or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › 'Game of Thrones' on HBO HD - NO SPOILERS or Book Discussion
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

'Game of Thrones' on HBO HD - NO SPOILERS or Book Discussion - Page 30

post #871 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by lonwolf615 View Post

Can't reply without bringing up the books, which is, correctly, forbidden.

- You could always jump over to the SPOILERS allowed discussion.
post #872 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by daryl zero View Post

You think the Kingsguard is told, look for a dark haired bastard because all of Robert's kids are dark haired?

Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

good point, but we don't know for sure.
it may or may not work and it certainly draws even more attention to her.


and what kind of escape was that. the kids all had a chance to run away but most just hide and watch the fight. seem rather convenient how easy it was to catch the kids afterwards.

I think they were told only have the helmet not of the hair color. The only one who knew the real difference were those who read the "book" and most of those that do know are dead. All that Joffery and they Queen know is that the bastard worked at the blacksmith and he had a custom helmet....at least thats what I remember from what was shown...Otherwise I would think they would ahve said somethign immediately in response...
post #873 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by tokerblue View Post

- You could always jump over to the SPOILERS allowed discussion.

Well, yeah...
But I appreciate the guys who have restrained themselves in this thread for the sake of those who HAVEN'T (like me) read the books.
post #874 of 4678
Zzzzz... as someone who has not read the books, I continue to be disappointed with this show. I was hoping that we'd see them do something this season, but it looks just like majority of last season so far - lots of characters that make it hard to keep up with who is allying with who, some payoff in the end that may or may not justify all the maneuvering.

If you're a book fanboy this is a great show. If not, I don't see the big lovefest here, it's very hard to follow with not a whole lot going on.

Tyrion is great btw, his deception trick was the fun part of this ep. He steals the show with every scene. Everyone else, meh.
post #875 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by RobertR View Post

I'm contemplating the absurdity of pushing Bran out a window for no apparent reason, because the "why" can't be depicted because it's "too adult".

No apparent reason? He witnessed sex between the queen and her brother!! pretty good reason to want him dead.
post #876 of 4678
After reading all the post about the last episode, I think the first episode with the child being pushed out a window several stories after walking in on relations between family members really set the tone.

Therefore, I'm not shocked in the least. Hell, they killed a baby just a couple episodes ago.

I the GOT, no ones head is safe!
post #877 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by vurbano View Post

No apparent reason? He witnessed sex between the queen and her brother!! pretty good reason to want him dead.

You either missed, or failed to comprehend, the discussion concerning the show's R rated nature. Try reading from post #821 on and see if you get it.
post #878 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by slowbiscuit View Post

Zzzzz... as someone who has not read the books, I continue to be disappointed with this show. I was hoping that we'd see them do something this season, but it looks just like majority of last season so far - lots of characters that make it hard to keep up with who is allying with who, some payoff in the end that may or may not justify all the maneuvering.

If you're a book fanboy this is a great show. If not, I don't see the big lovefest here, it's very hard to follow with not a whole lot going on.

Tyrion is great btw, his deception trick was the fun part of this ep. He steals the show with every scene. Everyone else, meh.

So why are you still watching? Neither my wife nor I have read the books, but we follow the story fine...and it's one of our can't miss shows each week.

I find it funny when people post about how much a show "isn't doing it for them" or "I don't see the big lovefest here"...well, don't watch. I don't see the "lovefest" with a lot of shows on TV right now...which is exactly why I don't waste my time watching them.

Sturmie
post #879 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by slowbiscuit View Post

Zzzzz... as someone who has not read the books, I continue to be disappointed with this show. I was hoping that we'd see them do something this season, but it looks just like majority of last season so far - lots of characters that make it hard to keep up with who is allying with who, some payoff in the end that may or may not justify all the maneuvering.

If you're a book fanboy this is a great show. If not, I don't see the big lovefest here, it's very hard to follow with not a whole lot going on.

Tyrion is great btw, his deception trick was the fun part of this ep. He steals the show with every scene. Everyone else, meh.

I and most others don't have a problem keeping up with the characters .. they are very well defined .. if the visuals / story / drama / don't do it for you, then nothing will ..

