AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › Official Sharp Elite PRO-70X5 and 60X5 Owners Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Official Sharp Elite PRO-70X5 and 60X5 Owners Thread - Page 101

post #3001 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leon! View Post


While your review may be a bit premature, I think Ken is okay with it staying up, for now. Everyone just needs to keep in mind that any perceived issues (clouding? flickering?) will likely be attributed to source, improper settings/setup, or faulty wiring in your house.

As far as the cyan "issue", this one is so insignificant that Ken himself was the only one to notice it initially, & even he has since confirmed that it's not a big deal. Viewers who see certain NFL jersey colors as being a shade off only see it this way because they already know what color those uniforms are supposed to be. Otherwise, this is not a problem AT ALL, and will be even less so once Sharp issues the fix for it.

Hmm, just a bit of sarcasm Leon?
post #3002 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leon! View Post

...snip...

As far as the cyan "issue", this one is so insignificant that Ken himself was the only one to notice it initially, & even he has since confirmed that it's not a big deal. Viewers who see certain NFL jersey colors as being a shade off only see it this way because they already know what color those uniforms are supposed to be. Otherwise, this is not a problem AT ALL, and will be even less so once Sharp issues the fix for it.

You know, you just presented an arguement that accurate color isn't important unless you happen to know what color something is suppose to be and its not that color.

I can understand someone defending their purchase but at some point reality should set in and you have to admit that the color decoder is off and hopefully Sharp will fix it.

I would go one step further for those looking at buying the Elite. Before spending the additional money for the Elite over the next two displays, wait for them to get the problem fixed. I've seen too many products where promises were made that never came through. How are you going to feel if they don't fix it and you've spent double for a display that's no more accurate than the next one down. If you were only spending a few hundred more, that might be different. Here we're talking about several thousand more.
post #3003 of 13287
Jim, the fix is 2-3 weeks away. I got confirmation from Robert yesterday they are working on it and it should be ready shortly.

BTW, the cyan issue is not a color decoder problem but rather a software problem. I too thought it was a decoder issue but was corrected by Kevin at the shootout.
post #3004 of 13287
Which models are you speaking of? Would it be the Sharp 734 and 735? Question? do they have the same color software issue as the Elite?
post #3005 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by marky22 View Post

Which models are you speaking of? Would it be the Sharp 734 and 735? Question? do they have the same color software issue as the Elite?

Huh? We've been talking about the Elite.

I would assume the software is very different in the Elite as opposed to the other Sharps.
post #3006 of 13287
Well I have had my Elite 70" for about 8 weeks now and it's time to give a opinion. I know this set has some Flaws as already mentioned several times on this thread and others. It is not the perfect Video Display, don't think I will see that in my Lifetime. For the past 25 years I have always had the Best of the Best Displays on the Market. I've had them Calibrated by some of the best Calibrators and some not. I went thru all the growing pains of new technologies, with my Pocketbook, Heart, and Eyes.
This is my Opinion.
This is the Best available Display on the Market today. It does so many thing's, so much better as a whole, that it can't be denied any longer.
It wasn't that I thought this Display would be Jaw Dropping and it isn't, cause I have had the pleasure of owning some really nice ones.
As a whole it does everything that's Important to me Better. I have Posted my thought's before so we will leave it at that.
Are there other display's that are close ? Yes ! Is it worth the extra coin over some other very fine displays ? To Me Yes ! Will I ever own a display that's better ? God I Hope so, but I'm just not willing to wait.
If you need or want a new State of the Art Display I think this is the obvious choice of what's available.
post #3007 of 13287
just a little update guys as I'm still in the process of comparing and getting things right, the change in color space to RGB has improved the washed out look. Also changed out the HDMI cable (don't know if this made a difference) but everything is looking vibrant! Will test some more (not much football on during the week) and update as I go a long.
post #3008 of 13287
i wish pinktri would comment on wheather or not he sees the pulsing on my set as i did. perhaps he's busy. we will hopefully be able to put this to rest once his outcome comes forth.
post #3009 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by airgas1998 View Post

i wish pinktri would comment on wheather or not he sees the flickering on my set as i did. perhaps he's busy. we will hopefully be able to put this to rest once his outcome comes forth.

