AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › MFW-15 Dual Opposed Build
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

MFW-15 Dual Opposed Build - Page 2

post #31 of 319
Love it - great budget build !!!!
Always a big fan of the dual opposed !!

Now - how do they sound in sealed ???
post #32 of 319
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the comments guys. It really was a budget build for what I got in sub 20 output. I have just a shade over a grand in these speakers. Of course that does not include some of the router bits and other tools I picked up to make these, time, and I already had the amp.

As for listening impressions, unfortunatly, I really havent sat down and watched a movie yet. I did watch some wotw, incredible hulk, terminator salvation. Tonight I should be able to set down an watch something, but my first impressions are....i like it!
post #33 of 319
Nice job Wembley! I've been searching for drivers to use for a pretty much identical project: multiple sealed ~6 ft^3 enclosures, run off one ep4000, and around $1000 for drivers. Your project has definitely helped me and I think I'm going to order some of those drivers now.
post #34 of 319
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by haanjamin View Post

Nice job Wembley! I've been searching for drivers to use for a pretty much identical project: multiple sealed ~6 ft^3 enclosures, run off one ep4000, and around $1000 for drivers. Your project has definitely helped me and I think I'm going to order some of those drivers now.

Order them you wont be disappointed

Wem
post #35 of 319
Very Nice,

How did you wire them. I think they are 4 Ohms each, correct?
post #36 of 319
Thread Starter 
Yes thet are 4 ohm. I wired each cab series, for 8 ohms, then I wired two cabs in parallel to the amp to represent a 4 ohm load to the amp.

Wem
post #37 of 319
Quote:
Originally Posted by wembley2000 View Post
Thanks Coctostan, you are the one that turned me on to these and I am glad you did. As for THD measurements ask and you shall receive.

I have also attached a correct REW graph. I am only using 3db of boost on the low end to get these measurements.



The MFW-15s are only rated for 225 watts so one EP 4000 will and do power 8 easily
Those distortion numbers aren't far off from what NotNyt got with this 8 LMS 18s. There are obviously tons of variables such as room, treatments, placement, electronics etc. That is extraordinary for the money though. What are your room dims btw?

I'm very interested in your subjective comments.
post #38 of 319
Quote:
Originally Posted by wembley2000 View Post

Yes thet are 4 ohm. I wired each cab parallel, for 8 ohms, then I wired two cabs in series to the amp to represent a 4 ohm load to the amp.

What Am I missing here?

Two 4 ohms wired in parallel is 2 ohms, putting two 2 ohms in series is 4 ohms.
post #39 of 319
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BIGmouthinDC View Post

What Am I missing here?

Two 4 ohms wired in parallel is 2 ohms, putting two 2 ohms in series is 4 ohms.

BIG, you are correct, i had my series- parallel messes up. I corrected the above post
post #40 of 319
Should be series first, parallel second?

post #41 of 319
Throw in a couple of blurays and let us know what you think...
post #42 of 319
Thread Starter 
Got to set down and watch the a-team the other night. Some good lfe in that, not as hot as I thought it would be though. So far I am really liking the new setup, one problem though, the octave lower in extension I am getting has really brought out some new rattles in the theater room. I really need to get those fixed, I had most of them fixed with the old setup.

I still got to finish the cabs also, I think I am going to order some duratex today, wife wants me to get them covered. Do you guys think one coat would be enough? I would really like to order only one gallon, that stuff is expensive!
post #43 of 319


Just guessing at the naked FR, which isn't too hard to do with a sealed sub and looking at that vs the in-room response, you can estimate the THD savings when the sub is moved into the room.

I remember years back when I posted a similar comparo with the Tumult MKI at 6 Hz, going from approximately 85% to <10% THD and Ilkka told me there was something wrong with my measurement.

It's nice to see further confirmation in other's posted efforts, so thanks for the data (thanks as well to you, notnyt).

Bosso
post #44 of 319
Within probably +/-13mm the drivers behave quite well with useful excursion well beyond that. At high excursion the suspension gets a bit unhappy and will start to make noise/popping. Use enough drivers within those limits, and you're good to go. 4, 8 or 16 of these in 2.5-3.5 cu.ft. with appropriate EQ for the room and you're set. If you want to insure the best sound quality, before looking at the response at the listening position, take a single driver and smooth the near field response to a nice 2nd order profile appropriate for the room. DCX does a nice job for this and a MiniDSP would be another top choice, especially if they ever get around to adding a limiter function, although I know such talk is blasphemy to some around these parts.
post #45 of 319
As some of you know I picked up 230 of these for a group buy effort. I didn't list them anywhere just yet, but it is coming. So there will enough to go around.
post #46 of 319
If anyone has some good T/S specs on those maybe I'll pick up a dozen or two.
post #47 of 319
Thread Starter 
http://www.audiocircle.com/index.php...9641#msg859641

Here is the site I got them from.

