AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Plasma Flat Panel Displays › The Official Plasma Input Lag Thread.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Official Plasma Input Lag Thread. - Page 8

post #211 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by varkeast View Post

I tested a Samsung 2011 PN59D7000 using a variety of modes against a mistubishi diamond CRT and using SMTT from frito:

I took 3 pictures in each mode, and tested movie, relax, and standard w/ game mode enabled all through my receiver, i also tested standard w/ game mode with the PC directly attached to the TV to make sure the receiver was not introducing any more lag. Attached is one of the Game mode direct shots (sorry so big, only way to read the monitor)



I didnt see much change between modes, all averaged around 38-40ms
First number is the decimal on TV, second is on Monitor, 3rd is the delta

Movie + receiver
80 108 28
608 654 46
312 353 41
Average 38.3333333333333

Relax + receiver
426 473 47
970 1012 42
279 316 37
Average 42


Game + Receiver
165 199 34
113 151 38
606 649 43
Average 38.3333333333333


Game Direct
854 889 35
85 119 34
unreadable
Average 34.5

That seems fairly high for a plasma.
post #212 of 691
That's what I was thinking
post #213 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by spoons View Post

That seems fairly high for a plasma.

I was thinking the same thing. I have tried various methods and keep coming up with the same values around 30ms. I made sure all the settings that might introduce lag are disabled. I have tried using a laptop utilizing it's LCD and using the flatpanelshd timer. There are the occasional fluke shots that show around 15ms, but a far greater number around 30
post #214 of 691
How are you splitting the signal? If you are just using dual outputs on your video card, it's possible some of the lag is on one of the outputs.
post #215 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by LastQuestion View Post

Panys usually have 16-20ms input lag. A few have had 30ms but the difference between 30 and 16 is basically imperceptible. As has also already been pointed out the Samsung achieves 16ms by turning off basically all post-processing which results in a poorer PQ when compared to a pany which would have input lag that's basically just as low. It should also be noted that the THX mode with gt/vt series of panys gives true-to-life color while also maintaining that same very low input lag. You'd no doubt have to get the samsung professionally calibrated to get good color in game mode. Panys give you the best out of the box performance and picture, period.

I thought the BEST picture quality is achieved by turning off all "post-processing" and calibrating.
post #216 of 691
That is weird because on my Sammy LED B8500 without game mode on the set was unplayable

On this 51D7000 with game mode OFF, I feel no lag that detracts from my gaming experience in MLB the show
post #217 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by obveron View Post

How are you splitting the signal? If you are just using dual outputs on your video card, it's possible some of the lag is on one of the outputs.

For all the testing i was using a 720p signal since the monitor i have to test against won't support 1080p, so maybe it is delay introduced in scaling the image

Using a PC with a radeon 5750 utilizing dual outputs:
HDMI to tv, dvi-rgb to CRT monitor

Using a laptop with unknown video card:
hdmi to tv, laptop LCD
post #218 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by varkeast View Post

For all the testing i was using a 720p signal since the monitor i have to test against won't support 1080p, so maybe it is delay introduced in scaling the image

Using a PC with a radeon 5750 utilizing dual outputs:
HDMI to tv, dvi-rgb to CRT monitor

Using a laptop with unknown video card:
hdmi to tv, laptop LCD

Good post. I think the fact that it was 720p might introduce some lag when upscaling

I cannot detect any major lag when using standard or movie mode in my D7000

I do not use game mode at all and that is a first for me since all other LED LCD sammy's have always needed game mode to be playable.
post #219 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977 View Post

Good post. I think the fact that it was 720p might introduce some lag when upscaling

I cannot detect any major lag when using standard or movie mode in my D7000

I do not use game mode at all and that is a first for me since all other LED LCD sammy's have always needed game mode to be playable.

Yea i'm not sure if game mode really does much or not on these plasmas. my (probably delayed) tests showed it was about par w/ movie mode as long as all the "enhancements" are disabled. game mode seems like it just forces standard picture mode, and cranks up the sharpness and edge enhancement feature. By default game mode really looks like trash with all the fake sharpness and edge enhancement.

