AVS › AVS Forum › A/V Control & Automation › Home Automation › Security camera recommendations
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Security camera recommendations

post #1 of 91
Thread Starter 
(Sorry for the cross-post.. I realized it probably fits better here than A/V distribution..)

I'm looking for advice in my first foray into security cameras and DVRs. Here are my requirements:
- Two baby monitors (separate rooms, close range, night vision required, color is a plus but not absolutely required.. or is this standard nowadays?)
- Two outside cameras.. range needed from 5 ft - 50 ft, w/night vision.. not extremely picky on the quality here, either.. basically best value (cost/performance)
- If it's wireless, I want it to be secure.. not like those stupid baby monitors that have two unsecured wireless channels. I have absolutely no problem running wires if necessary, especially Cat-5, since I'm running all of that through the house anyway. I generally prefer wired over wireless for almost everything.
- Definitely want a DVR, and ideally something that will plug into my PC (e.g. PCI card) that can make use of my existing CPU and hard drives, of which I have plenty. If it makes much more sense to get a device that's standalone and interfaces with a PC (or via IP), so be it.. but would really like the storage to be on the PC (cost/security/manageability). Ideally runs on Win7 x64, but if I need to run a little box for this, I've got the hardware, etc.
- Viewable via the Internet, but that's a given for all of them since they need to be stored on a hard drive (I can RDP to my home machine worst case)
- Cost is a factor, but will pay more if there's a significant benefit

Now my questions:
- Has anyone tried Monoprice's line of security cameras? They look like good specs for the buck (as with almost anything from them). Something like this one. It's not even obvious to me the connector it uses.. I'm guessing BNC off the back. Speaking of..
- Is it worth it to get coax anymore, or just use IP-based? Do the IP based cameras only do JPEG captures and you have to run it through a program to generate video?
- Are there cheap PCI solutions available to solve the DVR requirement? Has anyone used something like this? It's possible to mix and match CCTV cameras with DVRs that talk on coax (not IP), right?

Thanks much for any enlightenment on this.. I've tried to find some basic recommendations on the current state of security camera tech but haven't really.. it's mostly people just reselling of equipment.
post #2 of 91
I've been researching security cameras and dvr's for a long time... it is quite bewildering because there are literally thousands of options. It boggles the mind doesn't it?

If you are extremely budget conscious I'd just get an all in one bundle from Costco... can't go wrong at that price.

I was looking for a megapixel IP camera system and settled on the 209mfd from Axis and currently evaluating the Exacq NVR which seems to handle multiple HD cameras better than most NVRs on the market.

If you'd like to be confused more, I suggest http://www.cctvforum.com/viewforum.p...272e773c9ee766 where most security camera nerds hang out.
post #3 of 91
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the response, Thomas. Yikes! That's some serious cash for a "nice to have" component.. I'm not trying to secure my business, or even my house.. just have basic day/night vision capability with reasonable resolution like a $30 webcam on your laptop does (other than the night part). If it dumps frames to a computer, that's fine - I can process them later with open source apps.

I'll look into the Costco bundles.. I hope they have some kind of PC-connectivity. Thanks again for the help.. that forum is crazy in-depth with some good commercial gear.
post #4 of 91
I just installed a $37 Monoprice camera (product 6637 on the page linked above) to replace a color bullet camera that had failed (after about 10 yrs of continuous use outdoors). The quality of the Monoprice camera is very good - considerably better than the one that it replaced (which cost $200 originally).

I also just installed a Monoprice 4 channel security DVR system. Again, an awesome product & unbelievable value.

BB
post #5 of 91
Thread Starter 
Great info, thanks BB! I hope it's not too much to ask, but do you happen to have night/day screenshots of the camera? Which DVR did you get, and can it save to an MPEG file?

I'd really like to have remote view on my phone if possible, which seems to be a reasonable expectation with something like the free TinyDVR Android app (though perhaps need to all be IP cameras?)

Thanks again for your feedback.. I wish there were more reviews on those Monoprice cameras on their site..
post #6 of 91
Hi, Tim

The DVR that I got is the Monoprice 4 channel without DVD-R (the least expensive one). It records in H.264, not MPEG. I set it to record at full resolution / full time, and it seems to be able to hold approx. 30 days of video for my 3 cameras on a 1TB drive (which I put in myself). It just came out very recently, which is why there aren't any reviews up. You can run it either from a video output on the unit (VGA or composite) using a mouse-based interface, or over the network (either local or over the internet). The network interface uses either a PC-based stand-alone application or a web browser-based application. The web browser interface requires an active-x program -- which is a bit tricky to install and only works under Microsoft Internet Explorer.

I'm not sure what the prospects would be for being able to access the video using a phone. My bet is that it would be difficult, if not impossible, using the current available interfaces.

I'm not sure how I'd do a screenshot for you, but I'll think about how it might be done.

Best
bb
post #7 of 91
Thread Starter 
Very cool.. do you know if you can transfer the video off of the drive somehow, or is it purely accessed via the web page? I'm not sure of your technical knowledge, but do you know if you can login to the embedded linux OS and make any changes to provide connectivity? The more options in this regard, the more likely it is I can get it working to the phone (as well as other things like offsite backup).

