsung to address this problem with thier application, and not simply telling a customer to spend the next two hours contacting samsung on his own?

Yeah, it's a rant. If this were a 200 dollar a month bill it would be less bewildering to some of the mincing handwringers here with what they see as an aimless obsession. If that's your take, just ignore it and move on. Nothing here for you to see. But if part of this just doesn't sit right with you either, or if you can make it clearer to me without being insulting, then please comment.

I understand your frustration. But Netflix is not responsible for your TV being broken.

That is exactly what is going on here. Your TV is broken. The manufacturer of your TV is responsible, not Netflix.
post #1597 of 2670
Quote:


puganx555:
dfiler, just wanted to say that it looks like your iPad is being fed the iPhone/iPod interface. It'll probably be sorted out shortly.

If it were a mistake, they could have switched back within a few days. My guess is that the new interface is intentional. It really is a shame. I used to do all my movie browsing from the iPad. As you can see from the screenshots, That will no longer be the case. Attempting to surf and find a movie from the ipad app is now pointless.

I hope you're right but I'm not holding my breath. The app interface team at Netflix is in serious trouble. Not only is their work below industry standards, but their customer communication is inexcusable. They continuously foist new and random interfaces on PS3 users without any forewarning, announcement, or even after the fact justification. Imagine if websites did the same thing. Random versions for all users with no explanation? And now this iPad atrocity as well? Management of the UI team needs to change. Either that or upper management is responsible for making the team do what they're doing.

Imagine if you bought a PS3 for Netflix after seeing it at a friends house. You get it home and the experience is completely different than what you saw! Yet you have no recourse, no explanation, no way of even figuring out why it is happening.

While netflix isn't responsible for samsung tv malfunctions, they are responsible for this interface incompetence... and I'll hold their feet to the fire on this one.
post #1598 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by dfiler View Post

If it were a mistake, they could have switched back within a few days. My guess is that the new interface is intentional. It really is a shame. I used to do all my movie browsing from the iPad. As you can see from the screenshots, That will no longer be the case. Attempting to surf and find a movie from the ipad app is now pointless.

I hope you're right but I'm not holding my breath. The app interface team at Netflix is in serious trouble. Not only is their work below industry standards, but their customer communication is inexcusable. They continuously foist new and random interfaces on PS3 users without any forewarning, announcement, or even after the fact justification. Imagine if websites did the same thing. Random versions for all users with no explanation? And now this iPad atrocity as well? Management of the UI team needs to change. Either that or upper management is responsible for making the team do what they're doing.

Imagine if you bought a PS3 for Netflix after seeing it at a friends house. You get it home and the experience is completely different than what you saw! Yet you have no recourse, no explanation, no way of even figuring out why it is happening.

While netflix isn't responsible for samsung tv malfunctions, they are responsible for this interface incompetence... and I'll hold their feet to the fire on this one.

I deleted my comment a few seconds after posting because it turns out that that really is the iPad interface (at least according to a few other sites out there). Seems like a terrible waste of all the screen real estate. I can't blame you for being upset with that.
post #1599 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pugnax555 View Post

I deleted my comment a few seconds after posting because it turns out that that really is the iPad interface (at least according to a few other sites out there). Seems like a terrible waste of all the screen real estate. I can't blame you for being upset with that.

lol, I too thought it had to be a mistake at first. That sort of proves the point.
post #1600 of 2670
MI-5 Vol. 3, 7 & 8 unwatchable, Why????

I have no problems watching HD movies, yet MI-5 is awful and why is Vol.5 still not on streaming list.

I'm about ready to dump Netflix $20/month
post #1601 of 2670
Quite interesting.
post #1602 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by dfiler View Post
Netflix recently did a complete overhaul of the netflix interface on the iPad. Unfortunately the new version is a massive downgrade. 90% of functionality has been removed and it is ridiculously laggy. All clicks take at least three seconds to register. Scrolling looks like a jerky slideshow.

I'm not joking. They actually removed all movie info except for a couple sentence description, year, star rating, movie rating, duration,

If I was in charge at Netflix, the lead of the interface team would be fired
Here are examples of what the interface used to look like and what it looks like now. The old example had to be taken from the website but it is nearly identical to what the native iPad app used to show.
i notice the same thing on my ipad...annoying yes but this is not such a big deal.

all the prior functionality is still availble thru the browser on the ipad. so the netflix app becomes a tool to just watch a movie and nothing else. i would be more annoyed if the browser forced me to go to the app for everything. not the case at the moment...
post #1603 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by billatlakegeorge View Post
MI-5 Vol. 3, 7 & 8 unwatchable, Why????

I have no problems watching HD movies, yet MI-5 is awful and why is Vol.5 still not on streaming list.

I'm about ready to dump Netflix $20/month
Vol.8 is too recent for streaming. I tried 3 and 7 on a PC and they seem to work fine. Not sure why Vol.5 is not available for streaming.
post #1604 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by plasma21 View Post

i notice the same thing on my ipad...annoying yes but this is not such a big deal.

all the prior functionality is still availble thru the browser on the ipad. so the netflix app becomes a tool to just watch a movie and nothing else. i would be more annoyed if the browser forced me to go to the app for everything. not the case at the moment...

