AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Subwoofers, Bass, and Transducers › Sub calibration for dummy...me!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Sub calibration for dummy...me!

post #1 of 42
Thread Starter 
I have read tons of links and still don't quite understand how to calibrate a subwoofer. If I have an SPL meter (radio shack), what exactly am I doing and in what order? I understand subs are supposed to be calibrated @ 75db, but I don't even know how to get there. Run Onkyo test tone and adjust onboard level until meter reads 75db? Then, in some places it mentions setting mains first. I'm totally confused.

I would just run Audyssey but my sub manufacturer advises AGAINST using it (Elemental Designs). I'm also running dual subs, and what I've seen mentions calibrating them together, not one at a time. I just need someone to spell it out in simple steps or terms. I don NOT have any burned test tones at this time, so I'm just using the test tone that the Onkyo has onboard. Thanks guys...I'm reading everything I can but most links assume you know the most basic steps...and I don't

FYI...right now my subs have the their volume set @ 12:00 and the Onkyo level is set at -9.0db. Distance is set same as mains...which they are. hose two settings were what Audyssey recommended, but I have turned Audyssey off, but kept those 2 settings. My mains are crossed at 60hz, center and surrounds at 80hz and my LPF for LFE is set to 100hz crossover. As of right now I'm mildly underwhelmed by the subs, but if I creep up the gain on the receiver the subs get too hot for some movie passages. I just want to calibrate it in such a way where I can comfortably crank my system for most movies without having to turn down the subs.

Running dual A5-350's...setup in my room in a "stereo" config...1 between center and each main in front of seating position.
post #2 of 42
Can't imagine why eD would recommend against using Audyssey - that's where I'd start. Unless you have an EQ dedicated to the sub in the loop.
post #3 of 42
Using your spl meter set each sub to 75db. Then run audyssey and your set. Go to the audyssey thread and follow the set up guide. I run dual ed subs with audyssey.
post #4 of 42
Dude just run audyssey and be done with it. Adjust your sub trim to your preference. I don't know why elemental advises against it but the most likely reason is because they want to try and sell you one of their equalizers.
post #5 of 42
I think ED recommends against Audyssey because of a belief that it boosts frequencies below the tuning point of their ported subs which has caused issues with some folks in the past.I have no Audyssey experience so I can't say if its true or not, presumably you can run it and check settings afterward?
post #6 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by primetimeguy View Post
Using your spl meter set each sub to 75db. Then run audyssey and your set. Go to the audyssey thread and follow the set up guide. I run dual ed subs with audyssey.
Thanks for all the input guys...really appreciate it. But, to the above poster: Can you explain HOW to set subs to 75db? Using meter, how far from subs? Using test tone from Onkyo? It's when people say, "just set to 75db, then run Odyssey". I don't know what that means! lol
post #7 of 42
Just plug in the audyssey microphone that came with your receiver and follow the directions on the screen.
post #8 of 42
Don't listen to eD... Run audyssey, I did with dual A5's and I loved the results. Can't help with the 75db setting though as don't know how to do it either.
post #9 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Liquid$team
Don't listen to eD... Run audyssey, I did with dual A5's and I loved the results. Can't help with the 75db setting though as don't know how to do it either.
From the listening position and set your spl meter to slow and c weighting. Possibly the 2nd audyssey screen will measure this for you if your lucky.
post #10 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

Thanks for all the input guys...really appreciate it. But, to the above poster: Can you explain HOW to set subs to 75db? Using meter, how far from subs? Using test tone from Onkyo? It's when people say, "just set to 75db, then run Odyssey". I don't know what that means! lol

Go here for quick setup for sub: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...&#post10397679 or here http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=824554
post #11 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

I have read tons of links and still don't quite understand how to calibrate a subwoofer. If I have an SPL meter (radio shack), what exactly am I doing and in what order? I understand subs are supposed to be calibrated @ 75db, but I don't even know how to get there. Run Onkyo test tone and adjust onboard level until meter reads 75db? Then, in some places it mentions setting mains first. I'm totally confused.

