So, I asked a number of questions and Lucid was kind enough to give me his thoughts, after a lot of messing around myself, I thought I'd post my experience to help out the next guy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tiger00 
Hey all,
I've tried to find this information out for myself, but this 3d format stuff is confusing.
I have the following:
Mits 65638
i7-2500k
4 gb ram
Radeon 4850
samsung internal bluray drive
win 7 64 bit
My goal is to watch bluray 3d movies on my tv.
So here are my questions:
1. If I connect an hdmi cable from my video card to the tv, and then using powerdvd (which i understand outputs in a checkerboard pattern) is that enough to watch the movie with dlp-link type glasses?
Yes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tiger00 
2. Can I skip the adaptor (3da-1) because powerdvd will output in checkerboard format?
Yes, no adaptor needed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tiger00 
3. Do I need any drivers, like IZ3D to make this work? with or without the adaptor?
No, drivers are not needed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tiger00 
4. Can I use a DVI-->hdmi cable?
Yes, no quality difference noticed at all. Of course, the DVI does not carry audio, but I use a fiber connection to the surround system so it doesn't matter.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tiger00 
5. I don't believe my video card can run AMD's HD3D, will that matter?
No, HD3D is not needed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tiger00 
6. Will the signal needed for dlp-link be sent correctly, is that within the software, the adaptor, or the tv?
I think Lucid answered this question better, but short answer: it is within the TV's menu, not the adaptor or the software.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tiger00 
7. Any opinions on powerdvd versus TMT5 or another option?
I have been using Powerdvd 11.
Things that worked:
1) hdmi to hdmi or dvi to hdmi both work fine with this setup, with dvi to hdmi you will need another way to handle audio
2) With Powerdvd 11, going into the 3d settings, for source format setting to auto generally works, although somtimes you have to set the input manually, esp with top/bottom formats. For the output simply set to "3d-ready (checkerboard)" and you're all set. These settings will work with top/bottom, SBS, and FullHD3D for bluray 3d - with the bluray 3d, the transition to checkerboard will decrease to half rez as always, but it looks great all the same.
3) Optoma BG-ZD101 work perfectly, with no additional hardware other than the glasses. Never lost sync once yet. They turn off if you look away from the screen, which is great, and as soon as you look back at the screen they're up and running. Fit over standard glasses with no issues.
4) AMD's HD3D is irrelevant to this setup (can't say if it matters for video games) and no special drivers are required (IZ3D, etc).
5) The 3DA-1 adaptor isn't needed with the computer setup because Powerdvd is doing all the work to convert to checkerboard. So, if you are using another input like a standalone Bluray player/PS3 you may (and probably will) need the adaptor.
Problems I ran into:
1) Powerdvd + Bluray discs + Daemon Tools do not play nice together. If you put in a Bluray disc it says it can't read it or some other such nonsense. Turn off Daemon Tools and you're good to go. I switched from Daemon Tools to another similar program and it can run in the backround just fine.
2) Major problem I ran into, took me a bit to solve, was that when I originally turned on 3d, I could tell I was getting a checkerboard pattern, but when I put the glasses on I was seeing a larger checkerboard pattern... a checkerboard on a checkerboard if you will... oh, and no 3D effect.
The problem was caused because I was using the scaling option in CCC to solve the typical tv->pc overscan. You CANNOT use scaling with 3d movies, that is what caused my checkerboard on checkerboard issue, with scaling removed/set to zero, 3D suddenly appeared. hooray.

3) You cannot use the "reduce" format on the tv and turn on "3D mode". This is an issue within the TV itself, if you have reduce format on then 3d mode is simply greyed out/not selectable.
So, you will always have a slight overscan when using 3D. Its not much and really doesn't seem to detract. If anyone has thoughts on how to solve the slight overscan I'm all ears.
4) So far, I've had no success using VLC or MPC-HC to play 3D content. Never did try TMT5, so can't say either way on it.
Sorry for the long post, thought it might help others. If anyone has thoughts on the overscan issue, let me know.