So what you're saying is that the netlfix app is no longer useful for browsing?

Perhaps my standards are different, but that seems like a big deal to me. The website is slower than a proper app would be and the layout is not tailored to touch interaction. It is also buggy when switching between the two. It consumes an extra tab any time a stream is invoked, erasing tab history that might actually be useful. Recently watched history is not as accurately/instantly updated when streams are launched from the website. Switching apps is slow. Returning to the website is buggy, sometimes sending users into a continous loop of watching the stream that they are trying to exit.

And that's just a few of the problems I can recall off the top of my head!

When a company massively downgrades their app as a part of a service we are paying for, should we really let it slide simply because the app isn't entirely worthless? In my opinion, no. When a company ruins their app, the right thing to do is acknowledge what has happened and be proactive in providing feedback.
post #1605 of 2670
tried to stream S1, E1 of Doctor Who today on my PS3. I got a message saying there is a problem with that episode right now and to choose something else.
post #1606 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by b_scott View Post

tried to stream S1, E1 of Doctor Who today on my PS3. I got a message saying there is a problem with that episode right now and to choose something else.

That happens to me once in a while, usually during prime time. Just too many people on at once, I think.
post #1607 of 2670
Over the weekend, I decided it was time to get that free movie from VUDU, since "127 Hours" has been out of stock at the local video store and of course, Redbox and Netflix don't have it yet ..

Using their HDX feed, it was nice, but not really what I would consider great .. running 15mbps .. maybe a notch above a HD Netflix stream, but kinda underwhelming at $6 bucks a pop ..

Of course, it was free .. if they could get the price down under $3 bucks, I'd probably use VUDU once in a while .. there is a lot to be said for convienience ..
post #1608 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jim McC View Post

That happens to me once in a while, usually during prime time. Just too many people on at once, I think.

not prime time - I was trying it at 1AM. Only happened on the first episode, and only on PS3. Weird.
post #1609 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

Using their HDX feed, it was nice, but not really what I would consider great .. running 15mbps .. maybe a notch above a HD Netflix stream, but kinda underwhelming at $6 bucks a pop ..

Of course, it was free .. if they could get the price down under $3 bucks, I'd probably use VUDU once in a while .. there is a lot to be said for convienience ..

I'd say if you're used to Netflix 1080p through the PS3, Vudu is still a step up, but not as much as the step up from one of the "lesser" devices is.

However, everything in Vudu is 1080p/5.1 and OAR AFAIK. You also are paying for the ability to access something like 127 Hours which you're not going to get on Netflix right now.

On my 50" TV, I don't notice much of a difference between Vudu's HD and HDX....so you can save a buck if you're in the same situation I am and just get the HD stream. Also, keep an eye on their 99 cent deal of the day....I've seen everything from classics like Casablanca and Spartacus to newer releases like Easy A popup on it....and for 99 cents, it's a pretty good deal.

Right now Vudu is the best streaming gets (well, if you have an XBOX, Zune is right up there as well). Of course, you do pay for it, so due to the price I use it to compliment Netflix. Too expensive as a replacement, but it's nice to be able to get the occasional "very long wait" movie that I'm dying to see.
post #1610 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by mproper View Post

I'd say if you're used to Netflix 1080p through the PS3, Vudu is still a step up, but not as much as the step up from one of the "lesser" devices is.

However, everything in Vudu is 1080p/5.1 and OAR AFAIK. You also are paying for the ability to access something like 127 Hours which you're not going to get on Netflix right now.

On my 50" TV, I don't notice much of a difference between Vudu's HD and HDX....so you can save a buck if you're in the same situation I am and just get the HD stream. Also, keep an eye on their 99 cent deal of the day....I've seen everything from classics like Casablanca and Spartacus to newer releases like Easy A popup on it....and for 99 cents, it's a pretty good deal.

Right now Vudu is the best streaming gets (well, if you have an XBOX, Zune is right up there as well). Of course, you do pay for it, so due to the price I use it to compliment Netflix. Too expensive as a replacement, but it's nice to be able to get the occasional "very long wait" movie that I'm dying to see.

Good advice, and yes, it was a PS3 .. got a rebuffer once during the feed as well ..
post #1611 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by mproper View Post

I'd say if you're used to Netflix 1080p through the PS3, Vudu is still a step up, but not as much as the step up from one of the "lesser" devices is.

