AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Speakers › Help me choose... Klipsch or Polk
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Help me choose... Klipsch or Polk

post #1 of 49
Thread Starter 
I have been building a very modest and budget friendly Home theater for the last 5-6 years, and am in the upgrading state again. It all started with a Rear projection Set a few years ago and simple entry level sony 5.1 Audio System. Starting last year we started upgrading again when our Sony AV Receiver broke down on us. It was replaced with a Onkyo TX-SR505 that again forced us to pick up a new Polk PSW10 powered sub too as the Onkyo receiver ONLY supports a powered sub and our old Sony sub was powered from the old Sony receiver. The Onkyo 505 has proved to be adequate and the PSW10 was one of the best decisions I have ever made. Then later that year we picked up a Blu-ray player with a deal that we couldn't pass up. This Blu-ray player started to show the limitations of our aging Rear Projection unit and we opted to pick up a Sharp LC52D64U to take its place earlier this year. Needless to say, these few upgrades have got me going again and I am ready to start working on the surround sound again and that is what leads me to these questions... Which should I get when budget and space both play a huge role in the decision?

I have been looking at a few speaker packages from Polk and one in particular from Klipsch. The Polk options for me are the RM20, the RM75 and the RM85 that fall into the range that I would like to spend. Now unless I am mistaken it seem that all three packages include the exact same Center channel speaker, does anyone know this for a fact? And, if not which package has the best center channel? And is it just me or are the rear speakers shaped awful weird in the RM85 package, with speakers pointing in two directions? Is this a good thing or a bad thing in a rear channel like this? And last but not least with the RM20 and the RM85 being the same price $399.99 at amazon.com, which is the better package seeing as how the RM20 is on sale and was originally $799?

The one Klipsch package that falls anywhere close to my price range is the Klipsch Synergy Quintet III line. Amazon currently lists them at $525. Would I be able to hear $125 worth of improvement by picking up this bottom line Klipsch package?

I guess I should also add that since my receiver is a 7.1 that the two front channels (no matter what brand I go with) may/could be moved to the surround back channels in the future if I decide to add a couple towers to the front channels. Oh an one last question... I have only looked at package deals like this because it seems to be more cost effective. But would parting it out slowly and buying separates be a better tactic?

Thanks in advance...
post #2 of 49
I would check out THESE for $399 and just keep your existing sub if you're satisfied with it. These speakers are better than any of the sets you listed, although what matters is if you like the sound of them. Great quality and performance for your money though.
post #3 of 49
+1 for Energy speakers. The sound they produce defies the prices they are currently available for.
post #4 of 49
Thread Starter 
Some people crack me up... That is not what I asked... I WILL BE buying either Klipsch or Polk as they are what I have available to demo around here. Any thoughts on the packages that i ACTUALLY mentioned? Thanks...
post #5 of 49
Thread Starter 
Really? All these brains at work here and no thoughts? Nice...
post #6 of 49
sarcasm is it's own reward, do your own research and auditions. You might be able to determine which sounds better without any input from our "brains".
post #7 of 49
Quote:
Originally Posted by xboxFreak View Post

Really? All these brains at work here and no thoughts? Nice...

That's a nice attitude you've got there...well, have fun learning the hard way on your own.
post #8 of 49
c'mon, folks. How about some honest opinions? - it won't hurt.

Among the mentioned Klipsch and Polk packages (all 5.0 versions, w/o a sub, correct?) I pick RM20. At the same price as the current RM85, they are just "more speaker" for the money, and Quintet III set is a bit overpriced at $525.
post #9 of 49
I'm a noob here, and I even think the attitude you are copping is ridiculous. If you can audition the systems you are considering yourself, then YOU are the best person to determine which is of the most value to YOU. You are the best person to decide if the $125 difference is worth it.

