or Connect
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Star Trek 2 - Page 23

post #661 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

Well I think that's the idea of the "Genesis of the Borg" concept. In my mind, it's not so much about the Borg as we know it in the TNG story lines but rather how it came into existence. In fact, to me the ST3 story could be something seemingly unrelated to the Borg establishment that leads up to the "shocking revelation" at the end of the film that those events in fact caused the initial establishment of the Borg. We wouldn't even have to see the Borg (as we know it) IMO. I'm kind of thinking how they did The Terminator. They guy was working on the chip that led to the development of machines that would attempt to take over the world. Something similar but with less reveal.
Exactly. The Borg always struck me as something based on an humanoids with tech adaptations. How they came about would be interesting, was it evolution or an experiment that went wrong.
post #662 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by rezzy View Post

I think a project (TV series, anyways) based on the Klingons could be interesting. Maybe we could finally see that frakkin' famous "Battle at Kiddemar" that was always referenced, amongst other things.
I seem to recall there was an reenactment or some damn thing on one of the DS9 episodes....

Quote:
Originally Posted by tenthplanet View Post

Exactly. The Borg always struck me as something based on an humanoids with tech adaptations. How they came about would be interesting, was it evolution or an experiment that went wrong.
Wasn't this explained in the Borg Queen movie? confused.gif
post #663 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by oink View Post

Wasn't this explained in the Borg Queen movie? confused.gif

There was an explanation more or less but 1) it was from one perspective (the Borg's) and 2) nothing was shown (meaning no storyline, flashbacks or anything like that). They could certainly build more detail and develop a story about it but again, if it went in that direction I would not want another Borg movie. Or even Borg mentioned during the movie except perhaps a "big reveal" at the end indicating that this is where the Borg started.

Hey, kind of along the Kahn super soldier concept, maybe the Borg was also a Federation super soldier concept gone bad.
post #664 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

Hey, kind of along the Kahn super soldier concept, maybe the Borg was also a Federation super soldier concept gone bad.

In previous canon, the Borg originated from the complete opposite end of the galaxy and had no knowledge of Earth until Q introduced them to the Enterprise. They could not have been a Federation science experiment.

Of course, the JJ'verse has thrown most canon out the window already, so who can say how this will be ret-conned?
post #665 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josh Z View Post

In previous canon, the Borg originated from the complete opposite end of the galaxy and had no knowledge of Earth until Q introduced them to the Enterprise. They could not have been a Federation science experiment.

Of course, the JJ'verse has thrown most canon out the window already, so who can say how this will be ret-conned?

Unless Q interacted with someone from the Federation (in the Abrams universe) and took them to the opposite end of the galaxy. A mad scientist with cyber-organic ideals that went against Federation ethics became involved with Q who transported him and his ideals (which would suggest a Borg-like progression) to the opposite end of the galaxy. Or maybe his experiments created a galactic rift that propelled him (and his ideals) to the opposite end of the galaxy. With little creativity, there are any number of ways to make that work to keep with "canon". Wow.

Let's just keep it all safe and clean and make it about the Enterprise crew investigating a new energy source that actually ends up being a new life form that they ultimately choose to respect and protect from some hostile group with Kirk and crew saving the day when it's all said and done. Oh yeah, and Kirk gets a girl in the process, why not. No risk to canon there. wink.gif
post #666 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

Hey, kind of along the Kahn super soldier concept, maybe the Borg was also a Federation super soldier concept gone bad.
That will paint the humans as the trouble maker of the galaxy and will have too much trouble with the franchise fans.
post #667 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

There was an explanation more or less but 1) it was from one perspective (the Borg's) and 2) nothing was shown (meaning no storyline, flashbacks or anything like that). They could certainly build more detail and develop a story about it but again, if it went in that direction I would not want another Borg movie. Or even Borg mentioned during the movie except perhaps a "big reveal" at the end indicating that this is where the Borg started.
I have always felt the Borg were a great and creepy villainy bunch.
Next to the Klingons and Romulans, the best ST baddies ever.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bcruiser View Post

That will paint the humans as the trouble maker of the galaxy and will have too much trouble with the franchise fans.
Probably right there....
post #668 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by bcruiser View Post

That will paint the humans as the trouble maker of the galaxy and will have too much trouble with the franchise fans.

