New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

u boats on riser/floor?

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
I know the Auralex site shows the u boats spaced 16 oc on every joist of the riser but what if I just used them on the perimeter joists and suspended the interior joists?

I've heard that the fewer points of contact with the subfloor the lower the Hz it absorbs.

My riser will be approximately 14' by 12' across the entire back of the room.

I am using 2x12 lumber but would like an additional inch or two in height per the riser height calculator.

Would it work well/better to build up the outer four joist with, say, 1 1/2" of dimensional lumber to mount the u boats on and give me the additional height I would like to have?

I would appreciate input from anyone with experience using u boats .

thanks

ed
post #2 of 21
You could consider the rubber isolators for the rim joists of your riser. No need in a basement, but I assume you're not in a basement since you mentioned "subfloor."

You could use 4x4s in the 4 corners and in the middle of the long runs. Lets say this raises the riser height by 10". Then build out the rest of the riser framing with 2x6 and joist hangers.

The result is a vey minimal contact riser.
post #3 of 21
Thread Starter 
minimal contact riser is better right?

This is going over a concrete slab. I just want to float the floor to improve bass response.

I may consider hooking up my buttkickers to the riser instead of the seats too.
post #4 of 21
Thread Starter 
btw, I already have the 2 x 12s purchased and sitting on site so that is the material I will be using to build the riser with.
post #5 of 21
Aha so you're really wanting the riser to act as a bass trap, then. Sorry I misunderstood.
post #6 of 21
Thread Starter 
no problem
post #7 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by edfowler View Post

I know the Auralex site shows the u boats spaced 16 oc on every joist of the riser but what if I just used them on the perimeter joists and suspended the interior joists?

I did it... Click here for a link in my build thread.
post #8 of 21
Thread Starter 
thanks a bunch for the link
post #9 of 21
I also used U boats but did not do them on 16" centers went 24" or more in some places as I wanted my sub to get my riser moving

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...4#post11585004
post #10 of 21
Can anyone tell me why u-boats should be used in riser construction? I'm going to build my riser inthe back of my theater over a concrete slab. I don't plan to use it as a bass trap, so what are the benefits of using u-boats?

CJ
post #11 of 21
I'd like to know also. I'm gathering it provides a more tactile "ride" during heavy bass scenes?
post #12 of 21
Thread Starter 
I think I want to use them in order to get a smoother bass response.

I've heard that rigid surfaces tend to magnify bass frequencies. This is why a lot of recording studios will float the floor rather than have a solid surface.

Audioguy built his third listening room with single drywall instead of dd, to improve the bass. I am also going to use single drywall in this theater build.

Any improvement in the tactile side of the equation will just be an added bonus for me.
post #13 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by carboranadum View Post

Can anyone tell me why u-boats should be used in riser construction? I'm going to build my riser inthe back of my theater over a concrete slab. I don't plan to use it as a bass trap, so what are the benefits of using u-boats?

CJ

If it is at all possible try to make it a bass trap.

You cannot have too much bass trapping and if the riser goes across the entire back of the theater it would be easy to make into a bass trap.
post #14 of 21
Thread Starter 
BTW, my first question is now moot. After a little more research I've decided to curve the front of my riser and set the steps into the curve instead of tacking steps onto the front of the riser.

With this construction it will be better to float each individual joist.

Interesting discussion on u boats however. Hope more people can chime in with their experiences with u boats and u boat like materials
post #15 of 21
Dennis wrote a pretty good article on buiding a bass trap into a riser. I don't recall that he recommended using u-boats, hocky pucks, or anything to keep it off the concrete.

CJ
post #16 of 21
Thread Starter 
I read in a post that he said to just screw it to the wall, but I did not read the article.

It would be great if he would chime in as to the reason for or against this.
post #17 of 21
I'm not thinking Dennis actually said that. I'm sure that's what the post you mentioned said, however.

Coupling the stage or riser to the walls is not great.
post #18 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by carboranadum View Post

Can anyone tell me why u-boats should be used in riser construction? I'm going to build my riser inthe back of my theater over a concrete slab. I don't plan to use it as a bass trap, so what are the benefits of using u-boats?CJ

I can only chime in with why I did it. The pro's may not agree with my rational.

1. Poured concrete floors are not all that level. They are plagued with high spot (especially on seams). Using the u-boat on the outer edges allow you level and by selective placement of the u-boats with no "rocking" on high spots.
2. The u-boats get the riser off the floor thus eliminating the need for treated lumber.
3. The way I hung the center joists, it allowed me to cover the bottom thus not having insulation I filled it with in contact with the concrete.
post #19 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted White View Post

I'm not thinking Dennis actually said that. I'm sure that's what the post you mentioned said, however.

Coupling the stage or riser to the walls is not great.

I found a copy of Dennis's article from September 03. For using the riser as a bass trap, he did say to couple the riser to the walls. "First, install a 2x8 against the back wall, gluing and screwing the 2x8 through the sheetrock to the studs. ... Next, attach the two side 2x8s to each side wall, checking for level."

There was a sepatate sidebar for tactile response equipped platforms in which he advocated not coupling the riser to a wall, and only allowing the perimeter rim joists to touch the floor (floating the remaining joists 2" off of the floor using 2x6 joists with 2x8 rim joists).
post #20 of 21
A couple of notes ...

I would not suggest screwing the rim joists of the seating platform through to the studs. It would be to the HAT channel, or studs in a double wall or staggered wall construction. That would be required where the rim joists are not resting on the floor...something has to support the weight.

Typically, we damp the entire floor and therefore anything resting on the floor is damped from the rest of the structure. We do not place devices on the seating platform which create mechanical vibrations and hence don't see a performance decrease when the seating platform is in contact with a damped floor and damped walls.

OTOH, if you're all set to muck with the director's orginal intent and install butt kickers or other devices to the seating platform and convert the seating platform into a speaker, then you would need to keep the entire seating platform away from the walls and use something like rubber "U" sleeves to isolate the framing. (Is my bias against tactile transducers showing through?)
post #21 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dennis Erskine View Post

(Is my bias against tactile transducers showing through?)

Not at all...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home