AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › Front speaker distance and imaging
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Front speaker distance and imaging

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
I had a whole page typed out but AVS decided to log me out and I lost it all


Basically I just wanted to know what you guys thought about the distance between the two fronts and if the fronts should be toe-in on the listener or just positioned flat?

I was talking with a very knowledgeable and schooled installer and he said there is a formula to use for the distance of your two fronts.

Distance of TV divided by 1.428 = distance between two speakers

I tried this last night ans was surprised at the results. I have always kept the viewing distance and the distance between both speakers the same. Also I started thinking about the rule of thumb of turning the fronts inward or toe-in. Cinema's don't do this why should I? So I tried this also, turning the speakers outward from the toe-in position that I originally had and now set to a flat plane. Again I was surprised at the results. It seemed to fill the room up better and not as focused. Sweet spot still seemed to be there just better IMO. I don't know, this is totally not what I've been taught in the past and seems a little strange, but I like the results thus far.

Whatch think?
post #2 of 11
If it works....

... who are we to argue. I too keep my fronts aimed forward (more side reflection) but I haven't set any distance as precisely.
post #3 of 11
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MLKstudios View Post

If it works....

... who are we to argue. I too keep my fronts aimed forward (more side reflection) but I haven't set any distance as precisely.

Well I wasn't sure if there was any "scientific reason" I should do anything otherwise.

I get board with my setup sometimes and have to tinker.....ha,ha. My wifes Uncle has a large living room with 20ft ceilings and his setup is very mediocre with a late 90s Yamaha ProLogic receiver, Paradigm center, subwoofer and surrounds, with old, old Norman Lab towers that are falling apart. I just laugh everytime I hear it because it sounds so good for what it is. I think his room has everything to do with it. Its so lively and full sounding.
post #4 of 11
Speaker placement, room treatments and etc. will have a lot more affect on the sound you hear than what a new receiver will do.
post #5 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by BrentSP View Post

Basically I just wanted to know what you guys thought about the distance between the two fronts and if the fronts should be turned inward or just positioned flat?

Toe-in is a good thing.

Quote:


I was talking with a very knowledgeable and schooled installer and he said there is a formula to use for the distance of your two fronts.

It might be a good starting point. Speaker positioning is never exact because rooms are never exact. Neither are your preferences.

Quote:


Distance of TV divided by 1.428 = distance between two speakers

I tried this last night ans was surprised at the results. I have always kept the viewing distance and the distance between both speakers the same.

Quote:


Also I started thinking about the rule of thumb of turning the fronts inward. Cinema's don't do this why should I?

I'm not sure that we can pick up all of our ideas about regular listening rooms from very large rooms. But, toe-in is a good idea.

Quote:


So I tried that also turning the speakers outward set to a flat plane. Again I was surprised at the results. It seemed to fill the room up better and not focused. Sweet spot still seemed to be there just better IMO. I don't know this is totally not what I've been taught in the past and seems a little strange but I like the results thus far.

It is amazing how audible even small changes to loudspeaker position and/or listening position can be in some rooms.

As someone else pointed out quite correctly, changes in speaker position can easily be far larger than something you might think was a biggie, like changing to a new receiver.

If you get bored with the sound of your system, re-orienting and/or moving speakers around can be a big help.
post #6 of 11
Everyone is right, your room determines a lot. Having said that - I have tried almost every speaker-placement configuration there is and the best I've worked with is toe-in. What I do is establish an intersecting point about a foot behind the center listening spot (a foot behind my head). All 5 speakers are aimed there - simple as that. Granted, the 2 surrounds are 3 feet above ear level, the 2 mains are at ear-level, and center is angled down to the listener. I have a long narrow rectangular room so this helps in avoiding reflections. Pretending that I didn't have any walls to worry about I might still use this setup. Having all speakers fire in the same place creates the superb imaging on axis. Even if you're sitting slight to the left or right, your ears will still recognize the imaging, only a little bit to the side. I find that the sound is tight and well-balanced like this.

I find that speakers facing straight forward might be more ideal for a much larger room with a wider listening area. Different speakers different layouts. My experience with straight-forward is that the imaging sometimes collapses to whichever speaker you're sitting most in-line with, but then again you get a wider soundstage which can be more immersive. It's a tradeoff, but i've found the best balance is with what I described above.

As for your comments about movie theaters. No they usually don't toe-in speakers. Then again the speakers used in theaters I can only assume have a way of evenly dispersing sound so that you might get the same effect sitting in the center as you would a little off-axis. Just my thoughts.
post #7 of 11
Thread Starter 
My living room is 20' long X 19' wide with 10' ceilings so I guess 3800 cubic feet. I now have the two front towers positioned 9ft apart with each of the subs in the front next to each tower. The main seating position is 13ft. L/R surrounds are in-wall mounted in the ceiling as are both back L/R surrounds.

This is the best its ever sounded bar none!
post #8 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by BrentSP View Post

Distance of TV divided by 1.428 = distance between two speakers

Whatch think?

+1 for me. I was having a lot of imaging problems until I tried this. Things are must better now. Thanks for posting this.
post #9 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by BrentSP View Post

I
Basically I just wanted to know what you guys thought about the distance between the two fronts and if the fronts should be toe-in on the listener or just positioned flat?

You want to toe-in the front speakers to reduce side-wall reflection intensity which will confuse imaging. If they're too hot in the treble on-axis you can toe them in beyond where they point at the listener.

Quote:


I was talking with a very knowledgeable and schooled installer and he said there is a formula to use for the distance of your two fronts.

The usual starting point is with an equilateral triangle. There's no good reason to have the speakers even with the display since this leads to reflections off it. There are good reasons to move the speakers closer, notably to reduce the relative level of front-wall reflections, delay the reflections, push the first SBIR null out of the main speaker's pass-band, and to increase the level of the speakers relative to the reverberant field.

The greater of 4' and half the distance to the listener are good starting points for speaker to front wall spacing.
post #10 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Napoleon D View Post

As for your comments about movie theaters. No they usually don't toe-in speakers. Then again the speakers used in theaters I can only assume have a way of evenly dispersing sound so that you might get the same effect sitting in the center as you would a little off-axis. Just my thoughts.

Are horns still prevelant in theaters?

A lot of newer designs implement waveguides over the dome tweeters, thereby widening the sweet spot.
If yours have them, you still could try toe in.
If side wall reflections are a problem, you can use absorbers.
post #11 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by BrentSP View Post

I was talking with a very knowledgeable and schooled installer and he said there is a formula to use for the distance of your two fronts.

Distance of TV divided by 1.428 = distance between two speakers

Hmm. That's a speaker angle of 71* degrees. 60 degrees (equilateral triangle) comes up a lot for stereo speaker setup. 71 degrees doesn't ring a bell. Maybe somebody got their trig. wrong? (hope it wasn't me!)

- Terry
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Audio theory, Setup and Chat
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › Front speaker distance and imaging