AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Ultra Hi-End HT Gear ($20,000+) › Long HDMI Cable Pinkies & Spotties for YCrCb only with Sim2 C3X1080
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Long HDMI Cable Pinkies & Spotties for YCrCb only with Sim2 C3X1080

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
Long 35’ HDMI cable recommendation for Sim2C3X1080

I got my projector back about April 2008 and installed a 50 foot DVI Gear Super High Resolution HDMI to HDMI cable.
The cable comes with a powered extender at the projector end.

At that time, I installed some extra thick strings and CAT5 cable, with three 1.5” plastic pipes, so that we could insert new HDMI cable or whatever through if and when the need would arise.

I also use a Lumagen Radiance, initially XD, more recently upgraded to XE. Please, in this thread lets not discuss the merits of the XD or XE vs letting the projector do all the video processing and scaling. This has already been done in other threads.

I’ve had a really good video picture ever since. But when I change channels on DirecTV and go from one scan rate like 720p to 1080i, the projector will lose sync and take 3-5 seconds to reacquire and display the picture. When I had the XD, sometimes the picture would get pinkish or be digitally spotty, but I’d turn the XD off and then on again and all would be fine. When I got the XE upgrade, with HDMI 1.3, the latter problem pretty much went away.

By the way, I tested and the above situation was the same regardless of whether the XD or XE was in the video chain.

Last night, we watched a Blu Ray movie, and all was fine. A bit later I came back and when I turned on the projector, I got the pink and digitally spotty picture and nothing I did got rid of it.

So I did some video sleuthing. The “pink spotty” problem is only when I set the XE to output YCrCb 4:2:2 or 4:4:4. If I output RGB the picture is absolutely fine. But with YCrCb, instead of using projector HDMI input 1 that I’ve always been using, I switch the HDMI cable to projector HDMI input 2. Presto. Everythings fine, YCrCb looks perfect. This makes you think the HDMI input 1 to the projector requires repair, right?

But next in my quest I use projector HDMI input 1 but connect the cable direct to the Blu Ray player or to my Integra 9.8 (connected via HDMI to the Blu Ray player), picture is perfectly fine. And when I took the DVI Gear cable connected to projector HDMI input 1 and connected it at the XE output 2 instead I had same "pink-spottie" problem at projector.

I also have the XE HDMI output 2 connected to a Sharp 32" 1080p HDTV, and both from XE HDMI outputs 1 or 2 the picture was fine YCrCb wise.

My conclusion is what Mark Haflich told me a long time ago, HDMI is real finicky. And that I should replace my current DVI Gear cable. And I can get by with a 35’ cable, not 50’ cable.

What do you recommend and why?

Thanks.
post #2 of 21
This is classic digital "cliff effect". You are on the edge with your projector being able to acquire the signal(s) without error. The fact that HDMI input 2 works probably means that path or chip inside the projector is a little less touchy. It is also possible that that input is damaged as you suspect but I doubt it.

50 feet is troublesome especially with 444 at 1080P. I also agree another cable may be the fix.

FWEIW I use a CalRad 50 foot from my DVDO VP50pro into a Panny AE3000. It has always worked flawlessly. But that doesn't mean it will work with your gear as they are different.

Unfortuantly at these legnths and resolutions it's often a crap shoot. And money doesn't always equate to better performance. My cable was about $75, not very much for a 50 foot HDMI cable.

I would stick to certified cables though.

