AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › Is this wood any good?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is this wood any good? - Page 3

post #61 of 94
Quote:
Originally Posted by javygonx View Post

The enclosure already has double front baffles. And yes, I prefer the looks of the front baffle 3/4" behind than this. And I test the sub, Im totally dissapointed The PL200 sounds louder and better. What this could be?

a. No polyfill? The enclosure does not have polyfill. I will buy 4 lb today.
b. Not enough power? 250W RMS is not enough to move the driver efficiently?
c. Enclosure not desgined correctly? (Would be really sad if this after all hardwork)
d. And last; this really worries me: "A crap driver?"

Could be any number of things...poly, the amp and if it still doesn't sound good after that check for leaks and make sure you have it wired correctly. Could be something simple that is easily overlooked. My bet is the amp as you are grossly underpowering it and 250watts is probably a bit of an indulgence.
post #62 of 94
Thread Starter 
I have the same idea that problem could be power. As for wiring; this sub is Single Voice Coil 4 ohm. So the connection is just one positive and one negative connection. As for leaks its there any trick. Checking leaks at front of the driver is quite difficult. I can feel the sub vibrations so not sure if its leaks or air movement.

In my job they use helium to check leaks on very very tiny holes as small as 1/64" size of nozzles; but also use special equipmet to measure if there are leaks or not. But implementing this on sealed subs would be a costly proyect for enthusiasts like us.
post #63 of 94
Thread Starter 
I add some vinyl to the enclosure, but because I round over the edges its very hard to match the vinyl at edges. Next time I will not roundover if I decide to use vinyl or black ash laminate. I believe will sand the enclosure and paint it with Duratex.
LL
post #64 of 94
Thread Starter 
HELP!!!!! HELP!!!!! HELP!!!!!

I got the Inuke 3000 DSP and I dont know why my sub sounds extremedly soft. I raised volume to max in the amp, I raised sub levels in my receiver to max, I also add +12 gain on the amp and it just lights the first led level on the front panel on the inuke.

I touch the driver and yes is barely moving which means that is receiving a signal. What could be wrong? A faulty driver?, Speakon cable?, the XLR to RCA cable? Im so frustrated; spent all this money and hard work for this sh!t!!!.?

I also setup the inuke to bridge mode and nothing (

The Speakon cable has 4 connectors (+1, -1, +2, -2). The wiring is the red cable connected in +1 and the black in -1. Could be this the problem?

Tbe driver is a 15" single voice coil - 4ohm.

The XLR cable I am using is a Male XLR to Male RCA. So its connected from inuke to sub out on the receiver.
My PL200 sub sounds way way louder than this and its a cheapo $269 sub.
post #65 of 94
Open it up and make sure that no connections came UNdone inside. You might need a signal booster depending on your receiver.
post #66 of 94
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mpray1983 View Post

Open it up and make sure that no connections came UNdone inside. You might need a signal booster depending on your receiver.

My receiver is a Denon 3311CI. Do I need signal booster? If so, where can I find it? I have no idea what it is.
The only connection inside is the binding posts. The driver has the pos/neg cable already welded on driver. I just connected the cable to the binding post.
post #67 of 94
Quote:
Originally Posted by javygonx View Post


My receiver is a Denon 3311CI. Do I need signal booster? If so, where can I find it? I have no idea what it is.
The only connection inside is the binding posts. The driver has the pos/neg cable already welded on driver. I just connected the cable to the binding post.

If you connections are good then you probably need a signal booster. Art cleanbox pro and Samson s-convert are both commonly used.
post #68 of 94
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mpray1983 View Post


If you connections are good then you probably need a signal booster. Art cleanbox pro and Samson s-convert are both commonly used.

Which one is better? And what means if the sub is in a box or free air?
post #69 of 94
S-convert I believe doesn't have a limiter of 20hz. The art cleanbox is limited to 20hx but there is a mod to change it to 10hz. They don't make the s-convert anymore so you would have to buy it used if you can find it. If you can't find it then your options are pretty much limited at that point.
post #70 of 94
Thread Starter 
I raised volume on receiver pretty loud (around +2db, or 85 db) I was able to hear the sub but not as loud as it should be. The PL200 still sounds louder, but in terms of quality I noticed a great difference. The diy sub sounds lots better in terms of quality. Now I can noticed the difference in a cheapo sub and a higher quality sub.

