AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Speakers › Nakamichi or Monoprice (banana plugs)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Nakamichi or Monoprice (banana plugs)

post #1 of 173
Thread Starter 
I was just wondering, from a purely CONDUCTIVE point of view, which is better? The nakamichi 0534B banana plug, or the "closed type" monoprice one.

The nakamichi allows for insertion of the speaker wire and basically "screwing it tight" and the monoprice allows for the spreading out of the wire and letting you tighten over this, thus maximizing surface area. The pics are attached.

Also, from a "what do you like more" point of view, which would you prefer.
LL
LL
LL
post #2 of 173
I have the Nakamichi ones. Speaking from an electrician's point of view, there will be no difference between the two assuming you use 16AWG wire or bigger. The Nakamichis will spread out the wire as you smash it down with the screw.
post #3 of 173
I'm using the Nakamichi right now but it's purely for aesthetic purposes. Personally though I like the Monoprice head screwed type better and I'm in the process of replacing all the bananas I've got with that type.
post #4 of 173
I've always liked the looks of the Nakamichi plugs, but for ease of use and excellent price, I've used these "Safe Connect" GLS plugs for years....

http://www.speakerrepair.com/Merchan...e=safe_connect

As porksmash mentions, as long as the wire is of sufficient AWG and you have a tight connection, there will be no real difference from an electrical POV.
post #5 of 173
I like the set-screw style.
post #6 of 173
Monoprice has their banana plugs on sale for .94 a pair. What's not to like!!!!!
post #7 of 173
I like my Monoprice plugs, but the lug end (what goes into the binding post) has lost compression/spring-retention over roughly 2 years. They still hold, but I can feel play in the connection that I don't remember noticing when I firt installed them 2 years ago. I'm not planning on replacing them, but I am adding some heatshrink over the barell to ensure that a loose plug doesn't contact its mate and cause a short. I really wish Monoprice would come out with a version that has a non-conductive barell.
post #8 of 173
Quote:
Originally Posted by quadriverfalls View Post

I've always liked the looks of the Nakamichi plugs, but for ease of use and excellent price, I've used these "Safe Connect" GLS plugs for years....

Exactly the style of bananas I like. Cheap too...
post #9 of 173
If monoprice comes out with a safety type banana for $2.50/pr or less, I'll likely replace all 11 pairs I have in my setup (5 pairs at the AVR, 6 pairs on patch cables going from L/C/R to wall-plates). Actually, I might only replace the 5 pairs at the AVR since the L/C/R and wall-plate are well spaced with little chance of accidental touching, while at the AVR they're pretty close. At the AVR I'm currently using these Dayton plugs which I got 4-for-$1 with water-damaged packaging from their tent at the Dayton Hamvention... they have a black coating of some sort on the body, but I'm not convinced it's non-cunductive or that it would help if two inadvertantly touched.
post #10 of 173
Thread Starter 
Are the nakamichi's "plagued" with a conductive barrel? Seems to me that they are.

Anyone have a cheap source for heatshrink?
post #11 of 173
Nakamichis look better IMO, but I use monoprice for all my connections.
post #12 of 173
Thread Starter 
Are the nakamichis conductive on the outer side like the monoprice? Should I heatshrink either one of them anyways?

thanks.
post #13 of 173
The closed type at monoprice are on special today for .94/pair I guess I'm kind of late with this news...
post #14 of 173
Thread Starter 
Not anymore!!

Damn it they're back to 2.xx
post #15 of 173
what's the advantage of the banana plug over the regular wiring method?
post #16 of 173
Quote:
Originally Posted by Krisen Type-S View Post

what's the advantage of the banana plug over the regular wiring method?

Ease of use mainly.... just plug in and forget it. No binding post to come loose and need to be re-tightened and no bare wire to oxidize over time which can degrade the sound.
post #17 of 173
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gewow View Post

Anyone have a cheap source for heatshrink?

http://www.parts-express.com/heat-sh...TOKEN=82532456
post #18 of 173
Quote:
Originally Posted by Krisen Type-S View Post

what's the advantage of the banana plug over the regular wiring method?

