Quote:
Originally Posted by vinhsynd 
Hi Ted,
Here is my opinion on the sets you've listed:
65" Samsung ES6500 - does 3D and Smart Applications
65" Samsung EH6000 - does neither 3D or Smart Applications
70" Sharp LE640U - does Smart Applications
With a bright room that has sunlight directed at the televisions position I think you would be better served with a matte screen in comparison to a glossy one for cutting down on reflections and glare.
I have a 65" Sony HX729 next to a window which has the same lighting situation you describe - the set is wonderful but its a glossy screen which gives some reflections and glare that are a nuisance to daytime viewing.
The ES6500 is a semi-matte screen - which may give you more reflections and glare than the other two.
In night time viewing - I was unable to see a difference between the ES6500 and EH6000 when side by side in a dimly lit room.
Given a comparable picture quality, the only advantages the ES6500 have are 3D and Smart Applications which you've stated are not important to you.
Therefore I think the real competition here lies between the EH6000 and the LE640U.
Edge-Lit sets can have issues with flash lighting, and uniformity.
While the Direct-Lit sets can have issues with uniformity countenanced as darker corners.
I think the picture quality however is pretty comparable between the EH6000 and LE640U; maybe slightly in the LE640U's favor.
However, when taking into account your listed viewing distance of 14 - 25ft, I think the larger size of the LE640U is the deciding factor in favor of the Sharp.
Also there are some intangibles to think about as well - do you have a separate sound system? Do you wish to use HDMI-CEC to control everything via a single remote?
Now if you plan on using a Harmony remote these points are mote but:
Samsung HDMI-CEC (AnyNet+) only works with other Samsung devices while the Sharp HDMI-CEC does work with other manufacturer products.
Samsung HDMI-CEC (AnyNet+) does not turn on the sound system by design - so both the TV and sound system remotes are needed when turning everything on. Sharp HDMI-CEC will activate other manufacturer attached sound systems that support HDMI-CEC.
The reason for this that while there are defined HDMI-CEC standards; the manufacturers are allowed to pick what portions of HDMI-CEC standards they wish to follow and proprietary extensions/features are allowed.
More detailed information on HDMI-CEC can be found here: http://www.eetimes.com/design/audio-design/4013475/HDMI-Consumer-Electronic-Control-CEC-technology-and-testing

Hi Ted,
Here is my opinion on the sets you've listed:
65" Samsung ES6500 - does 3D and Smart Applications
65" Samsung EH6000 - does neither 3D or Smart Applications
70" Sharp LE640U - does Smart Applications
With a bright room that has sunlight directed at the televisions position I think you would be better served with a matte screen in comparison to a glossy one for cutting down on reflections and glare.
I have a 65" Sony HX729 next to a window which has the same lighting situation you describe - the set is wonderful but its a glossy screen which gives some reflections and glare that are a nuisance to daytime viewing.
The ES6500 is a semi-matte screen - which may give you more reflections and glare than the other two.
In night time viewing - I was unable to see a difference between the ES6500 and EH6000 when side by side in a dimly lit room.
Given a comparable picture quality, the only advantages the ES6500 have are 3D and Smart Applications which you've stated are not important to you.
Therefore I think the real competition here lies between the EH6000 and the LE640U.
Edge-Lit sets can have issues with flash lighting, and uniformity.
While the Direct-Lit sets can have issues with uniformity countenanced as darker corners.
I think the picture quality however is pretty comparable between the EH6000 and LE640U; maybe slightly in the LE640U's favor.
However, when taking into account your listed viewing distance of 14 - 25ft, I think the larger size of the LE640U is the deciding factor in favor of the Sharp.
Also there are some intangibles to think about as well - do you have a separate sound system? Do you wish to use HDMI-CEC to control everything via a single remote?
Now if you plan on using a Harmony remote these points are mote but:
Samsung HDMI-CEC (AnyNet+) only works with other Samsung devices while the Sharp HDMI-CEC does work with other manufacturer products.
Samsung HDMI-CEC (AnyNet+) does not turn on the sound system by design - so both the TV and sound system remotes are needed when turning everything on. Sharp HDMI-CEC will activate other manufacturer attached sound systems that support HDMI-CEC.
The reason for this that while there are defined HDMI-CEC standards; the manufacturers are allowed to pick what portions of HDMI-CEC standards they wish to follow and proprietary extensions/features are allowed.
More detailed information on HDMI-CEC can be found here: http://www.eetimes.com/design/audio-design/4013475/HDMI-Consumer-Electronic-Control-CEC-technology-and-testing
Thanks for your helpful feedback. I will have a separate sound system. I will most likely use a Harmony remote. So, no other sets I might have missed?
-Ted


