The softness and low volume on sub still worrying me. I have to work today; so tomorrow I will continue the tests. I will add polyfill and recheck all cabling.

I connected the inuke on the pc and setup 4 ohms and tried bridge vs stereo mode and the loudness are the same. I see no difference between Bridge mode and Stereo/Dual Mode in terms of power; and its supposed on bridge mode 1500w rms @ 4ohm while stereo/dual 880w @ 4ohm.

Not sure if speakon wiring needs to be different on bridge than in stereo/ dual mode setting because back on the inuke the diagram says "bridge +1 pos, +2 neg"; while channel a or b says "+1 pos, -1 neg". My speakon cables are wired as +1 pos, -1 neg.

If that is the issue then how can I wire the speakon to test bridge mode? All I have to do is leaving the red wire in +1 pos, and move the black cable from -1 neg pole to +2 neg pole??? The speakon cable I have has 4 poles; but cable splits in just one red wire and one black wire. Here is the pic of the back of the inuke outputs.
LL
post #71 of 94
From reading that you need to use the + from both channels.
You said
"My speakon cables are wired as +1 pos, -1 neg"

You need to wire as
"bridge +1 pos, +2 neg"

Wire the + lead from the speaker to + on one channel, wire the - lead from the speaker to the + lead on the other channel.

You should confirm, but that is the way that the Behringers wire up.

Just looked at your thumbnail. What I said is correct.

Here it is again.

Wire the + lead from the speaker to +1 on one channel, wire the - lead from the speaker to the +2 lead on the other channel.
post #72 of 94
Thread Starter 
During my break I wired the Speakon to be use in Bridge Mode at Inuke. Now I was able to feel the bass; deep bass; but not tight!... What can I do to get a tighter bass? Probably I have to do some EQs on DSP but I have to learn it how to use it. So; right now the 3000 DSP in Bridge mode performs pretty well on my 4ohm speaker.

I have to sell the 3000 DSP Model as soon as I can get the 6000 DSP Model to power the two 4 ohm subs; currently I have one now and will buy another driver in the near future; or replace my 4 ohm driver and get a 2ohm driver with tighter response; in this way I dont have to replace the 3000 DSP Model. What do you think? Opinions please!
post #73 of 94
Thread Starter 
I will quit on this DIY Project. I will try to sell everything. Im totally dissapointed.

After adding 4 lbs of polyfill the sub sounds better but look what I found. The foam surroundings is somewhat broken or cracked at the top, the bottom is ok. Now I have to check if this has warranty. Sub driver didnt last two days and I havent seen any movies yet to feel what a good sub sounds like in a movie. The only test I did was with some songs from Queensryche and Dream Theater; the Trailer of Gran Turismo 5 and the trailer of last movie of Resident Evil. Thats it! If I sum all tests in terms of time it did not reach not even an hour!

Im so frustrated. All this money spent and hardwork for nothing. I would stick with my first decision in getting an Epik Empire or a Rythmik F15HP instead of this. Plus I get warranty on drivers and plate amps from them.

Check the pics (Top and Bottom of speaker surrounding)
LL
LL
post #74 of 94
Thread Starter 
Can I convert my sealed enclosure into a ported one by adding two 4" Aeroport? Or; try to DIY a smaller enclosure; like 3 cF to see if I get better performance with the driver and amp I use? So far Im still not convinced with the performance on my DIY.
post #75 of 94
Why do you think a smaller box will give you more performance/output?
post #76 of 94
Do you have the equipment to run REW and see what the FR response is for the sub and within the room at various positions?

I built 4 small sealed MFW subs and I made the mistake of not really getting into analyzing what was happening until this past weekend. I found out I had a enormous null where I had placed two of the subs which basically eliminated anything below 70Hz and killed the performance.
post #77 of 94
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mpray1983 View Post

Why do you think a smaller box will give you more performance/output?

Because of the manufacturer's recommendation. According to manufacturer the driver needs to be use in a 2 cF - 3.5,cF on a sealed enclosure or between 3.5cF to 5 cF on ported sub. My sealed enclosure is 5 cF; almost 2 more cF than recommendation. Thats just my guessing of the poor performance of my diy.