Wait, I thought we decided on "pulsing"?

post #3010 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spiff69 View Post

Wait, I thought we decided on "pulsing"?


I suspect Color Space, big time here guys. The #1 symptom of incorrect color space handshaking is pulsing or image "flashing" on backgrounds. It does not appear in every scenario, but would appear from time to time. Try setting the Color Space to YCbCr 4:2:2 instead of RGB. You *may* see that the problem goes away.

Would be interested in hearing from pinktri as I think he was close to cracking it. Or any others with this issue.

-Brian
post #3011 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by pinktri View Post

just a little update guys as I'm still in the process of comparing and getting things right, the change in color space to RGB has improved the washed out look. Also changed out the HDMI cable (don't know if this made a difference) but everything is looking vibrant! Will test some more (not much football on during the week) and update as I go a long.

Replaced all my HDMI cables with Blue Jeans BJC-Belden Series-FE 12 footers. Everything was better.
post #3012 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by Glenee View Post

Replaced all my HDMI cables with Blue Jeans BJC-Belden Series-FE 12 footers. Everything was better.

Yeah, this is a critical point for folks. It is important to use "High Speed" HDMI cables, those capable of 10.2Mbps or higher, typically referred to as HDMI 1.4-capable cables. They are required to pass 36-bit color space (though 1.3 would work as well) as is used by many BR players, as well as better for 3D, etc. The point is, if you have 1st generation HDMI cables from the old HDMI 1.1 spec, they will leave much to be desired picture quality wise now. It's evil, and ridiculous, but it is what it is. I've recently swapped with some inexpensive but well made cables from cablemart.com and noticed an improvement compared to some expensive 1.1 Kimber HDMI cables that I had been using...go figure!

And Color Space toggling, that is the key to seeing if the problem goes away. Try RGB, try YCbCr4:2:2, and go with whatever looks better. Sometimes it is not clear cut which of the 2 is 'proper', because many sources take different liberties with it even when set the same as other sources. So compare/contrast and go with what looks best, period.

-Brian
post #3013 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by Glenee View Post

This is my Opinion.
This is the Best available Display on the Market today. It does so many thing's, so much better as a whole, that it can't be denied any longer.

Well said, I guess its safe to say "you like"
Reply
Reply
post #3014 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cleveland Plasma View Post

Well said, I guess its safe to say "you like"

You Betcha !
post #3015 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by pinktri View Post

just a little update guys as I'm still in the process of comparing and getting things right, the change in color space to RGB has improved the washed out look. Also changed out the HDMI cable (don't know if this made a difference) but everything is looking vibrant! Will test some more (not much football on during the week) and update as I go a long.

Great to hear! We suspected something wasn't right in your setup.
post #3016 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by ManWithAPlan View Post

And Color Space toggling, that is the key to seeing if the problem goes away. Try RGB, try YCbCr4:2:2, and go with whatever looks better. Sometimes it is not clear cut which of the 2 is 'proper', because many sources take different liberties with it even when set the same as other sources. So compare/contrast and go with what looks best, period.

-Brian

Brian, my hunch is also that it's the color space issue as opposed to the HDMI cable. I've never seen an HDMI cable swap out turn a drab picture into a vibrant one...but who knows?
post #3017 of 13287
Man I hope they don't come out with a color fix within 2 to 3 weeks. Then I might have to buy one.
post #3018 of 13287
I believe it was the color space. Also airgas I have yet to see pulsing but like you said I've been busy with other things. Will give full update when I have more time
post #3019 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by hhtatum View Post

I have the 70" Elite and I am using Ken's settings with a few tweaks. I am using two of the "enhancement" settings. I know, blasphemy. First I have motion set to 120 low. It makes a big difference for me.

I use Fluid Motion enhancement all the time and love it.

But I keep Film Mode off (or sometimes on Standard) because that's what creates the Soap Opera Effect.

Still debating Local Dimming because of the weird background effects it can create on occasion, but without it I can't get those really deep blacks.
post #3020 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken Ross View Post

Brian, my hunch is also that it's the color space issue as opposed to the HDMI cable. I've never seen an HDMI cable swap out turn a drab picture into a vibrant one...but who knows?

