or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › "Raising Hope" Fox HD
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

"Raising Hope" Fox HD - Page 2

post #31 of 67
Raising Hope Creator Greg Garcia on Balancing Sweet and Crass, and Being Licked by Cloris Leachman
By Josef Adalian, New York Magazine's 'Vulture' Blog - October 26th, 2010

Much of the media buzz surrounding Fox this fall has focused on Lone Star's spectacular belly flop and the struggles of Running Wilde. But lost in all that bad news has been the quiet success of Raising Hope, the network's sweet (and sometimes sour) new family comedy from My Name Is Earl creator Greg Garcia. The best-reviewed network newcomer of the fall on Metacritic, it was the first new show of the season to get a full-season order, a sign of how much faith Fox execs have in it. And while its post-Glee time slot is a big reason Hope is averaging a healthy 8 million viewers each week (counting DVR numbers), the show has held relatively steady since its debut, indicating viewers like what they see. Assuming Hope can keep it up, it could turn into something Fox hasn't had in years: a successful live-action comedy it can actually be proud of (sorry, 'Til Death). Vulture caught up with Garcia to talk about how the show has been evolving, the joke he ceded to It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, and what it was like running the perpetual TV-critic punchline Yes, Dear.

So how was Raising Hope born?
My Name Is Earl was canceled, and I think within a month, I was over at Fox pitching this idea. It was an idea I was thinking of maybe doing as a movie, but I didn't have it fleshed out fully ... and it didn't have an ending. So that made it a good TV show, because you don't need an ending.

What specifically led to this idea?
In the past I've said these things just pop into my head, and that's gotten me into a little trouble because people try to jump up and say I took it from them. But I really just try to sit back and think of what would make me laugh, and create the characters in my head and come up with these situations. It isn't anything from real life. It's just sitting down and creating a little world in your head.

With Earl and now Raising Hope, you've shown an ability to write blue-collar characters intelligently, without pandering. A lot of critics seem to appreciate that, but some have suggested you're making fun of middle America, or treating them as dumb.
That's certainly not my intent at all. Everyone's entitled to their opinions, but I don't get that. It's comedy: You're going to make some people dumb, whether they have money or not. It's always my intent to just kind of laugh with people, and to keep it as real as I possibly can. There's also a big difference: With Earl, it was about criminals and one of them was trying to make himself better. This show is just lower-income folks; they're not criminals. And I don't think they're dumb as much as they're just not as educated as perhaps they could be.

Why don't you think there's more blue collar on TV? You and The Middle, and maybe now Mike & Molly seem to be about it in prime time ...
I don't know if it's that more people aren't writing it or pitching it. Or perhaps maybe the networks are a little scared of it. Everybody loves glamour and glitz. When they see a dirty house with just normal people, they worry maybe that people won't want to sit down and watch that. They want more fantasy in their lives, to watch something that's nicer than what they have. But for me, I'd rather go home and look in the window of that family than the window of some family with money that has it all together. It just seems more interesting to me.

Earl and Hope have gotten largely good reviews. Yes, Dear, not as much so. Do you and Chuck Lorre ever trade stories about being underappreciated by critics?
I've only met Chuck once, during the writers' strike. Though last week I sent the writers on The Big Bang Theory a giant basket of cookies and muffins to thank them for kicking NBC in the nuts every Thursday. [NBC canceled Earl in 2009.] I heard Chuck thought that was funny, but I haven't traded stories with Chuck. You know, Chuck has had a lot more success than I have in the syndication game, so I'd guess that Chuck doesn't really give a **** what anybody thinks. He's got a great deal of America on his side liking his shows. I got beat up with Yes, Dear. You just kind of take all that hate and put it in a box, and when you need it, you go get it for inspiration. But [critics] have been nicer with the other stuff, which is definitely better than getting stomped on.

Do the bad reviews get to you?
At the time when you're in it, you really get bothered by that kind of thing. But when you work in the business for a long time, you get perspective. I get that people need to have their angles. But sometimes [critics] are like a dog with a bone and they just won't give it up. I mean, the thing that always was curious about Yes, Dear was, okay, I get it, you don't like the show. But then for six years to continually **** on the show? At a certain point, it's like, "Listen: America seems to be okay with it. They're watching it, it's staying on. Why don't you move on to something else?" I'm not sure it always has to be the easy joke to lash out at it ... We call [an easy joke] a clam in the comedy business. Critics can have clams just like comedy writers.