I was thinking perhaps the video quality would be able to be seen via the web server from your computer, which you could screenshot. I'm a bit concerned with the review I just saw on the 6655 DVR that says the picture quality is poor when going through the DVR as opposed to directly connecting the camera.. did you experience this as well?

Again, thanks for your insight!
post #8 of 91
I haven't made any purchases yet, but I wired my house for IP Cameras. IP cameras while expensive seemed like the best option for me. I wanted to use a simi normal computer to control and record everything and I only wanted to run one cable. So all the cameras I'll be choosing will be IP and have PoE (Power over Ethernet).

Also, get the new G25 series from Panasonic and it'll display the camera directly on your TV (with some caveats)
post #9 of 91
Thread Starter 
So I've found another decent PCI (express in this case) option: Q-See QSDT4PCRC 4 Channel H.264 PCI DVR Card

$80 for a 4-port H.264 card you can throw in your computer sounds like a great deal.. there's an 8-port option for $130 as well.

As for the single cable, I've seen (non-IP) cameras that have a single cable that just contain both power and RG-59, and you just hook the power up at the DVR-side. Not as ideal as PoE, for sure, but much cheaper. There are (of course) others that have the power as a separate AC adapter which would be good for my baby monitor situation where I'm going to have coax run to the room along with UTP (standard low voltage runs to each room), and don't need special two-wire cables for those.

So now I've found some components in my price range.. the Costco idea sparked some good ideas into researching the components used in the packages. I now need to decide between the PCI card in a separate computer, our existing desktop (that stays on all the time), or the standalone DVR. There are pros/cons with each option, of course. I'll probably go the cheapo route and get the above 4-port card (you can combine 1,2, or 4 of those cards in one PC) in our current desktop and separate it out to a different computer if necessary some day.

Then I need to find cameras that work for the special purposes I'll use them for.
post #10 of 91
I have been looking at the same thing and found this. http://www.tigerdirect.com/applicati...212&CatId=4445

Its h.264 and has four cameras with a 500 gig drive preinstalled. ALso it is set up to be viewable from any PC, iPhone or other 3g capable phones. I just can;t figure out if the cameras are any good.
post #11 of 91
Quote:
Originally Posted by miltimj View Post

Very cool.. do you know if you can transfer the video off of the drive somehow, or is it purely accessed via the web page? I'm not sure of your technical knowledge, but do you know if you can login to the embedded linux OS and make any changes to provide connectivity? The more options in this regard, the more likely it is I can get it working to the phone (as well as other things like offsite backup).

I was thinking perhaps the video quality would be able to be seen via the web server from your computer, which you could screenshot. I'm a bit concerned with the review I just saw on the 6655 DVR that says the picture quality is poor when going through the DVR as opposed to directly connecting the camera.. did you experience this as well?

Again, thanks for your insight!

There is a function to export the video for a given camera or group of cameras for a given time interval. When I tried it, it created a ".vid" file with the video and two other files (I think with indexing info). I haven't figured out how to view those files yet. If anyone knows, please post.

Regarding quality, it looks reasonably clear to me in real-time -- however when I tried to export a frame capture, it came out pretty pixelated. I'm still not sure how good/bad it is overall.

Regarding ability to get at the device to bypass the interface and (i.e. log in via Linux), I don't know. So far, I've just used it as an appliance. Again, I'd be interested in what others have found out.

bb
post #12 of 91
Thread Starter 
Lee, from what I've seen in my research, the bundled ones don't have very good cameras - so I'm planning on adding cameras that I select after deciding on standalone DVR or PCI card. Another reason to buy separately is that most of us probably have different requirements for each camera location (lens sizes, night/day, resolution, etc).

bb, that sounds like some decent basic functionality.. have you tried renaming to mpg, etc? Or just opening straight in WMP and seeing if it finds anything? I found this basic information on H.264.
post #13 of 91
Would love to hear feedback on the Monoprice cameras. If it's as good as the cables and accessories I have gotten from them for the price I think I might be in.

Paul
post #14 of 91
I too am interested in the monoprice camera's and the 4 channel DVR. It almost looks to good to be true. I would love a screenshot of the interface. If you just press the PrtScn button and open up paint and paste. Then save as a .jpg and then upload it to photobucket and post it here. That would be awesome!
post #15 of 91
Here's a screencap that shows the interface of the Monoprice DVR. The camera marked "driveway" is the low-end (12 LED) camera that I bought at Monoprice when I bought the DVR a few weeks ago.

Hope this helps!
BB
LL
post #16 of 91
Thread Starter 
Awesome, thanks BB! Any chance you could back it up to a night shot to show NV capabilities? Thanks again!
post #17 of 91
Quote:
Originally Posted by miltimj View Post

Awesome, thanks BB! Any chance you could back it up to a night shot to show NV capabilities? Thanks again!

Here's what the driveway cam looked like last night at midnight. Sorry, but it's not much to see. It's Monoprice's 12 LED model, so it has very little nightvision capability. Furthermore, the camera is mounted something like 12 ft up and is pointed at a cement driveway. I actually wanted a camera with no nightvision - which is why I selected this one (12 LED is the fewest that Monoprice offers).

