AVS › AVS Forum › Home Entertainment & Theater Builder › Dedicated Theater Design & Construction › The Cinemar Home Theater Construction Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Cinemar Home Theater Construction Thread - Page 31

post #901 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by roknrol View Post

I agree. I was wondering how you were going to take the columns from the renders and turn them into reality. Mystery solved!

My vote for the MDF edge concealment is to use sealant, generous amounts of wood filler, then palm sander. I've used that method and also the drywall compound. The latter is quicker initially, but may (in my case -- did) develop cracks down the line.

Good point. How thick was your drywall compound? For what I was advising, it ends up being absorbed into the MDF; there's nothing to crack. Again, it depends on how close to perfect the original cuts are. If they are way off and he's filling more than maybe 1/64th", I'd be concerned that many fillers could crack, including drywall compound.

Mario, do you have a router? If so, you could use that to flush trim the front so that it's exactly matched to the sides. Might be an easy way to ensure that any filler ends up at zero thickness.

Bryan
post #902 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry M View Post

How are you attaching the fabric in the columns?

Any more details on the trim you used? Interested in the back profile

Hi Larry,

Here's a diagram showing the moulding I'm going with.



I'm still on the fence about how to tackle attaching the fabric. Especially on the sides. I'm open to recommendations.

For the sides, I was thinking of just using hot glue or contact cement to attach it to the MDF. I'm thinking stapes may fray the edge of the MDF since I only have about 1/2" of contact with the mdf to fabric.

Here's an illustration. The moulding is 3/4" and I'll finish nail it over the top of the fabric and then into the mdf.


For the lower front of the column, I have a lot more room to staple or glue the fabric. The top half grill needs to be removable. I'm planning to use a plastic speaker frame from parts-express.

I ordered the Black GOM so I'll be getting to that phase soon.

I cut all the mouldings for the first column. I became more and more efficient. I started using a finished cut moulding piece as a template to mark the next piece for cutting. The trick was to place them back to back on the floor and then use a sharp pencil to trace the cut line. This narrowed by cuts down to about two or three per moulding per side. Much easier than using the measuring tape. Then to shave off a hair, I would lower the mitre saw blade down and push the moulding against the blade. Then lift the blade up and make the cut. The teeth are a little larger, so it just shaved a smidge off the end moving me closer and closer to my finished cut. These are probably all stuff the pro's know, but being my first time. I'm learning as I go.
post #903 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by cowger View Post

Good point. How thick was your drywall compound? For what I was advising, it ends up being absorbed into the MDF; there's nothing to crack. Again, it depends on how close to perfect the original cuts are. If they are way off and he's filling more than maybe 1/64th", I'd be concerned that many fillers could crack, including drywall compound.

Mario, do you have a router? If so, you could use that to flush trim the front so that it's exactly matched to the sides. Might be an easy way to ensure that any filler ends up at zero thickness.

Bryan

Bryan,

I can definitely say that the edges are not perfect. And even with the Kreg jig, as I tightened the screws it pushed the edges a bit over their mark as I joined the pieces together. I think I'll need to clamp the MDF together next time before joing them to keep them from moving off their square. I think the hairline edge can be sanded though.

I do have a router. What type of bit are you suggesting using? The edges that I cut for the first column look pretty smooth.

Everything's going black, so I'm hoping shadows and just the overall room will hide some of the imperfections.
post #904 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

I do have a router. What type of bit are you suggesting using? The edges that I cut for the first column look pretty smooth.

Everything's going black, so I'm hoping shadows and just the overall room will hide some of the imperfections.

Awesome. My advice would be to get a bit like this:
http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?p...20router%20bit

Make your face frame about 1/8" too wide, attach the sides as straight as you can, with about 1/16" of overhang on each side, then trim it flush with that bit. Should yield perfect results every time.

Bryan
post #905 of 2757
While building speaker cabinets I do exactly what is listed above with the fluch bit. Cut the pieces about 1/8 inch too big, then use the Kreg to join them with a slight overhang and use the flush bit to trim. Makes a perfect seam every time.

I wouldn't use wood filler or dryuwall compound on the MDF or seams. It will crack. If it's possilbe to construct these columns in a well ventilated area I sugguest using Bondo. It smells horrible (think of the glue used in model cars when you were growing up) but it will seal well and when sanded will give you a SMOOTH surface. I used bondo on my curves speaker cabinets. Here is a picture of the before and after. You can see how rough the before was, and how smooth the bondo is sanded and painted.



post #906 of 2757
Larry,

You can also special order cabinets at Menard's. They will design your space for free but it does require time and thought. I must have changed our plan at least 10 times You might also want to stop by Menard's / Home Depot and grab a cabinet catalog to see what sort of cabinets, styles, hardware, and trim you're interested in. There are a ton of choices.

