I received an Oppo BDP-83SE as a Christmas gift from my wife and kids. Prior to that we were using a 2007 vintage 60GB PS3 for Blu-Ray duty until it went belly up as early PS3's BD drives are famous for doing.
The PS3 frequently had problems reading Blu-Ray disks but continued reading DVD's, SACD's, and DVD's to the bloody end. Some were dirty and cleaning helped. The rest seemed to be related to a manufacturing defect in either the disk or the failing PS3 drive. So, I expected the Oppo to be a big improvement. It's three years newer technology than the PS3 and it's received rave reviews as a Blu-Ray and audio drive. I expected better read capability and error correction. So far, it's been flawless with any sort of audio format. But, in two weeks I've encountered two Netflix BD disks that refuse to read certain portions of the disk. One was visibly dirty with a fingerprint. However after cleaning, it still refused to read. The second had no problem visible to the naked eye.
So, are Blu-Ray disk manufacturers simply not exercising quality control in the production process? Are these tightly packed little slabs of data extremely sensitive to even tiny physical flaws or dust and dirt? Is the error correction standard inadequate? Does the Oppo suck like the PS3? Am I the only one experiencing problems? It's frustrating to spend a lot of money on technology that fails on a regular basis. I can easily see this being another nail in the coffin of physical media for me. Once the quality of streaming media reaches acceptable levels, there will be no reason to own a BD player or a bunch of hyper sensitive disks.
The PS3 frequently had problems reading Blu-Ray disks but continued reading DVD's, SACD's, and DVD's to the bloody end. Some were dirty and cleaning helped. The rest seemed to be related to a manufacturing defect in either the disk or the failing PS3 drive. So, I expected the Oppo to be a big improvement. It's three years newer technology than the PS3 and it's received rave reviews as a Blu-Ray and audio drive. I expected better read capability and error correction. So far, it's been flawless with any sort of audio format. But, in two weeks I've encountered two Netflix BD disks that refuse to read certain portions of the disk. One was visibly dirty with a fingerprint. However after cleaning, it still refused to read. The second had no problem visible to the naked eye.
So, are Blu-Ray disk manufacturers simply not exercising quality control in the production process? Are these tightly packed little slabs of data extremely sensitive to even tiny physical flaws or dust and dirt? Is the error correction standard inadequate? Does the Oppo suck like the PS3? Am I the only one experiencing problems? It's frustrating to spend a lot of money on technology that fails on a regular basis. I can easily see this being another nail in the coffin of physical media for me. Once the quality of streaming media reaches acceptable levels, there will be no reason to own a BD player or a bunch of hyper sensitive disks.
























