AVS › AVS Forum › Other Areas of Interest › What's Your System Configuration › craig john's theater
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

craig john's theater - Page 11

post #301 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

I have Wides. I have no room for heights unless I use in-ceiling speakers:



Craig
Damn that picture always gives me the goosebumps
post #302 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

...... you shouldn't wait for a visit to investigate the Crowson tactile actuators. They're one of the best additions I've ever made to my system. You didn't hear me say this, but I would accept lesser subwoofage before I would give up my Crowson's. eek.gif

Now, go spend some money!!! biggrin.gif

Craig

I have experienced various seat "stimulation" products and each time, I felt it to be a major distraction from the movie. I've heard(felt) the D-Box which is/(was) supposed to be the ultimate implementation of seat actuators since some movies had D-Box information encoded in them. I think I also heard different versions of Butt Kickers.

Since everyone that comes to your theater seems to like them (and goes home and spends their hard earned money to replicate what you have), there must be something about the way you implemented it that is better than what I have heard the 4 or 5 times I have heard it -- or it's just not my cup of tea.

I did get a sample of seat actuators when I put all 4 subs in the rear of my room. The bass was INTENSE but the seat was constantly moving/vibrating in tune with the movie --- didn't like that either!!

But my interest in hearing your system has much much much less to do with having my rear end being massaged by explosions in a movie and more about your listening to your speakers and the implementation of "wides".

All of that aside, I will somehow get up there.
Edited by audioguy - 2/26/13 at 5:29am
post #303 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

That's funny!
I'm looking to your lead on the server. Between you and Dennis, I'm sure you'll figure it out. if it works for you, I will probably go ahead and get one too.
Then I highly recommend you get the BluRay. I'd bet even your parents would love to watch it with you.
It is a DVD-A, but it also has a regular DTS track on it. You'll want to listen to the Multi-Channel track though as that is the Hi-Rez track.

Craig
First, did you get my address? So, when I put this disk into the player, on the Integra, do I scroll around the surround "modes" until I see Multi on the display? Will there be a menu section on the disk as well that I have to select a listening mode? Then I will be getting almost the same sound quality that you have on your disk. Is that right? If the server works for me, it will work for anybody. I AM the lowest common denominator when it comes to stuff like this tongue.gif. I am assuming Dennis put in my order for the server. He said the wait time is 6-8 weeks. So about a month in a half to two months. Then he will load everything on their for me and set it up. Then he will program the tablet I am getting as well, So that will also take time. I am probably looking at just over 2 months before I have it in my system.

Again, I just have to say it, as I have said it before in many places here. You and Dennis have really helped me elevate my system to a place I really did not think I would be to attain in my room. So for that, I have to say thanks again smile.gif. Without you guys there is no way my room would sound as good as it does now. Anyway, back to the server. I am really looking forward to having everything at my command and I am really curious to see if getting the DVD racks out of the makes the room seem bigger. So just let me know if you got my info. One more thing. I listened to part of that demo disk. eek.gif. That about sums it up. It sounded amazing. I was just curious and I put my system in bypass mode(you know me). The total sound, from the highs down to the bass was just insane. I could not believe the bass my speakers were putting out on their own. It was truly mind blowing so thanks for that. It was a great day. Great people to hang out with while listening to a great system. I am sure Dennis will keep you posted and I will keep you updated on the server side of things.
post #304 of 335
Craig,

I certainly appreciate that insight. I am actually considering getting the studios instead of the Phantoms—I do love direct radiating surrounds, as all my setups have eschewed diffusion (bi-pole and di-pole) in the past, in favor of mono-polar speakers. Believe it or not, I like the concept of localizing surround effects, as makes for precise imaging. I generally test out surround imaging by popping on an Xbox 360 game and standing the character next to a source of persistent sound (could be an in-game power generator, or some other source of noise. I then just move my POV from right to left, and listen to how well my surrounds pan, and—at a 180 degree turn, I listen to see how well the speakers create a phantom (pun intended) 6th channel directly behind me. I hadn’t given much thought to the multi-polar nature of the Phantoms until reading your post, but I do think I’ll be sticking with direct radiation in the Studios.