About REW; I dont have any tools for measurment (Omnimic, rews, etc). What would be the cheapest method for measurement? And yes, I placed the sub in three different corners of my house snd same sh..t.
post #78 of 94
Quote:
Originally Posted by javygonx View Post


Because of the manufacturer's recommendation. According to manufacturer the driver needs to be use in a 2 cF - 3.5,cF on a sealed enclosure or between 3.5cF to 5 cF on ported sub. My sealed enclosure is 5 cF; almost 2 more cF than recommendation. Thats just my guessing of the poor performance of my diy.

About REW; I dont have any tools for measurment (Omnimic, rews, etc). What would be the cheapest method for measurement? And yes, I placed the sub in three different corners of my house snd same sh..t.

Did you model it in winisd?
post #79 of 94
Thread Starter 
Yes, but needs some parameters that are missing. Does winisd calculates the net cubic feet recommended?
UPDATE:

Ok, I was able to run WinIsd sucessfully and according to the parameters enter it calculates a Volume Box of 42 ft^3 !!
Box outer dimensions: W: 43.8 in, H: 69.2 in, D: 26.9 in. I carefully check the values entered; if its Liters; cm^2, or in^3 etc. I cant believe it calculates a box so big!!

Parameters Entered: -> This are Platform 1 Parameters; not the Custom Platform 1 Parameter

Revc = 2.9001 ohms
Fms = 27.8340 Hz
Zmax = 21.4774 ohms
Qes = 0.7948
Qms = 5.0914
Qts = 0.6875
Sd = 490cm^2
Vas = 70.3680 L
BL = 10.3991 N/A
Mms = 169.4703 g
Xmax = 32mm total
post #80 of 94
Quote:
Originally Posted by javygonx View Post

Yes, but needs some parameters that are missing. Does winisd calculates the net cubic feet recommended?
UPDATE:

Ok, I was able to run WinIsd sucessfully and according to the parameters enter it calculates a Volume Box of 42 ft^3 !!
Box outer dimensions: W: 43.8 in, H: 69.2 in, D: 26.9 in. I carefully check the values entered; if its Liters; cm^2, or in^3 etc. I cant believe it calculates a box so big!!

Parameters Entered:

Revc = 2.9001 ohms
Fms = 27.8340 Hz
Zmax = 21.4774 ohms
Qes = 0.7948
Qms = 5.0914
Qts = 0.6875
Sd = 490cm^2
Vas = 70.3680 L
BL = 10.3991 N/A
Mms = 169.4703 g
Xmax = 32mm total

^^^This, is very different from this ...

Quote:
Originally Posted by javygonx View Post

Greetings:

Finally I got the custom PSI HT Sub. SVC 4 ohm - 1000W RMS; 2000W Peak; Dual Spider Layer. I will post pics as soon as I pick up from USPS but the storm dont let me.

Here are the specs:

Revc = 4.01 ohms
Fms = 24.2777 Hz
Zmax = 35.4840 ohms
Xmax = 32mm
Qes = 1.0747
Qms = 8.0662
Qts = 0.9484
Le = 5.2537 mH (at 1 kHz)
Diam = 330.2000 mm ( 13.0000 in )
Sd = 85633.5536 mm^2(132.7323 in^2) Vas = 114.5520 L ( 4.0454 ft^3)
BL = 15.2125 N/A
Mms = 390.8193 g
Cms = 109.9639 uM/N
Kms = 9093.8896 N/M
Rms = 7.3908
R mechanical Efficiency = 0.1433 % Sensitivity= 83.5807 dB @1W/1m Sensitivity= 86.4081 dB @2.83Vrms/1m

What are the actual specs of the driver as I couldn't get the second one above to work in WinISD (kept telling me the qts/qms/qes specs were not compatable). Actually, it kept wanting to calculate a negative qts.

Also, are you sure you have not wired the subwoofer out of phase? You note above that very little volume is coming from it, and that (as I well know) is a common issue.
post #81 of 94
Okay, managed to get the driver parameters to work (though qts looks different). WinISD is giving me a 24 cubic foot box, and the driver alignment options were odd (1.0 Equal ripple repsonse, 1.1) instead of "0.707 Max Flat Amptitude" which I typically get for drivers that are to be used in a sealed enclosure.

Looks like a great driver for the trunk of a car??