Yep, agreed totally Ken. But an older 1.1 HDMI cable may result in a "washed out" look, as it can't hold the full color bit depth that the newer 1.3 or 1.4 certified 'High Speed' cables can. I know some folks have complained of washed out looks, so that's another thing to consider. But yeah, the flashing image or 'pulsing' is much more likely to be a Color Space issue.

Incidentally, after being kind of a cable snob with lots of Kimber and other high end cables for years, I decided to try something different this time. I had to replace my long 25 foot run from the Anthem D2V's HDMI output to the Elite (because my old Kimber run was 1.1 only), and I went with a 65 dollar HDMI 1.4-certified cable from CableMart. It has locking tabs to screw the cable terminators into the termination point as well which is nice, they don't fall out that way. That doesn't work on the Elite side, but it's the source side I was most worried about. That's now not a concern. It's what they call their 'Professional' HDMI cables (just longer length and more industrial looking). Great for restaurants, bars, etc. And those of us who need 25 feet from source to destination! I am suprised at how great everything looks for sure. I don't think I need to spend hundreds of dollars on HDMI cables anymore, just my 2 cents.

-Brian
post #3021 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by AZREOSpecialist View Post

This is probably very basic information, but if there is an A/V receiver/switcher between your video component and the TV, make sure that AVR is set to pass-thru the signal without upscaling and also make sure it is set to the same color mode as all of your other components. I have a 5 year old Denon AVR that I've set to signal pass-thru mode (no scaling) and YCbCr color space.

I couldn't figure out why some Blu-rays and TV shows looked so crappy on the Elite. Thank you very much for this bit of advice! Indeed, my Onkyo TX-NR809 was factory set to apply enhancements to the HDMI signal which caused all the problems. Setting HDMI to "Direct" passthrough for each input on the amplifier fixed all my display issues. Awesome!
post #3022 of 13287
I think Airgas is right!

I was watching one of the CSI shows last night (the one with Big from Sex and the City) and during one of the questioning scenes, which took place in a dark room, the background started to shimmer WILDLY. The term "pulsing" isn't sufficient to describe what I witnessed. It was literally a shimmering, a dark shadowy area that seemed to snake up and down, back and forth in the dark background. This only occurred when half the screen was a dark, sold background (darker than middle gray) and there was a more brightly lit object on the opposite side of the screen. The dark shimmering was pretty wild to the point where the scene was almost unwatchable.

I disabled all the motion controls, as had solved what I thought was the same issue but in different content, and guess what? NO EFFECT! So I took Airgas' advice and turned off LD. Lo and behold - the shimmering disappeared! It would appear that what I saw before as the "pulsing" may not have been the same issue that Airgas was speaking of, at least not until last night.

If I had to guess, I'd say the LD logic gets confused when there is a large, featureless area of dark color with a solid object opposite. The software can't seem to decide whether or not it wants to dim that area. Also, after pausing the scene the shimmering would continue for a handful of seconds, after which, it settled down and the picture looked fine. But restarting the scene brought the shimmering back. It seems the software has trouble with certain scenes, and it takes a few seconds for the algorithm to determine which end is up.

I have had this set now for a couple of months and this is the first time I've seen the pulsing/shimmering with such severity, and where I could not solve the issue by turning off the motion controls. I am also using 5 year old HDMI cables on all of my components - I don't know if that has anything to do with it, or why that would affect scenes with a certain composition. I doubt that is the issue. All of my components feed through a 5 year old Denon AVR set to YCbCr colorspace and "pass-thru" for the video signal.

I would really like to capture a video of this happening, I don't know how useful a call to Elite support would be if I can't show them exactly what is happening.
post #3023 of 13287
Indeed. I have some long (35 ft) low gauge cables from monoprice that work just great. Quality is important, but not always related to price.
post #3024 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by ERosenbrg View Post

I use Fluid Motion enhancement all the time and love it.

But I keep Film Mode off (or sometimes on Standard) because that's what creates the Soap Opera Effect.

Still debating Local Dimming because of the weird background effects it can create on occasion, but without it I can't get those really deep blacks.


