AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Subwoofers, Bass, and Transducers › Official Rythmik Audio Subwoofer thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Official Rythmik Audio Subwoofer thread - Page 276

post #8251 of 9639
Brian,

When you say this:

In terms of port chuffing, LV12R and FV12 is same (as I did a side-by-side comparison). If one plans to play loud on LV12R, I do recommend to leave a bit more space in the back.

What exactly do you mean by leaving a bit more space in the back?
post #8252 of 9639
I think the chuffling might be due to placement. I just moved it yesterday nearfield by where my wife and I always sit, but there is a full wall on one side and a small portion of a wall on the other. The sub is corner loaded, so maybe I need to move it back to being next to the tv in the corner with two full walls. I'm going to try that when I get home today and see if that helps.
post #8253 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by JT78681 View Post

I think the chuffling might be due to placement. I just moved it yesterday nearfield by where my wife and I always sit, but there is a full wall on one side and a small portion of a wall on the other. The sub is corner loaded, so maybe I need to move it back to being next to the tv in the corner with two full walls. I'm going to try that when I get home today and see if that helps.

Corner loaded helps output and it is our first recommended placement.
Reply
Reply
post #8254 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rythmik View Post

Corner loaded helps output and it is our first recommended placement.

So, with a rear ported sub, it will not compromise flat/ accurate frequency response?
post #8255 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Flatliner View Post

I don't know a lot about ported subs so I'm just curious, what was the reason for moving the port from the front to the back? Seems like it would mean placement/ distance from the wall would have more influence with maybe a tradeoff between deeper bass/ more output closer to the wall behind it but more accuracy further away - but that seems to be counter to your suggestion? I have a pair of Vandersteen 1b's for my fronts which are extremely sensitive to distance out from the wall so I'm just trying to get an idea of where to start with sub placement for best accuracy (I don't really listen at very loud levels these days). I'm guessing between the two mains and not really in the corner on the outside of the main pair.

The main reason that you hear very different results with the distance to wall of your Vandersteen is the front speaker has a baffle width related roll off below 200-300hz. Some call this baffle loss which takes place because sound at higher frequency is no longer omni-directional. All speaker designers who know what they are doing will compensate that by boosting the frequency band below 300hz (using voice coil inductance) if they are supposed to be placed off wall. On the other hand, if the speakers are meant to be placed close to wall, the baflle loss will be much less and there shouldn't be much boost below 200-300hz. In short, to get the speakers sound right, you need to learn from the speaker company if they are supposed to be placed close to wall or off wall. Of wall placed front speakers have better image. The reason we have stereo image and sound stage is because wall reflection. The sound played in anechoic room (even if they are in stereo) is very boring. It has nothing resembling what we hear every day. BTW, a lot of members have favored low indutance drivers and forgot about the baffle loss compensation. The resulting sound from a lof of DIY project using low inductance drivers is the mid bass is just lacking, period. This is off topic.

Now sub is different. There is no baffle loss. So place in the corner is ok. The boost from corner loading is supposed to be very uniform. Don't worry about the boomy sound coming from our subs. The reason we hear boomy sound is because some subs do have a very narrow sweet-spot. If you turn the volume low, you don't hear bass, and if you turn the volume up, you hear boomy sound. But our subs address those problems. Once you hear the sound from our subs, you will agree. smile.gif
Reply
Reply
post #8256 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rythmik View Post

The main reason that you hear very different results with the distance to wall of your Vandersteen is the front speaker has a baffle width related roll off below 200-300hz. Some call this baffle loss which takes place because sound at higher frequency is no longer omni-directional. All speaker designers who know what they are doing will compensate that by boosting the frequency band below 300hz (using voice coil inductance) if they are supposed to be placed off wall. On the other hand, if the speakers are meant to be placed close to wall, the baflle loss will be much less and there shouldn't be much boost below 200-300hz. In short, to get the speakers sound right, you need to learn from the speaker company if they are supposed to be placed close to wall or off wall. Of wall placed front speakers have better image. The reason we have stereo image and sound stage is because wall reflection. The sound played in anechoic room (even if they are in stereo) is very boring. It has nothing resembling what we hear every day. BTW, a lot of members have favored low indutance drivers and forgot about the baffle loss compensation. The resulting sound from a lof of DIY project using low inductance drivers is the mid bass is just lacking, period. This is off topic.

