AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › Unsatisfying results with Audyssey
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Unsatisfying results with Audyssey

post #1 of 53
Thread Starter 
Just re-ran Audyssey on my Onkyo TX-SR606 amp since I just got a new BIC VK12 subwoofer. Followed the directions in the "Audyssey Setup Guide" document on the forums to the letter. I keep getting weird results that I was hoping someone could shed some light on.


First off, the speaker levels keep getting set to very low values -- most stuff is -7dB or so. I find I have to turn the volume way up when watching TV or movies to hear anything. My room is only about 14x14x12 and the receiver is at 35ish to make things audible. Here's what it decides on:
L: -7
C: -8
R: -8
SR: -7
SL: -9
LFE: -11

Second, whatever it's doing with the equalizer is causing ridiculous hiss. When I set the EQ to off or flat, it sounds much better. I confirmed that prior to the test running I have all the audio options at off/default (no weird EQ, dialogue boost, cinema mode, night mode, DRC, etc.)


Lastly, it is over-estimating my rear speaker distances by several feet. I have to dial it back down a bit. I think it might have to do with how I've got them turned at about a 30 degree angle?


What am I doing wrong here? I have actually done the "IntelliVolume +8dB" trick and it isn't enough.

My setup:
Onkyo TX-SR606
Polk R50 (f) -- tilted inwards very slightly
Polk CSi (c)
Polk R15 (r) -- tilted at about 30 degrees
BIC VK12 (sub) -- about one foot away from each wall in a corner
post #2 of 53
I suggest posting this over in the Official Audyssey thread in the amp/receiver section, you'll get a lot more traffic there.

I can comment on a couple of minor aspects to your situation. None of the settings you do before running Audyssey matter because they are ignored by Audyssey. Also, whatever distance Audyssey sets your speakers at you should leave it there whether you think it's accurate or not. Audyssey is setting that distance in an effort to make all of your speakers sonically similar, when you change it you're throwing off its readings.

I have no idea what is causing your Hiss, that's why you should post the question in the other thread. One of the head guys from Audyssey frequently posts over there and might be able to help.
post #3 of 53
I believe that your speakers are set the way they are such that at 0dB (reference level) your speakers will be playing at 85dB (THX reference levels).

Negative numbers such as yours indicate that your room/speaker combination is "efficient".
post #4 of 53
TheGSRGuy, I also have had some disappointing results with Audessy, but it wasn't because of the 'weirdness' you're experiencing. Mine is more of being unsatisfied with the EQ curve being applied. Here's a graph showing my mains, with analog in, 'flat', Audessy, and NAD EQ curves.

Notice the HF rolloff in the upper end. I don't have a current graph, but right now I've added a SMS1 sub EQ to take care of that lump in the bottom end, and only use the x-over and time alignment in my preamp. It's much closer to a 'true' flat response.
I've heard that the mic placement during the EQ phase is critical, but I tried several different positions, and they all rolled off the top end too much. I'm trying to get NAD to sell me their 'installer' kit, so I can manually tweak the internal curves. I'm not holding my breath on that one...
post #5 of 53
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by fsrenduro View Post

I suggest posting this over in the Official Audyssey thread in the amp/receiver section, you'll get a lot more traffic there.


Ha, I did and two people were in the middle of some flamewar apparently...my comment went unanswered after a few pages of bickering. Silly.


I re-ran Audyssey again. The couch is pushed up against the back wall and the guide says you get better results by having the mic at least a foot away from the wall, so I slid the ouch forward slightly. It seemed to help a tad, but I still needed to bump the surround level down by 2dB on LS and RS. Also angled the center speaker up ever so slightly with a thin book, and that corrected my muffled dialogue problem.

On the last calibration my strange hiss has gone away...maybe it had picked up some strange background noise or whatever. My damn neighbors are noisy at times.

I'm still thinking I need to just go for dipoles/bipoles in back instead of the monopoles, but we'll see.
post #6 of 53
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by biomed_eng_2000 View Post

I believe that your speakers are set the way they are such that at 0dB (reference level) your speakers will be playing at 85dB (THX reference levels).

Negative numbers such as yours indicate that your room/speaker combination is "efficient".


Care to elaborate? I've never heard that negative numbers are "efficient" in that setup.
post #7 of 53
Are you mounting the mike onto a tripod and aiming it straight up while maintaining absolute silence during the tests....I mean nothing...no HVAC running....quiet as you can make your house.....do it at 3 am if needed~!
post #8 of 53
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by theelviscerator View Post

Are you mounting the mike onto a tripod and aiming it straight up while maintaining absolute silence during the tests....I mean nothing...no HVAC running....quiet as you can make your house.....do it at 3 am if needed~!

