AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Plasma Flat Panel Displays › Panasonic 11G/12G/13G black levels have seemingly doubled overnight?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Panasonic 11G/12G/13G black levels have seemingly doubled overnight? - Page 156

post #4651 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by jackal2001 View Post

Question about Infinite Black Feature.

I set my tv to vivid on an input that wasn't being used. The tv didn't do anything. It just sat there at a well blackish screen. I didn't see it change like the tv turned off.
I have a tech coming out to look at my tv for something else Thursday. Is this infinite black feature documented anywhere that I can point them to it?
Has anyone gotten anything replaced in their tv to fix this yet?

I have commented on this a couple of times. I used the infinite black problem along with the IR to get panny to send a tech to my house. I am waiting on parts to be replaced. Infinite black is a well advertised "feature" of this set. If it doesn't work they have to fix it regardless of whether it is a useless feature or not.
post #4652 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by donnymac51 View Post

I have commented on this a couple of times. I used the infinite black problem along with the IR to get panny to send a tech to my house. I am waiting on parts to be replaced. Infinite black is a well advertised "feature" of this set. If it doesn't work they have to fix it regardless of whether it is a useless feature or not.

OK but what I want to know is this documented anywhere. When the tech comes to my house to flash the firmware again, i don't think it is going to do anything, i want to tell them about the IB feature. He won't know anything about it, so i need to show him in some documentation what it is supposed to do so I can get that looked at as well.
post #4653 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by jackal2001 View Post

OK but what I want to know is this documented anywhere. When the tech comes to my house to flash the firmware again, i don't think it is going to do anything, i want to tell them about the IB feature. He won't know anything about it, so i need to show him in some documentation what it is supposed to do so I can get that looked at as well.

I don't believe they explain how it works. It's just a marketing term. I'll be happy to be wrong on this.

Going to read this AFTER I post it here.
http://www.avforums.com/forums/plasm...e-explain.html
post #4654 of 10800
I just tried this:
set non-used input to vivid
turned tv off
waited
turned tv on.
tv was on for about 10 seconds.... then...
tv picture turned off/flicker off for about1 second then went back on.

it seems random as i can't reproduce it to do that all the time.

anyway my tv shows 218:40 hrs on it. I'm guessing since I had tried flashing with the THX firmware that didn't do anything and that reset the timer. Either that or because my Aboard was replaced.

Yes I did see that other website already and read it. Not really documentation though.

I'm still using your SM offsets and settings, Audiotitis.
post #4655 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by jackal2001 View Post

Sorry I haven't been following this thread from the start. I've been in the THX thread all the time.
So you are saying that 1.28 broke infinate black feature across the board. Every TV that has 1.28 infinite black doesn't work anymore???

Some people here are stating that theirs still works.

Firmware 1.28 seems to have "broken" this feature, making it work one time, and not another. It may work sporadically. All S1 sets, in which the 1.28 firmware doesn't apply, have a fully functioning IB feature. In every case of a broken IB function, firmware 1.28 is installed.
post #4656 of 10800
Mostly, for me, it's about the pursuit of objectivity and trying to slice through the horrendous fog of this thread with its absurd signal-to-noise ratio.[/quote]

I haven't heard signal-to-noise-ratio in a long time, CTB - Composite Triple Beat was another catch phrase. Apologize for being off topic just had a way back moment.
post #4657 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by Audiotitis View Post


Excuse the pun - But I'm not advocating it of course. Its just info.
http://www.lemonlawclaims.com/Panaso...s%20Action.htm


Typical ambulance chaser
post #4658 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by jackal2001 View Post

I just tried this:
set non-used input to vivid
turned tv off
waited
turned tv on.
tv was on for about 10 seconds.... then...

tv picture turned off/flicker off for about1 second then went back on.

it seems random as i can't reproduce it to do that all the time.

anyway my tv shows 218:40 hrs on it. I'm guessing since I had tried flashing with the THX firmware that didn't do anything and that reset the timer. Either that or because my Aboard was replaced.

Yes I did see that other website already and read it. Not really documentation though.