If you come into a forum asking for advice between multiple systems, you have to expect to get recommendations for what people think are better values. If you don't want to hear about other options, be clear on that fact and don't cop attitude when someone attempts to HELP you.
post #10 of 49
Quote:
Originally Posted by xboxFreak View Post

Really? All these brains at work here and no thoughts? Nice...

all you mentioned suck!

hows that.
post #11 of 49
Thread Starter 
I just find it highly frustrating when I can browse these forums and see you all rant over newbie questions and off topic subjects but when someone comes along with legitimate questions, they get ignored. I didnt mean to offend but it is frustrating. Sorry for the sarcastic attitude...
post #12 of 49
Seeing as you probably won't be pushing them to reference levels either will do just fine. I have owned Klipsch speakers for 20 years, I haven't had an ounce of problems with any of them. They were top of line when I bought them so I push them pretty hard. I can't speak for Polk but Klipsch has good customer service.
post #13 of 49
I forgot to add... What sounds best to you? That kind of answers your question.
post #14 of 49
Thread Starter 
Okay, if I am being cooperative and looking in the Energy direction... The package you linked me to in the 2nd post is a little large for me right now. But I managed to look up this smaller/cheaper package and wanted to know what you all though about it. I will most likely inquire about these in the Energy owners thread too...

Amazon (can you tell Im a BIG Amazon fan? lol) has the Energy Take Classic 5.0 Package for 199.99 right now. Now when you guys were suggesting Energy as a brand to be looking toward, were you saying all models of Energy were great, or only compared to the two packages I had listed. Let me know what you think of this package as Energy is completely new to me... Thanks...
post #15 of 49
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bluedevilfan View Post

I forgot to add... What sounds best to you? That kind of answers your question.

Well I can only hear these at our Best Buy store and it is all just display. I wanted to know if anyone had heard any of these first hand in a theater room/living room setting...
post #16 of 49
I have the Polk RM10 with Onkyo 605 and they sound fabulous.
I can only assume that the RM20 is at least as good.
post #17 of 49
Quote:
Originally Posted by xboxFreak View Post

Okay, if I am being cooperative and looking in the Energy direction... The package you linked me to in the 2nd post is a little large for me right now. But I managed to look up this smaller/cheaper package and wanted to know what you all though about it. I will most likely inquire about these in the Energy owners thread too...

Amazon (can you tell Im a BIG Amazon fan? lol) has the Energy Take Classic 5.0 Package for 199.99 right now. Now when you guys were suggesting Energy as a brand to be looking toward, were you saying all models of Energy were great, or only compared to the two packages I had listed. Let me know what you think of this package as Energy is completely new to me... Thanks...

I've never heard them, but it's my understanding that Energy makes good speakers in general, not just some specific lines. That seems to be a good price on the system you found on Amazon. My question, then, is what would you be doing for a sub? Do you need the speaker setup to come with a sub, or do you have one already you can use if you get a speaker setup without one? Also, if you don't mind me asking, why is the tower package from earlier in this thread too big for you?
post #18 of 49
Quote:
Originally Posted by xboxFreak View Post

Well I can only hear these at our Best Buy store and it is all just display. I wanted to know if anyone had heard any of these first hand in a theater room/living room setting...

Best Buy should have a return policy. See if you can take the Klipschs' home try them out...if you don't like them return them immediately and take the Polks home.
post #19 of 49
Quote:
Originally Posted by xboxFreak View Post

Well I can only hear these at our Best Buy store and it is all just display. I wanted to know if anyone had heard any of these first hand in a theater room/living room setting...

Make sure your auditions are in YOUR theater/living room setting with an exchange policy. I think you could arrange something at Best Buy. Your room is part of your sound reproduction system and they are all different.
Attitudes around here vary because we all have our own bias....we all have our own and varied hearing.
Good luck shopping and make it fun.
post #20 of 49
Since you built the system you have now over 5 years, why not start upgrading piece by piece over time? I'd hate to get one of those package deals just because the price is right and you can get it all at once.

If you listen to mostly movies I'd go for Klipsch. If you're into a lot of 2 channel music I'd go Polk.

Are you open to buying used? I'm sure you can find some good deals on used Reference series towers and go from there. Check your craigslist or stores for demo models. Last month I sold a pair of RF-62's for $300. Those would be a decent speaker to build around. This week went my RC-62 for $300. Down the road you'd have a nice front stage for only $600. I've heard the Quintet (sounded good) and this setup would eat it for breakfast.

I actually had that same sub paired with them and it sounded good for HT (with a pair of bass shakers under the couch for extra punch).

