Quote:
Originally Posted by snrsuave 
I've been thinking about jumping into this whole 3d thing, but I have a few questions that maybe some of you can help answer. My TV is a Samsung HL61A750. I have my PS3 connected to Yamaha RX-V661 (HDMI 1.2a). I would like to get the adapter kit, but am unsure of how I could hook things up and keep lossless audio from my PS3 to my receiver. Ideally, I would like to place the 3d adapter between my AVR and TV. I guess this wouldn't work because the AVR will not be able to pass the 3d Bluray bandwidth, even though the AVR just does passthrough. Is this correct?
Secondly, why aren't people using a splitter? I would like to know if you could take the PS3's output, send it to a splitter, which sends one output to the 3d adapter and TV, and the other output goes to the AVR for full lossless HD audio. Why wouldn't this work? I saw 3d capable HDMI 1.4 splitters on monoprice for like $20. Would this not work? If this option does work, then I am ready to order my adapter from TRU3d and get me some Optoma DLP link glasses. If there is no way for me to get 3d and keep my lossless audio without having to get a new AVR, then I may just have to pass on 3d for now. That would suck since I keep reading how great the 3d quality is with these sets. Thanks for the advice!

I've been thinking about jumping into this whole 3d thing, but I have a few questions that maybe some of you can help answer. My TV is a Samsung HL61A750. I have my PS3 connected to Yamaha RX-V661 (HDMI 1.2a). I would like to get the adapter kit, but am unsure of how I could hook things up and keep lossless audio from my PS3 to my receiver. Ideally, I would like to place the 3d adapter between my AVR and TV. I guess this wouldn't work because the AVR will not be able to pass the 3d Bluray bandwidth, even though the AVR just does passthrough. Is this correct?
Secondly, why aren't people using a splitter? I would like to know if you could take the PS3's output, send it to a splitter, which sends one output to the 3d adapter and TV, and the other output goes to the AVR for full lossless HD audio. Why wouldn't this work? I saw 3d capable HDMI 1.4 splitters on monoprice for like $20. Would this not work? If this option does work, then I am ready to order my adapter from TRU3d and get me some Optoma DLP link glasses. If there is no way for me to get 3d and keep my lossless audio without having to get a new AVR, then I may just have to pass on 3d for now. That would suck since I keep reading how great the 3d quality is with these sets. Thanks for the advice!
The sound on a 3D disc is encoded differently, and a 1.2 or 1.3 AVR can't recognize it, even with a splitter.
http://hdguru.com/3d-hdtv-and-hdmi-explained/1336/
Quote:
Unfortunately, your current HDMI equipped surround sound receiver will not pass the new FHD3D signal and no upgrades are possible according to both Sony and Denon. Why? A system called EDID (Extended Display Identification Data) currently handles communications between your TV, receiver and source components and it works fine. However, when your new 3D television communicates that it is a 3D television, the receiver will not understand because the 3D ID was not part of the standard when your receiver was designed. The receiver will shut off the HDMI signal and your new 3D TV screen will go black.
Unfortunately, your current HDMI equipped surround sound receiver will not pass the new FHD3D signal and no upgrades are possible according to both Sony and Denon. Why? A system called EDID (Extended Display Identification Data) currently handles communications between your TV, receiver and source components and it works fine. However, when your new 3D television communicates that it is a 3D television, the receiver will not understand because the 3D ID was not part of the standard when your receiver was designed. The receiver will shut off the HDMI signal and your new 3D TV screen will go black.
The PS3 will not output lossless audio while playing Bluray3D discs, so hook it up with optical (for 3D), and a splitter/switch combination connecting it through the AVR for 2D, and through the adapter for 3D.




