GOT is TV at it's finest ..
post #880 of 4678
Except for the opening credits I can't really tell the difference between this show and The Tudors. Maybe the Tudors are a soap using people? I think if if GOT had Queen, Sean Connery, Christopher Lambert, and a Kurgan it would be better for me. First season was decent but season two so far is a bit boring, IMHO.

It's a good show but the hype is unwarranted.
post #881 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by slowbiscuit View Post

...If you're a book fanboy this is a great show...

This struck me as an odd comment. How would you know this if you haven't read the books?
post #882 of 4678
I think that the statement is obvious from all the comments here.
post #883 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sturmie View Post

So why are you still watching? Neither my wife nor I have read the books, but we follow the story fine...and it's one of our can't miss shows each week.

I keep hoping it gets better, and I promise I won't come here to bitch about it every week. Just my two cents.
post #884 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sturmie View Post

So why are you still watching? Neither my wife nor I have read the books, but we follow the story fine...and it's one of our can't miss shows each week.

I find it funny when people post about how much a show "isn't doing it for them" or "I don't see the big lovefest here"...well, don't watch. I don't see the "lovefest" with a lot of shows on TV right now...which is exactly why I don't waste my time watching them.

Sturmie

I see nothing wrong with people sharing how much they don't like the show for whatever reason--it's just the other side of the coin--as plenty of people share how much they enjoy the show. Why tell them not to watch?...they're capable of making that decision on their own.

It's okay to offer a differing opinion. The truth is there are a lot of people that really enjoy this show (myself included), but there are going to be those that don't understand why, and those that simply hate it for what amounts to a very good reason in their minds. I'm honestly surprised we don't have more posts from people that gave it a try, and decided they're not fans...not that it's necessary for them to post, but from my experience on the internet, people aren't shy about expressing their displeasure. lol
post #885 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by JediMastr View Post


I see nothing wrong with people sharing how much they don't like the show for whatever reason--it's just the other side of the coin--as plenty of people share how much they enjoy the show. Why tell them not to watch?...they're capable of making that decision on their own.

It's okay to offer a differing opinion. The truth is there are a lot of people that really enjoy this show (myself included), but there are going to be those that don't understand why, and those that simply hate it for what amounts to a very good reason in their minds. I'm honestly surprised we don't have more posts from people that gave it a try, and decided they're not fans...not that it's necessary for them to post, but from my experience on the internet, people aren't shy about expressing their displeasure. lol

At some point, though, you have to wonder if some people have masochistic tendencies.
post #886 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by JediMastr View Post

I see nothing wrong with people sharing how much they don't like the show for whatever reason--it's just the other side of the coin--as plenty of people share how much they enjoy the show. Why tell them not to watch?...they're capable of making that decision on their own.

It's okay to offer a differing opinion. The truth is there are a lot of people that really enjoy this show (myself included), but there are going to be those that don't understand why, and those that simply hate it for what amounts to a very good reason in their minds. I'm honestly surprised we don't have more posts from people that gave it a try, and decided they're not fans...not that it's necessary for them to post, but from my experience on the internet, people aren't shy about expressing their displeasure. lol

+1

However, I do understand the comment about how it is difficult to keep up with who is allied with who.
Someone posted a link a few pages back to an HBO page which breaks down the relationships and characters a bit more.
post #887 of 4678
There's nothing wrong with criticizing a show on its thread. I've done so on other shows' threads. What invites a response is when you make generalizations about people who enjoy the show. Neither my wife nor I have read the books, but we enjoy the show.
post #888 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ron Temple View Post

Yeah, the problem with that little misdirection is that Lommy was a redhead and they're looking for a dark haired bastard.

They are looking for a kid with a bull helmet, which was lying right next to him.
post #889 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by slowbiscuit View Post

If you're a book fanboy this is a great show. If not, I don't see the big lovefest here, it's very hard to follow with not a whole lot going on.

I'm confused? How is it hard to follow something that has "not a whole lot going on"? This isn't a David Lynch film.