I would just run Audyssey but my sub manufacturer advises AGAINST using it (Elemental Designs). I'm also running dual subs, and what I've seen mentions calibrating them together, not one at a time. I just need someone to spell it out in simple steps or terms. I don NOT have any burned test tones at this time, so I'm just using the test tone that the Onkyo has onboard. Thanks guys...I'm reading everything I can but most links assume you know the most basic steps...and I don't

FYI...right now my subs have the their volume set @ 12:00 and the Onkyo level is set at -9.0db. Distance is set same as mains...which they are. hose two settings were what Audyssey recommended, but I have turned Audyssey off, but kept those 2 settings. My mains are crossed at 60hz, center and surrounds at 80hz and my LPF for LFE is set to 100hz crossover. As of right now I'm mildly underwhelmed by the subs, but if I creep up the gain on the receiver the subs get too hot for some movie passages. I just want to calibrate it in such a way where I can comfortably crank my system for most movies without having to turn down the subs.

Running dual A5-350's...setup in my room in a "stereo" config...1 between center and each main in front of seating position.

If you want to use an SPL meter then you need test tones; however, with dual subs it is a herculean project to do it. You've invested a lot of money in your system, spend another 1-3 hundred and buy measuring gear to properly place your dual subs. Using measuring gear will give you the greatest bang-for-the-buck improvement in SQ by far.

Using the tones in your AVR is basically a waste of time and I would just use Audyssey and forget about it if that is the route you're going to take. The 75 dB is at your primary listening position and is simply related to setting the sub level to reference when AVR volume is at 0 dB (relative scale)
post #12 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gooddoc View Post

If you want to use an SPL meter then you need test tones; however, with dual subs it is a herculean project to do it. You've invested a lot of money in your system, spend another 1-3 hundred and buy measuring gear to properly place your dual subs. Using measuring gear will give you the greatest bang-for-the-buck improvement in SQ by far.

Using the tones in your AVR is basically a waste of time and I would just use Audyssey and forget about it if that is the route you're going to take. The 75 dB is at your primary listening position and is simply related to setting the sub level to reference when AVR volume is at 0 dB (relative scale)

Okay, I get some of what you're saying. Follow me though...If I open up my menu in my receiver and select 'level calibration" under speaker settings, the tones it spits out are not effected by my receiver's volume level. So, if I didn't want to run Audyssey, I would just play the test tone through each speaker and subs, one at a time and adjust level in receiver until SPL meter at my listening position reads 75db?
post #13 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post


Okay, I get some of what you're saying. Follow me though...If I open up my menu in my receiver and select 'level calibration" under speaker settings, the tones it spits out are not effected by my receiver's volume level. So, if I didn't want to run Audyssey, I would just play the test tone through each speaker and subs, one at a time and adjust level in receiver until SPL meter at my listening position reads 75db?

Yes but your sub should be around 80db
post #14 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

Running dual A5-350's...setup in my room in a "stereo" config...1 between center and each main in front of seating position.

"Stereo" config??? Does that mean you're not using the subwoofer output on your receiver? If so, that changes everything about how you calibrate. How *exactly* do you have your subs connected?

Craig
post #15 of 42
what AVR do you have ? Audyssey XT32 does calibrate dual subs
post #16 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fastslappy View Post

what AVR do you have ? Audyssey XT32 does calibrate dual subs

Brunt has multeq
post #17 of 42
While I know there is differing opinions on this I would set the LPF of LFE to 120. While there isn't always a lot of content above 80hz in the LFE channel sometimes it is there and any setting below 120hz will be throwing that content away.

Remember this is only on the LFE channel and has nothing to do with redirected bass from the mains.
post #18 of 42
Thread Starter 
Yes, I have have the MultEQ that comes aboard the Onkyo HT-RC180. By stereo config, I just meant the subs both sit in between the center channel and mains under my screen.

So, would I be adjusting the level calibration to 80db because of the Radio Shack SPL meter or some other reason?

Thanks again for your input everyone.
post #19 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

Yes, I have have the MultEQ that comes aboard the Onkyo HT-RC180. By stereo config, I just meant the subs both sit in between the center channel and mains under my screen.