Interestingly enough, I was looking at my room last night and if I went with the width channels at 60 degrees, they would be placed right in front of each of my Submersives. I may not be able to do the 60 degree location—perhaps around72 degrees will have to suffice, at which point, I could (theoretically) wall-mount each studio (although the amount of hassle involved would be monumental)

LOL, definitely—I will definitely be hosting the next one once the Legacies are up and running. It should be lots of fun 8-)
post #305 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by audioguy View Post

I have experienced various seat "stimulation" products and each time, I felt it to be a major distraction from the movie. I've heard(felt) the D-Box which is/(was) supposed to be the ultimate implementation of seat actuators since some movies had D-Box information encoded in them. I think I also heard different versions of Butt Kickers.
D-Box is so "over-the-top" it's gimmicky. It actually makes me nauseous. Comparing BK's to Crowsons is like comparing Cerwin Vega to Seaton Sound. BK's have massive output and strong effect, but they lack the subtlety and finesse of the Crowsons. The Crowsons add detail to the sound as well as just simple shaking.
Quote:
Originally Posted by audioguy View Post

Since everyone that comes to your theater seems to like them (and goes home and spends their hard earned money to replicate what you have), there must be something about the way you implemented it that is better than what I have heard the 4 or 5 times I have heard it -- or it's just not my cup of tea.
It may be my implementation, but others have easily duplicated it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by audioguy View Post

I did get a sample of seat actuators when I put all 4 subs in the rear of my room. The bass was INTENSE but the seat was constantly moving/vibrating in tune with the movie --- didn't like that either!!
Maybe they're just not for you. That's fine. If you come up, I can easily turn them off.
Quote:
Originally Posted by audioguy View Post

But my interest in hearing your system has much much much less to do with having my rear end being massaged by explosions in a movie and more about your listening to your speakers and the implementation of "wides".

All of that aside, I will somehow get up there.
You're welcome anytime. smile.gif Just check your wallet at the door. I don't want to be held accountable for any damage to it. biggrin.gif

Craig
post #306 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MIkeDuke View Post

First, did you get my address?
Yup! I will get it sent out today. smile.gif
Quote:
Originally Posted by MIkeDuke View Post

So, when I put this disk into the player, on the Integra, do I scroll around the surround "modes" until I see Multi on the display? Will there be a menu section on the disk as well that I have to select a listening mode? Then I will be getting almost the same sound quality that you have on your disk. Is that right?
Yeah, it's easy to navigate.
Quote:
If the server works for me, it will work for anybody. I AM the lowest common denominator when it comes to stuff like this tongue.gif. I am assuming Dennis put in my order for the server. He said the wait time is 6-8 weeks. So about a month in a half to two months. Then he will load everything on their for me and set it up. Then he will program the tablet I am getting as well, So that will also take time. I am probably looking at just over 2 months before I have it in my system.
This will be good!
Quote:
Again, I just have to say it, as I have said it before in many places here. You and Dennis have really helped me elevate my system to a place I really did not think I would be to attain in my room. So for that, I have to say thanks again smile.gif. Without you guys there is no way my room would sound as good as it does now.
You're certainly welcome Mike! We have enjoyed the experience and getting to know you!
Quote:
One more thing. I listened to part of that demo disk. eek.gif. That about sums it up. It sounded amazing. I was just curious and I put my system in bypass mode(you know me). The total sound, from the highs down to the bass was just insane. I could not believe the bass my speakers were putting out on their own. It was truly mind blowing so thanks for that. It was a great day. Great people to hang out with while listening to a great system. I am sure Dennis will keep you posted and I will keep you updated on the server side of things.
Yeah, that demo disc is AMAZING! Every song on it is unique and they all have excellent sound quality. Enjoy!

