Quote:
No idea, but my initial email inquiring about it was sep 24th i believe. They did not have pricing at that time, so not sure they officially did pre-orders...

|
I just came across another data point on the 720p side-by-side discussion as being used by ESPN/Directv/cable. Back in Aug. 2010 Cablelabs, the cable industry standards body, issued a cable industry specification for "Content Encoding Profiles 3.0 Specification" that includes the cable industry specifications for 3D and this does not include the 720p side-by-side format. Rather at 720p resolution only the 3D top and bottom format is supported. HERE is one reference and HERE is the actual spec. itself (pdf file). Look in section 10 for the 3D related requirements. In section 10.1 of the Cablelabs spec., where the top and bottom 3D format is defined, it says:
"1. TaB formatting MUST be used with progressive (720p and 1080p) HD video formats exclusively."
While in section 10.2 where side-by-side is defined it says: "1. SbS formatting MUST be used with interlaced (1080i) HD video formats exclusively." So the offical cable industry standard formats for 3D are: While Cable TV standards do not apply to Directv, it would seem to me that ESPN should distribute their 3D programming in a format that does comply with Cable TV industry standards. |

|
Not to keep pounding this subject like Sly Stallone in the first Rocky but . . . (I'm gonna cause it needs to be until corrected!) . . .
Go on to the JVC website BEFORE they take it off now that I am posting this but do any of you see an issue with their advertisement??! . . . Extraordinary Picture Quality
|
|
Jason, Daniel, and Bobbijean are calling those that are getting from the batch that just arrived. I am not because none of my customers are getting one given that I didn't start working for AVS and taking orders until about 6 weeks ago or so. Not all have been called yet. Emails if we can`t reach you by phone so all the err winners will get promptly notified. Also a few more may trickle in next week We would anticipate receiving another big batch, and bigger than this week's batch, about 2 weeks from today. BTW. This is exactly the same scenario we get from JVC every year. Two week shipments, increasing in size, with only a small amount in the first shipment, itself always delayed a few weeks from the originally announced shipment date.
|
|
In summary, the 3D formats that are missing and causing incompatibilities are 720p SbS, and 1080i TnB, right? Anything else?
|
|
Depends on the definition of "all modern 3D formats". For example, caveman era 3D did not account for active-shutter glasses, polarization light loss, or really wide HT screens created to accomodate really wide sofa butts. Obviously a spec level would have clarified this meaning... ie: post-iceage man is a little more clear. No?
It should be interesting to see who blinks first... 1) JVC acknowledging the limitiations of this 1st gen 3D PJ incarnation or fixing it with and update, or 2) customers pulling the plug. In the beginning there was a void. A dark abiss without form or light. |
|
I think that the 720P SBS one is the one we're all mostly concerned about, everything else comcast/directv 3D works just fine with the JVCs
|
|
I just came across another data point on the 720p side-by-side discussion as being used by ESPN/Directv/cable. Back in Aug. 2010 Cablelabs, the cable industry standards body, issued a cable industry specification for "Content Encoding Profiles 3.0 Specification" that includes the cable industry specifications for 3D and this does not include the 720p side-by-side format. Rather at 720p resolution only the 3D top and bottom format is supported. HERE is one reference and HERE is the actual spec. itself (pdf file). Look in section 10 for the 3D related requirements. In section 10.1 of the Cablelabs spec., where the top and bottom 3D format is defined, it says:
"1. TaB formatting MUST be used with progressive (720p and 1080p) HD video formats exclusively." While in section 10.2 where side-by-side is defined it says: "1. SbS formatting MUST be used with interlaced (1080i) HD video formats exclusively." So the offical cable industry standard formats for 3D are: While Cable TV standards do not apply to Directv, it would seem to me that ESPN should distribute their 3D programming in a format that does comply with Cable TV industry standards. |