So, would I be adjusting the level calibration to 80db because of the Radio Shack SPL meter or some other reason?

Thanks again for your input everyone.

The radio shack meter is off a little bit. You can actually download a calibration correction table is actually available to download. It gives you the correction at different frequencies. At 75 db it's only a few db off but most prefer to run a few db hot on the LFE channel as well. Its all personal preference. You will also need to change the distance settings as well. One easy way to accomplish this is to run audyssey and then just switch it off if you prefer not to use it and it will still leave the measurements intact. Is there any other particular reason you are against audyssey besides eD telling you not to?
post #20 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mpray1983 View Post

The radio shack meter is off a little bit. You can actually download a calibration correction table is actually available to download. It gives you the correction at different frequencies. At 75 db it's only a few db off but most prefer to run a few db hot on the LFE channel as well. Its all personal preference. You will also need to change the distance settings as well. One easy way to accomplish this is to run audyssey and then just switch it off if you prefer not to use it and it will still leave the measurements intact. Is there any other particular reason you are against audyssey besides eD telling you not to?

No, not really. I had access to an SPL meter so I was thinking about calibrating that way. I think I'm just going to use Audyssey. ED didn't want me to use it because they claims it can boost certain frequencies incorrectly. What I find odd about that is it's my understanding that MultEQ can't do that to subs, just their levels/distance. Anyway...seems like running it isn't such a bad thing after all.

One more question: if after running Audyssey, if i want to bump up the sub volume, is it best to do with the receiver or use the sub gain knob?
post #21 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

Yes, I have have the MultEQ that comes aboard the Onkyo HT-RC180. By stereo config, I just meant the subs both sit in between the center channel and mains under my screen.

Your subs have speaker level connections. You are NOT using them, correct? Are your subs "daisy chained" or Y'd together?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

So, would I be adjusting the level calibration to 80db because of the Radio Shack SPL meter or some other reason

If you have 2 subs, and they are both up front, between the speakers, then here's what you want to do:

1. Turn off one of the subs. Set the SPL meter at the listening position, pointed straight up.

2. Play the receiver's subwoofer test tone. Use the sub's Volume Control to set the level to 72 dB. The SPL meter will jump around some. Set it so the average is 72 dB.

3. Turn off that sub and turn on the other sub. Repeat Step 2. (Your subs are now "level-matched" at the listening position. Check that both subs are set to very close to the same Volumes. They should be, but if they are not, we may want to try "gain-matching." Let me know if they are not close to the same Volumes and I will tell you how to gain-match.)

4. Turn on both subs. When combined, they will sum and add 3 dB to the output, equaling 75 dB.

5. Run Audyssey according to The Guide:
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...5#post14456895

Come back and post the speaker/subwoofer levels, distances and crossovers. We'll help you with post-Audyssey optimization, if necessary.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

One more question: if after running Audyssey, if i want to bump up the sub volume, is it best to do with the receiver or use the sub gain knob?

It's best to use the receiver's subwoofer trim control. It's much more precise, and it adjusts both subs at the same time.

Craig
post #22 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post


No, not really. I had access to an SPL meter so I was thinking about calibrating that way. I think I'm just going to use Audyssey. ED didn't want me to use it because they claims it can boost certain frequencies incorrectly. What I find odd about that is it's my understanding that MultEQ can't do that to subs, just their levels/distance. Anyway...seems like running it isn't such a bad thing after all.

One more question: if after running Audyssey, if i want to bump up the sub volume, is it best to do with the receiver or use the sub gain knob?

Multeq has limited sub filters...2eq is the one that doesn't adjust the sub. Just follow Craig johns directions as they keep it simple.
post #23 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by craig john View Post

Your subs have speaker level connections. You are NOT using them, correct? Are your subs "daisy chained" or Y'd together?


If you have 2 subs, and they are both up front, between the speakers, then here's what you want to do:

1. Turn off one of the subs. Set the SPL meter at the listening position, pointed straight up.

2. Play the receiver's subwoofer test tone. Use the sub's Volume Control to set the level to 72 dB. The SPL meter will jump around some. Set it so the average is 72 dB.

