Originally Posted by Mark the Red
First off, let me say I enjoyed Prometheus. I didn't expect it to be like Star Trek: The Motion Picture, whereby I could go an take a 30 minute smoke break, come back and not really miss anything.
Yes the people on board did do some stupid things as many have stated. But were the crew on the Nostromo (Alien 1) really geniuses by comparison? This is the same crew who sent their captain (by himself) into a duct to 'scare' a 15ft tall super-predator away, using a piddly-ass flame thrower with an effective range of a zippo lighter? Great idea. Pure Davinci society material guys. Not to mention nobody even tried to kill the damn thing when it burst out of John Hurt's gut just because Ash said no? The crew of the Nostromo were pants-on-head retarded by comparison to the Prometheus crew.
Umm...no, not great points. I need to watch it again, and someone correct me if I'm wrong, but two points regarding the Dallas duct scene: 1. A flamethrower seemed like the best weapon option they had available. They had no idea that the Alien was pretty much fire resistant unlike other living organisms. 2. I'm pretty sure they still had no idea that is was already a fully grown alien.
Regarding the chesburster scene, it was obvious that they were in an immediate state of shock (just like the audience when they watched it for the first time). And being that they had just witnessed the creature before squirt out acid upon being cut, I'm pretty sure most people would be reluctant to do much within those few seconds, especially with only having a freaking dinner knife or fork!!
The people on wild kingdom or whatever are professionals that know what exactly they are dealing with, they are not toying or taunting a completely unfamiliar species. You guys are really stretching for your justifications.
Edited by maintman - 6/12/12 at 3:58pm
First off, let me say I enjoyed Prometheus. I didn't expect it to be like Star Trek: The Motion Picture, whereby I could go an take a 30 minute smoke break, come back and not really miss anything.
Yes the people on board did do some stupid things as many have stated. But were the crew on the Nostromo (Alien 1) really geniuses by comparison? This is the same crew who sent their captain (by himself) into a duct to 'scare' a 15ft tall super-predator away, using a piddly-ass flame thrower with an effective range of a zippo lighter? Great idea. Pure Davinci society material guys. Not to mention nobody even tried to kill the damn thing when it burst out of John Hurt's gut just because Ash said no? The crew of the Nostromo were pants-on-head retarded by comparison to the Prometheus crew.
Quote:
Originally Posted by zoey67 
Yes, exactly and great points. Ok since this was probably thee most complaint allow me to further the obvious. 1st of all people the crew have been sleeping for 2 yrs. When you wake up, your body, muscles, nerves, brain, motor function are NOT 100%, kinda like when your butt or leg goes numb when it's been the same place for too long. And when going out to the caves to do some exploration is like a prisoner who's been let out so they there's all kinda of god knows emotions, adrenalin, anxiety, etc that's going through their minds. Don't you recall when you've been inside for a long time for some reason like snow storm and allowed to go outside later you have compulsions and act stupid doing daring things you would not normally do in a far out foreign land and time.
2nd that guy with the buzz cut who freaked out you can't fault him. Again, they're on a place millions miles from home under duress, stress so everyone reacts and responds to pressure differently. And the botanist who petted that snake again he's a lover of nature so of course to the average person that may seem hap hazard. How many times have you watched wild kingdom or the crocodile hunter and they have handled animals you would think is crazy. Well to him that's the same mind process.

Yes, exactly and great points. Ok since this was probably thee most complaint allow me to further the obvious. 1st of all people the crew have been sleeping for 2 yrs. When you wake up, your body, muscles, nerves, brain, motor function are NOT 100%, kinda like when your butt or leg goes numb when it's been the same place for too long. And when going out to the caves to do some exploration is like a prisoner who's been let out so they there's all kinda of god knows emotions, adrenalin, anxiety, etc that's going through their minds. Don't you recall when you've been inside for a long time for some reason like snow storm and allowed to go outside later you have compulsions and act stupid doing daring things you would not normally do in a far out foreign land and time.
2nd that guy with the buzz cut who freaked out you can't fault him. Again, they're on a place millions miles from home under duress, stress so everyone reacts and responds to pressure differently. And the botanist who petted that snake again he's a lover of nature so of course to the average person that may seem hap hazard. How many times have you watched wild kingdom or the crocodile hunter and they have handled animals you would think is crazy. Well to him that's the same mind process.
Umm...no, not great points. I need to watch it again, and someone correct me if I'm wrong, but two points regarding the Dallas duct scene: 1. A flamethrower seemed like the best weapon option they had available. They had no idea that the Alien was pretty much fire resistant unlike other living organisms. 2. I'm pretty sure they still had no idea that is was already a fully grown alien.
Regarding the chesburster scene, it was obvious that they were in an immediate state of shock (just like the audience when they watched it for the first time). And being that they had just witnessed the creature before squirt out acid upon being cut, I'm pretty sure most people would be reluctant to do much within those few seconds, especially with only having a freaking dinner knife or fork!!
The people on wild kingdom or whatever are professionals that know what exactly they are dealing with, they are not toying or taunting a completely unfamiliar species. You guys are really stretching for your justifications.
Edited by maintman - 6/12/12 at 3:58pm










![Alien [Blu-ray]](http://cdn.avsforum.com/6/6a/50x50px-ZC-6aa4eef9_B004RE29T0-51Wt7n6YsRL.jpeg)

![Alien vs. Predator [Blu-ray]](http://cdn.avsforum.com/8/8d/50x50px-ZC-8dda5c15_B000K0YLLY-516X2CK9ZSL.jpeg)








What about