For a guy who puts a lot of borderline crass stuff in his shows, there's also an amazing amount of heart, like Martha Plimpton's singing to Hope in the pilot.
You're trying to appeal to a broad audience. So there are going to be people who are not going to enjoy a baby getting thrown up on. But they're not going to not watch the show next week, because they also really enjoyed the sweetness of Martha singing. And then there are people who don't give a **** about the singing and the sweetness, and they're going to be talking about the next day, "Hey, did you see that they threw up on a baby?" There's a certain amount of spreading it around. It's life: Nobody's sweet all the time, nobody's gross all the time. We just try to capture all of that. And then at the end of the day, do whatever's funny and tells a good story. We're not always going to be gross, but if we feel it's funny, we'll do it. And we're not always going to be sweet, but if we have a story that we feel we've earned it with, we'll go for it.

Do you shoot for a certain ratio between the two?
No, there's no chart on the wall of grossness versus sweetness. You know, in the pilot, we shot it where you didn't actually see him throwing up on the baby. Then I thought, What the hell, let's shake it up a little bit. It's not what the whole show is. But it got people talking, and they wrote about it, so: Good!

So how is the show evolving from the pilot? Is the universe expanding beyond the core of the family?
It's a slower build than in Earl. But we're populating different parts of the show, like the grocery store. They're going to go see a lawyer, and I can see them going back to him. I like to create a world and then go back to those characters. But it's going to be a slower build-out than Earl. There's also the possibility of aging this baby at some point. I've talked about jumping forward in time so that the baby is all of a sudden 3 years old. Because there's a lot more stories to be told with a 3-year-old than, say, the ages of 8 months and 2. I have three kids and it's been my experience that things get a lot more exciting when they start talking and have emotions.

So what's coming up on future episodes?
[In an episode airing tonight] we're going to investigate the world of secrets and what you keep from each other. We have Bijou Phillips coming back as our executed mother. She left a bunch of tapes for Hope. They're life lessons, and they're a bit crazy. So it raises the question of how much you hide from her, and how much you tell her one day. We're doing a Thanksgiving one where we're going to have the executed mom's parents over for the first time. Greg Germann (Ally McBeal) is paying the father and Valerie Mahaffey (Northern Exposure) is playing the mom. And the Christmas episode will reveal around a living manger. The discussion in the house is whether Hope is allowed to be part of the living manger and what the church feels about it.

Any more singing from Martha?
I think maybe in the Christmas episode.

Will we be seeing more of Shelley (Kate Micucci), the babysitter with a dead tooth and a crush on Jimmy?
Yes, she comes back quite often, but we took her dead tooth away. I watched the season premiere of It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, which I think is the funniest show on TV. And they had a woman with a dead tooth. And I was like, "Awww, ****! Ours hasn't even aired yet! How the **** can you have two people with dead tooths?" So we shot an episode with her last week where we took her dead tooth away. I thought, What's the point? They did a dead tooth, I don't want to keep doing it.

How do you explain it?
Martha's character asks her, "What happened to your dead tooth?" And Shelley says, "Well, I thought it was unique and then I was watching a hilarious episode of It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia and a girl had a dead tooth, so I decided to have it fixed." I just figured, we got all our dead-tooth jokes out. And their dead tooth looked better than ours. That just bummed me out. Their's was all cool and gray. Ours didn't look as good. But Shelley has more to offer than a dead tooth.

How is the relationship between Jimmy and Sabrina (Shannon Marie Woodward) developing?
We're kind of taking it slow. It's the one thing in our show that's a little bit serialized so I don't want to say too much about it. But [tonight's] Halloween episode is a big episode for them. It progresses the relationship a little bit.

Cloris Leachman is a difficult character. You don't want to portray an old person as just dumb and batty, do you?
Her official diagnosis is: She has funny TV dementia. You can't take it too seriously. There are people out there who are confused, and it's sad and hard thing for families. But we're not telling that story. We're telling the story of a kooky woman who lives in the house, and sometimes she's not kooky. Hopefully people can just have fun with that. But we've actually found there are really great ways to have her not only be great comic relief in scenes. When she's lucid, she can really help advance stories a lot. Cloris is a hoot to work with. She licked me the other day.

She licked you?
Yeah, I feel like we've gotten to a place in our relationship we might not be able to turn back from. She's very affectionate. She's 84 years old and she's allowed to do whatever she wants. She's Cloris Leachman.