In regards to the Local Dimming, try using Intelligent Variable Contrast setting on low (third from the bottom on LD menu). This is how I have abated/ended the pulsing background AND the picture looks better. The PQ also remains very stable which is normally why I wouldnt use this type of feature.

For the few people who use Ken's settings for movies only because they find it washed/yellow or whatever on non-film, try turning on the above and change color temp to medium. I havent felt the need to change any settings since I did this on any programming.

For any fellow Elite owners, I just watched the documentary "Inside Job" from my Direct TV Dvr (dont remember which movie channel) and it has been the most spectacular PQ I have yet seen on my TV. Wow.

One day I might even fire up this new Bluray player...........
post #3025 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by pinktri View Post

I believe it was the color space. Also airgas I have yet to see pulsing but like you said I've been busy with other things. Will give full update when I have more time

if you have a br copy of tdk go to the scene where there in the court room, pay close attention to the walls. if you see nothing whatsoever that would satisfy me enough to think the issue was on my end.
post #3026 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by ERosenbrg View Post

I use Fluid Motion enhancement all the time and love it.

But I keep Film Mode off (or sometimes on Standard) because that's what creates the Soap Opera Effect.

Still debating Local Dimming because of the weird background effects it can create on occasion, but without it I can't get those really deep blacks.

"weird background effects"

please do explain....
post #3027 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by AZREOSpecialist View Post

I think Airgas is right!

I was watching one of the CSI shows last night (the one with Big from Sex and the City) and during one of the questioning scenes, which took place in a dark room, the background started to shimmer WILDLY. The term "pulsing" isn't sufficient to describe what I witnessed. It was literally a shimmering, a dark shadowy area that seemed to snake up and down, back and forth in the dark background. This only occurred when half the screen was a dark, sold background (darker than middle gray) and there was a more brightly lit object on the opposite side of the screen. The dark shimmering was pretty wild to the point where the scene was almost unwatchable.

I disabled all the motion controls, as had solved what I thought was the same issue but in different content, and guess what? NO EFFECT! So I took Airgas' advice and turned off LD. Lo and behold - the shimmering disappeared! It would appear that what I saw before as the "pulsing" may not have been the same issue that Airgas was speaking of, at least not until last night.

If I had to guess, I'd say the LD logic gets confused when there is a large, featureless area of dark color with a solid object opposite. The software can't seem to decide whether or not it wants to dim that area. Also, after pausing the scene the shimmering would continue for a handful of seconds, after which, it settled down and the picture looked fine. But restarting the scene brought the shimmering back. It seems the software has trouble with certain scenes, and it takes a few seconds for the algorithm to determine which end is up.

I have had this set now for a couple of months and this is the first time I've seen the pulsing/shimmering with such severity, and where I could not solve the issue by turning off the motion controls. I am also using 5 year old HDMI cables on all of my components - I don't know if that has anything to do with it, or why that would affect scenes with a certain composition. I doubt that is the issue. All of my components feed through a 5 year old Denon AVR set to YCbCr colorspace and "pass-thru" for the video signal.

I would really like to capture a video of this happening, I don't know how useful a call to Elite support would be if I can't show them exactly what is happening.


"If I had to guess, I'd say the LD logic gets confused when there is a large, featureless area of dark color with a solid object opposite. The software can't seem to decide whether or not it wants to dim that area. Also, after pausing the scene the shimmering would continue for a handful of seconds, after which, it settled down and the picture looked fine. But restarting the scene brought the shimmering back. It seems the software has trouble with certain scenes, and it takes a few seconds for the algorithm to determine which end is up."

you just nailed it to a T. word by word this is my issue from day one. i think it is most certainly a ld algorithm problem.
post #3028 of 13287
Hey guys look at what I just got!!!!!!! Thanks Chris form Cleveland plasma your the best at what you do!!!!!!
LL
LL
LL
post #3029 of 13287
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigballermike99 View Post

Hey guys look at what I just got!!!!!!! Thanks Chris form Cleveland plasma your the best at what you do!!!!!!

What's up with the Tony Montana Sofa.....
post #3030 of 13287
Hey if Tony rocked it so can I
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: LCD Flat Panel Displays
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › Official Sharp Elite PRO-70X5 and 60X5 Owners Thread