Quote:
Originally Posted by Timinator30 
When people complain or compare black levels...what exactly are they looking at?
It seems like people only talk about the BARS above and below the picture while watching blu-ray, etc. I mean, that has nothing to do with the picture itself. I've never heard anyone actually say something like:
"Man, these blacks aren't very good. The sky isn't as dark as I'd like it to be in Star Wars."
or
"Man, Darth Vader's helmet isn't as dark as it was on my other tv. I'm so bummed!"
It's always about how they want the black bars to disappear in the bezel. But what the hell does that have to do with watching a movie? I bet if the black bars didn't exist, none of us would be able to tell the difference between any televisions black level unless we hooked up equipment to the tv. And that seems to only help someone who visually can't tell a different, but wants bragging rights in the form of a number. Bragging rights that make no sense considering we aren't the ones making the televisions. It's something we chose to buy, not something we created. It's like Samsung vs. Panasonic vs. whoever...is one 'who has the biggest weiner' contest. lol...
Meanwhile, I watched "Predators" on Directv on Demand over the weekend. It's a really good movie that allows you to admire the set. A lot of green colors, red/orange fire and explosions, blues, and several scenes in the dark. A lot of motion as well. I recommend it (decent movie too) for those of you that want to see the amazing images that your tv produces from a 1080p24 source.

When people complain or compare black levels...what exactly are they looking at?
It seems like people only talk about the BARS above and below the picture while watching blu-ray, etc. I mean, that has nothing to do with the picture itself. I've never heard anyone actually say something like:
"Man, these blacks aren't very good. The sky isn't as dark as I'd like it to be in Star Wars."
or
"Man, Darth Vader's helmet isn't as dark as it was on my other tv. I'm so bummed!"
It's always about how they want the black bars to disappear in the bezel. But what the hell does that have to do with watching a movie? I bet if the black bars didn't exist, none of us would be able to tell the difference between any televisions black level unless we hooked up equipment to the tv. And that seems to only help someone who visually can't tell a different, but wants bragging rights in the form of a number. Bragging rights that make no sense considering we aren't the ones making the televisions. It's something we chose to buy, not something we created. It's like Samsung vs. Panasonic vs. whoever...is one 'who has the biggest weiner' contest. lol...
Meanwhile, I watched "Predators" on Directv on Demand over the weekend. It's a really good movie that allows you to admire the set. A lot of green colors, red/orange fire and explosions, blues, and several scenes in the dark. A lot of motion as well. I recommend it (decent movie too) for those of you that want to see the amazing images that your tv produces from a 1080p24 source.
I hear ya. I have often tried to compare the bezel, black bars (top/bottom) and black scenes within the picture frame. Its tough because a lot of what we see (judge) is relative as the eye can't make an acurate measurement.
For me, the most important viewing benifits come from an image that dosen't offend the viewers. I.e. white whites, black blacks, no noise etc... but again all the picture qualities are working together (hopfully) to present the image. Accuracy is important as a reference of course.





