What sort of story lines will we see with her?
Well, in the Christmas episode, there's some discussion about the fact that there are no estate taxes in 2010. So they really only have two weeks left for her to die if they want to pay no taxes on the house. There's debate over whether they should stop trying to keep her character so safe. It's a nice little Christmas message that only our show will deliver.

post #32 of 67
I missed a few episodes, then just watched the last two on Hulu. The show has a improved a bit.
Jason Lee guest starred as Smokey Floyd a washed up rock star who performed at the grocery store.

The 2nd one was the one from last night, the Christmas episode. Also pretty funny, but heart warming too.

Hopefully it will continue to get better.
post #33 of 67
Wow this show gets no love here @ AVS. Rasing Hope is funny stuff. It's Married with Children with heart. Last night's season premiere was hilarious and so far the show hasn't really missed a beat. People you should be watching this!
post #34 of 67
Not here. I love this show. A wonderful venue to see Martha Plimpton doing what she does best and Garret Dillahunt finally play a good guy.
post #35 of 67
"Welcome. Want to see my ass?"

That line by maw maw last night had us rolling.....anytime Cloris Leachman is on-screen is funny stuff.

Garrett Dillahunt's Burt is awesome and Martha Plimpton's weekly misguided decision making somehow has a sweet resonance that *works* in my household's view.

I've been watching this show since week 1 and try to tell EVERYONE I can that it's funny, worthwhile viewing.
post #36 of 67
I don't think it is as good as My Name is Earl was, but it has definitely improved. It's gotten away from making every episode being about the baby, which probably is good.
post #37 of 67
"gee MawMaw back then you looked like the horny neighbor on the Mary Tyler Moore show" ....funny stuff
post #38 of 67
I love this show but has anybody else noticed how great the sound is on the show? The bass in particular is amazingly deep, dynamic and clean. Last night's epeisode was hilarious, especially when the cutting between the two families at dinner in their respective homes.
post #39 of 67
Originally Posted by audiomagnate View Post

I love this show but has anybody else noticed how great the sound is on the show? The bass in particular is amazingly deep, dynamic and clean. Last night's epeisode was hilarious, especially when the cutting between the two families at dinner in their respective homes.

Was this a repeat? I didn't notice anything on the DVR this AM from Tuesday night....
post #40 of 67
Originally Posted by jaypb View Post

Was this a repeat? I didn't notice anything on the DVR this AM from Tuesday night....

Yes - it was the "playdate" episode.
post #41 of 67
Hopefully this show isn't ignored in viewer-land like it is here! Great episode this week. Illicit drugs, flirting and all kinds of shenanigans. Burt was hilarious as usual and Plimpton consistently nails her delivery as Virginia. This show never disappoints.
post #42 of 67
My wife and I watch it and enjoy it quite a bit (one of maybe 2 sitcoms we both like). There's just not a whole lot to discuss with most sitcoms (even the more popular ones like The Office don't seem to get much attention here).

With standalone episodes, there's not as much to discuss versus a serialized drama with plot developments and story archs.

Regardless, we both really like the show. The awkward "drink from a hose" scene between Burt and the lady had us rolling.
post #43 of 67
If anyone cares...

TV Notes
Fox Renews Glee', New Girl' And Raising Hope'
By Nellie Andreeva, Deadline.com - Apr. 9, 2012

Fox has renewed three more series for next season: freshman comedy New Girl, hourlong musical comedy Glee and family comedy Raising Hope. It will be a second season for New Girl, fourth for Glee and third for Raising Hope. Over the past season, New Girl has become the hottest new appointment series for young adults; Raising Hope has established itself as one of the smartest and most unique offbeat comedies on television; and Glee has continued its success as a genre-defying, global cultural phenomenon, said Fox's entertainment president Kevin Reilly. All three of these comedies add a fresh and distinctive flavor to our Tuesday nights, and I'm really happy to bring them back to our air next season.

The pickup comes after Raising Hope delivered solid numbers when moved to the anchor 8 PM position in the two-hour comedy block Fox tried out while Glee is on hiatus, earning a spot on the renewal list alongside shoe-ins Glee and New Girl. Fox's Tuesday lineup returns to normal tomorrow with new episodes of all three newly-picked up series, Glee, followed by New Girl and Raising Hope. The three comedies join recently renewed Fox dramedy Bones.

