Originally Posted by Toe
Which one was a better 3d presentation?
Truthfully, I thought Under the Sea had better 3D and really only a couple of instances of obvious ghosting. There was one shot in Under the Sea of a potato fish coming out of the screen that was really impressive as it seemed to be only a few inches from my nose.
Deep Sea 3D looked nice and had good depth but the presentation seemed drier to me and the narration by Depp was really dry and Winslet often sounded like she was speaking to a five year old. There was also visible banding in this title, especially in a few shots featuring jellyfish in the deep ocean. Instead of inky black backgrounds, the sea took on a greyish hue like a satellite TV broadcast that didn't have enough bandwidth. While I got that feeling of looking out a window, at no time did anything ever really have the pop that I experienced with Under the Sea.
Other folks seem to think Deep Sea 3D was the superior title but the above was my experience.