Yeap, there's no advantage to ultra tightened spades either as far as SQ. Choose whatever is the safest and easiest to connect.
post #19 of 173
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by quadriverfalls View Post

http://www.parts-express.com/heat-sh...TOKEN=82532456

The shipping is 4x the price of the item!! (I live in Canada). Thanks though.
post #20 of 173
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gewow View Post

The shipping is 4x the price of the item!! (I live in Canada). Thanks though.

Oops.... sorry about that. Any electrical wiring type wholesaler will have heat shrink. You should be able to just walk in and buy it off the shelf. It may be in three or four feet pieces (way more than you might need) but it will be cheap and no shipping.

Here are a couple of electrical/wiring business I fount in Montreal doing a quick and rudimentary Google search. I probably could have come up with more if I could read French....

Good luck.

http://www.montreal.servpro.ca/listc...lectronic.html
post #21 of 173
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stephen Hopkins View Post

I like my Monoprice plugs, but the lug end (what goes into the binding post) has lost compression/spring-retention over roughly 2 years. They still hold, but I can feel play in the connection that I don't remember noticing when I firt installed them 2 years ago. I'm not planning on replacing them, but I am adding some heatshrink over the barell to ensure that a loose plug doesn't contact its mate and cause a short. I really wish Monoprice would come out with a version that has a non-conductive barell.


Easily fixed without dismantling your speaker cable; The compression fitting unscrews seperately from the barrel and retainer.

I didn't notice they were a 3-piece unitl I accidentally unscrewed one.
post #22 of 173
Quote:
Originally Posted by cybe View Post

Easily fixed without dismantling your speaker cable; The compression fitting unscrews seperately from the barrel and retainer.

I didn't notice they were a 3-piece unitl I accidentally unscrewed one.

That will still require me to order more... since they still hold, but now with a little play, I think I'll just hold out until I can get a good deal on some safety type lugs, and possibly some with a screw set.
post #23 of 173
Thread Starter 
bump
post #24 of 173
To those with the Nakamichi plugs, does the plug end have 4 or 6 spring leafs?

I've noticed the same thing that Stephen Hopkins has - the 4 spring leaf end of the monoprice plugs tends to lose it's tension over time.

A 6 spring leaf plug might provide a firmer contact.
post #25 of 173
Thread Starter 
Given the way this looks:
http://cgi.ebay.ca/12-pairs-of-Nakam...3A1|240%3A1307

I would say it's 6...correct me if I'm wrong.
post #26 of 173
I checked with the seller...and it is 6.

I had bought some Lowe's banana plugs that are basically the same style at these Nakamichi plugs - double set screw with 6 leafs on the plug...

The Lowe's plugs definitely gave a tighter connection than the Monoprice plugs I have. The downside is the Lowe's plugs cost approx $4 per pair when buying the 5 pair pack, so I returned them.

These Nakamichi plugs can be had for approx $2 per pair shipped, so they're much more appealing.
post #27 of 173
Thread Starter 
should i just say the hell with it and get the nakamichis?
post #28 of 173
I'd say it comes down to personal preference.

So far I've worked with both the closed screw and open screw type Monoprice plugs, the Lowe's set screw type plugs, and the Blue Jeans Cable compression type plugs.

For connection to the speaker wire, I like the set screw style (I've connected them to 14 and 16 awg wire), but I think all of the plugs I've tried work just fine. The BJC plugs are a nicer style of compression plug because they have a "slug" insert that tightens down on the folded wire.

My biggest gripe with the Monoprice plugs is that plug end not connecting as firmly to the binding post as others. I think the BJC plugs were the best for this, followed by the Lowe's plugs.

I am thinking about getting some of the Nakamichi plugs since they seems to be just like the Lowe's plugs, but cheaper.
post #29 of 173
The same ebay seller has these Nakamichi plugs as well:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...m=180318796175

Just like the 0534B, but with a plastic barrel - so non-conductive outside and no need for heat shrink.
post #30 of 173
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by alphaiii View Post

The same ebay seller has these Nakamichi plugs as well:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...m=180318796175

Just like the 0534B, but with a plastic barrel - so non-conductive outside and no need for heat shrink.

they don't ship to canada! I sent him/her a message to see if they can.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Speakers
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Speakers › Nakamichi or Monoprice (banana plugs)