I'm still using your SM offsets and settings, Audiotitis.

Well they did not say how long the IB would last. Works as designed. Thank you for contacting Panasonic

Btw, my IB does not work too. Not sure if it worked prior to 1.28(a).
post #4659 of 10800
Well this thread was enough for me, bundling back up my 46G10 and sending it back to Amazon. The picture is fantastic, but I can't see dropping $1k on a tv and holding my breath that the black level doesn't rise, or Panasonic eventually comes out with a fix. This was my 3rd Panasonic plasma going back to the EDTVs, but looks like that streak is over. If Panasonic had issued some kind of press release that they were really looking into it, I would definitely keep it.

Any recommendations for 42-50" alternatives? Samsung plasmas seem to be the best alternative for the price, unless you can scrounge up a kuro?
post #4660 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by mattmull5250 View Post

Well this thread was enough for me, bundling back up my 46G10 and sending it back to Amazon. The picture is fantastic, but I can't see dropping $1k on a tv and holding my breath that the black level doesn't rise, or Panasonic eventually comes out with a fix. This was my 3rd Panasonic plasma going back to the EDTVs, but looks like that streak is over. If Panasonic had issued some kind of press release that they were really looking into it, I would definitely keep it.

Any recommendations for 42-50" alternatives? Samsung plasmas seem to be the best alternative for the price, unless you can scrounge up a kuro?

Depending on how much you want to spend, you could still probably snag a Kuro on ebay or possibly Best Buy.

You could also wait for the new Samsungs...should be out shortly.
post #4661 of 10800
my 50s1 with 988 hours showed .019, .019, .018 on the 3 initial runs I did with my new i1 LT. I'll do another run later tonight and give it a bit more time to warm up..this was just a real quick and dirty run through to test out hcfr. also had a bit of IR from the window patterns so I don't know if that threw off the readings or not. If they are indeed accurate readings it would seem mine has risen slightly. To my eyes I don't really see a difference from when the set was new. I did think some scenes in Lost looked washed out the other week though.


Edit: later readings with more warm up time measured .016. I'll wait till I've done more to give what I feel is an accurate number.
post #4662 of 10800
thanks for the data your readings fit the pattern for what we would expect for a 50" set with 500+hrs, somewhere btwn 0.015-0.020...

still no data to contradict the hypothesis that this affects ALL sets (at least sub-58" ones) -- I am curious how many people who think they don't have the issue are like you, and simply weren't bothered by it. This supports D-Nice's earlier statements that it's the "human factor".

not to start a panic seems you are still happy with the set, and the PQ is still great overall. It does continue to raise the issue of what is "normal" and whether Panasonics needs to worry, since the vast majority of their customers probably would never notice the difference between 0.008 and 0.018...
post #4663 of 10800
well, I'd recommend holding off on adding it to your data set until I can do another run through tonight. As I said, this one was quick and dirty so I think i was a little short of 30 minutes warm up on the meter and I'm going to insulate it better for the meter calibration before doing the run through. I don't think it'll make a huge difference, but we'll see.

and yes, still very satisfied with the set. now, if it continues to rise through .20 and closer to .30, my mind might change
post #4664 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by mustangs1 View Post

Firmware 1.28 seems to have "broken" this feature, making it work one time, and not another. It may work sporadically. All S1 sets, in which the 1.28 firmware doesn't apply, have a fully functioning IB feature. In every case of a broken IB function, firmware 1.28 is installed.

Just curious, where did you get your information from? I'm asking, not because I doubt you, but because I asked a similar question about G10's (I have a 42G10) and some G10 owners responded that their infinite black feature is indeed still working after the Viera Cast 1.28 firmware update.

When you say firmware 1.28, are you referring to the Viera Cast update or the 1.28 THX fix that requires an update through the service menu?