Craig
post #307 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BrolicBeast View Post

Craig,

I certainly appreciate that insight. I am actually considering getting the studios instead of the Phantoms—I do love direct radiating surrounds, as all my setups have eschewed diffusion (bi-pole and di-pole) in the past, in favor of mono-polar speakers. Believe it or not, I like the concept of localizing surround effects, as makes for precise imaging. I generally test out surround imaging by popping on an Xbox 360 game and standing the character next to a source of persistent sound (could be an in-game power generator, or some other source of noise. I then just move my POV from right to left, and listen to how well my surrounds pan, and—at a 180 degree turn, I listen to see how well the speakers create a phantom (pun intended) 6th channel directly behind me. I hadn’t given much thought to the multi-polar nature of the Phantoms until reading your post, but I do think I’ll be sticking with direct radiation in the Studios.

Interestingly enough, I was looking at my room last night and if I went with the width channels at 60 degrees, they would be placed right in front of each of my Submersives. I may not be able to do the 60 degree location—perhaps around72 degrees will have to suffice, at which point, I could (theoretically) wall-mount each studio (although the amount of hassle involved would be monumental)

LOL, definitely—I will definitely be hosting the next one once the Legacies are up and running. It should be lots of fun 8-)
Hi Matt,

If you're planning to do Wides and Sides, I think monopoles are a much better choice. I'm sure you can work around the placement issues. Instead of sitting in front of your F2's, could they sit on top of them? If not, then I think I would opt for "inside" the F2's at less than 60 degrees rather than "outside" the F2's at greater than 60 degrees. Can you try it out both ways before you install them?

Craig
post #308 of 335
"Yup! I will get it sent out today smile.gif."
Sweet
"Yeah, it's easy to navigate."
I like easy.
"This will be good!"
Indeed. It will be very convenient.
"You're certainly welcome Mike! We have enjoyed the experience and getting to know you!"
I appreciate that. You know it's the same for you.
"Yeah, that demo disc is AMAZING! Every song on it is unique and they all have excellent sound quality. Enjoy!"
I can't wait to listen to the entire disk from start to finish.
post #309 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

Comparing BK's to Crowsons is like comparing Cerwin Vega to Seaton Sound. BK's have massive output and strong effect, but they lack the subtlety and finesse of the Crowsons. The Crowsons add detail to the sound as well as just simple shaking.
It may be my implementation, but others have easily duplicated it.
Craig

Besides what Craig mentioned above, I think the Crowson react faster and seem much quieter.
I only experienced the BK once. It was a few years ago at my friend's house and I believe he had it turned up too much and using too high of a crossover. It also was making some buzzing noises. I thought it was too gimmicky and distracted me from the movie experience. My friend, on the other hand, loved it but he has complained a few times about the Buttkicker bottoming out and making some god awful sounds. He still loved it though. My wife also experienced the Buttkicker at this friend’s house. She originally did not want me to buy the Crowson based off that BK experience. We probably would have enjoyed the BK experience better if it was dialed in more. The Crowsons also require some tweaking but, I think, the end result is awesome.

If it was not for Mike, Matt, and Craig, (THANKS AGAIN GUYS!) I would have based my limited transducer experience on the one, over the top, Buttkicker setup and never would have gotten the Crowson. That would have been a huge mistake on my part.
post #310 of 335
For me, what did it was the subtlety of the system. It just felt like a natural extension of the soundtrack. At least in my system. it seems to grab the last bit of grunt that's on the disk. The Tron grid scene, it just has that extra "shake" if you will. Not like it's going to shake you out of your chair, but you get every last bit of that movie with the Crowson. Not that I felt like I missing anything with the SubMersive HP. But with the Crowson, you just get that extra, not over the top extra though, that makes you smile just a bit more. Experiencing it at Craig's house again was a real treat since his is setup different then mine. Not that I don't, but Craig really has them dialed in really good. But again, I really like how it is setup in my room. It's a wow factor addition for sure.
post #311 of 335
Wonderful set-up. When I see Brolicbeast and MikeDuke drooling, I know the set-up is something special. Maybe someday I will have the resources and knowledge to build something comparable. Very well done.
post #312 of 335
When you take the entire package, meaning audio, video, and the room(seats), it's really hard not to say great things about Craig's system. I know Matt is excited to get his Legacy speakers. When he does, his system will also have some major drool factor. Not that it doesn't now, but I have a feeling that the new speakers will take that up a notch. Me, I think I have really good sound with a small screen. Oh well, what can you do tongue.gif. Since I had to compromise on the picture size, I refuse to compromise on the sound. But Craig's setup everything setup right. In the right proportions. His sound and picture go hand in hand.
post #313 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frohlich View Post

