Originally Posted by
MrMart 
Hi guys! Been following this thread for a while now. Here is my small review of my LG 55LW650 (European model of the LW5600) recently posted on avforums:
After playing around with my new 55 inch LW650W for two days, I'm definately more happy than i ever expected to be! The 3D quality and experience is just incredible and much much better in almost every aspect compared to active shutter 3D!
So far, this sunday and monday, Ive been totally watching 3 entire 3D Blu-ray movies, and also partially tested around 14-15 other various 3D Blu-Ray movies (both through standalone LG Blu-Ray player and HTPC over hdmi with TMT5 as player.
All this titles, I have previously seen on my previous Samsung 3D plasma (C680), and every one of them had various amount of crosstalk on the Sammy. Some of them had horrible double-image crosstalk everywhere, and some of them much less but still noticable crosstalk, which was destroying the 3D-experience. Also, the subtitles was kindof impossible to read due to all crosstalk...
Watching all those movies on my new LG LW650, I couldnt find ANY crosstalk at all!!! Belive me - I was really searching for it, and I almost was hoping to find some hehe.. But to my big surprise, no matter how deep the 3D effect was and how much "pop-outside-the-screen" 3D i saw, there was no sight of crosstalk whatsoever. The subtitles was also loking crisp and spot on - no double images and fully readable without the need of fully focusing my eyes on them. Its just crazy, in my opinion!
Ive been reading a lot of 3D Blu-ray movie reviews since I bought my first (active) 3DTV last year, and many of the 3D-titles often gets low scores due to "noticable crosstalk". Well, I actually believed that it was all about the movies' 3D-quality, used cameras, bad angles, etc etc... Until now! Now i understand that the problem is that most reviews are based on active shutter 3D tests. Its just the active 3D-technology that isnt enough, simply as that!
The worst 3D experience I remember with active shutter 3DTV was watching IMAX The Universe on 3D Blu-Ray. It was just unwatchable due to the high contrast (mostly black backgrounds and light stars/planets). I shut it off after 10 minutes. Yesterday I tested it on the LG, and...guess what... NO crosstalk at all! I couldnt belive it for a while...
Anyway... Yes - the lower vertical resolution in 3D mode is noticable, expecially while watching animated movies with crisp and sharp image such as "How to train your dragon", but its still no problem for me at all. Of course I really hope LG will introduce the 1080i algoritm soon, which would make the experience even better, but I could actually live with the lower resolution anyway, without whining about it. The passive 3D technology is just so much better anyway, and I really think this is the future of watching 3D at home.
I have so far not tested any Side-By-Side titles or TV channels, so I dont know if any crosstalk is visible in that 3D format. Anyone have some input here? I have a bunch of 3D channels (Sky 3D, Viasat 3D etc..) via my satellite dish, but I didnt had time to test it out yet, maybe because its not that important, after all...
The 3D glasses are very comfortable, light weight, and feels great without any flickering. Also, finally I wont loose sync while watching 3D movies Thats a great advantage!
By the way, I also tried two pairs of regular Real 3D glasses from my local cinema. They actually work with the TV, but those glasses quality is noticable worse. Somehow, the cinema glasses gives a little more blur, a little different colors and also a darker image. I guess I wont be using the cinema glasses at home, but as a side-note, Im kindof curious if the LG glasses would make the quality better at cinema, maybe? I guess I will give it a try hehe...
Somehow, Ive noticed that after tweaking a little with the "Film"-mode on LG LW650, i get the best movie-feeling and picture quality so far while watching 3D Blurays and regular Blurays. I tried calibrating and adjusting the ISF-modes, but it gives me a more video-look than a real movie-look. Maybe I just need more time to tweak it...
One thing is for sure - the True Motion effect is a big no-no! I turn it off in both 2D and 3D mode...
Besides the 3D then...
I think this LG TV generally has really great black levels, very good contrast and the colors are spot-on! Im impressed by the HD quality on both Blu-Ray movies, MKV rips as well as HD-channel broadcasts. I also like the local dimming actually, it gives me the inky black picture I was expecting from this TV, and it also "dims down" the noticable edge-light-bleeding my TV got in the lower right corner. Its not perfect, but still a very good feature, and thats why i have it on "High". Btw, i see no banding or clouding on my TV!
The SD picture could ofcourse be better on the LG, but I cannot imagine getting it SO much better on any other LED TV anyway. After all, its still a huge 55 inch TV, and Im sitting about 2,7 meters (around 8-9 feets) from the TV, so I wont be expecting to get "perfect quality" from any low-resolution SD-source from that distance... The LG still gives me better SD-quality than on my previus Sammy plasma anyway, probably due to the much better blacks, sharpness and contrast levels on the LG....
Well, thats all for now... As you probably can see, Im more than happy with my LG so far!
Lets hope we get this new 3D-algoritm update very soon so we can watch full HD 3D on this TV... This would make the TV even more perfect!
Regards,
Martin