AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Recorders › The Official AVS Dish DTVPal DVR Topic!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Official AVS Dish DTVPal DVR Topic! - Page 99

post #2941 of 16895
Sill waiting for echo* to fix the problems and staying with the Sony HDD250 for now.

Many posts complain about EPG data availability (and TVGOS data for that matter).

Here is a link to my findings for EPG in San Diego:
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showp...86&postcount=6
post #2942 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by catmother View Post

Don't be to sure of that. See my post 492 here:
http://tivocommunity.com/tivo-vb/sho...=1#post7074164

I'm not a TIVO guy so I bow to you, a more knowledgeable user.

Does TIVO have a similar history as Dish's of repeatedly releasing not ready for prime time products or is TIVO still around because they make their stuff work?
post #2943 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by Padawan View Post

So, now that these have been out a while, is it worth purchasing? We have cut the cable for a few months now and are finding that we can't really go without tv. The wife and I are watching shows off the websites right now on a 19" laptop and that works, but is annoying. Like watching the same commercial all hour long. Ugh.

We are looking at getting a small 1080p tv for the bedroom, getting a OTA HDTV DVR, and going that route just to quit all the "poor user experience" of the laptop solution. Is it worth it?

Thanks,

Padawan

I'm still waiting for a stable unit to be produced. It appears to be strictly YMMV at present. How "small" is your 1080p TV going to be? If it's "small" you have rock solid options for an OTA DVR, but then 1080p may not make a lot of sense - hence the question.
post #2944 of 16895
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by catmother View Post

Don't be to sure of that. See my post 492 here:
http://tivocommunity.com/tivo-vb/sho...=1#post7074164

The last TiVo software update introduced a nasty bug where the analog tuners periodically "go out." To get them back, you've got to either reboot the TiVo, or switch to a digital channel and then back to the analog channel. This is a killer bug for customers that are using basic (analog) cable.

A variation of bug was actually introduced back in late 2007, it was fixed shortly thereafter, and then it was introduced again a bit over a month ago. According to that thread, TiVo is rolling out a fix this week to a limited number of users.

Thankfully, this issue does not affect OTA digital channels.
post #2945 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by jerrisn View Post

I just looked at http://www.dtvpal.com/. It appears that the DTVPal DVR is all sold out. Has Dish Network realized the problems and heading back to the drawing board, or is this the end of the DTVPal DVR? I have my unit that is rebooting fairly often now. I am going to try the choke idea. I have removed it from a APC Backup with no results. I just find it odd that they are "Sold Out" with as many problems that are showing up. hmmm...

Solidsignal still has them, and the price is now $249.
post #2946 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by kerrym80 View Post

Solidsignal still has them, and the price is now $249.

Now the TR-40 is sold out. Either there is a mad rush before the conversion, or they are discontinuing the unit. I may have to buy another unit to be safe.
post #2947 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by kerrym80 View Post

Solidsignal still has them, and the price is now $249.

They are still available here as well.
post #2948 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by kerrym80 View Post

phil,
The first zip that worked for me was that of KPIX in SF, that is 94111, but after that worked, I switched to my real zip, it works also.

Thanks, I'll give it a try!
post #2949 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by RAS49 View Post

On 23 December I received the following:

Receiver ID R188004967-67
Software Version F201TALD-N (subsequently upgraded to F202TALD-N)
Boot Strap Version 1011 TALD
Processor ID 29347110

On 28 December I contacted Dish due to the number of reboots (coming at the rate of one every 2 - 3 minutes). After approximately 10 calls and a similar number of hours on the telephone they finally sent a UPS label by email to return the machine (note: machine only, not the remote, cables or book). I received a new machine on 10 February as described below:

Receiver ID R1880052685-89
Software Version F201TALD-N
Boot Strap Version 1011 TALD
Processor ID 29379332

The latest machine appears to be working well and only reboots when the guide is updated. (I have now shut off the guide updates and eliminated all stations with a signal strength of less than 80. I live in the Dallas area so have only eliminated 3 stations as most signals are strong.) The latest machine was sent shrink wrapped without remote controller, cables or book. It did, however, contain another return UPS label!!

I do not understand the differences between the two machines except one did not work and the other does. Any ideas on the differences? (I have deliberately not updated the software version on the latest machine lest it effect it in some detrimental way. Any advice on this will be appreciated.)

I appreciate this forum and the good efforts and goodwill by so many. Thank you.