The extra's from mouldings to trim to real 3/4" cabinet construction can get expensive but not as much as custom cabinets. We ended up getting all of our cherry cabinets at Menard's at 20% off. I also ordered a couple of quarts of matching stain and ended up staining much of the trim and wainscoting around the bar and saved a ton of money that way.

All of this is detailed in the link below.
post #907 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by deewan View Post

While building speaker cabinets I do exactly what is listed above with the fluch bit. Cut the pieces about 1/8 inch too big, then use the Kreg to join them with a slight overhang and use the flush bit to trim. Makes a perfect seam every time.

I wouldn't use wood filler or dryuwall compound on the MDF or seams. It will crack. If it's possilbe to construct these columns in a well ventilated area I sugguest using Bondo. It smells horrible (think of the glue used in model cars when you were growing up) but it will seal well and when sanded will give you a SMOOTH surface. I used bondo on my curves speaker cabinets. Here is a picture of the before and after. You can see how rough the before was, and how smooth the bondo is sanded and painted.




Looks cool. How easy is it to work with bondo?
Would I need to bondo the entire column or just the corners?

One thing to that's in the back of my mind is that I'm not necessarily trying to make it look like the corner doesn't exist, but rather create a smooth matching finish on the cut edge so it's paintable. I want it to look like painted wood (but without the grain). If I look at my expensive kitchen cabinets, you can see where the wood panels were seamed together. But the edges are nice and flush.

I'm not necessarily looking to make it look like the columns were drywalled and there are no seams.
post #908 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Any tips/tricks for cutting the GOM and working with the large roll? It seems like it'd be challenging to get nice straight cuts with scissors.
post #909 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

Looks cool. How easy is it to work with bondo?
Would I need to bondo the entire column or just the corners?

One thing to that's in the back of my mind is that I'm not necessarily trying to make it look like the corner doesn't exist, but rather create a smooth matching finish on the cut edge so it's paintable. I want it to look like painted wood (but without the grain). If I look at my expensive kitchen cabinets, you can see where the wood panels were seamed together. But the edges are nice and flush.

I'm not necessarily looking to make it look like the columns were drywalled and there are no seams.

Bondo is fairly easy to work with. Must like Drywall compound, only you have to mix the material with a hardener and it dries solid within minutes (depending how much hardener you use). Sometimes it's 3-4 minutes, sometimes 10. It won't work well if you are trying to keep the seams of the wood and just seal the end cut MDF. It's more if you don't want to see seams. I would maybe suggest using something like pine instead. Keeps the seam, won't have to seal the end cut after sanding. Just my two cents.
post #910 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

Hi Larry,

Here's a diagram showing the moulding I'm going with.



I'm still on the fence about how to tackle attaching the fabric. Especially on the sides. I'm open to recommendations.

For the sides, I was thinking of just using hot glue or contact cement to attach it to the MDF. I'm thinking stapes may fray the edge of the MDF since I only have about 1/2" of contact with the mdf to fabric.

Here's an illustration. The moulding is 3/4" and I'll finish nail it over the top of the fabric and then into the mdf.


For the lower front of the column, I have a lot more room to staple or glue the fabric. The top half grill needs to be removable. I'm planning to use a plastic speaker frame from parts-express.

I ordered the Black GOM so I'll be getting to that phase soon.

I cut all the mouldings for the first column. I became more and more efficient. I started using a finished cut moulding piece as a template to mark the next piece for cutting. The trick was to place them back to back on the floor and then use a sharp pencil to trace the cut line. This narrowed by cuts down to about two or three per moulding per side. Much easier than using the measuring tape. Then to shave off a hair, I would lower the mitre saw blade down and push the moulding against the blade. Then lift the blade up and make the cut. The teeth are a little larger, so it just shaved a smidge off the end moving me closer and closer to my finished cut. These are probably all stuff the pro's know, but being my first time. I'm learning as I go.

Nice selection of trim, may I suggest a fancier base? You have a lot of curves in all your trim, but the base looks relatively flat.

By the way, absolutey incredible job with the diagrams...jeez I ask for the molding profile and I basically get the CAD version...pure excellence
post #911 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

Any tips/tricks for cutting the GOM and working with the large roll? It seems like it'd be challenging to get nice straight cuts with scissors.

