My apologies to Eldrad for hijacking his thread. Sorry, but...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rammitinski 
After the insufferably whiny and nasal Peri, my second least favorite assistant ever was the unbearably whiny and b****y Tegan (I actually disliked her just as much - she just wasn't as bad of an actress. Bad for sure - just not
as bad).
After who came before Peri, I liked her. Not great, but I certainly did NOT dislike her as you did.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rammitinski 
Nyssa was lame alright (nepotism at it's finest there - she was one of the staff's daughters or nieces), but next to Tegan, Adric and Davison, she didn't seem so bad. The whole thing about that period is they were trying to make the show as "kid-friendly" as they could get away with. Unfortunately, the original series stayed in that vein all the way to the end, and actually really started with T. Baker at the Romana I point - but really didn't get too bad until Adric and Tegan came on).
As I said, I disliked most of the Davison era. Kindred, Snakedance... Ugh. You haven't mentioned Turloug, who was the worst in my opinion. And still, in all this, there were some good episodes. Enlightenment for one.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rammitinski 
Jo Grant (with Pertwee) was sho' e'nuff cute - but that "mildly retarded, child in a woman's body" act just irritated the heck outta me sometimes.
She wasn't bad at all. I found her relatively useless, but not irritating. Some good episodes with her. Two Dalek stories, (I like them for some reason [EXTERMINAT!]) Axos, The 3 Doctors, even the Green Death, a bit.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rammitinski 
I didn't really like or dislike Mel - she was just sort of - there. I was really too busy hatin' on McCoy to pay her much mind (he was by far my least favorite of all the Doctors).
She wasn't around long enough for me to have formed a strong opinion.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rammitinski 
Rose was the only one of the new ones that would even make my list of best - except for all that schmaltzy, "lovey-dovey" crap. Could've left "the family" out, too (like the OP noted). But I did like her character otherwise. Just wish Eccleston would've stayed on.
I agree, too much affectionate attachment, and WAY too much family, and boyfriend!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rammitinski 
Nobody can touch Sarah Jane's eyes and fine, little butt, though (at least when she was young).
No disagreement on this at all. There are some scenens that still stay with me. In her last episode, after the Doctor hypnotizes her, she points to her head and says "Eldrad must live," and the Doctor spins around and looks at her closely and says "What!" to which she answers with a killer smile, and says "Just testing." That's great interaction.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
doswonk1 
Gotta agree there--Peri was so bad you have to wonder if the series got off on some sort of self-parody tangent!
Noted! I am the only one who liked Peri.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
doswonk1 
I basically missed the McCoy era--graduated from college just about that time. I did pick up most of the eps from the local public TV station a couple of years ago. So you might say I now have an opportunity to experience the, uh, Real McCoy.

I envy you. I haven't had the opportunity to see the classic Who episodes for many years (mid 90s at least).
Quote:
Originally Posted by
doswonk1 
Hanky-panky in the TARDIS? Wouldn't have done back in our day, old boy!

Yeah, even with Romana, who was at least the same species as the Doctor. This whole "Doctor falling in love with Rose, Rose falling in love with the Doctor, Martha falling in love with the Doctor," stuff was off-putting to someone who was so familiar with the classic series.