I also live in Dallas. I was curious if you get the full 7 days for your TVGOS guide. I get a few stations that go 7 days out but over half of them (including NBC (channel 5), ABC (channel 8) and CBS (channel 11)) only go out 24 hrs or less. Is your guide loaded similarly to mine?
post #2950 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by NorthDallasGuy View Post

I also live in Dallas. I was curious if you get the full 7 days for your TVGOS guide. I get a few stations that go 7 days out but over half of them (including NBC (channel 5), ABC (channel 8) and CBS (channel 11)) only go out 24 hrs or less. Is your guide loaded similarly to mine?

I am in Arlington and I have the same problem. Only a few stations are getting TVGOS data and it appears that the remainder are using PSIP data. I base this on the fact that the channel 5 PSIP data went away completely recently and so did the schedule information on the DTVPal DVR.
post #2951 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by bfdtv View Post

The last TiVo software update introduced a nasty bug where the analog tuners periodically "go out." To get them back, you've got to either reboot the TiVo, or switch to a digital channel and then back to the analog channel. This is a killer bug for customers that are using basic (analog) cable.

A variation of bug was actually introduced back in late 2007, it was fixed shortly thereafter, and then it was introduced again a bit over a month ago. According to that thread, TiVo is rolling out a fix this week to a limited number of users.

Thankfully, this issue does not affect OTA digital channels.

To do justice to TIVO, I just received a reply from TIVOJerry pointing out that the original bug wich plagued me had been resolved and he also mentioned the Ver 11 software bug you referred to.

BTW, You are to be commended for the excellent FAQ's on TIVO and the PAL DVR etc. A real credit to AVS
post #2952 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by Super_Chachi View Post

I'm in Austin and I experience reboot/lockups at random. I probably average 3 per week during heavy use, but I've gone up to 2 weeks without anything. Are you getting more than 12 hours of guide on KXAN NBC?

No, I emailed KEYE (they host the TVGOS data) and asked whose issue it was to correct this problem. They really didn't know. They said I was the first to report this issue...so I'm assuming they aren't that worried about it. Maybe you can also email them and ask and see if we can get TVGOS data for KXAN. What you see is the PSIP data only.
post #2953 of 16895
Thread Starter 
Did anyone order from Solid Signal? If so, what revision did you get? F20*TALD-N or F20*TAKD-N?
post #2954 of 16895
I don't think it is possible to shutoff TVGOS updates, only software update. I'm I missing something here? I had my first lockup since installing Jan 24th. F201, no update connection, L software.
post #2955 of 16895
The RFI hypothesis is reasonable and thanks to S73 for sharing his experiences. As mentioned this morning, my set was spriraling into reboot hell so I changed the power hookup. Right now, reboot free, the power cord is connected to an adapter and sharing one 120V receptacle with the TV. I don't know why this would work or if it will over the long term so I have ordered a couple of snap chokes to play with. It could be that this particular hookup is presenting a somewhat different load impedance to the wall receptacle. If that attenuates, grounds or reflects some of the RF junk coming in on the line all to the good. We'll see. Keep the faith.

Note to padawan; the PAL DVR is amazing.
post #2956 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by bfdtv View Post

Did anyone order from Solid Signal? If so, what revision did you get? F20*TALD-N or F20*TAKD-N?

Yes, received "L". One lockup, Heat sealed, double boxed. Tracking info.
original software 201. Did not reset.
post #2957 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by s73v3 View Post

I may have discovered a fix for reboot issues. I have second wave "L" unit:

Receiver R1880052698-02
Firmware F201TALD-N
Boot Rom 1011TALD
Real zip code
Getting TVGOS
No network
Updates disabled

I had been getting 1 to 3 reboots per session. After reading the discussion on power line issues and use of UPS to resolve issues, I got to thinking. The DVR power supply basically is just a regulated 5 Volt and 12 Volt supply. The regulators can't be that bad that they can't handle a little variation in line voltage. It must be that the DVR processor is sensitive to RFI and EMI. So as an experiment I dug through my computer junk box and found one of those ferrite chokes that typically come with computers, monitors and other electronic stuff. Its a RFI filter (ferrite donut) that you just clamp around the power cord. I put it on the DVR power cord last week and now have gone an entire week without any reboots. I plan to leave it on for another week and see how it does. If is still reboot free I'll take it off and see if the reboots come back.

This may be cheap and simple fix. Anyone else tried this?

I put a ferrite donut on the power cord after reading this thread 1 hour ago and just had another reboot a few minutes ago...darn, was hoping it could be something this simple!
post #2958 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chuck44 View Post

It was probably the station.