On the bright side, it did stop raining since the previous screencap posted above.

BB
LL
post #18 of 91
Your driveway looks nicer in the rain.

Thanks for sharing, really is helpful. You should consider a motion sensor for your driveway floodlights.
post #19 of 91
Thread Starter 
Thanks for that - I wonder what would be the best for an indoor baby cam with minimal light..? Does anyone have any cheap CATV cams that are decent for that?
post #20 of 91
Hi bb80301,

I am also interested in the monoprice cameras. The quality looks pretty decent for the price and I intend to try one of the slightly more expensive cameras in hopes the night vision and overall quality is a bit better than my current setup.

My current cheapo lorex bundled bullet cams (from costco) uses a long twinned bnc/power cable to provide video feed and power. I cannot find a similar cable on monoprice, so how did you solve providing power to "far from a power outlet" areas?

I am guessing the camera has a bnc and power connector? I will just need to buy the appropriate power adapter and bnc cable?

Thanks in advance for any advice!
post #21 of 91
Quote:
Originally Posted by chitoko View Post

My current cheapo lorex bundled bullet cams (from costco) uses a long twinned bnc/power cable to provide video feed and power. I cannot find a similar cable on monoprice, so how did you solve providing power to "far from a power outlet" areas?

I am guessing the camera has a bnc and power connector? I will just need to buy the appropriate power adapter and bnc cable?

Thanks in advance for any advice!

Ebay has baluns that will do video, audio, and power over a single cat5.

Try this link.
post #22 of 91
Each of the camera locations has coax w/ BNC connector and a power cable with what seems to be a standard DC power plug connector. The cables all go down into the basement, with video split & going into the DVR and a modulator that distributes over TV channels in real time. The power to the cameras is provided by a 12v power supply, also in the basement.

BB
post #23 of 91
Acecannon and bb80301,

Thank you very much for the info!

I had no idea you could use a cat5 cable and a balun. My lorex package came with a specialized paired wire. Looking at monoprice's prices and now knowing I can use a simple cat5 cable... it almost makes me cry at how much I've spent on the lorex bundles (I got 2 on special - but still so expensive!). They work, are decent, and I don't have the headache of remembering to record as with my super old vhs system lol! , but I need to upgrade a couple cameras to get suitable "face" shots at eye level. I have a feeling I could have spent the same amount and gotten better quality cameras from monoprice. We will see...

I have a small business, and just yesterday got hit with another fake $100, among other things. *sigh* (it's getting pretty bad lately)

Your advices are very much appreciated!
post #24 of 91
Thread Starter 
chitoko, the cables are generally called an "RG-59 with 18/2 siamese cable", and I've seen them for around $100 for 500 ft online.

You might consider rejecting any bills over $50 at your business and/or record their driver's license #, etc, in order to use it. I'd consider that reasonable if I were at a small business.
post #25 of 91
Thread Starter 
Let me extend a blanket request for everyone who ends up getting any of these Monoprice security cameras..

Please post screenshots of daytime and night vision use, and which Monoprice ID# it's from! (Like BB already has)

That should help in our decision making.. thanks everyone!
post #26 of 91
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by AceCannon View Post

Ebay has baluns that will do video, audio, and power over a single cat5.

Try this link.

Thanks for the link! Do you know if all of these power plugs are the same? That would be slick if all of these are plug 'n play..
post #27 of 91
BB, That monoprice camera you have with the 12 IR LEDs. Could I mount that under my eve of the house? I wouldn't want this to hang upside down because of the weather shield or do you think the DVR software could flip my picture and it wouldn't matter much under the eve?

Thanks
post #28 of 91
Quote:
Originally Posted by gluc0se View Post

BB, That monoprice camera you have with the 12 IR LEDs. Could I mount that under my eve of the house? I wouldn't want this to hang upside down because of the weather shield or do you think the DVR software could flip my picture and it wouldn't matter much under the eve?

Thanks

Yes. That's how mine is mounted. It's on a ball joint that rotates 360 degrees. The weather shield snaps on either direction, so that's no problem.

Best
BB
post #29 of 91
What a week, bleh! Among other silly & weird things, the same guy who passed the fake came in again. Police are now involved. The problem was my employee KNEW the guy somewhat and this guy took advantage of that (talked her up and she didn't bother looking at it closely *sigh*) I just can't believe the guy had the gall to come back! /end of rant

Anyway, I did order one of the cameras (6640) and once it comes in, I will test and post pics so others can be informed. Don't ask me why I chose that camera, I just went for mid-price hoping I get a better quality picture than I currently have. Also, I am in Canada, so I expect it will take some time to arrive. It should be interesting to see how my cheapo lorex cams compare.

miltimj, great idea on the blanket request! I hope more people find this thread so we can get a better idea on which camera is best for which situation and price point.
post #30 of 91
I wish someone made a cheap network camera?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Home Automation
AVS › AVS Forum › A/V Control & Automation › Home Automation › Security camera recommendations