Quote:
Originally Posted by truck-a-sauras 
eh, this is debatable. Weight shifts are too small and I doubt the balance board has that kind of precision. You really shouldn't be shifting weight or swaying during a swing. picture an imaginary stripper pole running vertically up through your body. You should be rotating around that axis, not making any weight shifts perpendicular to that axis (which is the type of motion the balance board detects I think)
There are torque points (knees,feet) for the lower body during the swing hence cleats and Tiger's constantly blown out knee, but could the balance board really sense that kind circular motion around the axis I mentioned. I don't have a balance board so I don't know how well it works, why I listed this as debatable.
at best it would destroy your real life golf swing and give you bad habits like the horrible swaying hip motions.

eh, this is debatable. Weight shifts are too small and I doubt the balance board has that kind of precision. You really shouldn't be shifting weight or swaying during a swing. picture an imaginary stripper pole running vertically up through your body. You should be rotating around that axis, not making any weight shifts perpendicular to that axis (which is the type of motion the balance board detects I think)
There are torque points (knees,feet) for the lower body during the swing hence cleats and Tiger's constantly blown out knee, but could the balance board really sense that kind circular motion around the axis I mentioned. I don't have a balance board so I don't know how well it works, why I listed this as debatable.
at best it would destroy your real life golf swing and give you bad habits like the horrible swaying hip motions.
The BB is VERY sensitive. It has pressure sensors.....weight scales.....at the four corners. It can figure weight shifts but not torque. There is a balancing test where you standing on it and try to keep your weight "centered" on it. It is very difficult to keep it in the targeted range as the board is that sensitive.
Your’s is one philosophy for one type of swing....a more “stacked” position, but it’s far from a universal consensus. You can also easily have a weight shift without a sway. A simple turn without any sway WILL change the pressure distribution under the feet....left to right....front to back.....depending on your spine angle and second axis tilt.
Most players set their weight at address more to the left or right depending on the club and the shot. Most players shift some weight to the inside of the back foot on the backswing, some specifically to the inside back heel, and then shift it to the left heel at the start of the downswing. This is more pronounced with the longer clubs and more subtle with the shorter clubs. Some have very subtle shifts, like Aaron Baddely, and some have large shifts like Nicklaus and Miller. Most great player finish the follow through with about 90 percent of their weight on the their front foot no matter the club. All this would be very easy to measure. Even if you wanted NO weight shift, the BB could pick up if fail to stay "centered".
It’s moot anyway. The reality is that the board is too narrow and even if it wasn’t, it would be extremely complicated to implement. Plus, would anyone really want it?











a golf game that would be THAT realistic would be very cool...