I just heard from the station and they claim to have only one audio stream. I find it hard to believe that they would run without audio for such an extended time period.
post #2959 of 16895
I really want one of these boxes, but I am a little concerned with paying for one of these and getting a defect. Does anybody that has one of these live around Memphis and if so, does yours work without the freezes/reboots? Also does the local CBS station provide TVGOS?
post #2960 of 16895
Any advantage/disadvantage in buying the DTVpal DVR from Solidsignal?
post #2961 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blaaz View Post

Any advantage/disadvantage in buying the DTVpal DVR from Solidsignal?

After all the problems dealing with Dish for my order solid signal has got to be better both in orders and returns if need be.
post #2962 of 16895
The DTVPal arrived a couple of days ago, and I'm very impressed so far. Watching everything in SD right now until my cables arrive from monoprice.

This is my first DVR, and I'm wondering if the included rubber feet isolate the unit sufficiently from the bass and other vibrations coming from a home theater system? Right now I have the DTVPal on it's own stand about 10 feet away from the subwoofer in a carpeted room. The current sub isn't all that powerful (Onkyo HTiB), but I'd like to upgrade to a SVS PC12-NSD in a few months.
post #2963 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by schultdw View Post

I am in Arlington and I have the same problem. Only a few stations are getting TVGOS data and it appears that the remainder are using PSIP data. I base this on the fact that the channel 5 PSIP data went away completely recently and so did the schedule information on the DTVPal DVR.

I am in North Dallas and the guide information I get is most comprehensive for channel 13 (PBS) which extends out about 3 days. The other stations go out no more than a day or so and in some cases less. On the other hand my computer which also receives digital TV programming gets guide information that extends out at least a week for PBS, sometimes two weeks, while the other stations have several days of information for the guide. I do not know much about this guide information and how it is transmitted but there is definitely a difference between what the DVR displays and what the computer (a HP desktop with digital tuner) shows. Any thoughts?
post #2964 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by pheons View Post

The DTVPal arrived a couple of days ago, and I'm very impressed so far. Watching everything in SD right now until my cables arrive from monoprice.

This is my first DVR, and I'm wondering if the included rubber feet isolate the unit sufficiently from the bass and other vibrations coming from a home theater system? Right now I have the DTVPal on it's own stand about 10 feet away from the subwoofer in a carpeted room. The current sub isn't all that powerful (Onkyo HTiB), but I'd like to upgrade to a SVS PC12-NSD in a few months.

If you can't wait you can always use the supplied A/V cable as a component cable.
post #2965 of 16895
I received my DVPal DVR January 30. Since then, I have had some lock ups, so I started watching this thread. I contacted DISH's tech support via e-mail and chat. I updated my software, and disabled automatic software updates. The unit still locks up under heavy use. I contacted DISH again by e-mail, and they immediately suggested I contact their call center to get an RA. Like many of you, I am frustrated by this company's terrible customer service, and their use of their paying customers to test a product that is not ready. I have included a little of the chat dialogue below for your analysis:

The highlighted response is something I had not seen in any other post.

(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: You are all set. Have I handled everything to your satisfaction?
: No, no one has explained to me why a new unit will work better. If your company really believes this is the correct solution you should send a new one to me first. I should not have to pay the shipping to return a defective device.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: It could be that the hard drive has a bad sector in it that is causing it to freeze.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: Unfortunately we have to receive the defective unit first before we can send out a new unit to you.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: We pay for the charges for the new unit to be sent out to you
: But why do I have pay to return the bad one?
: What if you send another bad one?
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: I apologize for any inconvenience. That is the business rules for the return procedures of a DTVPal unit. If you had a regular DISH account with us I would make an adjustment to your billing to compensate for the shipping charge that you would have to pay to us.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: If by chance you were to get another defective unit, we would have to look into what to do about that if the situation were to arise.
: You can still make an adjustment. You could make an adjustment to the card I used for payment. According to your return policy you still have that number and would use it to charge me if the unit is not under warranty.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: Did you purchase the DTVPal through a retailer?
: No, according to your own website this unit is only available directly.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: The credit card information is used for customer's that have an actual DISH tv services
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: It is just a standard disclosure that we give
: You could send me a paid shipping label.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: We would not be able to send out a pre-paid shipping label to you.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: I apologize for any inconvenience.
: sure you could.
: just send it out.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: I apologize for any inconvenience, but we would not be able to send you a pre-paid shipping label
post #2966 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by kerrym80 View Post

After all the problems dealing with Dish for my order solid signal has got to be better both in orders and returns if need be.