I am LOVING COD on this thing, its like a whole new game after my 6 old 720p samsung dlp, no extra lag noticeable there.
post #220 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by varkeast View Post

Yea i'm not sure if game mode really does much or not on these plasmas. my (probably delayed) tests showed it was about par w/ movie mode as long as all the "enhancements" are disabled. game mode seems like it just forces standard picture mode, and cranks up the sharpness and edge enhancement feature. By default game mode really looks like trash with all the fake sharpness and edge enhancement.

I am LOVING COD on this thing, its like a whole new game after my 6 old 720p samsung dlp, no extra lag noticeable there.

Quick question, what settings do you turn off when gaming
post #221 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977 View Post

Quick question, what settings do you turn off when gaming

I cant remember exactly off the top of my head, but i think everything was already off except the following:

edge enhancement
black tone

pretty much any of the settings that can be disabled, i disable
post #222 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977 View Post

That is weird because on my Sammy LED B8500 without game mode on the set was unplayable

On this 51D7000 with game mode OFF, I feel no lag that detracts from my gaming experience in MLB the show

The 8500 has pretty much the worst lag I've ever seen on a set. Which is why I do not game on mine. Home mode on or off. It's to slow. Amazing picture. But horrid lag.
post #223 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by JukeBox360 View Post

The 8500 has pretty much the worst lag I've ever seen on a set. Which is why I do not game on mine. Home mode on or off. It's to slow. Amazing picture. But horrid lag.

I was able to game on it with game mode ON, but not with it off

I am sure the game mode had input lag but it did not bother me when playing games that I play like shooters and baseball games.

With my new Sammy Plasma I do not even need to engage game mode and I feel no input lag that would hamper my gaming (Very happy with that)
post #224 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977 View Post


I was able to game on it with game mode ON, but not with it off

I am sure the game mode had input lag but it did not bother me when playing games that I play like shooters and baseball games.

With my new Sammy Plasma I do not even need to engage game mode and I feel no input lag that would hamper my gaming (Very happy with that)

I play a ton on cod. The lag was just messing me up lol. Samsung plasma sets are great for gaming. But the 8500 is just horrid. I don't think they planned on having people game on this set. Super high price. It does an amazing job for movies.
post #225 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by JukeBox360 View Post

I play a ton on cod. The lag was just messing me up lol. Samsung plasma sets are great for gaming. But the 8500 is just horrid. I don't think they planned on having people game on this set. Super high price. It does an amazing job for movies.

Yea it is a great set, but one thing that it cannot match to the D series plasmas is the color accuracy.

But that B8500 is the best LED ever till this day.
post #226 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977 View Post

Yea it is a great set, but one thing that it cannot match to the D series plasmas is the color accuracy.

But that B8500 is the best LED ever till this day.

Really? The new sets are that good?! I might have to take a look at them then. How's the black level? Input lag? I've been thinking of getting something to replace my 8500. But I haven't seen anything worthy enough to replace it's amazing picture.
post #227 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by JukeBox360 View Post

Really? The new sets are that good?! I might have to take a look at them then. How's the black level? Input lag? I've been thinking of getting something to replace my 8500. But I haven't seen anything worthy enough to replace it's amazing picture.

The black levels are amazing on this set, not like my Kuro Elite but better then the B8500 which is to be expected from a plasma. (Even though the B8500 for an LED had terrific black levels)

But is the color accuracy and the uniformity of the screen that I love. From any angle this tv looks the same. And as CNET put it the color accuracy is now their bench mark for testing other sets

I first bought a Best Buy display of the C8000 plasma and it was great but gaming was horrible without game mode.

I then returned it for the D7000 to get 1 more inch for 51" and tested my COD and MLB the show without game mode and felt like game mode on the C8000 plasma I returned. That made me happy to have the ability to not have to engage game mode to enjoy gaming on this set.
post #228 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977 View Post

The black levels are amazing on this set, not like my Kuro Elite but better then the B8500 which is to be expected from a plasma. (Even though the B8500 for an LED had terrific black levels)

But is the color accuracy and the uniformity of the screen that I love. From any angle this tv looks the same. And as CNET put it the color accuracy is now their bench mark for testing other sets

I first bought a Best Buy display of the C8000 plasma and it was great but gaming was horrible without game mode.