Now sub is different. There is no baffle loss. So place in the corner is ok. The boost from corner loading is supposed to be very uniform. Don't worry about the boomy sound coming from our subs. The reason we hear boomy sound is because some subs do have a very narrow sweet-spot. If you turn the volume low, you don't hear bass, and if you turn the volume up, you hear boomy sound. But our subs address those problems. Once you hear the sound from our subs, you will agree. smile.gif

Thanks, that's very reassuring to hear! I'm really excited to hear your sub.

Reading remarks that Richard Vandersteen has written, his design is supposed to minimize the baffle issue (the top of the speakers where the tweater and mid range driver are mounted are open on all four sides and the baffle is extremely small). He does recommend placement at least 10" away from the wall, though I have found it better for imaging to even have them further out.

One thing that attracted me to your subs is your emphasis on accuracy. Interestingly, in the interview below, Richard Vandersteen was not a fan of servo controlled subs but that's likely due to how the technology existed 20 years ago (the article is from 1988). I guess his point back then was that one can't correct something that has already occurred in time (servo mechanism sensing a bad response and then correcting it).

http://www.stereophile.com/interviews/688vandersteen/
post #8257 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Flatliner View Post


One thing that attracted me to your subs is your emphasis on accuracy. Interestingly, in the interview below, Richard Vandersteen was not a fan of servo controlled subs but that's likely due to how the technology existed 20 years ago (the article is from 1988). I guess his point back then was that one can't correct something that has already occurred in time (servo mechanism sensing a bad response and then correcting it).

http://www.stereophile.com/interviews/688vandersteen/

Every expert has his own blind spot (including me). To give you an example. Dr Klippel is well-known for its speaker test equipments. He can also do spider test. I sent one for him to test and he sent back the report, but there is no test on hysteresis. I asked him for a test like that and he explained there is no hysteresis in spiders. But anyone who can mark the voice coil and observve hysteresis from spider. Pull the cone up and let it return to the resting position and then push the cone down and let it return to the position. These two resting positons are not same. The difference is not much in ours (maybe 1/2 mm). So it does exist.

Now, back to servo. we call our servo direct servo because there is no active device added to the servo feedback. It ensures the most pristine signal quality. It is very different. In addition, the analysis of servo feedback was very ad hoc. There were no theory behind it and often the engineers at that time is just do a bunch of trials-and-errors. But it all changed after our patent. I could have submitted a technical paper to AES. But I didn't bother. I already published what I think enough papers in another field in EE. I didn't care too much in getting my name known in audio and that is the story of our servo design, very humble and yet it is a design advantage that is truly scalable.


-
Edited by Rythmik - 2/7/13 at 12:00pm
Reply
Reply
post #8258 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rythmik View Post

Every expert has his own blind spot. To give you an example. Dr Klippel is well-known for its speaker test equipments. He can also do spider test. I sent one for him to test and he sent back the report, but there is no test on hysteresis. I asked him for a test like that and he explained there is no hysteresis in spiders. But anyone who can mark the voice coil and observve hysteresis from spider. Pull the cone up and let it return to the resting position and then push the cone down and let it return to the position. These two resting positons are not same. The difference is not much in ours (maybe 1/2 mm). So it does exist.

Now, back to servo. we call our servo direct servo because there is no active design added to the servo feedback. It ensures the most pristine signal quality. It is very different. In addition, the analysis of servo feedback was very ad hoc. There were no theory behind it and often the engineers at that time is just do a bunch of trials-and-errors. But it all changed after our patent. I could have submitted a technical paper to AES. But I didn't bother. I already published what I think enough papers in another field in EE. I didn't care too much in getting my name known in audio and that is the story of our servo design, very humble and yet it is a design advantage that is truly scalable.

Brian you are a genius! My hats off to you for the quality of products you produce and for being so hands on with your customers.
post #8259 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by justindo View Post

Hi all,

I'm considering a Rythmik sub and have a couple questions that I was hoping you could answer for me. Thanks in advance.

First, it seems I've read that the cabinets are sourced from Asia and that the subs are assembled in Austin. Is this true? What about the drivers? Rythmik doesn't seem to mention any of this on their site compared to, for example, PSA.

Second, I'm looking at the F15 and the F15HP. Do you think the latter is worth the extra money? My room is 24x18x8.

