AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Technical › Satellite vs Cable +ISP
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Satellite vs Cable +ISP

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
Sorry for yet another thread on this but coming from always having cable and looking towards the future - we're just not clear on which way to go any more when starting from scratch (due to relocation). Cable provider on the other side is Suddenlink FWIW. Also there is a very strong possibility this move will be for one year only - then another move following.

Needs -
HDTV on whatever/as many channels as it's available.
HD-DVR - currently use TiVo2, but would like to drop them going up to HD
ISP - has to be very high speed (likely only available through cable company - from what I've read satellite is really poor performing comparatively)
CHANNELS - NO premium channels - but all of the secondary ones like - Golf, E, TNT, FOX, ABC Family, TBS, SYFY, ESPN (basic), TBS etc. Don't want/care about Music Channels.
PHONE - NO! Some satellites seem to offer this - DO NOT WANT IT.

There are lots of promos, and fine print associated with Dish/DirectTV - so one question first - if we move in a year and have a 2 year deal - can I move it with us? I assume yes - but then the question of how complicated is the installation/moving? My guess is that everything is wireless and a move would be completely transparent inside the house - but climbing up on a roof and moving a dish off of one house and on to another might be a challenge not worth paying out for....yes the first install is free - but not the move or reinstall.

I've read that satellite companies nickel and dime you to death with hidden monthly rental charges for each set top box you want "extra". True?

I've read comments saying that some satellite companies only give you "HD Lite" - whatever that means???

Also with a satellite you may not get local channels at all (in some markets).

Satellite shopping is a bit foreign to us - so any additional input - particularly hidden caveats and negatives - per company - or in general - would be helpful. Going with cable is the easy thing to do - but if we can get the HD-DVR, better IQ and lower monthly and long term costs then it's worth considering changing to one of the other options.

Speaking of which - the 3 options we know of are Suddenlink, Dish, and DirectTV - if there are any others with better offerings, please do tell!

(Other media center/network items we use - Roku, AppleTV1 w/XBMC, SD Homerun, EyeTV3)

Thanks!
post #2 of 5
I suggest you start here - http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/forumdisplay.php?f=45

Just search for a thread for your DMA, you can talk with other users in the area you'll need service. The main problem with comparing sat to ground based services is the ground based ones can vary heavily depending on where you are located. For example where I live in MD, we have Comcast and we literally just got HD service last month and still don't have On-Demand. If I drive 20 mins north or south of my county I can get better Comcast service and Verizon FIOS.

As for Internet access, I wouldn't use satellite unless it's the only high speed choice available.

Any service you go with is going to charge rental fees for hardware, cable does the same thing.
post #3 of 5
IF you require a very high speed internet connection, I see Cable as the way to go. That said, check what's available locally. I use Comcast in ATL and I couldn't be happier...well, it could be cheaper. or free.
post #4 of 5
For internet access:

Fios->cable or U-Verse->DSL->satellite->dial up modem.

For picture quality nationwide:
Fios->DirecTV->U-Verse.

Over the air picture quality and cable picture quality will depend entirely on your local options. They could be as good as Fios, they could be crappy compressed standard def or (in the case of cable) lousy analog infrastructure. You'll just have to check you local thread to see what options are like where you live.
post #5 of 5
Re moving with satellite: With DirecTV, moving is free and they setup all the equipment at the new location. Just bring the boxes (not the sat dish) when you move. Your programming contract will re-start at the time of the move. Not sure about dish network. AFAIK, Dish or DirecTV do not provide telephone service or internet. Wildblue or Hughesnet sat ISPs do, but are a last resort, due to lag and data caps.

For locals, don't overlook OTA antenna reception, which often offers better quality and more local channels than sat or cable. And there are no monthly fees.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HDTV Technical
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Technical › Satellite vs Cable +ISP