3. Turn off that sub and turn on the other sub. Repeat Step 2. (Your subs are now "level-matched" at the listening position. Check that both subs are set to very close to the same Volumes. They should be, but if they are not, we may want to try "gain-matching." Let me know if they are not close to the same Volumes and I will tell you how to gain-match.)

4. Turn on both subs. When combined, they will sum and add 3 dB to the output, equaling 75 dB.

5. Run Audyssey according to The Guide:
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...5#post14456895

Come back and post the speaker/subwoofer levels, distances and crossovers. We'll help you with post-Audyssey optimization, if necessary.


It's best to use the receiver's subwoofer trim control. It's much more precise, and it adjusts both subs at the same time.

Craig

okay, so i'm doing all of the above and then running Audyssey...which will change the gain levels that I set in the receiver? Why would I set subs to 75db just to turn around and have Audyssey change my settings?
post #24 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

okay, so i'm doing all of the above and then running Audyssey...which will change the gain levels that I set in the receiver? Why would I set subs to 75db just to turn around and have Audyssey change my settings?

The reason you want to set the sub to 75 (or duals to 72dB each) BEFORE calibration is because the receiver will try to fine tune the levels to 75 when it does the calibration. By doing it yourself first, you are getting it in the ballpark already. Then when the receiver calculates the final setting, it doesn't have to correct for the levels much (or at all). It does not have to boost or cut the sub output signal because it already is set correctly. You basically want the receiver to not have to make major adjustments because that might cause the auto-on feature of your sub not to activate correctly (because the receiver had to reduce the final ouput signal too much) or the sub's amp may chop off the signal (if the receiver has to boost the output too much)
post #25 of 42
Because the subs run off a separate amp and you have to get that as close as possible before running the calibration. You only need the spl meter to match the dual subs since they will be different volumes at different places. If you were only using one then you could do it by trial and error.
post #26 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by warpdrive View Post

The reason you want to set the sub to 75 (or duals to 72dB each) BEFORE calibration is because the receiver will try to fine tune the levels to 75 when it does the calibration. By doing it yourself first, you are getting it in the ballpark already. Then when the receiver calculates the final setting, it doesn't have to correct for the levels much (or at all). It does not have to boost or cut the sub output signal because it already is set correctly. You basically want the receiver to not have to make major adjustments because that might cause the auto-on feature of your sub not to activate correctly (because the receiver had to reduce the final ouput signal too much) or the sub's amp may chop off the signal (if the receiver has to boost the output too much)

Well, this is where I bow out! lol. Not trying to be a jerk but I flat out don't understand this. You're saying if I use the level calibrator (after setting sub gain to 12:00 for example) on board the Onkyo first, to dial the subs in to 72db...then, run Audyssey, I will get more accurate numbers? I don't see how. Audyssey changes whatever db levels I had previously set, based on it's own calculations. Whatever settings I may have set on my own are overridden by AUdyssey.

For example, when I got my first sub, I ran Audyssey. I had sub gain knob at 12:00 and it set the internal sub gain to -13.5db. This level was no good so I crept up that number until sub level was acceptable to me. If I initially set that number to whatever would cause my SPL meter to read 75db(or 72 for dual), it would just have been changed by Audyssey back to that -13.5db, no?

On my receiver, when you engage Auddysey settings, it completely overrides any level or EQ settings you have previously dialed in.
post #27 of 42
Think of all the gain knobs and settings on your receiver and sub as a bunch of adjustments that need to all sum together so that the receiver is putting out exactly 75dB at your listening position with the test tone.

If your receiver's sub gain is -13.5, that is WAY too low. That means you turned up the sub's knob too high. You want to end up with a receiver sub gain setting near 0dB, so you want to back down the sub volume below 12 o clock. If you run the test tone and your meter reads 72dB for each sub with the receiver's sub setting at 0 dB, then you've established the proper baseline settings for both subs at your listening position.