Wonderful set-up. When I see Brolicbeast and MikeDuke drooling, I know the set-up is something special. Maybe someday I will have the resources and knowledge to build something comparable. Very well done.
Hold up just a sec. I wrote that reply without talking a look at your system first. Are you kidding me? You hope to someday build something comparable. Um... I hate to say this, but you are already there. You have NAD gear, which I know is top notch. You have 7 JTR speakers and 2 JTR S2's. You have 4 automatic reclining chairs. And you have a 110" screen. I will say it again, you are there. The ONLY things I might suggest is if your preamp does not have XT32 maybe you should think about getting one that does like an Integra. Yea, Craig may have more power but your speakers are really sensitive as well so I am sure the NAD amp can make them sing. And he has a larger screen rolleyes.gif. Like 110" isn't big enough. The only other thing I would recommend you look into are room treatments. They will make a world of difference and you will hear what your gear really sounds like. In fact, I would do that regardless of any of my other comments. If you are not sure where to start with treatments, as I said many times, I would look into, and contact GIK treatments. They will really help you out. But enough about not being there. You are closer then you think.
post #314 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frohlich View Post

Wonderful set-up. When I see Brolicbeast and MikeDuke drooling, I know the set-up is something special. Maybe someday I will have the resources and knowledge to build something comparable. Very well done.

You know--a room designed from the ground up is a reflection of it's designer, and your room is quite drool inducing visually. Although I haven't ever heard JTR's offerings, the firm's reputation among the enthusiast community is purely positive, which leads me to believe it's audibly drool-inducing as well. I'd love to hear JTR's Noesis' horn-loaded compression driver in an a/b test with the Triad Platinum horn-loaded silk dome tweeters. Epic!
post #315 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

Hi Matt,

If you're planning to do Wides and Sides, I think monopoles are a much better choice. I'm sure you can work around the placement issues. Instead of sitting in front of your F2's, could they sit on top of them? If not, then I think I would opt for "inside" the F2's at less than 60 degrees rather than "outside" the F2's at greater than 60 degrees. Can you try it out both ways before you install them?

Craig

Craig, ive been thinking about this all day....I'll probably try to rig an old receiver to pull amp-passthrough duty so I can test this week or next.
post #316 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by MIkeDuke View Post

Hold up just a sec. I wrote that reply without talking a look at your system first. Are you kidding me? You hope to someday build something comparable. Um... I hate to say this, but you are already there. You have NAD gear, which I know is top notch. You have 7 JTR speakers and 2 JTR S2's. You have 4 automatic reclining chairs. And you have a 110" screen. I will say it again, you are there. The ONLY things I might suggest is if your preamp does not have XT32 maybe you should think about getting one that does like an Integra. Yea, Craig may have more power but your speakers are really sensitive as well so I am sure the NAD amp can make them sing. And he has a larger screen rolleyes.gif. Like 110" isn't big enough. The only other thing I would recommend you look into are room treatments. They will make a world of difference and you will hear what your gear really sounds like. In fact, I would do that regardless of any of my other comments. If you are not sure where to start with treatments, as I said many times, I would look into, and contact GIK treatments. They will really help you out. But enough about not being there. You are closer then you think.