If you're referring to the Viera Cast update, do you have any information on if the 1.28 THX fix makes the infinite black feature work again?
post #4665 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by batpig View Post

It does continue to raise the issue of what is "normal" and whether Panasonics needs to worry, since the vast majority of their customers probably would never notice the difference between 0.008 and 0.018...

kinda my point from earlier... see this thread for info on that

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1227535
post #4666 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by prozak View Post

Just curious, where did you get your information from? I'm asking, not because I doubt you, but because I asked a similar question about G10's (I have a 42G10) and some G10 owners responded that their infinite black feature is indeed still working after the Viera Cast 1.28 firmware update.

When you say firmware 1.28, are you referring to the Viera Cast update or the 1.28 THX fix that requires an update through the service menu?

If you're referring to the Viera Cast update, do you have any information on if the 1.28 THX fix makes the infinite black feature work again?


My infinite black has always worked. I just recently did the 1.28a(SD cardTHX fix) and it still works.

I just ordered my i1lt to measure my 0IRE to add to bdemers data.
post #4667 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert Zohn@************** View Post


I spent a lot of time at Panasonic's CES exhibit and viewed their demo of the new 2010 Infinite Black dedicated demo room. They had the Infinite Black directrly next to the current V10 in a almost totally black room. Both panels looked very good, but to my surprise I liked the current V10 pq better. It had more detail in the image and the black level was extremly close to the 2010 Infinite Black model.

I'm at the show with 2 of my kids and we're working on uploading all of our photo's so stand by for the link.

-Robert

Replace deaf with def below
http://www.highdeafjunkies.com/showt...Infinite-Black

Love this comment there : They could just change the name to "4 month Black Pro"
post #4668 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by SIRL0INofBEEF View Post

take it to a manager and they should understand what you are saying, and probably be able to help if it really is deffective. Plus, i doubt they are all informed on the black level problems


This is the truth....my buddy's wife is a customer service manager at BB...she says that BB will come out and fix the TV if you claim their is an issue...hell, BB will even fix Burn-In if you are stupid enough to ruin your TV in this day and age...
post #4669 of 10800
Guys with Infinite Black problems, I posted this a few pages back.

You might want to just hit your volume button after you change to Vivid on a unused input source. For some reason, it causes my IB to "kick in" and blacken the screen like the TV is turned off.

If I don't touch the volume, the IB doesn't activate.

I was going to call Panasonic to come fix it, but adjusting the volume on the remote seems to work.

I have the Vieracast 1.28 update.




Earlier post..........

Hi all,

For those having Infinite Black problems in Vivid mode try this.....

Go to an unused HDMI source. Once there turn the volume control up or down for a second an let go.....

Now does the IB kick in?

It did for me. If I just went to the unused source and did nothing else it would not kick in.....

Good luck!

BTW, at 150 hours 00IRE black level is .015 fl

Kevin
post #4670 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by defdog99 View Post

Maybe Panasonic expects everyone to use "Gamma: Normal"
while we're all using CO1's settings of "Gamma: Mid"

Sorry bro but my settings were all calibrated with gamma adjustment: normal


http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showp...&postcount=410
post #4671 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by CO1 View Post

Sorry bro but my settings were all calibrated with gamma adjustment: normal


http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showp...&postcount=410

I have a question for you. I'm trying to get my head wrapped around different aspects of calibration. Is the goal to get the set at 6500 K? At this point would it be a successful calibration? You have like 4 different sets of settings, why so many? Are those different inputs?

When I first started reading about plasmas many years ago, I remember people advocating against really high contrast settings. You and other members seem to have your settings jacked up way high; are there any pros and cons against this? Will it prematurely age the set?

I personally like fairly muted color settings I think compared to most. I usually watch in a dark room, and I like colors to look vibrant, but also to be true. I like blacks to be dark, but not crushed.

Is it hard to calibrate a TV with virtually no experience using the service manual settings and a cheap light meter?

Just curious.
post #4672 of 10800
Quote:


I have a question for you. I'm trying to get my head wrapped around different aspects of calibration. Is the goal to get the set at 6500 K? At this point would it be a successful calibration?

well, it's ONE of the goals, but the answers to those questions are really beyond the scope of this thread. There is plentiful information on the Display Calibration forum, but I suggest you start with this article (Grayscale for Dummies) as it is outstanding, it was a huge help to me in understanding calibration -- what the goals are, why you want to do it, what equipment and software you will need, and how difficult it will be:
http://www.curtpalme.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=10457

If you are reasonably technical and enjoy playing with new gadgets and can absorb new concepts quickly, it's a fun way to learn more about how your display works and optimize your PQ.