As for Fox's other comedy series, I Hate My Teenage Daughter has been practically canceled, while Breaking Ins chances for another comeback after surviving last year's cancellation appear slim. On the drama side, another, probably shortened season of Fringe still looks like a possibility if the economics are worked out.

post #44 of 67
still a very good and silly show
post #45 of 67
Originally Posted by randosel View Post

still a very good and silly show

I agree - I watch it each week via DVR for some serious chuckles. I 'specially like the chemistry amongst the main characters - and Cloris is a hoot as granma!
post #46 of 67
I've only recently caught up with this show. I really like it and am glad that it has been picked up for another season.

Martha Plimpton does a perfect job in playing one of the most endearing characters on TV today. Her delivery couldn't be any better, especially when her character gets her words wrong.
post #47 of 67
Didn't see that surprise ending coming! I liked the short clip of My Name is Earl.
post #48 of 67
Originally Posted by MSmith83 View Post

I've only recently caught up with this show. I really like it and am glad that it has been picked up for another season.

Martha Plimpton does a perfect job in playing one of the most endearing characters on TV today. Her delivery couldn't be any better, especially when her character gets her words wrong.

Plimpton's mispronunciations crack my wife and I up...and help us explain to the kids just what the heck the words are that they need to make sure they pronounce correctly!!

And maw-maw is awesome. And the guy who plays Frank cracks me up with his mannerisms.

Great show all around. Especially appreciate the way they have no problem poking fun at each other...and in the end they wind up wrapping up the episode with a nice (crazy) but neat bow to show even a family as wacky as the Chance's somehow continue to survive and stay together.

Burt rules~!!
post #49 of 67
I still like the show; it's consistently funny and genuinely sweet (and crass), and the twins who play Hope are the loveliest toddlers in recent memory. I'm not much of a baby fan, but these little girls are real naturals, and I find myself rewinding the DVR to watch their reactions constantly.
post #50 of 67
Loved the "Earl J Hickey" Retirement Home.
post #51 of 67
Originally Posted by jabbathespud View Post

Loved the "Earl J Hickey" Retirement Home.

Yep - loved that nod to Earl and also LOVED Sabrina in that green dress = absolutely SMOKIN!!!
post #52 of 67
Originally Posted by filtor View Post

Yep - loved that nod to Earl and also LOVED Sabrina in that green dress = absolutely SMOKIN!!!

She is a very attractive in a plain girl way.

And that outfit was ridiculous.

I still love this show. If Betty White gets all the love as an older actress....where's the national love for Cloris Leachman? !?!?

post #53 of 67
This week's episode is hilarious. The writing is really top notch, and the actors have great chemistry with their roles.

I went back and started watching the first season via Netflix. The first 3 episodes were a little rough, but I watched the 4th one last night, and they had locked in the mood and chemistry already.
post #54 of 67
Not sure which ep it was in the first season, but it was the one where they were getting the family pictures taken where I was laughing so hard tears were rolling down my face.
post #55 of 67
Originally Posted by fhall1 View Post

Not sure which ep it was in the first season, but it was the one where they were getting the family pictures taken where I was laughing so hard tears were rolling down my face.

I haven't seen that one yet, but the 4th one, that I watched last night, was where Hope crawled into the shed full of junk, and they used Maw Maw's Jenga skills to pull out stuff so they could reach the baby.

Edit: Maybe it's actually the 3rd episode...
post #56 of 67
I think of all the comedies I watch, this results in the most laughter.

I loved tonight's "My Name is Earl" reunion episode. The two parter, "Yo Zappa Do", to Hollywood was hysterical. The Modern Wedding spoof on Modern Family was excellent as well.
post #57 of 67
It was indeed great to see Earl's gang back together again... was like seeing an old, hilarious friend you haven't seen in a long time.
post #58 of 67
I never watched "My Name is Earl", but yes, this show makes me laugh as well. There's just so much funniness involved. Visual background stuff. Physical acting. The characters themselves. The dialogue. The setups. The payoffs.
post #59 of 67
Cloris Leachman > Betty White ALL DAY LONG.
post #60 of 67
Lots of in-jokes. I particularly chuckled at the bit (in an earlier show) where Martha Plimpton lectured Lucas Neff and Garret Dillahunt about how some actresses start off working with Stevern Spielberg and end up stuck on obscure sitcoms.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HDTV Programming
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › "Raising Hope" Fox HD