I measured the length that I needed, unrolled the length onto the floor in another room, then used a level on top of the GOM, and cut beside the level using it as a guide.

It worked really well and I didn't have any errant cuts.

Good luck!
post #912 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Guys.

Thanks for all the great advice. My father-in-law seems comfortable with the bondo. So I think we'll try that on the edges. Then use sanding sealer on the entire unit along with sanding.

Larry,
I actually intended on going a bit fancier with the trim. But I had quite a bit left over from the basement that I decided to use that instead of just throwing it away. Otherwise, I would have gone with a slightly taller base and more decorative.
post #913 of 2757
Thread Starter 
I haven't gotten into the theater tonight. But here's some progress from last night.

I built a speaker frame out of a speaker frame kit from Parts-Express. I removed the nubs on the back that fit into the female socket fittings. The sockets seemed like it was going to be challenging to get the grills in and out. So instead I'm using magnets to attach the frame.

The frame certainly took some time and I have to believe there's a faster way. Was thinking of a metal bar on the top wrapped in the GOM and then another metal bar to add some weight to the bottom. Then magnets would hold the material taught vertically both at the top and bottom. My concern with this method is the edges may not always look taught over time unless they are attached to something and could possibly get snagged or frayed over time.

Any one else try the gravity method with magnets.

Overall the parts-express kit was easy to work with. I initially made some cuts with a hacksaw, but then just used a table saw for more precise straight cuts. The frame was hot glued together and then the material applied using hot glue. You really just need to take your time with the hot glue and keep pulling the material so it has a smooth edge. I started with the corners. Going from one diagnol to the other and then working towards the middle.

One thing I'll be doing with the next frame is adding the provided supports that the kit comes with in the middle. I can see a bit of bowing in the frame. It was most likely from me pulling the GOM to tight on the plastic frame. So next one, I'll be a little less agressive. I'll probably slip a small piece of black velcro on the bottom of the speaker frame against the fabric so I can pull the frame off the column easily.

Right now, I have screws attached into the back of the speaker frame that line up with the magnets in the female socket fittings within the column. I think I'll switch that around and put the screw in magnets on the frame and just a piece of metal in the column. Requires less presicion and lining up screw to magnet.











post #914 of 2757
You probably could get away with just friction fit frames. People do it for entire front screen wall, your speaker frames should hold in place.
post #915 of 2757
Mario,

Where did you get your speaker fabric from? I looked at parts express, but some reviews stated the cheaper one it's not exactly black, thanks!
post #916 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

Guys.

Thanks for all the great advice. My father-in-law seems comfortable with the bondo. So I think we'll try that on the edges. Then use sanding sealer on the entire unit along with sanding.

Larry,
I actually intended on going a bit fancier with the trim. But I had quite a bit left over from the basement that I decided to use that instead of just throwing it away. Otherwise, I would have gone with a slightly taller base and more decorative.

I can solve your problem then...use the base up side down on your ceiling and then mount your crown molding to that.

It will look really nice

post #917 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry M View Post


I can solve your problem then...use the base up side down on your ceiling and then mount your crown molding to that.

It will look really nice

Have that thru out my house now, gives a nice clean look and a lot bigger crown appearance too.
post #918 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheaterChad View Post

Mario,

Where did you get your speaker fabric from? I looked at parts express, but some reviews stated the cheaper one it's not exactly black, thanks!

I'm using GOM fabric. I modified the speaker kit frame from Parts Express. I've got samples of speaker fabric from parts express. The premium is nice...but has a sheen. In the end I preferred the black GOM since it was darker and would blend with the red GOM I'm using on the side walls.
post #919 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry M View Post


I can solve your problem then...use the base up side down on your ceiling and then mount your crown molding to that.

It will look really nice

I like it. We did that in our dining room. Im also using the base on the ceiling soffit. I'll have to see how much I have left. Also, I'll have to match the same height since I've already cut the speaker column holes and I have the chair rail and base symetrical. Thanks for encouraging me to spend more money.

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!
post #920 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

I like it. We did that in our dining room. Im also using the base on the ceiling soffit. I'll have to see how much I have left. Also, I'll have to match the same height since I've already cut the speaker column holes and I have the chair rail and base symetrical. Thanks for encouraging me to spend more money.