I am setting it on the top of the cushion of the couch. That puts it within 3 inches of ear location, and points it straight up.
post #9 of 53
./dev/null (lol, I still laugh at that username )

What software are you using?

btw, Im not an audyssey fan at all, I tweek outside of Audyssey.
post #10 of 53
Quote:
First off, the speaker levels keep getting set to very low values -- most stuff is -7dB or so. I find I have to turn the volume way up when watching TV or movies to hear anything. My room is only about 14x14x12 and the receiver is at 35ish to make things audible. Here's what it decides on:
L: -7
C: -8
R: -8
SR: -7
SL: -9
LFE: -11


How do you set your volume before you run audyssey..do you use any SPL meter to determine 75dBs?
post #11 of 53
Quote:
I am setting it on the top of the cushion of the couch. That puts it within 3 inches of ear location, and points it straight

Could be the couch mounting...I use a tripod and its out of the way of any furniture (higher then the coach).
post #12 of 53
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheGSRGuy View Post

Care to elaborate? I've never heard that negative numbers are "efficient" in that setup.

As long as your speaker trim levels aren't at their limits you are good. In my Onkyo Pro 885 those limits are +/- 12 db. I'll assume your Onkyo has the same +/- 12 db trim limits so your settings seem fine. You could bump up your sub's volume control a smidgeon if you wanted to.

When you run Audyssey it sends out a tone that it knows is 75db and bypasses all settings within your receiver. When that sound gets to the microphone Audyssey immediately knows how much it needs to boost or trim the levels for each speaker to get it to 75db (hence your settings). A problem arises when you hit the trim limits because you don't know how far from 75 Audyssey got before it hit the limit.

After Audyssey sets your trim limits it makes it so that when your volume is set to Zero you are at reference levels. Any number on your Onkyo volume control (i.e. -25) is then that number of decibels below reference.

My 885 has a function within the menu items that allows me to adjust the level of different inputs (TV, DVD, Blu-Ray) so that they are close to equal. This way when I go from one input to another it isn't a jarring change in volume. If you feel you have to turn the TV volume up you could try increasing the input level for the TV input on your receiver (not sure if the 606 has this function).
post #13 of 53
penngray, I'm using Fuzz Measure for the Mac, with an Earthworks TC30 mic running through a MOTU Traveller. Fuzz Measure uses a swept sine, instead of pink/white noise. That's how it's able to get the step response as well.

As to the username, not too many people get it... Not sure why...
post #14 of 53
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by penngray View Post

How do you set your volume before you run audyssey..do you use any SPL meter to determine 75dBs?


It's my understanding that it doesn't matter where you put the volume knob.

And in reference to your tripod suggestion, that is not what Audyssey recommends -- you're supposed to get close to ear-height.
post #15 of 53
Quote:


It's my understanding that it doesn't matter where you put the volume knob.

...you're supposed to get close to ear-height.

Yes, the unit should be setting itself to correct levels.

Placement of the mic? I tried on the back of my couch, then on a pile of pillows(ear height), then on a mic stand(also at ear height). None made an appreciable difference. When I get a chance, I'm going to try running my TC30 through a mic pre, into my unit. See if the mic really does make a diff.
post #16 of 53
I too have experienced low volume issues with my new (refurbed) 805, similar to those in the 805 thread. Even with 525 wpch and 97 dB sensitive speakers I couldn't get peaks above 95...no matter where the volume was.
I followed all of the audyssey set up recommendations, 8 measurements, my room is heavily treated, 2 floors underground and dead quiet.

I took out the 805 and replaced it with my yammy and wow...blows the house down. What a giant waste of money the reciever is. I noticed there are two for sale, here, today. Wanna bet that goes up a lot?
post #17 of 53
Quote:
Originally Posted by /dev/null View Post

Yes, the unit should be setting itself to correct levels.

Placement of the mic? I tried on the back of my couch, then on a pile of pillows(ear height), then on a mic stand(also at ear height). None made an appreciable difference. When I get a chance, I'm going to try running my TC30 through a mic pre, into my unit. See if the mic really does make a diff.

Are you using the TC30 to run the Audyssey calibration? If so you should be using the supplied mic as it is specifically calibrated for the receiver/processor.
post #18 of 53
Thread Starter 
It is setting my center channel to "full range". It's a Polk CSi25 -- two 5.25" woofers and a 1" tweeter. Supposedly rated to 55Hz but I doubt that.