Carefully read SolidSignals' return policy before you assume that.
post #2967 of 16895
I have tried to read almost every page of this thread.... Some very good information here that's for sure. Anyhow, I'm struggling with making a decision about purchasing the DTVPal DVR. Currently I have been using a HTPC loaded up with SageTV. Had been working fairly well with the exception of stuttering/gittering video on fast moving programs like sports. I could never get it fixed. Sometimes it would be good, barible... So I decided to update to the latest drivers, latest SageTV release etc last night. Well that failed miserably. At this point I'm just so sick of messing with trying to tweak the HTPC to get it all working properly I just want something that works out of the box!

Found out about this DTVPal DVR and was very eager to jump on the bandwagon until I found this thread... I only get OTA channels, gave up on DirecTV and Cable years ago, actually 3 years now. Have a nice channel master antenna isntalled on the roof that gets very good reception, even stations some 75 miles away. For what we watch, such shows as CSI etc, the HTPC has worked failry well, only thing I really miss of cable is ESPN.....

So my question is to you all, do I buy this DTVPal DVR or go the darkside and buy a TivoHD with the stupid montly fees?? I want the DTVPal so bad because of the one time fee of $250 instead of $199+subscription for TIvo. Tivo looks impressive with the features and more less problem free solution, it's just those damn montly fees, which is why I went strictly OTA in the first place 3 years ago. HELP!!! I'm done with the HTPC, use to be fun tweaking it to get it right, but not anymore, guess I'm just getting old!
post #2968 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by saxboater View Post

I received my DVPal DVR January 30. Since then, I have had some lock ups, so I started watching this thread. I contacted DISH's tech support via e-mail and chat. I updated my software, and disabled automatic software updates. The unit still locks up under heavy use. I contacted DISH again by e-mail, and they immediately suggested I contact their call center to get an RA. Like many of you, I am frustrated by this company's terrible customer service, and their use of their paying customers to test a product that is not ready. I have included a little of the chat dialogue below for your analysis:

The highlighted response is something I had not seen in any other post.

(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: You are all set. Have I handled everything to your satisfaction?
: No, no one has explained to me why a new unit will work better. If your company really believes this is the correct solution you should send a new one to me first. I should not have to pay the shipping to return a defective device.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: It could be that the hard drive has a bad sector in it that is causing it to freeze.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: Unfortunately we have to receive the defective unit first before we can send out a new unit to you.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: We pay for the charges for the new unit to be sent out to you
: But why do I have pay to return the bad one?
: What if you send another bad one?
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: I apologize for any inconvenience. That is the business rules for the return procedures of a DTVPal unit. If you had a regular DISH account with us I would make an adjustment to your billing to compensate for the shipping charge that you would have to pay to us.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: If by chance you were to get another defective unit, we would have to look into what to do about that if the situation were to arise.
: You can still make an adjustment. You could make an adjustment to the card I used for payment. According to your return policy you still have that number and would use it to charge me if the unit is not under warranty.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: Did you purchase the DTVPal through a retailer?
: No, according to your own website this unit is only available directly.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: The credit card information is used for customer's that have an actual DISH tv services
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: It is just a standard disclosure that we give
: You could send me a paid shipping label.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: We would not be able to send out a pre-paid shipping label to you.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: I apologize for any inconvenience.
: sure you could.
: just send it out.
(24DrDcb) Brandi S. OFB: I apologize for any inconvenience, but we would not be able to send you a pre-paid shipping label

Keep calling. Eventually you will get an agent that will send you a label by mail (allow two weeks) or by email. I got both after many many calls. Don't give up. In fact, I got three UPS labels, one by mail, one by email and one with the replacement unit! I suggest you call at random hours. If you get someone in Makati (Manila Philippines) you will get the standard line. If you get someone in Colorado, they have more discretion to send a label.
post #2969 of 16895
Quote:
Originally Posted by saxboater View Post

....

I notice that at one point she refers to it as a DTVPal yet she seems to realize it has a hard drive. Should not be the same policy for both units.

Can't and won't are not the same thing

I think you can test for a bad sector by formatting the disk.
post #2970 of 16895
I still after weeks have had only one reboot.

However I have had several losses of sound or freeze ups, so I manually have to reboot. This happens about 2x per week. When it happens I am usually recording two shows watching a third, and trying to do something with a menu.

Seems like there are some timing issues when things get too busy.

Once I had 2 recordings set to go but was watching a different channel. One recording started but the other didn't and I got no message to stop watching the channel I was on.
I think usually it just takes over and switches.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HDTV Recorders
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Recorders › The Official AVS Dish DTVPal DVR Topic!