or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › Thinking about building HTPC, or getting PS3, any major advantage to HTPC? pleasehelp
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Thinking about building HTPC, or getting PS3, any major advantage to HTPC? pleasehelp

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I want to be able to stream and watch HD content on my TV. I thought about getting a PS3, it does well with MKV, Blueray, DVD, Xvid. The main formats i'll be using. It streams or plays direct, and has a hard drive. Is there any main advantage to a HTPC?? from what I can tell at $400 the PS3 would be a good bit cheaper also. Please help. Also this isnt a "PS3 is just as good as a HTCP" I just would like to get better informed of the difference.. thanks for any input!!
post #2 of 6
If you want a seamless, problem-free, all-in-one solution then go with the PS3. If, however, you are a tweaker by nature and want to have the headroom and ability to upgrade as time goes on, then go with an HTPC.

Some of the obvious advantages of an HTPC over the PS3 are:
- Can be used for more than just media playback (browsing, etc.).
- Easier to upgrade and expand.
- Can support more features than a PS3, e.g. TV tuner card, etc.
- Slicker and sexier front-ends than the PS3 (see my post here: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showp...9&postcount=17
- Can be used for PC games (if you have any interest in any PC games).
post #3 of 6
My main reason why I went with a HTPC (still own a PS3) is the ability to rip BR movies to the HDD and play it from there. And I use FFDShow for upscale standard movies which does a far better job than my PS3.

But after installing a new LG BR drive in my HTPC last night and going thru various issues, I can definitely tell u the PS3 offers simplicity and a 'no-headache' approach to playing movies.
post #4 of 6
For Blu-ray, I'd go with the PS3 (or a standalone Blu-ray player). For other media, though (mkv, old avi files, etc), I'd go with the HTPC. I have an 80GB PS3 (the earlier model that came with MGS4, still with PS2 support) and it's been a headache trying to get self-encoded mp4 files (yeah, I used the MeGUI PS3/Xbox360 profile) to play properly. With the new firmware update, DivX 5/6 playback (using Home Theater Profile) improved a lot. I used to get a lot of artifacts before (green/black dots, squares, vertical lines, etc) and now DivX 5/6 is pretty much perfect. Funny thing is, I've got a bunch of files encoded for the PSP which play perfectly on the PSP but feature the same weird artifacts when played on the PS3.
post #5 of 6
Thread Starter 
evidently theres a streaming program made specificly for PS3 its self that streams MKV files very well, have you tried that?
post #6 of 6
I've got Tversity installed on the PC serving media to the PS3. Not sure if that's the program you're referring to. I don't have re-encoding enabled since the PC doesn't have the grunt to do realtime HD encoding, not to mention you lose quality every time you transcode.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Home Theater Computers
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › Thinking about building HTPC, or getting PS3, any major advantage to HTPC? pleasehelp