Then after....you have to run Audyssey with both subs turned on. Audyssey WILL override all the settings in its calibration, but because you've established the proper baseline, you'll see that it (probably) won't alter the receiver gains that much. Because Audyssey is way more accurate when it measures the sound, you may find it wants to alter your gain from what you set it to manually. Any deviation from 0dB should be expected and acceptable. These are the final settings you should keep.

If you still find that Audyssey wants to do a big correction of say more than 6dB difference something is still off. You should probably need to adjust the sub volume controls again (use the meter to make sure both subs read the same individually at your listening position) and then run Audyssey again.

Basically, the role of the meter is to:
- provide a rough guide to where to set the sub's volume knob (you want 72dB for each sub).
- get each of the subs individually reading about equal at your listening position.

then you let Audyssey do its work. Its final settings are the correct ones.
post #28 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by warpdrive View Post

Think of all the gain knobs and settings on your receiver and sub as a bunch of adjustments that need to all sum together so that the receiver is putting out exactly 75dB at your listening position with the test tone.

If your receiver's sub gain is -13.5, that is WAY too low. That means you turned up the sub's knob too high. You want to end up with a receiver sub gain setting near 0dB, so you want to back down the sub volume below 12 o clock. If you run the test tone and your meter reads 72dB for each sub with the receiver's sub setting at 0 dB, then you've established the proper baseline settings for both subs at your listening position.

Then after....you have to run Audyssey with both subs turned on. Audyssey WILL override all the settings in its calibration, but because you've established the proper baseline, you'll see that it (probably) won't alter the receiver gains that much. Because Audyssey is way more accurate when it measures the sound, you may find it wants to alter your gain from what you set it to manually. Any deviation from 0dB should be expected and acceptable. These are the final settings you should keep.

If you still find that Audyssey wants to do a big correction of say more than 6dB difference something is still off. You should probably need to adjust the sub volume controls again (use the meter to make sure both subs read the same individually at your listening position) and then run Audyssey again.

Basically, the role of the meter is to:
- get the subs reading about equal
- provide a rough guide to where to set the sub's volume knob (you want 72dB for each sub)

then you let Audyssey do its work. It will use its massive computational power to adjust and EQ all the channels better than you can do so yourself.

Okay, so If I wasn't using an SPL meter, I should rerun Audyssey and adjust my sub gain knob before each time until Audyssey has my sub gain set to within 6db of zero or my mains?
post #29 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

Okay, so If I wasn't using an SPL meter, I should rerun Audyssey and adjust my sub gain knob before each time until Audyssey has my sub gain set to within 6db of zero of my mains?

for a single sub, basically yes. I'd say that within 6dB is pretty safe.

For dual subs, you need a meter to get both subs equal BEFORE you run Audyssey.
post #30 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brunt View Post

Okay, so If I wasn't using an SPL meter, I should rerun Audyssey and adjust my sub gain knob before each time until Audyssey has my sub gain set to within 6db of zero or my mains?

Let me start over and add one more step...

Before you do anything else, go to the receiver's Speaker Setup menu and set the Subwoofer Trim to 0. Then proceed as below, (noting the highlighted text.)

1. Turn off one of the subs. Set the SPL meter at the listening position, pointed straight up.

2. Play the receiver's subwoofer test tone.

3. Go to the subwoofer. Use the subwoofer's Volume Control to set the level to 72 dB. The SPL meter will jump around some. Set it so the average is 72 dB.

4. Turn off that sub and turn on the other sub. Repeat Step 2. (Your subs are now "level-matched" at the listening position. Check that both subs are set to very close to the same Volumes. They should be, but if they are not, we may want to try "gain-matching." Let me know if they are not close to the same Volumes and I will tell you how to gain-match.)

5. Turn on both subs. When combined, they will sum and add 3 dB to the output, equaling 75 dB.

6. Run Audyssey according to The Guide:
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...5#post14456895


Note that Audyssey will ignore all the settings you set *before* you run it. It will have all new settings when it is done. These new settings will be based on the measurements it has taken. Come back and post the speaker/subwoofer levels, distances and crossovers. We'll help you with post-Audyssey optimization, if necessary.

Craig
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Subwoofers, Bass, and Transducers › Sub calibration for dummy...me!