Quote:
|
I decided to get a pair of headphones and ordered the HD598 last month. I was going to use them with my Oppo BDP-83 and Carver Receiver (80's vintage integrated) headphone jack. Unfortunately, the bass was horribly bloated. Then I tried them out with the headphone jack of my Pioneer Elite AVR (SC-25) and they sounded good (if a little bright for my tastes).
So I ordered the HD650. Carver bass problem mostly solved - but still a little loose. They sound good with many of my discs but with some recordings, they sound muddy and dark (Diana Krall albums for example I can't hear the wire brush strokes, rim shots, and high hat taps). I decided to try out an amp to see if that would clear them up. I ordered a Schiit Audio Asgard. The amp did tighten up the bass a little but it did nothing for the high freqs. I haven't seen this talked about anywhere (here or head-fi), but it seems to me that there is a wide variation in the frequency response of different recordings. Some albums sound bloomy and muffled on the 650 and other albums sound lean and bright (have you ever listened to Dire Straits, "Brothers in Arms" SACD? I can't imagine any amp/headphone taming that shrill beast!). What I'm thinking about is finding a nice integrated receiver or amp that has a good headphone stage and tone controls (Heresy, I know!). Does this even exist? What do you do when you listen to an album and the mastering just doesn't sound right? |
One thing to try (for a CD that you like) is buy a different pressing of it. Since you live in USA, that'd be an "import"
Quote:
|
I figure that if I basically like the sound of the 598s driven from my Pioneer AVR, shouldn't a higher-end stereo receiver from NAD or Yamaha provide even better analog sound?
|
Quote:
|
That and the flexibility of being able to trim the frequency response from album to album if needed should be a great "mid-fi solution, right? And If I choose the 650 (or another higher-end headphone), it can grow with me as I upgrade.
Believe me, I really want to like the HD650 and I'd love to buy a sweet Burson or Woo amp and make them sing. But I'm afraid that even if I do, they will still only sound great with 1/3 of my music collection. I listen to CDs, SACDs, and DVD-A discs mostly. I'm not into FLAC or computer audio yet, but I'm open to broadening my horizons. |

BTW while the 650's have the better sound the 595's are easier to wear and still good enough in SQ that it's an interesting tradeoff (wearability) that doesn't get discussed enough. The 650's are also one of 4 or 5 headphones that Stereophile lists as class A (top class). Each of them is different, none of them is perfect.
Even if you aren't demanding, there is no perfect headphone nor any other piece of home hifi gear.
I haven't gotten around to setting up headphones for use with SACD and DVD-A discs, but am giving serious thought to doing what glangford did with getting a Cute Beyond.

















I'm just along for the ride...








Good God!! do you own that setup or you're just auditioning them?