I then returned it for the D7000 to get 1 more inch for 51" and tested my COD and MLB the show without game mode and felt like game mode on the C8000 plasma I returned. That made me happy to have the ability to not have to engage game mode to enjoy gaming on this set.

What! Better blacks then my Sammy! Are you 100% on that!? If that's true I'm listing my tv for sale right now lol. The blacks are unbelievable on this thing. I can't imagine better. Other then KURO.
post #229 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by JukeBox360 View Post

What! Better blacks then my Sammy! Are you 100% on that!? If that's true I'm listing my tv for sale right now lol. The blacks are unbelievable on this thing. I can't imagine better. Other then KURO.

Go watch the cnet review for the 51D8000

And the viewing angles and refresh rate are incredible as well

The Panny has better black levels then the B8500

The B8500 has the best on any LED I have ever seen
post #230 of 691
Thread Starter 
Thanks Varkeast, I'll add it to the OP. Your Game Mode results are about what would be expected, but it's strange you're not seeing a big increase in Movie Mode.
post #231 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977

Go watch the cnet review for the 51D8000

And the viewing angles and refresh rate are incredible as well

The Panny has better black levels then the B8500

The B8500 has the best on any LED I have ever seen
Idk if the rating is old but the 8500 says it has the darkest blacks of any tv aside from a kuro. Must be becuase the review is old?
post #232 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by JukeBox360 View Post
Idk if the rating is old but the 8500 says it has the darkest blacks of any tv aside from a kuro. Must be becuase the review is old?
Yea that review is 2 years old. At that time he was right but no way are those blacks better then the D line plasma this year.

And I have both and the Kuro Elite
post #233 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by NJPapi1977 View Post


Yea that review is 2 years old. At that time he was right but no way are those blacks better then the D line plasma this year.

And I have both and the Kuro Elite

I knew the d sets were amazing. But I didn't think there blacks would he darker then the 8500. Off to the store I go.
post #234 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by JukeBox360 View Post

I knew the d sets were amazing. But I didn't think there blacks would he darker then the 8500. Off to the store I go.

They are. I put them side by side in my dark living room and the blacks are better on the D7000. No doubt about it and viewing angles FTW
post #235 of 691
This is my first post.

These are the results I have after testing my new Panasonic TC-P65GT30.

I toke a total of 21 shot for an average of 53.52 ms.

The total above was taken in game mode, but I also tested in standard mode and found the lag to be the same.

I only began to test the tv as I found I was doing badly when playing Black Ops. Over a few days I realized there was more to it than a bad ping or simply better players.

I play C.O.D at least as much as I watch tv and movies, so I will have to return this tv at great cost and effort, as I ordered it online and drove from Ontario to Buffalo to pick it up.

I thought I'd done my homework, and that Panasonic was the best bet, sadly I was wrong.

The picture and 3d are awsome on this set, Unfortunatly I can't seem to play C.O.D.

I don't know if the screen size (64 inch) makes a difference.

On a whim I tested my old Hitachi 57SWX20B and it had multiple shots at 0 ms lag and, one shot that showed 10 ms.

I used to think I was pretty good at C.O.D, now I wonder if it's just my old tv.
LL
LL
LL
post #236 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by chudsmith View Post

This is my first post.

These are the results I have after testing my new Panasonic TC-P65GT30.

I toke a total of 21 shot for an average of 53.52 ms.

The total above was taken in game mode, but I also tested in standard mode and found the lag to be the same.

I only began to test the tv as I found I was doing badly when playing Black Ops. Over a few days I realized there was more to it than a bad ping or simply better players.

I play C.O.D at least as much as I watch tv and movies, so I will have to return this tv at great cost and effort, as I ordered it online and drove from Ontario to Buffalo to pick it up.

I thought I'd done my homework, and that Panasonic was the best bet, sadly I was wrong.

The picture and 3d are awsome on this set, Unfortunatly I can't seem to play C.O.D.

I don't know if the screen size (64 inch) makes a difference.