P.S. Steve, this is how inferior or too long cables react with digital signals. We and others have argued this before but this is why I don't subscribe to better HDMI cables resulting in deeper blacks and more saturated colors. That just doesn't happen with digital signals. When the cable capacitance is high enough to cause significant HF roll off with analog signals, you lose highs in audio and detail in video. But with a digital signal, what you are seeing is what happens. The picture is still as sharp and bright as with good cables but instead has zits and breakup.
post #3 of 21
We've had a lot of luck with the Key Digital and Audioquest cables. The Audioquest HDMI A long cables use a pvc coating and is CL3 rated. I had some issues with a Digital Projection projo but after swapping the original no name cable (supplied by the client), for the Audioquest unit, all was well.
btw, it was a 12m and the price is very reasonable.
post #4 of 21
Steve, we use Ultralink for our HDMI. Never had a problem with it. They have a line of cables that are certified up to 150 ft. un-amplified. The Audioquest and Key are good also. The problem is most cables will show a collapsed waveform over too long a distance. Once the waveform collapses your done. That's what you're probably seeing. Regards, Norm
post #5 of 21
WHat Glimmie said. it is also important to mention that when a cable for a digital signal is good enough... it works. there is no better than "works" if things are problematic to not working... then the the cable is insufficient.

No cable for digital will make things better than works.
post #6 of 21
i just ordered 2 35' blue jeans hdmi cables. they are the bjc-1 belden bonded pair hdmi cables which are a bit pricey but everyone who used it has had good results. i am also going to run a couple cat6 cables as well in case the hdmi has issues and i could always use powered baluns over cat6. i would suggest trying out the blue jeans cable, i used monoprice in the past but i did have a couple with issues. hopefully won't be the case with the blue jeans stuff.
post #7 of 21
My recommendation - upgrade to the Lumis HOST with the fiber optic cables.
post #8 of 21
Quote:


But next in my quest I use projector HDMI input 1 but connect the cable direct to the Blu Ray player or to my Integra 9.8 (connected via HDMI to the Blu Ray player), picture is perfectly fine. And when I took the DVI Gear cable connected to projector HDMI input 1 and connected it at the XE output 2 instead I had same "pink-spottie" problem at projector.

I had a similar problem recently when I would manually changed my Dish output from 1080i to 720p. To make a long story short the XD was changing from Config0 to Config2 [why I don't know] when I changed the Dish to 720p. Config2 had the wrong color space and gave me a garbled picture. I reset Config0 to have the correct color space with a 720p input and haven't had a problem since.

So you may want to check that your XE is using the correct Config when DTV changes output resolution.
post #9 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by GGA View Post

I had a similar problem recently when I would manually changed my Dish output from 1080i to 720p. To make a long story short the XD was changing from Config0 to Config2 [why I don't know] when I changed the Dish to 720p. Config2 had the wrong color space and gave me a garbled picture. I reset Config0 to have the correct color space with a 720p input and haven't had a problem since.

So you may want to check that your XE is using the correct Config when DTV changes output resolution.

I did check and that's not it. Its the cable!!!@@ Most likely.

I went ahead and ordered a 35' Blue Jeans best HDMI cable. The DVI Gear I have now is 50' and its longer than I need.
post #10 of 21
do let us know if the cable resolves your issues. i am running mine inwall now, but wont be able to actually test/use them until my house is finished which will be the end of the year. im curious what your impressions will be on this cable.
post #11 of 21
Steve, I'm actually somewhat surprised that you got an older 50' cable to work at all. I'm sure the 35' one will work fine with no glitches.
post #12 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Curt Palme View Post

Steve, I'm actually somewhat surprised that you got an older 50' cable to work at all. I'm sure the 35' one will work fine with no glitches.

Curt, what do you mean by "older"? This is DVI Gear's current best model HDMI cable and since its over 12M it comes with a powered extender.
post #13 of 21
Steve, you said that you installed the cable and projector in 2008. A year ago (OK, 17 months), HDMI was still pretty flaky at 25' or more, not to mention 50'. I'd say that changes have been made to the cable in the last 18 months, even if it's still called the same thing.

But heck, I could be wrong.
post #14 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Curt Palme View Post

Steve, you said that you installed the cable and projector in 2008. A year ago (OK, 17 months), HDMI was still pretty flaky at 25' or more, not to mention 50'. I'd say that changes have been made to the cable in the last 18 months, even if it's still called the same thing.

But heck, I could be wrong.

