STF-1 vs DSW microPRO 1000

Looking for a small hide-able musical sub for less than $350. Seems like the STF-1 gets a lot of good press, but the Polk Micro looks good on paper (1200W RMS, 27Hz -3dB) and is pretty cheap refurb from Polk direct on eBay. These will be paired with Polk RTi8s. Any opinions or other suggestions? Here's the requisite background info:


1. Budget. $350 including shipping.

2. Size requirements/limits. 15Wx15Dx20H *or* 12Wx16Dx19H

3. Room dimensions. ~4500 ft^3 15x45x10, but primary listening distance is 10-12 ft from front corner of room.

4. Primary uses. 80% music 20% sports, no HT.

5. Listening habits. Lowish SPL. 85dB max

6. Appearance requirements. None, will be hidden behind side of couch in front corner.

7. Timeframe. 0-2 weeks.

Yes, it will be in the front right corner. I'm willing to sacrifice volume in this application, but if you know of anything else that would be better in this price/size range I'm all ears!

I have done quite a bit of research, but there is very little information on the DSW series. There is nothing in the link you gave or any of its sub-links about the Micro 1000 or any of the DSW series subs. Certainly Polk has earned a bit of brand avoidance by putting out the miserable PSW series, but they do make decent speakers in general and the DSWs seem to be an attempt at a better low-end sub line.

Perhaps Polk has just burned the bridge here and won't ever break back into this market even if they do decide to put out decent subs.

datranz: Thanks, that about the first piece of actual information about the microPRO series I've found other than mentioning it in passing or "Polk=evil". I live close to one of the Fry's that has a floor model, I'll try to get down there to listen to it.

lalakersfan34: Yeah, honestly one of the things keeping me from jumping on on the STF-1 is that fact that the STF-2 is sitting there for a few dollars more with much better performance. I'll broach the subject of rearranging the furnature with the WAF. Wish me luck! :-O