Quote:


You have like 4 different sets of settings, why so many? Are those different inputs?

to allow the user to customize settings for different sources or uses, for example the "cinema" or "movie" mode could be for critical movie viewing in a dark room, the "standard" mode for TV viewing in the daytime with the lights on, the "dynamic" mode for video games when you want it bright and oversaturated, whatever. It's just there to allow you to tweak.

For people who want a calibrated picture, they will probably never use all of these. You may have a dark-room calibration and bright-room calibration, so maybe you use two of the modes.... but the fact of the matter is the feature set of these TV's is NOT designed with the goals of a calibrator in mind! 90%+ of buyers couldn't give a crap about flat grayscale.
post #4673 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by erupted View Post

Guys with Infinite Black problems, I posted this a few pages back.

You might want to just hit your volume button after you change to Vivid on a unused input source. For some reason, it causes my IB to "kick in" and blacken the screen like the TV is turned off.

If I don't touch the volume, the IB doesn't activate.

I was going to call Panasonic to come fix it, but adjusting the volume on the remote seems to work.

I have the Vieracast 1.28 update.




Earlier post..........

Hi all,

For those having Infinite Black problems in Vivid mode try this.....

Go to an unused HDMI source. Once there turn the volume control up or down for a second an let go.....

Now does the IB kick in?

It did for me. If I just went to the unused source and did nothing else it would not kick in.....

Good luck!

BTW, at 150 hours 00IRE black level is .015 fl

Kevin

What model and size of television do you have?

I just tried doing this thing with the volume and it didn't work for me. Infinite Black still does not kick in. Some people have said that their Infinite Black is wonky, sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't.

It is really odd that this 'infinite black' feature is so buggy. I have no idea what the programming is but I thought it would have been pretty simple. In vivid mode, no input=screen off.

But a lot of people seem to have this feature broken, for some it works on and off, and now for some it works when playing with the volume button. Bizarre.
post #4674 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by CHUCKCHILLOUT View Post

When I first started reading about plasmas many years ago, I remember people advocating against really high contrast settings. You and other members seem to have your settings jacked up way high; are there any pros and cons against this? Will it prematurely age the set?

Too high of a contrast setting in the past was a surefire path to burn in but technically shouldn't be an issue with current Panasonic plasmas. Since my black level increased I get crazy IR which I fear may lead to problems down the road so my previous statement isn't 100% true if you have the BL issue. The contrast setting controls peak light output so typically for direct view displays your target is between 30 & 40 foot-lambert. That's why I have several settings, higher light out put for daytime and lower fl for a dark environment. In addition the first 3 settings have the greyscale done with just the WB under the Pro Settings for members that didn't want to enter the service menu. Ultimately I just wanted to give you guys more than one option to better suit your viewing environment or personal taste. If memory serves me correctly THX mode with contrast set to 100 only nets me approx 27fl where as Custom mode with contrast set to 79 gets me 40fl so you can see the contrast settings vary from one mode to the next. donnymac51's 50V10 with a contrast setting of 67 produces approx the same foot-lambert as my 54V10 with a contrast setting of 77 so it can also vary from one set to the next. Will it prematurely age the set? I assume one TV calibrated at 30fl would age a little slower than 40fl but 40fl shouldn't hose your set.
post #4675 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by erupted View Post

Guys with Infinite Black problems, I posted this a few pages back.

You might want to just hit your volume button after you change to Vivid on a unused input source. For some reason, it causes my IB to "kick in" and blacken the screen like the TV is turned off.

If I don't touch the volume, the IB doesn't activate.

I was going to call Panasonic to come fix it, but adjusting the volume on the remote seems to work.

I have the Vieracast 1.28 update.




Earlier post..........

Hi all,

For those having Infinite Black problems in Vivid mode try this.....

