Quote:
Originally Posted by djams 
Well, this IS an owner's thread not a calibration thread. Posters come here with a perceived picture issue looking for help. "Go buy a meter" or "Get a professional calibration" just isn't a very helpful response.
To best explain how I see our difference of opinion on this topic I'll present a fictitious dialog between a new owner of this set and someone with your rigid point of view:
[New owner]: Hey everybody! I just picked up one of these bad boys and plugged in the CNET review settings. Picture looks awesome - you guys should check these settings out. Here's a link...
[Calibration Purist]: No, no, no - you can't do that. Sharing display menu settings between different sets will not work. You've made the picture worse.
[New owner]: So I should reset it?
[Calibration Purist]: Yes.
[New owner]: Ok. Bummer...
[Calibration Purist]: You are doing the right thing.
I hope you can see how ridiculous this looks.

Well, this IS an owner's thread not a calibration thread. Posters come here with a perceived picture issue looking for help. "Go buy a meter" or "Get a professional calibration" just isn't a very helpful response.
To best explain how I see our difference of opinion on this topic I'll present a fictitious dialog between a new owner of this set and someone with your rigid point of view:
[New owner]: Hey everybody! I just picked up one of these bad boys and plugged in the CNET review settings. Picture looks awesome - you guys should check these settings out. Here's a link...
[Calibration Purist]: No, no, no - you can't do that. Sharing display menu settings between different sets will not work. You've made the picture worse.
[New owner]: So I should reset it?
[Calibration Purist]: Yes.
[New owner]: Ok. Bummer...
[Calibration Purist]: You are doing the right thing.
I hope you can see how ridiculous this looks.
To add to this:
Calibration is a technical thing and also a belief. Anytime you question a persons beliefs there will be , reaction, questionings and fear of loosing the notion of "having it all figured out". People don't react well to having their mind set messed with. So, in some cases. . . maybe let others have their own mind set, if it isn't a threat to life or freedoms. The possibilities for owners desire to set up their TV are many:
1. I want a fast and easy set up for my TV inputs with as little fuss as possible.
I would like to use the presets, but maybe make some settings in Expert to get that yellow tinge out of the picture.
2. I want to know what the settings do on my TV, so I can get a good picture and learn enough to do that with the controls available without a lot of time invested. I don't believe a TV is a laboratory device capable of complete accuracy so damn the torpedo's and let's get to it!
3. I want to know ALL about why there are all these controls, what they do and how to use them. And, what? There may be differences from one brand or model of TV and another? How do I deal with that? I want complete accuracy! I don't care if it's a $400 low end for the bedroom or my $5,000 home theater! I just KNOW I can wring more out of it!- - - -Go to the Display Calibration sub-forum
And there are probably a couple more scenarios. I went the to the deep end of calibration obsession in the past, and have settled on adapting to what people want. Most people do move on. Maybe next it will be wood working tools, audio equipment [vintage or new], or car restoration and collecting. And all the levels involved in those things.




















Fast forward a few months and suddenly they're "grizzled vets" arguing over the merits of i1D2's vs. specto's vs. profiling for specific displays. 