I disagree. For the last week or so I used a PS3 (getting HDX most of the time) and noticed very little difference between its image and my TiVo Premiere (doing several A/B comparisons). However VUDU looks dramatically better than anything else I stream. Ultimately I was so underwhelmed I returned the PS3. I think for 5.1/1080p the new Panasonic players should be a much better selection... going to find out soon.
post #1612 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by mproper View Post

However, everything in Vudu is 1080p/5.1 and OAR AFAIK

I've seen quite a bit of SD only content browsing around, but I don't think I've seen any new releases that aren't in HDX.
post #1613 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charles R View Post

I disagree. For the last week or so I used a PS3 (getting HDX most of the time) and noticed very little difference between its image and my TiVo Premiere (doing several A/B comparisons). However VUDU looks dramatically better than anything else I stream. Ultimately I was so underwhelmed I returned the PS3. I think for 5.1/1080p the new Panasonic players should be a much better selection... going to find out soon.

Confused Comparing Netflix on your PS3 vs Tivo or comparing Vudu? You say "HDX" on your PS3 but maybe your meant "X-High." I am assuming that's what you meant, since I don't think the Tivo does Vudu, does it?

If Netflix, that surprises me, given that my PS3 blows away every device I've seen Netflix through (XBOX, Roku, several BD players, the Wii obviously). However I have not seen it through a Tivo Premiere, so I will take your word for it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by cubiczee View Post

I've seen quite a bit of SD only content browsing around, but I don't think I've seen any new releases that aren't in HDX.

Oh yes...sorry. I meant anything recent. Honestly haven't browsed much of the catalog on Vudu. Anything I have been interested in has been available in HDX.
post #1614 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by mproper View Post

Confused Comparing Netflix on your PS3 vs Tivo or comparing Vudu? You say "HDX" on your PS3 but maybe your meant "X-High."

Sorry, I did mean X-High. Comparing players to a large degree it's what one prefers. As an example the LG BD550 looks very detailed on the surface (far superior to the TiVo Premiere). However once you see the perceived increase in detail is made up of higher intra-scene contrast and edge enhancing processing the image ends up being less desirable. You can easily spot both via coarse skin tones.

Regarding the PS3 I keep hearing about its superiority especially with 1080p and simply haven't seen it to any degree. I keep trying and as my bandwidth increased I gave it yet another try. Now that other players have 5.1 personally I see very little reason to go the PS3 route. I tried streaming MKV (and other files) and support is so lousy they had to be transcoded on the fly...

If one wants to play the game card it certainly makes sense (Pinball Hall of Fame is a lot of fun) but other wise I think it's becoming rather outdated to recommend the PS3 as the best... included Netflix. Even the Panasonic handles DD+ correctly.
post #1615 of 2670
what other players stream 5.1 netflix?
post #1616 of 2670
You can see my report on the Panny DMP-BDT110 here (one of the other systems which can now handle Netflix 5.1 sound), with many little bandwidth graphs snapped from my router's monitor.
post #1617 of 2670
so far, Doctor Who Season 1 and 2 have been 4X3 (except the special Xmas episode starting S2). They were broadcast in widescreen and they are widescreen on DVD. What gives? Why would they seek out an inferior aspect ratio?
post #1618 of 2670
I've got an interesting Netflix streaming issue. Both Sat. and Sun. night I was watching an HD streaming movie. Sat. halfway through the movie the screen went black and it reloaded into SD, about 5 times. I kept restarting the movie and finally got it back to HD. I watched 2 other movies later all SD with no issue. Sun. the same thing happened.

Frustrated I called Netflix and the guy was quite helpful but found interesting stuff in my history. He saw all my history and all my devices. He indicted that my typical connection speed is 10-11.5M, indicated I needed at least 5 for HD. However he looked a little closer and found that on EVERY stream in my file the speed dropped to 4M about 10 minutes into the stream but then bounced back to 10+m right after that. He had no idea why. I asked if they were having issues with ATT Uverse throttling the stream and he said no.

So, does anyone have any idea what is going on? Every time I do a speed test, regardless of what type of test I do I always get a little over 11m down, low ping, A rating on Speedtest.net.
post #1619 of 2670
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt L View Post
So, does anyone have any idea what is going on?
Posted elsewhere in this forum:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wendell R. Breland

IMO the best way to check your internet speed is by using some large real world download files. The Speed Boost that IP use leads to false readings when using Speed Test. Go to the fastest site you can find and download a very large file and look at your browsers download manager to see your real world speed.

It is the Speed Boost that makes Speed Test appear to be good. That is the reason for using a large file download as a test. The first several megabytes will download rather quickly then the download speed will taper off as more of the file is downloaded.
All the Speed Test that I have run indicate about 8 mbps for my connection. I stream content from Hulu, CBS, PBS, ABC, etc., and most of it is SD, 4 x 3, B&W. It is not uncommon to have the program stop wait for short period of time then continue. Another reminder, the internet was not designed for streaming video. If you want to stream then you may as well get ready to accept the warts that come with IPTV.
post #1620 of 2670
As Wendell suggested, do a prolonged large file speedtest.

I wouldn't worry too much about the "internet is not designed for video" comment, since that has nothing to do with your issue (obviously something is causing your bandwidth to drop, then go right back up). The internet does a lot of stuff it wasn't designed to do, and technology keeps marching on.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Video Download Services & Hardware › Netflix streaming quality