Unless I inputted something incorrectly. I followed the guide here (good link to keep on hand btw)...

http://www.hometheatershack.com/foru...tml#post298892
LL
post #82 of 94
Quote:
Originally Posted by pbc View Post


Looks like a great driver for the trunk of a car??

I don't know why he went with this especially on his first time. Should have gone with a proven design and driver.
post #83 of 94
Did you get a signal booster yet? It sounds like that is your problem with the lack of power. I would listen to it with proper power before you try changing more things.
post #84 of 94
Hmmm ... just going back and reading your original thread on the PSi driver, it looks to me as if it was a driver geared towards cars that they then tried to adjust it as best they could to make it more HT friendly??
post #85 of 94
Quote:
Originally Posted by haanjamin View Post

Did you get a signal booster yet? It sounds like that is your problem with the lack of power. I would listen to it with proper power before you try changing more things.

... and check the polarity before bothering with this as well...
post #86 of 94
Thread Starter 
Hi to all. I got the Samson S-Convert, but not the power supply for it!!.. I have to go to Radio Shack to find a power supply.

According to parameters; why 2 parameters? Well; the first parameter I posted was for my custom PSI Platform 1. The second parameters are the normal parameters that all Platform 1 Model have. The parameters of my sub is the custom one.

I took the risk and bought this PSI because the only company that was able to ship to PR is PSI. Parts Express can also ship but the pics of the PSI catch my attention. I emailed PSI and explained my situation and they told me that they make custom subs for HT Purpose!.. Thats the sad story; the very high qts parameter always worried me!...

Ok; about polarity; they are connected correctly. PSI told me the blue cable is the positive and the black the negative so that's exactly the way they are connected right now. I can try to connect the binding post cable upside down to make sure about polarity but Im afraid if that can damage the driver.

Im thinking seriously in get another driver; honestly this driver does not convinced me after all. Most 4 - 5 cF sealed enclosures performs pretty well then why this driver didnt!!!? First option: Dayton 15" MK3; second: TC SOunds 15" for $433. But for that I have to see if I can sell my PSI Driver for $200.

Need some help on the Samson S-Convert Connection. I use XLR to RCA Cable that goes from Inuke to Receiver and a Speakon to Binding Post Cable that goes from Inuke to Enclosure. How the connection should be? and/or what other cables do I need?
post #87 of 94
You need RCA-RCA cable to go from receiver to the S-convert and XLR-XLR cable to go from S-convert to the amp. S-convert has RCA inputs and XLR outputs when using it to increase signal voltage.
post #88 of 94
Thread Starter 
Thanks. I got the cabling and performed the test!... I used the power supply of my DSL Modem in which is 12V - 1.0A; the Samson recommends 18V DC; but with the DSL Power Supply it works!; The power LED looks bit dim but works; I can assume that with the 18V will perform better.

Results?!!....... An Improvement! Now I can said that the Sealed Enclosure @ Stereo Mode performs exactly as the PL200. At Bridge Mode performs bit louder.

So; using an Inuke 3000 DSP on 4ohm Speakers should be enough for Dual Enclosures in Stereo/Dual Mode. I can imagine that 2 ohm speakers will sounds lot louder!....

For those Denon Receiver users that think the sub output voltage is enough they should give it a try with this Samson S- Convert. This device has more connectors than needed to amplify sub out. I own a Denon 3311CI; and most Denon users do not use a Samson S-Convert. Give it a try and will see nice results!

According to my tests; that means if I do a ported enclosure the output should be twice as loud as my sealed DIY if using same wattage or not neccesarly?.

Second; I received the precut panels from Elemental Designs; all cuts are perfect!; bracing is very nice. EFS are as heavy as MDF; surface is smoother; and have a more tan color than MDF.

I really want to swap that drive!... Recommendations please!... So far Im not tollaly convince from a PL200 and my DIY; because of 250W vs 1500W; but with the Samson its really a very, very nice improvement!!!
post #89 of 94
Thread Starter 
New Enclosure ......

Im doing a new enclosure; smaller and better build than the first one. 20x20x22

Will use a new driver. Maybe a Dayton Titanic MK3. But also for $500 I can get an used Emotiva XRef shipped to PR. So what now?
LL
LL
LL
post #90 of 94
Hi javygonx,
Quote:


Will use a new driver. Maybe a Dayton Titanic MK3. But also for $500 I can get an used Emotiva XRef shipped to PR. So what now?