Go to an unused HDMI source. Once there turn the volume control up or down for a second an let go.....

Now does the IB kick in?

It did for me. If I just went to the unused source and did nothing else it would not kick in.....

Good luck!

BTW, at 150 hours 00IRE black level is .015 fl

Kevin

tried that too and it still doesn't work. please post your model of your tv.
post #4676 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by bucknuts07 View Post

I suggest you contact Panasonic, and demand a technician be sent to your home. A gradual increase in black level is what is reported to be acceptable. Also, the picture quality is still supposed to be fantastic. If its as bad as you say, then Panasonic is obligated to fix your issue.I had my panel replaced about 3 weeks ago due to the blacks being more of a charcol grey, but also terrible image retention that wasnt going away. A tech looked at my tv for 5 minutes, said my panel was bad , and replaced it. For the time being, my blacks look like new, plus I got them to put a new A board to fix the thx mode , for my hassle. Maybe what panasonic is stating is that yeah its in the patent that the voltage levels will raise the black level, but for people having a true grey, and washed out picture, your panel is defective. I wouldnt accept a case #, I would demand a manager if they refuse to send a tech, and if that manager wont help you, then ask for his/her manager. Maybe I have been just lucky, or something is noted in my file, because my first g10 buzzed, i went a round with them for a bit and they agreed to replace my tv, now 6 mos later with 1300 hrs i started getting terrible image retention, i called in , they sent a tech, and now I have a new panel in my plasma. If your blacks changed more than gradually, meaning it should be hard to notice, then you have a defective tv, and let them know you will not go away, until your issue is resolved. If you have to call every day, then be persistient. They cant make you quit calling. You bought a panasonic for the hardware, as well as their customer service.

To add to my problem, I am also having clouding in the corners. I will call for service, I will be moving shortly so when I finally get the TV into the new house, I'll get them in. It will not be wall mounted in the new house so that should make it easier. Now if I can just get some blackout curtains so the tech can see how bad the problems are. I might have to put it down in the basement when them come. Also last time I checked, IB was not working. TV is running 1.28 from Vcast.
post #4677 of 10800
you could probably tack something up over the window temporarily like a blanket...act like it is broken or a construction thing.
post #4678 of 10800
Prozak, batpig, CO1, et al,

For all of us novices out here with V10s or other Panasonic sets, can someone tell us exactly how to check to see if the Infinite Black is working or not.

I've seen several attemps at this on this thread but no one has documented exactly what the procedure might be.

This would help all readers of AVS Black Level Rising thread to finally see if their set is working properly and line up much more support for us to confront Panasonic with.


Thanks,

Longoak
post #4679 of 10800
Mines a 42G10. I feel your pain.

I was ready to call Panasonic, too. One night I was still trying to figure out why the IB just wouldn't work and I accidentally bumped the volume key. Once the volume indicator went away the IB kicked in and blacked out the screen.

Kevin

Quote:
Originally Posted by prozak View Post

What model and size of television do you have?

I just tried doing this thing with the volume and it didn't work for me. Infinite Black still does not kick in. Some people have said that their Infinite Black is wonky, sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't.

It is really odd that this 'infinite black' feature is so buggy. I have no idea what the programming is but I thought it would have been pretty simple. In vivid mode, no input=screen off.

But a lot of people seem to have this feature broken, for some it works on and off, and now for some it works when playing with the volume button. Bizarre.
post #4680 of 10800
Quote:
Originally Posted by erupted View Post

Mines a 42G10. I feel your pain.

I was ready to call Panasonic, too. One night I was still trying to figure out why the IB just wouldn't work and I accidentally bumped the volume key. Once the volume indicator went away the IB kicked in and blacked out the screen.

Kevin

Can you do that every time? How many times have you repeated it? I just want to be sure that it was not just a coincidence. It just sounds like very strange engineering; to have the panel light shutdown triggered by an audio command. Of course this whole programmed elevation of the MLL is also very strange engineering, so anything is possible.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Plasma Flat Panel Displays
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Plasma Flat Panel Displays › Panasonic 11G/12G/13G black levels have seemingly doubled overnight?