On a whim I tested my old Hitachi 57SWX20B and it had multiple shots at 0 ms lag and, one shot that showed 10 ms.

I used to think I was pretty good at C.O.D, now I wonder if it's just my old tv.

wow thats a horrible time. You had motion smoother off, right?? I know that adds to the lag.

Also after looking at the fist page of this thread, I see a ST30 was tested and had pretty good timing. 15~30ms
post #237 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by chudsmith View Post

This is my first post.

These are the results I have after testing my new Panasonic TC-P65GT30.

I toke a total of 21 shot for an average of 53.52 ms.

The total above was taken in game mode, but I also tested in standard mode and found the lag to be the same.

I only began to test the tv as I found I was doing badly when playing Black Ops. Over a few days I realized there was more to it than a bad ping or simply better players.

I play C.O.D at least as much as I watch tv and movies, so I will have to return this tv at great cost and effort, as I ordered it online and drove from Ontario to Buffalo to pick it up.

I thought I'd done my homework, and that Panasonic was the best bet, sadly I was wrong.

The picture and 3d are awsome on this set, Unfortunatly I can't seem to play C.O.D.

I don't know if the screen size (64 inch) makes a difference.

On a whim I tested my old Hitachi 57SWX20B and it had multiple shots at 0 ms lag and, one shot that showed 10 ms.

I used to think I was pretty good at C.O.D, now I wonder if it's just my old tv.

Has to be something wrong there. That unbelievingly high.
post #238 of 691
Quote:
Originally Posted by chudsmith View Post

These are the results I have after testing my new Panasonic TC-P65GT30.

Is Aero on?

Why isn't your desktop mapping 1:1 with the TV? Are you running an ATi graphics card? Overscan setting in CCC need to be set to zero.
post #239 of 691
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by chudsmith View Post

This is my first post.

These are the results I have after testing my new Panasonic TC-P65GT30.

I toke a total of 21 shot for an average of 53.52 ms.

The total above was taken in game mode, but I also tested in standard mode and found the lag to be the same.

I only began to test the tv as I found I was doing badly when playing Black Ops. Over a few days I realized there was more to it than a bad ping or simply better players.

I play C.O.D at least as much as I watch tv and movies, so I will have to return this tv at great cost and effort, as I ordered it online and drove from Ontario to Buffalo to pick it up.

I thought I'd done my homework, and that Panasonic was the best bet, sadly I was wrong.

The picture and 3d are awsome on this set, Unfortunatly I can't seem to play C.O.D.

I don't know if the screen size (64 inch) makes a difference.

On a whim I tested my old Hitachi 57SWX20B and it had multiple shots at 0 ms lag and, one shot that showed 10 ms.

I used to think I was pretty good at C.O.D, now I wonder if it's just my old tv.

Yea like Wermy mentioned, it sounds like you might have forgotten to turn off the motion interpolation feature Chud. I forget what exactly they call it, Motion Smoother or something. I believe it has an Off/Weak/Mid/Strong setting or possibly Off/Low/Med/High--could be buried in the menus somewhere. Obviously you'll want it off for measuring, and be careful when switching inputs or picture modes (e.g. HDMI 1 Vs. HDMI 2, Game Vs. Standard), it may keep a separate memory for each one and wind up turning itself on without you noticing as you change stuff around. Those values you posted would be pretty unexpected if accurate, and quite a ways off from the NA ST and EU ST/GT/VT. They do however line up with some of the Motion Smoothing tiers.
post #240 of 691
Hey guys, thanks for your suggestions. I think they helped.

I checked everthing mentioned except the overscan setting, but I will tonight.

When I first got the TV, I had made sure motion smoothing was off, but when I checked this morning I found it set to weak. I turned off the motion smoothing and it made a HUGE difference - closer to 20 ms. I will re-test and post new pics tonight.

For some reason the motion smooting seems to turn itself back on. Any suggestions on how to lock it off?

Thanks again. I think you may have saved me a lot of grief and disappointment.

Greg
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Plasma Flat Panel Displays
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Plasma Flat Panel Displays › The Official Plasma Input Lag Thread.