I appreciate the kinds words Mike. I don’t want to threadjack Craiq’s thread so I will keep it short. I think on the L/C/R speaker front, projector front and room treatment front Craiq has the upper hand. I love my new room and am very blessed to able to have put it together. Seeing Craiq’s room, for example, gives me something to look forward to as I know there is room for improvement for me.
post #317 of 335
I won't thread jack either except to say that Craig's room is one of the rooms I look to for inspiration.
post #318 of 335
I've been wanting to demo the plats for awhile. I've heard a system comprising of Gold LCRs+ Silver LCRs for surrounds and loved em. Do you think they will do well for an 18x24 room?
post #319 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frohlich View Post

I appreciate the kinds words Mike. I don’t want to threadjack Craiq’s thread so I will keep it short. I think on the L/C/R speaker front, projector front and room treatment front Craiq has the upper hand. I love my new room and am very blessed to able to have put it together. Seeing Craiq’s room, for example, gives me something to look forward to as I know there is room for improvement for me.
Since HT is not a competitive sport, I try to stay away from comparing the relative goodness of one system vs. another. Your system looks absolutely fantastic, and I have no doubt you are very happy with it, and proud of it... as you should be. Still, it's nice to know that others appreciate the hard work we put into our "labors of love." smile.gif

Craig

Edit: The "not-so-man-cave" is AWESOME!!!
Edited by craig john - 2/26/13 at 2:17pm
post #320 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MIkeDuke View Post

I won't thread jack either except to say that Craig's room is one of the rooms I look to for inspiration.

Thanks Mike. See above as my response to Frohlich applies equally to you. smile.gif
post #321 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BrolicBeast View Post

Craig, ive been thinking about this all day....I'll probably try to rig an old receiver to pull amp-passthrough duty so I can test this week or next.
Let us know how it goes. I'll be interested in your thoughts and impressions of the Wides in different positions.

Craig
post #322 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by pokekevin View Post

I've been wanting to demo the plats for awhile. I've heard a system comprising of Gold LCRs+ Silver LCRs for surrounds and loved em. Do you think they will do well for an 18x24 room?
My room is 24' long. The width varies from 15' to about 19'. There is a stairwell off the right, front corner and a hallway to a bathroom in the rear, so the right side of the room is "uneven." The total cubic footage is about 3,800. Short answer... yes, I'm sure the Plat's would work well in your room. The seating distance is key. You want to be far enough away that the output of the drivers blends into a cohesive signal. I am 11' away, and I don't think I would want to be much closer than that. Ask Paul Scarpelli what the optimal minimum seating distance is. I'm sure he can tell you.

BTW, I think you've seen this before, but if I could do it over, I would seriously consider a "baffle wall" with the Plat's. Anthony Grimani uses these and they make the whole system significantly more efficient:

040601_baffled_again.pdf 182k .pdf file

Craig

Edited to fix link
Edited by craig john - 2/26/13 at 4:16pm
post #323 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

D-Box is so "over-the-top" it's gimmicky. It actually makes me nauseous.
Craig
When is the last time you tired D-Box? Also, did you know to can tweak it? You an adjust the motion and vibrations to almost infinite levels. At one point Crowson even wanted to be able to use D-Box codes for their vibrations due to the fact that they are more intelligently coded vs just running off the bass track. Hope I am not out of place here. I am a D-Box owner, and at one point I thought they sounded so gimmicky but now I don't enjoy movies nearly as much without it.

I do want to point out that I am not the biggest fan of the theater implementation of D-Box, but then again, I don't like going to the theater much anyway.

Great setup btw. smile.gif
post #324 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by thxman View Post

When is the last time you tired D-Box? Also, did you know to can tweak it? You an adjust the motion and vibrations to almost infinite levels. At one point Crowson even wanted to be able to use D-Box codes for their vibrations due to the fact that they are more intelligently coded vs just running off the bass track. Hope I am not out of place here. I am a D-Box owner, and at one point I thought they sounded so gimmicky but now I don't enjoy movies nearly as much without it.