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

Happy Thanksgiving to everyone

Isn't that what we're all here for, to help each other...spend more money

Someone has to bring the economy out of this rut...it might as well start here

BTW did you purchase your screen yet? I'm on the fence between SE 4K or an SMX
post #921 of 2757
I don't think it'll do much, but if you have extra dark paint left over, you can paint the inside of your columns.
post #922 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tbraden32 View Post

You probably could get away with just friction fit frames. People do it for entire front screen wall, your speaker frames should hold in place.

Actually, they would probably would just stay in there with my current design. I'll try removing the magnets and see.
post #923 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry M View Post

Happy Thanksgiving to everyone

Isn't that what we're all here for, to help each other...spend more money

Someone has to bring the economy out of this rut...it might as well start here

BTW did you purchase your screen yet? I'm on the fence between SE 4K or an SMX

I've certainly been doing my part between the theater and the entire basement. Most of the people I hired were out of work or had hit a very slow period. Menards, Home Depot and Lowes have certainly excercised my wallet too.

Maybe AVS should change this section of the forum from Dedicated Theater Design & Construction to "Economy Stimulus".

I'm planning to go with the Seymour AT screen.


In the spirit of progress, I ripped down some of the MDF last night and broke out the jig saw. Have almost two more of the columns ready for assembly.

I don't know if it's realistic, but my goal is to have the theater done by the Superbowl. I may have to develop a concrete schedule in order to keep myself on pace. I'll have to see how long carpet will take. That alone might need to be ordered 6 weeks ahead of time.
post #924 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry M View Post

I don't think it'll do much, but if you have extra dark paint left over, you can paint the inside of your columns.

Hey Larry,

What would that be for? More stimulus?

When the columns are against the wall, you can't see through the GOM fabric.
post #925 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

Hey Larry,

What would that be for? More stimulus?

When the columns are against the wall, you can't see through the GOM fabric.

I work for Benjamin Moore so every gallon counts :-)
But in all seriousness I wasn't sure if with the lights on you could see through the GOM

What does GOM feel like?
post #926 of 2757
Thread Starter 
That's what I was thinking when you wrote that. I remembered you work for Benjamin Moore.

It's kind of like burlap. Initially I wasn't sold on it. But it seems durable, fire retardant and will match the other GOM color. I'm happy I went with it.
post #927 of 2757
Hi Mcascio,

I'm loving your build, the renderings look great. I was looking at the picture of your bulkhead/light tray and it looks like its only a 2x4's width from the ceiling? What pot lights did you use that require such a shallow enclosure? The smallest lights I've found require 4 inches, but you seem to be at about 3.5 inches, correct?

I apologize is that's be discussed earlier in the thread, I tried to look for it, but didn't have any luck.
post #928 of 2757
Thread Starter 
I used Juno 4" Air Tight housing. I couldn't have any light leaking up into the ceiling from the back sides of the enclosure.

I went with these from Lowe's:
http://www.lowes.com/pd_90674-38269-...ght&facetInfo=

They are taller than 3.5". I'd have to double check, but they may require 5.75" above the tray. I plan to disguise them though with crown moulding.

I would have preferred a 3" can, but couldn't find anything airtight.
post #929 of 2757
Thread Starter 
Worked in the theater until about 2am last night getting a total of 5 columns cut up for assembly. Was a little slow after all that Turkey.

I noticed my jig saw started straying a bit even along the straight edge. Do these blades eventually get bent or worn which would cause this? Or perhaps it was fatigue setting in.

I was using the T101B Clean blade that I purchased. But then moved back to the T144DP Precision blade that came with the Bosch. That one seemed to cut as clean and faster anyways.

post #930 of 2757
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcascio View Post

Worked in the theater until about 2am last night getting a total of 5 columns cut up for assembly. Was a little slow after all that Turkey.

I noticed my jig saw started straying a bit even along the straight edge. Do these blades eventually get bent or worn which would cause this? Or perhaps it was fatigue setting in.

I was using the T101B Clean blade that I purchased. But then moved back to the T144DP Precision blade that came with the Bosch. That one seemed to cut as clean and faster anyways.

Wow, that is dedication!

With straight cuts there should not be a lot of bent blades. Sometimes if you are doing continuous cutting the blades do get too hot and can warp. You may want to let a blade cool after a longer cut.

The T308B is by far the best jigsaw blade for cutting wood. Very clean cuts can be achieved with this blade. They really are thy much better and I highly recommend them and use them exclusively.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Home Entertainment & Theater Builder › Dedicated Theater Design & Construction › The Cinemar Home Theater Construction Thread