Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jack Morris 
Is Rovi still in business?
Yes, and they still provide TVGoS; but it's only available via Internet now.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jack Morris 
If I buy a car with anti-lock brakes, and the manufacturer has some troubled financial times in the future and discontinues the car software which continues to provide those anti-lock brakes, then that is legally pursueable as a breach of contract.... just as this is regarding TVGOS. Nothing is preventing Rovi from continuing to adhere to the contract we signed except they have decided our contract is now too expensive for them to continue to adhere to.
That's a really terrible analogy. Has anyone ever heard of anti-lock brakes that stop working if they don't receive a continuous data stream from the car manufacturer? Ridiculous!
A better analogy would be something like OnStar, or a Sirius/XM satellite radio subscription. You may buy a car with a 1-year prepaid subscription, which you can continue at your own expense. If the service were turned off during the prepaid subscription, the dealer may owe you a (probably tiny) refund; but they're certainly not going to take the car back; nor would anyone argue that OnStar or Sirius/XM is obligated to provide service in perpetuity as long as someone, somewhere, continues to subscribe.
The situation with your Pal is even less favorable, since you aren't even subscribing to anything! Once the warranty is up, no one owes you anything if one of its features stops working.
Read the 13th Amendment to our Constitution: "Neither slavery nor
involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction." It's a free country. No one can force anyone else to do a job they don't want to do. (The courts have recognized an exception for military service, of course; but I'm pretty sure Rovi Corp. isn't an enlistee.)
Edited by JHBrandt - 2/11/13 at 10:32am