I do want to point out that I am not the biggest fan of the theater implementation of D-Box, but then again, I don't like going to the theater much anyway.

Great setup btw. smile.gif
Hi thxman,

I last tried D-Box at CEDIA 2 years ago in the D-Box booth. They weren't allowing any tweaking of the system. The effect they were using was really over the top. The scene they used was from Live Free or Die Hard, the scene where Bruce Willis is driving the semi while being attacked by the plane. The tipping and tossing of the seat followed the action very well, but it was just way too much for me. It was only about a 2 minute demo, but I was slightly dizzy and nauseous the rest of the day from it. I've never tried D-Box while having the ability to adjust the system. I would imagine it would be better if I could adjust it to taste.

At that same CEDIA I spoke with Randy Crowson about their interest in using the D-Box track. It seemed like D-Box was being very "proprietary" about their track, and the impression I got was that they were not interested in sharing it with other tactile actuator vendors.
Nonetheless, so much of the D-Box programing is front/back and left/right motion, I'm not sure it would translate effectively to simple up/down motion.

Anyway, thanks for visiting my thread and the nice words. smile.gif

Craig
post #325 of 335
I had a DBox demo at a NYC audio show, and it was not to my taste either. We saw a Shrek demo, and were tossed about as Shrek rode in a runaway carriage and a horse. Most of the action lined up with what was happening on screen, but the program missed some obvious bumps in the action, which took me out of the moment. I also thought it was set too high, just to make the point of what it could do, but again, i found it more distracting than anything else. I much prefer the Crowson experience, where you feel exactly what is on the bass track, instead of a contrived DBox motion program. An especially after looking at the price difference, Crowson wins in my book.
post #326 of 335
Thank you both for describing your experiences. Your time is much appreciated. My 1st experience was with Iron Man 1 (1st fight scene) I have been sold every since. I don't want to derail your thread any further.

Going back on track, would love to hear the Triad Plats. They seem to fit the bill for my next upgrade.
post #327 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

My room is 24' long. The width varies from 15' to about 19'. There is a stairwell off the right, front corner and a hallway to a bathroom in the rear, so the right side of the room is "uneven." The total cubic footage is about 3,800. Short answer... yes, I'm sure the Plat's would work well in your room. The seating distance is key. You want to be far enough away that the output of the drivers blends into a cohesive signal. I am 11' away, and I don't think I would want to be much closer than that. Ask Paul Scarpelli what the optimal minimum seating distance is. I'm sure he can tell you.

BTW, I think you've seen this before, but if I could do it over, I would seriously consider a "baffle wall" with the Plat's. Anthony Grimani uses these and they make the whole system significantly more efficient:

040601_baffled_again.pdf 182k .pdf file

Craig

Edited to fix link

Hmm sounds good! I'll definitely contact Paul Scarpelli to see what he thinks. He always seems to give out really solid advice!

On the side note I was looking at the crownson tranducers and was really interested in them till I saw the price. DAMN!
post #328 of 335
Hey Craig john Ive been doing catch up and read that your GTG was a success. Ive read great things about your theatre which is awesome. I would love to come to the States one day and catch up with all you guys. Take care mate talk to you soon. smile.gif
post #329 of 335
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

Hey Craig john Ive been doing catch up and read that your GTG was a success. Ive read great things about your theatre which is awesome. I would love to come to the States one day and catch up with all you guys. Take care mate talk to you soon. smile.gif
Hi Frank,

If you ever do get to the US, do an East Coast Tour and come see all of us. Would love to have you over.

Craig
post #330 of 335
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

Hi Frank,

If you ever do get to the US, do an East Coast Tour and come see all of us. Would love to have you over.

Craig

Thank you Craig. My son (5yr old )wants to go to lego land in the States, apparently we've been told its amazing.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Other Areas of Interest › What's Your System Configuration › craig john's theater