AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › DVD Recorders (Standard Def) › Best recorder for upscaling TV signal
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Best recorder for upscaling TV signal

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
As the thread title asks, I'm after a recorder which passes through my cable signal and upscales it to 1080p. Is there anything particularly good at this task available?
post #2 of 5
The Panasonic EZ-28 DVDR has about as good of a tuner as I've seen, but note like all DVDRs they're not true HD but downconvert HD before upconverting it back to 1080p.
When I was using one in this manner I noted very good 480i and almost HD like 720p but 1080i channels didn't look as good as true 1080i HD(displayed on a HDTV).
If you have a true HDTV and plan on watching many 1080i channels(CBS, NBC, etc.) you'd probably want a true HD tuner, like the Centronics 502.
post #3 of 5
None of my recorders upscales as well as my worst player. I don't know why though but players are just much better.
post #4 of 5
It depends what you mean by "passes thru". If you mean "when its turned off, it passes the full HD signal from my cable to the TV tuner, so it can decode and display full HDTV", the answer is all recorders do this. But if you're asking "will the recorder tune HDTV signals itself and play them on my older HDTV that doesn't have a digital tuner" the answer is no, it will upscale as you suggest but the quality won't be near as good as direct tuning on a newer tuner-equipped TV or via an HD cable box.

Even if you have a new TV or recorder with QAM tuner for HD cable signals, it ain't a slam dunk. First of all, you need to have an HD signal on your cable, second, your TV itself needs to be able to tune those signals directly via its internal tuner, and third (but most important) your cable company needs to be passing the signals thru the bare cable wire unencrypted. Thats a lot of factors that need to coincide, and in more and more cities the whole shebang is unraveling as cablecos decide to take advantage of loopholes in DTV regulation to effectively force some kind of box on all subscribers. So no matter what recorder or TV you own or buy, eventually you will be tuning it via an external cable decoder box. "Cable" tuners in TVs and recorders will become about as useful as the human appendix within the next couple years.

As far as recorder upscaling goes, there's Panasonic, and there's everything else. Whatever their merits and drawbacks as usable recorders, Panasonics are known to be noticeably better at upscaling than all other recorder brands, which are a distant second at best. This is more significant re commercial DVD playback than tuner upscaling, however, and as jjeff & joed32 remarked a good dedicated player will beat any recorder at upscaling.
post #5 of 5
I have both the panasonic EZ28 and the Magnavox MDR513. Both are very good at up-scaling SD channels. The magnavox is easier to use with none of the bugs that plague panasonic.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: DVD Recorders (Standard Def)
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › DVD Recorders (Standard Def) › Best recorder for upscaling TV signal