I tend to go against the consensus in that I use a single F12 in a room a little larger than yours (20x25x8). The F12 fills my room just fine for me, but then I'm not a bass head either. I like everything to blend with no one part of the spectrum overpowering any other. The F12 does this very well and still has plenty of punch for movie sound effects for me. But then, if I wanted things rattling off the walls I'd move back to California smile.gif.
Edited by mlundy57 - 2/7/13 at 2:42pm
post #8260 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by mlundy57 View Post

... But then, if I wanted things rattling off the walls I'd move back to California.

Hey! Don't you guys in OK flatlands get your walls rattled by them twisters too?? tongue.gif






(I went to OK State, Stillwater for a sem. Fond memories of that quaint li'l place.)
post #8261 of 9639
^^
Trust me, once you have an FV15HP in your room, you will be asking yourself that you were happy with the smaller sub F12? For me, I had the SVS SB12nsd in my living room and thought it was all I needed, then came the Monster FV15HP for my dedicated theater. I spent a few weeks listening and watching those 5 stars bass movies in my theater and was amazed. One night, I was lazy to go to my theater for a movie, so I fire up one of those 5 stars bass movie in my main living room with the SB12nsd and kept finding myself increasing the volume on my receiver and the LFE trim (10dbs hot) and it was not enough. So I put in a movie that I know it sounded loud and deep with the SB12 before but I was disappointed this time around.
post #8262 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cowboys View Post

^^
Trust me, once you have an FV15HP in your room, you will be asking yourself that you were happy with the smaller sub F12? For me, I had the SVS SB12nsd in my living room and thought it was all I needed, then came the Monster FV15HP for my dedicated theater. I spent a few weeks listening and watching those 5 stars bass movies in my theater and was amazed. One night, I was lazy to go to my theater for a movie, so I fire up one of those 5 stars bass movie in my main living room with the SB12nsd and kept finding myself increasing the volume on my receiver and the LFE trim (10dbs hot) and it was not enough. So I put in a movie that I know it sounded loud and deep with the SB12 before but I was disappointed this time around.

Well the FV15HP oughta give you more than the F12, seeing as how it costs twice as much!
post #8263 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by mlundy57 View Post

I tend to go against the consensus in that I use a single F12 in a room a little larger than yours (20x25x8). The F12 fills my room just fine for me, but then I'm not a bass head either. I like everything to blend with no one part of the spectrum overpowering any other. The F12 does this very well and still has plenty of punch for movie sound effects for me. But then, if I wanted things rattling off the walls I'd move back to California smile.gif.

What, North of Hwy 80 and West of Hwy 5 isn't good enough for you? tongue.gif

Two cheaper subs is better than a decent sub and two decent subs is better than three lesser subs and an analyzing program and two decent subs is the best alternative to the prior.

I'll take two E15's for a thousand Alex. tongue.gif

(If my room was that big, I'd opt for four of the rascals.)
post #8264 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by BDP24 View Post

Well the FV15HP oughta give you more than the F12, seeing as how it costs twice as much!
I am not comparing the two but trying to tell my story that once one heard/owned a better sub, you don't know what you miss.
post #8265 of 9639
Happy to say my FV15HP will be here next Wednesday. Hopefully our expected 30" of snow this weekend won't cause any issues!
post #8266 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by lennyp View Post

Happy to say my FV15HP will be here next Wednesday. Hopefully our expected 30" of snow this weekend won't cause any issues!

This is tricky. Only fire up the sub after the sub is brought to room temperature for over a day (let us be safe). There can be condensation on the eletroncis. Last winter I had a sealed sub delivered to a customer northeast in a big storm. That one was a DOA. I cannot quite figure out the reason. But let us just play safe. If the package was left to freeze outside, broght the sub into the house and unpack it and make sure it is room temperature for sufficient amount of time.
Reply
Reply
post #8267 of 9639
That is going to be a long wait with it sitting there warming up but it is totally worth it once you hear it:)
post #8268 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rythmik View Post

This is tricky. Only fire up the sub after the sub is brought to room temperature for over a day (let us be safe). There can be condensation on the eletroncis. Last winter I had a sealed sub delivered to a customer northeast in a big storm. That one was a DOA. I cannot quite figure out the reason. But let us just play safe. If the package was left to freeze outside, broght the sub into the house and unpack it and make sure it is room temperature for sufficient amount of time.


+1.