Uh, if first you don't Succeed try, try again, or buy a new Sub...Now that you respect the work that goes into one! LOL!

I built two Sub Cabs for my Band and I had no idea what I was getting myself into!
I got much help over at ProSoundWeb with WinIsd and just general help from professionals that Build and Design speaker cabinets such as JBL, etc.
They do not cater to Home Theatre at all, so don't think of trying, just Professional or Semi Professional Pro Audio!
You would pick up a few things though by being a fly on the wall, they have a section that deals with Subs but again these are SUBS and not the kind in your living room or bedroom LOL!
It is for Local Bands and Professional Concert Tours but they also use Winisd as well as other Design Programs.

Quote:


If that is the issue then how can I wire the speakon to test bridge mode? All I have to do is leaving the red wire in +1 pos, and move the black cable from -1 neg pole to +2 neg pole??? The speakon cable I have has 4 poles; but cable splits in just one red wire and one black wire. Here is the pic of the back of the inuke outputs.

The Bridge Wiring is +1 (Positive) +2 (Negative) You would wire your Speakon this way....
The end that connects to your Speaker cabinet will be left at +1 and -1 for the Speakers Positive and Negative.
The Speakon for your inuke would be wired: +1 is still +1 for the Positive but you would move the wire that is in the -1 or Negative position to the +2 contact for the Bridged Negative.
I know that it seem weird that you are putting the speakers Negative wire into a Positive +2 location on the Speakon connector but that is how Bridging of most Power Amps work.
Make sure that you use a Sharpie or something to mark one of the ends as either Speaker or Amp, because if you reverse this cable you will hear nothing!
Lastly, on my Crown Power amps there is a switch that I need to use for either Parallel or Bridged operation.
Make sure that your Inuke does not have the same thing.

Do you know how to read that Picture of Output settings on the back of your amp?
On the upper Right side where you see one large diagram that shows Channel A, Channel B and Bridged that means that by plugging your Speaker Cabinet's Speakon into JUST Channel A
those combinations are available. Think of it as this, you had 4 wires in your Speaker cable wired to all of the speakon's terminals, +1 -1 +2 -2,
you plugged that connector into just the Channel A Speakon on the inuke, then +1 and -1 are for Channel A of the amp and +2 and -2 are for Channel B of the Amp.
You can now run just one cable from the Power amp to two speakers rather than two seperate cables from the Power Amp's Channel A & B Speakons to each speaker.
The way that this works at the speakers is that one speaker uses the +1 and -1 and then you Daisy chain another Speakon out of that cabinet and over to a second cabinet for the +2 -2 Channel B

I have this setup in my Bands Top Cabinets, it's easier than it sounds, I can run one cable to stage Right and then one cable from that speaker across the stage to my other speaker at Stage Left.
Some speakers have a switch that will set whether it's speakers are using the +1 -1 or the +2 -2 myself I have prewired 2 conductor Cables that are +2 -2 on one end and +1 -1 on the other.
Mark the ends and make sure that you plug the +1 -1 connects into the last speaker, the +2 -2 end will plug into the cabinet with the cable from the amp.
Inside the cabinet their are short jumper wires that connect the two speakons +2 to +2 and -2 to -2 so when I plug in the cable from the Amp it will just pass the +2 and -2 right back out again via the second Speakon connector and it makes no difference which speakon I plug the amp into.
Lastly for Bridged mode you would also plug into Channel A but only using +1 and +2 for Bridged in the Speakon connector!
Again, make sure that there is not a switch for Bridged Mode.

Down at the Bottom it show Channel B all by itself and just +1 -1 that is because that is all that you will ever get out of the Channel B's inuke Speakon.

This amp shows that it puts out 3,000 watts in Bridged Mode @ 4ohms, are you really considering that in your living room?
Even if you ran at 900 watts in Parallel that's an awful lot.
My Bands Crown Sub amps are rated like this and running Parallel in my living room I'm at about two clicks up on my pots.
Way overkill for a Home Theater Sub Amp.
If that amp can't liven up your Sub, it must be dead! LOL!

Good Luck,

Bud B
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: DIY Speakers and Subs
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › Is this wood any good?