Mr. Seaton,

I know you did some work with these drivers, do you know what the X-mech is on them?
I was pushing them the other day and did hear the popping noise you reffered to.

Wem
post #48 of 319
Hey, thanks for the specs, Wem.

Hmmm...hmmm!! These ARE very interesting drivers. Indeed. $80 a pop, eh? Oh crap.
post #49 of 319
Quote:
Originally Posted by Erich H View Post

As some of you know I picked up 230 of these for a group buy effort. I didn't list them anywhere just yet, but it is coming. So there will enough to go around.

Good deal! You can put me down for a couple.
post #50 of 319
Quote:
Originally Posted by wembley2000 View Post

http://www.audiocircle.com/index.php...9641#msg859641

Here is the site I got them from.

Mr. Seaton,

I know you did some work with these drivers, do you know what the X-mech is on them?
I was pushing them the other day and did hear the popping noise you reffered to.

Wem

The drivers were built by Eminence per my input for use in the ill-fated MFW-15. The suspension (spider) is the weak link of the driver, but kept within +/-20mm you shouldn't have any trouble. Sandbagger & I will have a modified SA-1000(rack version) able to drive 4 of these in 2.5-3 cu.ft. each making for a more plug and play option, but pro amps and some time to EQ and set up will make for a very high bang-for-buck solution, especially as the number of drivers goes up.
post #51 of 319
When I ordered 2 from gr-research today they said they have a few hundred left too.
post #52 of 319
Thread Starter 
Quote:


The drivers were built by Eminence per my input for use in the ill-fated MFW-15. The suspension (spider) is the weak link of the driver, but kept within +/-20mm you shouldn't have any trouble. Sandbagger & I will have a modified SA-1000(rack version) able to drive 4 of these in 2.5-3 cu.ft. each making for a more plug and play option, but pro amps and some time to EQ and set up will make for a very high bang-for-buck solution, especially as the number of drivers goes up.

Thanks for your input Mark. Would like to hear more about that amp though, some family members were asking about these and I wouldn't want to try to set them up with a pro amp and EQ.

Wem
post #53 of 319
Quote:
Originally Posted by kibe29 View Post

When I ordered 2 from gr-research today they said they have a few hundred left too.

I ordered 4 of them and looking forward to see what people are doing. I think this dual opposed has got me hooked, but I still have a lot to learn before starting the project.
post #54 of 319
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Seaton View Post

The drivers were built by Eminence per my input for use in the ill-fated MFW-15. The suspension (spider) is the weak link of the driver, but kept within +/-20mm you shouldn't have any trouble. Sandbagger & I will have a modified SA-1000(rack version) able to drive 4 of these in 2.5-3 cu.ft. each making for a more plug and play option, but pro amps and some time to EQ and set up will make for a very high bang-for-buck solution, especially as the number of drivers goes up.

How does this driver com pair to the Dayton 15" HF? They seem very close.
post #55 of 319
Closer moreso to the Dayton DVC15. The Reference series uses a lower distortion motor and has multiple shorting rings. This is definitely a budget wall buster. I like that!
post #56 of 319
This is an incredible bang-for-buck solution. I would say better than THT considering the extension gained.



Simply outstanding for only needing one amplifier to drive the whole set...reference to 10Hz with less than 5% THD. Run it at 6dB below and THD will fall to near nothing.

JSS
post #57 of 319
I keep kicking that around myself.

I was thinking 4 per enclosure, at least 2 cabs.
It should be bad ass. I mean the LMS is an amazing driver, but you can buy a ton of these for the price of one and spread 'em around.
post #58 of 319
^^^^^

DUDE! Are you reading my mind or what!?!? That's exactly what I was thinking of doing.

I'm thinking two or four cabs with four drivers per enclosure. One or two ep4k's. Daaayyyummmm!!!
post #59 of 319
Okay, that's it, I'm putting a limit of 4 per order! Nah just kidding. I've had 2 guys mention they might get 16 each, and one guy mentioned 10. That's crazy stuff.

I was hoping to sell them for $75 each, but I thought they should be double boxed for shipping protection. So the extra box with packing materials would put them closer to $77 each.

I opened up a FedEx account, and it looks like it saves about 15-20%, so that should help out. Might as well pass it on to the DIY guys. I wish it was more, and maybe it will get better as more items are shipped. The lady I spoke with said that many companies can save 30-40% on shipping pretty easy, but that most don't pass the savings to the customer. I've got no problems passing those savings on, so hopefully we'll get the higher discounts later.
post #60 of 319
Holy budget badassery batman!

Bravo wembley.........bravo.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: DIY Speakers and Subs
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › MFW-15 Dual Opposed Build