I lost a TV like that some years back. Brought it in from the u-haul trailer and it went poof as soon as I turned it on. I made sure my FV15HP was thoroughly up to room temp before plugging it in.
post #8269 of 9639
Temperature-change caused condensation is definitely a nasty killer; we see that pretty commonly in consumer electronics at work (I do safety and environmental testing). I'd probably not even open the shipping box for a couple of hours to let everything to warm up.

I'm hoping my LV12R comes in tomorrow - it's scheduled to, but it's been sitting in Mesquite, Texas since Wednesday morning and WV is a long way away for a one-night trip. Hopefully it's just UPS's tracking system being borked.
post #8270 of 9639
Yes, good advice - I will definitely let it acclimate. No need to cause potential startup issues. Temps look like 40F as a high next week. With any luck, UPS wll be gentle and not leave it without signature. I guess an advantage of internet buying, I don't know what I'll be missing until I finally fire it up, so I will wait a couple days!
post #8271 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by raaj View Post

Hey! Don't you guys in OK flatlands get your walls rattled by them twisters too?? tongue.gif






(I went to OK State, Stillwater for a sem. Fond memories of that quaint li'l place.)

Actually, we have been getting more than our share of earthquakes here also. We had over 1,000 quakes in OK last year with a 5.6 that my brother felt in St. Louis. First time I ever heard an earthquake roar in. I could actually hear it coming before I felt it.

By the way, the F12 passed the wife test. The old sub was really boomy and would run on and cover up dialog. With the F12 she enjoyed the movie, even though the bass extension is much deeper and the experience more visceral the effect is enjoyable.
post #8272 of 9639
OMG if I had to look at my FV15HP for a day or two without hearing it after the dreaming, research, saving, and waiting on UPS I think I'd explode... well, it's better then having to ship around in circles and waiting longer.
post #8273 of 9639
I sped up the process with a hair dryer. Just make sure you don't melt anything. biggrin.gif
post #8274 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by dstew100 View Post

OMG if I had to look at my FV15HP for a day or two without hearing it after the dreaming, research, saving, and waiting on UPS I think I'd explode... well, it's better then having to ship around in circles and waiting longer.

Patience, young grasshoppa !! I've been going through multiple receivers due to issues, and waiting on what would hopefully be the one I'd settle with. eek.giftongue.gif Four more days to wait for it to show up, and then another week or so to get my sub, and set it all up. I understand how :pyou feel, but better be safe than sorry.
post #8275 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by lennyp View Post

Yes, good advice - I will definitely let it acclimate. No need to cause potential startup issues. Temps look like 40F as a high next week. With any luck, UPS wll be gentle and not leave it without signature. I guess an advantage of internet buying, I don't know what I'll be missing until I finally fire it up, so I will wait a couple days!

UPS (oops) left my FV15 with out a sig and in full view of the street. I live in a fairly secure subdivision and we have a block watch that really does a good job. But the box is so HUGE and heavy NO ONE in their right mind would attempt to steal it. I left a note to have him take it next door and he wrote me that he couldn't. Don't blame him really!

Jeff
post #8276 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cowboys View Post

I am not comparing the two but trying to tell my story that once one heard/owned a better sub, you don't know what you miss.

Hey, this raises a good question: Is there more difference between the SVS SB12 and the Rythmik F12 or between the F12 and the FV15HP? The only sub I was considering buying for my music-only system before I discovered Rythmik and GR was a sealed SVS, the SB13. I'm so glad it was discontinued for an update just as I was about to buy!
post #8277 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by lennyp View Post

Happy to say my FV15HP will be here next Wednesday. Hopefully our expected 30" of snow this weekend won't cause any issues!
Mine is scheduled for delivery on Tuesday. Forecast.. 80 degrees.. I love Florida! :-)
post #8278 of 9639
Quote:
Originally Posted by GIXX1300 View Post

Mine is scheduled for delivery on Tuesday. Forecast.. 80 degrees.. I love Florida! :-)

It was in the 70's here (California low desert) today. Eat yer heart out, the rest of ya's!
post #8279 of 9639
70's and 80's. Gawd I hate you guys.
post #8280 of 9639
Cheer up Stanley. I'm sure you have plenty of rain over there and quite a bit of coffee to drink.biggrin.gif
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Subwoofers, Bass, and Transducers › Official Rythmik Audio Subwoofer thread