AVS › AVS Forum › Home Entertainment & Theater Builder › Dedicated Theater Design & Construction › Not too long HDMI cable issues
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Not too long HDMI cable issues

post #1 of 14
Thread Starter 
Hi everyone,

I am having a problem that I can't resolve so far. I hope some of you can offer advice. I bought a Panasonic PT-AE4000 projector. My basement is all drywalled so I ended up buying a 40' Atlona HDMI flat cable ($160) to be able to connect my receiver (Denon AVR 2310CI) to the projector. I installed the cable without testing it first, silly me, and when everyting was installed to my suprise there was no image. I tried several combinations, my various components going through the receiver, and also each component on its own, but no signal. I had to get the cable out and return it to the supplier since I assumed it was faulty. I bought from a local supplier a triple shielded HDMI cable 22 gauge 35' long which he sells to installers which I got for $95. Anyway, this time, I tested it before installing it with my Xbox and it worked well. I installed it and connected it to the receiver and to my dismay, no signal. This time, if I tried the Xbox alone (even at 1080p) I would be getting an image but if I did it through the receiver, no signal. I also had no signal from my other components (Oppo blu ray and Scientific Atlanta Cable HD box), either going through the receiver or on its own. I only got a message from the cable box when connecting it directly saying that the device I was trying to connect to was non-HDCP compliant and to try component instead. My guess is that the cable at 40' was too long and the 35' one was just at the maximum range of the Xbox; however if trying it through the receiver the signal would weaken and wouldn't be in good shape by the time it got to the projector. Another test I did was to try my 3 foot HDMI cable connecting my Oppo to the projector and I get an image.

The company that I got the local cable is getting me a powered booster to see if that will fix it. If that doesn't work, my next option is to go and try a premium cable, and if that doesn't work, perhaps it is the projector.

Any suggestions or opinions on my problem?
post #2 of 14
I think you are barking up the wrong tree. If the cable works before you run it behind drywall, then it should work afterwards too. There is something going on. See if you are putting it through tight bends that are kinking it. There could also be interference like from a power wire running in parallel with the HDMI. That should cause noise, not a blank screen. Also, it could be a really stupid mistake like setting something up wrong. Check the input on the projector to make sure you are using the right one. Sounds dumb but silly things can mess you up and it's hard for us to diagnose this over the Internet.
post #3 of 14
Why spend so much money on cables? Monoprice is a lot cheaper. I have a 35ft and a 30ft run near power wires without a single issue. Are any of your cables run parallel with wiring?
post #4 of 14
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tlllava View Post

I think you are barking up the wrong tree. If the cable works before you run it behind drywall, then it should work afterwards too. There is something going on. See if you are putting it through tight bends that are kinking it. There could also be interference like from a power wire running in parallel with the HDMI. That should cause noise, not a blank screen. Also, it could be a really stupid mistake like setting something up wrong. Check the input on the projector to make sure you are using the right one. Sounds dumb but silly things can mess you up and it's hard for us to diagnose this over the Internet.

Thanks for your comment. Sorry, I wasn't very clear with my posting. Running my 35' cable inside or outside the drywall gives me the same result. Image from the Xbox alone but not from any other component alone or through the receiver. Also, no image from the Xbox through the receiver. I also tried various combinations using the three HDMI ports on my projector.
post #5 of 14
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Remax View Post

Why spend so much money on cables? Monoprice is a lot cheaper. I have a 35ft and a 30ft run near power wires without a single issue. Are any of your cables run parallel with wiring?

I have speaker and ethernet cable together with the HDMI cable but none are connected yet.
post #6 of 14
Quote:
I bought from a local supplier a triple shielded HDMI cable 22 gauge 35' long which he sells to installers which I got for $95.

WAY too much. HDMI of that length is about $15 on amazon.com (and any other reasonable e-tailer). Decent build quality, too.

HDMI is the latest version of the Monster Cable speaker cable scam. There's nothing magic about it, other than it's ability to generate obscene profits.


As for your failure mode, the posts above are on target.
post #7 of 14
Jeez guys, how about toning down the personal crusade against over priced cables and taking a bit of effort to help the guy with his problem?

To the OP, I have an AE3000u and a Denon AVR connected with a 35' HDMI cable (a 22AWG Monoprice cable) and I have been fighting issues with the connection too. I can get the signal to pass, but it will drop out randomly and sometimes be almost impossible to keep locked on. Some nights I would spend dinking with the cables and never be able to get a singal to come through on the PJ.

I wouldn't worry that the Denon AVR isn't powerful enough to send the signal that far, mine does it just fine when the stupid connectors are seated properly. (Do make sure that you do not have a large section of the HDMI cable coiled around into a pile. If the cable is all coiled up on itself, then the signal will likely not get through.)

First and foremost, HDMI connectors are a crap design. Most times, it is not too bad to cause problems, but when you get one of these 22AWG in-wall rated cables, they tend to be very thick and heavy. It is very difficult to get the connectors to make proper contact unless your cables feed to your components just right so that there is no strain on the connection.