Good luck with whatever you decide.
post #21 of 49
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by fireman325 View Post

My question, then, is what would you be doing for a sub? Do you need the speaker setup to come with a sub, or do you have one already you can use if you get a speaker setup without one?

I have already been forced to pick up a powered sub last year and wend with the PSW10 and am LOVING it, it works great in my current living room. The Sub being Polk is the main reason for me looking in the Polk direction for the rest in the first place...

Quote:
Originally Posted by fireman325 View Post

Also, if you don't mind me asking, why is the tower package from earlier in this thread too big for you?

My current living room just doesnt have the room for the towers right now. That is why I was looking for a 5.0 setup, where I could move the front right and lefts to surrounds backs in the future and add a couple decent towers when we moved to a new house...
post #22 of 49
@OP,

Two different types of speakers and styles. The Klipsch speakers are horn-loaded speakers. Some people love horn-loaded speakers and some don't. The Polk's should feel a little more laid back and "warmer" and the Klipsch speakers will have more volume to them and should feel brighter to you. I personally prefer Polk speakers to Klipsch, only because I find horn-loaded speakers to be a little fatiguing to my ears. I would definitely set aside some time and try and compare these two sets of speakers back-to-back and try and listen as long as you can.
post #23 of 49
Oh yeah, I would also recommend listening to some larger bookshelf speakers as well from Polk, Klipsch, Deftech, etc at your local Best Buy (especially if they have a Magnolia store). Try to use an Onkyo reciever when you demo them. It may very well be worth your while to step up to some nicer bookshelves for your fronts (left, center, right) and then save up for some satellites. You always want to make sure your fronts are the same speakers and are timbre matched. IMHO, I would go this route (spending that $500 or so on slightly larger and better bookshelf speakers). BTW, what are the dimensions of the room that these are going in (length, width and height)?
post #24 of 49
Thread Starter 
the room is around 14' wide, 20' long and about a 8' high ceiling...
post #25 of 49
Quote:
Originally Posted by xboxFreak View Post

the room is around 14' wide, 20' long and about a 8' high ceiling... I will throw together a quick sketch...

That is a pretty big space. I would definitely recommend stepping up to some bigger bookshelves for now. With you budget, you should have some options (but you can probably only get your mains for now). Check out some local stores and demo them. If the prices at the local stores are out of reach, check online for some deals.
post #26 of 49
At 2240 cubic feet, it's a shame you can't squeeze some towers up front, but some good bookshelves would do quite well also. Given the size of your room, I have to second ack_bk's advice about looking at bigger bookshelves for your front stage for now, and adding surrounds later as the budget allows. In the long run, I think you'd be much more satisfied.
post #27 of 49
Klipsch, of course bing that they would be more than Adiquite (I hate that word) to fill the room, with rich sound.
post #28 of 49
Thread Starter 
hmmm... Energy is starting to sound better, based on some reviews i have read. I have read of people taking back Polk and Klipsch speaker sets and picking up the Energy 5.1 Take Classic Home Entertainment System which Amazon is currently selling for $399.99. From what i gather, this is just the newer model replacing the older Energy Take Classic 5.0 models. What do you guys think?

http://www.amazon.com/s/qid=12405097...65836,n:172563
post #29 of 49
People seem to like it a lot, but I've never heard it for myself.
post #30 of 49
Quote:
Originally Posted by xboxFreak View Post

Here is a quick CAD sketch of the room and HT layout. You can see the reason I dont have room for towers on the front wall right now. Also, feel free to comment on my speaker placement and if it can be done better in the given space (note the "possible" mounting areas). I MAY be able to get away with bookshelfs for the front right and lefts IF they can be wall mounted above the 6' tall entertainment center and aimed down accordingly...

Wow. That is a tough space to work with. Ideally you want your tweeters being at ear level for your mains. If you having them sitting on top of a 6' tall entertainment center pointing down, that is definitely not ideal. Can the bookshelf speakers be placed inside those component towers so the tweeters would be about ear level? Also, where do you do your main viewing/listening? From the couch or the loveseat?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Speakers
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Speakers › Help me choose... Klipsch or Polk