BTW, I haven't read the books either.
post #890 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by oink View Post

+1

However, I do understand the comment about how it is difficult to keep up with who is allied with who.
Someone posted a link a few pages back to an HBO page which breaks down the relationships and characters a bit more.

Half the fun of the show comes from the fact you don't KNOW who is really allied with who (Littlefinger, Tyrion, Varys, all have their not-fully-realized allegiances).
post #891 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by adpayne View Post

They are looking for a kid with a bull helmet, which was lying right next to him.

Don't forget the prisoners (Arya) said it was him also. So we have bull helmet and claims from those who knew him.
post #892 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by iontyre View Post

Half the fun of the show comes from the fact you don't KNOW who is really allied with who (Littlefinger, Tyrion, Varys, all have their not-fully-realized allegiances).

You have a good point (and I agree), but I was referring to the various kingdoms.

EDIT: Here is the link I was speaking of....
http://viewers-guide.hbo.com/game-of.../guide/houses/
post #893 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by oink View Post

You have a good point (and I agree), but I was referring to the various kingdoms.

EDIT: Here is the link I was speaking of....
http://viewers-guide.hbo.com/game-of.../guide/houses/

this post should be made into a sticky to help all us got folks.

i watch each week with my kid and we regularly pause the recording during playback to ask each other what each of us thinks is going on. really helps us keeping up with intricacies of the plot.
post #894 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by slowbiscuit View Post

I keep hoping it gets better, and I promise I won't come here to bitch about it every week. Just my two cents.



nothing wrong with your post. you seem to think most of us have read the books so that's why we get it.

on this no spoiler thread i would venture many, many people, maybe half or more
have not read the books, including myself.
post #895 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by adpayne View Post

They are looking for a kid with a bull helmet, which was lying right next to him.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wytchone View Post

Don't forget the prisoners (Arya) said it was him also. So we have bull helmet and claims from those who knew him.

watched it again and when they showed him in the barn the bull helmet was right next to him. presumably he took it with him when he went outside.
post #896 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

watched it again and when they showed him in the barn the bull helmet was right next to him. presumably he took it with him when he went outside.

The actuial son of Robert left it in the barn when they were being called ot arms....That kid was the last one out and saw that left helmet in the barn. When he saw this, he went back quickly and grabbed it. It was jsut his "bad luck" ;-) he knew twho the helmet belonged to, but at the time didnt care (old habits bie hard they say)...This was sort of a quick shot and if you dont pay attention when you are watching (with this show you cant multitask) you might have missed it.
post #897 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by slowbiscuit View Post

Zzzzz... as someone who has not read the books, I continue to be disappointed with this show. I was hoping that we'd see them do something this season, but it looks just like majority of last season so far - lots of characters that make it hard to keep up with who is allying with who, some payoff in the end that may or may not justify all the maneuvering.

If you're a book fanboy this is a great show. If not, I don't see the big lovefest here, it's very hard to follow with not a whole lot going on.

Thrones fits in perfectly with the great majority of HBOs dramatic output. Deadwood, Boardwalk, Treme, Rome etc. All shows where the characters drive the story and not vice versa and exist in an interesting time and place.

If you don't like the characters on Thrones then you'll find nothing here because you are not interested in what they do. But if you like those other HBO shows then you should know what to expect, because the only real differentiator is the setting. And for me, that's a huge plus point. It's an interesting world filled with interesting characters.

I don't do that books reading stuff either.
post #898 of 4678
Is it a spoiler to discuss things HBO makes available on the web, or in the HBO Go extras, or the DVD/Blu-ray bonus features?

I don't think so, as long as it doesn't spoil unaired episodes. Yet a thorough grasp of that extra material would bring most folks up to the same speed as the book readers as far as current and past developments.
post #899 of 4678
Thread Starter 
If it hasn't aired on television, it's a spoiler!
post #900 of 4678
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobby94928 View Post

If it hasn't aired on television, it's a spoiler!

I agree, plus the occasional early views offered OnDemand do not count as having been aired.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HDTV Programming
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › 'Game of Thrones' on HBO HD - NO SPOILERS or Book Discussion