Before buying anything further, I would test just to make sure your AVRs HDMI circuit isn't hosed. If you have a monitor with an HDMI input handy, put it next to your AVR and hook the two together with a short, lighter weight cable to make sure your AVR is passing the signal.

If that works, then start dinking with the connectors. If possible, strain relieve the cable coming into both components. There are adaptors you can get that are built specifically for this. I've bought a couple of these:

http://www.monoprice.com/products/pr...seq=1&format=2


http://www.monoprice.com/products/pr...seq=1&format=2

The articulating adaptor helped some, the 8 port saver cable really helped a lot, but still hasn't completely eliminated the dropouts. I can wiggle one of the terminations on the 35' monoprice cable and make the signal come in and out. But it is still far from what I would call a robust connection.

-Suntan
post #8 of 14
I have a 20-25 foot cable installed in the wall. Can not recall where I purchased the cable. I have had similar problems. Cable feeds a Mitsu projector. All examples are fed with 720p. With input from Directv HD DVR I see no problems. With input from a popcorn hour there is red splotchy noise in dark scenes. With new Oppo player there is what I would call dropout snow (white noisey areas intermittently on screen). I would guess the combination of driver hardware and my cable are being marginal. I don't mind trying a different cable. I would like to know who has used a 25 foot plus cable with a popcorn hour and an oppo player with success and what brand cable was it.
post #9 of 14
Thread Starter 
Hi guys,

I installed the switch ($40) on the 35' cable and it didn't work. So, my son and I proceeded to remove the cable from the wall and tested it on the outside. We made sure that there were no kinks or coils before testing. Same results again, the only image was with the Xbox connected directly. In between the installation and the testing of the two cables I had spent about 18 hours and my whole family was giving up on having the setup ready for Christmas (this is our Christmas present). The local guy that sold me the cable told me that we could try now with HDMI over ethernet but I needed to buy the adaptors. This option didn't appeal to me. So, I ended up going to the store where I bought my projector (they also do installs - not a box store) and they told me that it certainly was the quality of the cables. They told me that their standard cable Ultralink Advanced Performance would do it. I bought a 35' ($200). We got home and tested it before setting up behind the wall and everything worked with no problems. I installed it and I had no problems the only thing I had to be careful is that it is a unidirectional cable so I had to make sure to set it up the correct way. All of the others I am returning and will get my money back.

I had done quite a bit of research before choosing Atlona but I was very disappointed since it didn't work at all. The local guy that sells cables to installers was recommended to me by a friend. In the end, length was an issue for my setup. I had read about so many other people who have had not problems with 35-50' setups in this forum but I did. My other 4 HDMI cables are 3' and paid $8 ea.

I guess I will have lot of people who will hate me but it worked for me.

Thanks for all the comments! Merry Christmas!
post #10 of 14
achi,

If it fixed your problem then thats all that matters.

In the past I have used BlueJeans [longer runs] and Ethereal and they work well.
post #11 of 14
For the amount of money that we put into these theaters, to get it working right for $200 = priceless. Enjoy.
post #12 of 14
Quote:
it is a unidirectional cable

Wire is bi-directional. Copper doesn't care what direction the electrons are moving. Unless there's an active component in there somewhere, "unidirectional cable" makes no sense.


(There is the case where you prefer to connect a single-ended shield drain to the source component ground, but I don't think that applies to HDMI.)
post #13 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by DMF View Post

Wire is bi-directional. Copper doesn't care what direction the electrons are moving. Unless there's an active component in there somewhere, "unidirectional cable" makes no sense.


(There is the case where you prefer to connect a single-ended shield drain to the source component ground, but I don't think that applies to HDMI.)

It would have been an active cable. They can use thinner wire (cheaper) and then add an equalizer to compensate.

We import and sell HDMI cables (thousands of).

For runs upto :-

15m (50 ish feet) we use 26 AWG
20m (65 ish feet) we use 24AWG

These will pass 1080p/60 without any help.

We can goto to 40m (133 ish feet) on 24 AWG if we only require 1080i/720p.

A thicker cable does not mean higher performance. It may, but since this is digital it pretty much works 100% or not at all.

The OP had a 22awg cable which should have been more than up to the task, but as it wasn't it would suggest either a faulty wire (unlikely) or a faulty connection (bad solder joint).

As an aside, the majority of Chinese manufacturers won't even offer 22AWG as a standard option. It has to be ordered to your spec. Why ?? Higher costs / no real performance gain and a stiff bulky cable that doesn't want to stay seated in the HDMI socket.
post #14 of 14
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by DMF View Post

Wire is bi-directional. Copper doesn't care what direction the electrons are moving. Unless there's an active component in there somewhere, "unidirectional cable" makes no sense.


(There is the case where you prefer to connect a single-ended shield drain to the source component ground, but I don't think that applies to HDMI.)

Thanks for your comment. Ultralink cables are directional. Not sure why but what I know is that if you don't install them in the direction established in the cable they don't work.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Home Entertainment & Theater Builder › Dedicated Theater Design & Construction › Not too long HDMI cable issues