It picks 80Hz for the surrounds, which are R15s -- a single 5.25" woofer each, rated to 65Hz.

This would lead me to believe that the center should probably be set at 80Hz too...or should it stay at full range?
post #19 of 53
All your speakers should be set to small.

This will allow the high resolution subwoofer MultEQ to be applied and off-load distortion causing bass from your mains.

From: http://www.audyssey.com/faq/index.html#largesmall
"Audyssey recommends changing the speaker setting to Small manually after the calibration is finished."
post #20 of 53
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by biomed_eng_2000 View Post

All your speakers should be set to small.

This will allow the high resolution subwoofer MultEQ to be applied and off-load distortion causing bass from your mains.


I don't have MultiEQ, just the intro-level Audyssey 2EQ. The LPF of LFE is set to 80Hz, per the instructions.

My fronts are full-range Polk R50 towers with dual 6.5" cones and can hit down to 24Hz (though it's likely something more like 60 or 80). I was under the impression that you should pick full range if the speakers are bigger ones, but set everything else to small.
post #21 of 53
Thread Starter 
Okay, so what crossover settings DO I use for the different channels? I do not have LARGE/SMALL.

There's Full Range, 40, 50, 60, 80, 100, 120, 150, 200Hz.

I picked 80 for all the speakers and left the LPF of LFE at 80Hz. That should prevent any gaps.
post #22 of 53
Quote:


Are you using the TC30 to run the Audyssey calibration? If so you should be using the supplied mic as it is specifically calibrated for the receiver/processor.

No, I've used the supplied mic, but as I said, I've been unhappy with the results. I'm curious to see what an actual calibrated mic does. Some people have postulated that the mic calibrations vary.
post #23 of 53
Thread Starter 
Audyssey claims the mic is accurate to 2dB, which is better than most handheld SPL meters.

2dB is damn good. Not even sure I could detect anything better. I would be curious to use an Audyssey MultiEQ amp instead for this...get more measurements or something. SR706 time? Heh.
post #24 of 53
Quote:


It's my understanding that it doesn't matter where you put the volume knob.

And in reference to your tripod suggestion, that is not what Audyssey recommends -- you're supposed to get close to ear-height.

Yes, it does get to that level, of course I like to verify everything!

And yes close to ear-height is the correct setup BUT coach/pillow, etc could be causing issues. I do a lot of measurements with my system and I always found that any mic should be have complete 'free air' around it so a tripod is the best solution. Heck I try to get out of the room too.
post #25 of 53
/dev/null, Im still curious about what software you use?

it doesnt look like REW or RTA.
post #26 of 53
Fuzz Measure Pro is the software. Instead of a steady-state noise like pink noise or white noise, which covers the entire spectrum at the same time, the software uses a swept sine wave. The audio [sweep] is sent from the computer to the receiver. The computer uses the mic to compare what it's sending to what it's receiving, and draws the representative graph. Because it only sends a sweep when you tell it, it's able to determine timing differences as well.
If you look at the bottom graph, you'll see that it's volts vs. time. The red trace is my preamp in full analog mode, and the 30ms delay is the result of the input A/D converter on the mic. Also notice, that when the digital processing on the preamp is turned on(blue, purple and green traces), there is an additional 50ms delay because of the preamps' DSP.
The top graph is standard frequency vs. power. Multiple sweeps can be displayed at the same time, to show differences in the results.
The sweeps are adjustable for duration and start/end frequency, as well. For example, the full analog pass(red), was run from 1hz to 96khz. the other passes were 1hz to48khz, as my preamp (NAD 175) uses an internal 96k sample rate, so anything higher would be truncated.
As to the mic and A/D it's using, the mic is flat well out above 20k, and the MOTU Traveller was sampling at 192khz.
post #27 of 53
Thank you!!

EDIT: ah crap, its for macs Maybe I will look at running it through VMware.
post #28 of 53
Quote:
Originally Posted by /dev/null View Post

As to the username, not too many people get it... Not sure why...

I've been a programmer since the early 1980s so I definitely get it.

--Ethan
post #29 of 53
Thread Starter 
Sign on my desk reads: "Please direct all comments to /dev/null". :-D
post #30 of 53
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheGSRGuy View Post

Okay, so what crossover settings DO I use for the different channels? I do not have LARGE/SMALL.

I picked 80 for all the speakers and left the LPF of LFE at 80Hz. That should prevent any gaps.


Am I right with this?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Audio theory, Setup and Chat
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › Unsatisfying results with Audyssey