Curt, can you give me some objective examples of this, and what cables you recommend for 1080p 60 and 24 over say 35,40, 50 feet or longer. Thanks.
post #15 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve Bruzonsky View Post

Curt, what do you mean by "older"? This is DVI Gear's current best model HDMI cable and since its over 12M it comes with a powered extender.

The powered extender is probably the problem!
post #16 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Glimmie View Post

The powered extender is probably the problem!

What do you recommend for a replacement powered extender?
post #17 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve Bruzonsky View Post

What do you recommend for a replacement powered extender?


Nothing! As said above by others, 35 feet is not a problem these days for HDMI. Even 50 feet is doable - I have a 50 foot run using a lower cost ($75)cable with no problem.

When you get into extenders I would go with fiber. Expensive but many of the CAT5 units I have tried at work do a poor job. But again a typical HT needs no more than 50 feet.

The Blue Jeans cable you ordered should be just fine provided you don't have a hardware problem inside one of your units.
post #18 of 21
Steve, I'm going by the 100s of posts over the last 3ish years on my forum regarding the HDFury. When the DVI protocol came out, I read nothing but complaints about dropped sync/signal with runs over about 10'. The solution to 'no picture' always came down to firmware upgrade issues with the source, or to use a shorter run between the DVI source and the HDFury. THe rule of thumb was to keep DVI runs short, and run a longer RGBHV cable from the Fury to the analog projector.

I'd say that about 18 months ago, longer DVI/HDMI runs became far less of an issue than before, and I did several CRT setups where the customer ran a 25'+ HDMI run without issues.

Still, even today though, the standard tech support answer when someone complains about an issue with an HDFury is: 'connect the source to the Fury to the projector with a short <6' cable and see if that works. If so, start adding your receiver, and longer cables one at a time until you find your issue.

I still think that the HDMI/DVI signal is the biggest prematurely released POS that the consumer industry has seen and been frustrated over. I'd say it was all released about 3 years too early, and I'll bet I have 1000s of frustrated installers that have lost money on repeat service calls due to the HDMI protocol that would agree with me.
post #19 of 21
In my experience, DVI Gear cables are the best you can buy at any price and are the only ones we feel confident using.

As already described, the extender is more likely to be the problem rather than the cable. If the wall wart has failed then you will still get 5V from the source device, some of these sometimes do not supply the specified 30mA (or it is below this level once it reaches the extender on very long cables). This is probably why you have no problems from some sources.

When talking about HDMI it is also very important to remember that the source and receiver ICs can have a huge impact on whether you get a picture or not. It is common for receivers to have built in correction which can lull you in to a false sense of security over the cable performance. DPI projectors have no such luxury but with DVI Gear we can get perfect 1080P60 performance up to 20m before switching to the optical cables. With most other brands - especially so called high end brands like Chord - you do well to get 10m.

The Blue Jeans is a good cable but IMO you just wasted money buying something that is not as good as what you have already got.

Neil
post #20 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by ifor View Post

We've had a lot of luck with the Key Digital and Audioquest cables. The Audioquest HDMI A long cables use a pvc coating and is CL3 rated. I had some issues with a Digital Projection projo but after swapping the original no name cable (supplied by the client), for the Audioquest unit, all was well.
btw, it was a 12m and the price is very reasonable.

I've had no good luck with audioquest cables over long distances. Use the Belden from bluejeans if you require a long passive cable. That's my universal backup.
post #21 of 21
Thread Starter 
I just got a Blue Jeans BC-1 15' cable to use simply as a test.

On HDMI input 2, works fine and identical to my in wall 50 foot with powered extender DVI Gear cable.

On HDMI input 1, identical problems as with DVI Gear cable. So apparently the problem is the HDMI receiver chip for HDMI input 1. It doesn't seem to be a cable problem.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Ultra Hi-End HT Gear ($20,000+)
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Ultra Hi-End HT Gear ($20,000+) › Long HDMI Cable Pinkies & Spotties for YCrCb only with Sim2 C3X1080