Quote:
Originally Posted by black_macleod 
Its not that they don't run at 7200rpm ... but they use variable speeds which will definitely wreak havoc with the Moxi. I think I'll update the first post advising people to avoid "green" drives, as your case is not the first I've heard of.
If you already have the enclosure, just order a drive from somewhere and don't buy a green one ... I've ordered plenty of drives for work from vendors, and have never received a green drive unexpectedly ...

Its not that they don't run at 7200rpm ... but they use variable speeds which will definitely wreak havoc with the Moxi. I think I'll update the first post advising people to avoid "green" drives, as your case is not the first I've heard of.
If you already have the enclosure, just order a drive from somewhere and don't buy a green one ... I've ordered plenty of drives for work from vendors, and have never received a green drive unexpectedly ...
The "Green" drives do not operate at variable speeds -- they do not change speeds on the fly. That is a myth and a misunderstanding of what Western Digital does.
The original "Green" drives were only variable in the sense that the actual RPM was set in firmware at the factory, and varied slightly from drive to drive. I don't know whether that is still the case; Western Digital may have standardized on 5400rpm.
Modern 5400rpm drives provide more than sufficient performance for a dual-tuner DVR. The 5400rpm drives of today exceed the performance of 7200rpm drives from a few years ago in most respects.