I suspect that 500 or 1000 years from now that will probably be the truth. We do have a knack for despoiling our nests.
post #669 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by bcruiser View Post

That will paint the humans as the trouble maker of the galaxy and will have too much trouble with the franchise fans.

Not really any different than the Kahn storyline IMO but fine. It doesn't have to be anything related to the Federation. It was just a random thought to get the idea ball rolling. It can just be a guy with a crazy idea that has Federation implications. Just looking at Star Trek familiar themes that we can all relate to without recreating existing story lines.
post #670 of 682
The Borg are my fave ST bad guys. Resistance is futile.
post #671 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Waboman View Post

The Borg are my fave ST bad guys. Resistance is futile.

This has nothing to do with my preferences on what they do with the third movie, but to me the Borg was one of the most intense and imaginative "bad guys" to come around in a long time. Many movies (and television shows) have good enemies but most of the time it's just "another enemy" by the time it's all said and done. The Borg felt formidable. They made you feel outmatched. There was a screen impact with the likes of Vader, the Terminator, even Jason and Freddy (before parts 15,16 and 17...). I guess what I'm saying is over the years there are villians that had an impact. That you remember, or better yet, cared to remember. The Borg IMO is one of them.
post #672 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

This has nothing to do with my preferences on what they do with the third movie, but to me the Borg was one of the most intense and imaginative "bad guys" to come around in a long time. Many movies (and television shows) have good enemies but most of the time it's just "another enemy" by the time it's all said and done. The Borg felt formidable. They made you feel outmatched. There was a screen impact with the likes of Vader, the Terminator, even Jason and Freddy (before parts 15,16 and 17...). I guess what I'm saying is over the years there are villians that had an impact. That you remember, or better yet, cared to remember. The Borg IMO is one of them.

They kept coming back too, across several ST series. We saw a lot of them. Paramount got a lot of mileage out of the Borg.
post #673 of 682
Yeah, they did but that was one where it worked. That being said, I do feel like bringing the Borg as we know it back would be been there done that at this point. That's why I suggested doing something that leads up to the creation of the Borg but not a "Borg Story" so to speak. Whether it be in line with Star Trek canon or the Abrams universe with an alternate timeline canon, just do it right. Doing anything solidly Borg I think would be like Friday the 13th part 64: Jason's Walker.
post #674 of 682
What was the name of the species that gave the Borg a run for their money? Seems like they enjoyed hunting Borg if I remember correctly..
post #675 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josh Z View Post

In previous canon, the Borg originated from the complete opposite end of the galaxy and had no knowledge of Earth until Q introduced them to the Enterprise. They could not have been a Federation science experiment.

Of course, the JJ'verse has thrown most canon out the window already, so who can say how this will be ret-conned?
They wouldn't have to be federation related and they can come still from the far side of the galaxy. Humanoid based doesn't mean Earth.
post #676 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

This has nothing to do with my preferences on what they do with the third movie, but to me the Borg was one of the most intense and imaginative "bad guys" to come around in a long time. Many movies (and television shows) have good enemies but most of the time it's just "another enemy" by the time it's all said and done. The Borg felt formidable. They made you feel outmatched. There was a screen impact with the likes of Vader, the Terminator, even Jason and Freddy (before parts 15,16 and 17...). I guess what I'm saying is over the years there are villians that had an impact. That you remember, or better yet, cared to remember. The Borg IMO is one of them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

That being said, I do feel like bringing the Borg as we know it back would be been there done that at this point.
+100000000

Quote:
Originally Posted by rezzy View Post

What was the name of the species that gave the Borg a run for their money? Seems like they enjoyed hunting Borg if I remember correctly..
Yeah, I vaguely recall that.......confused.gif
post #677 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Waboman View Post

Resistance is futile.
Bring it on!
Species8472.jpg
post #678 of 682
Thanks for reply. I had posted the picture in a couple other threads to also show my new built in entertainment system/ 7.1 and my 70" and got slammed as a spammer so I've removed all my pics except this one and will keep my future posts to tech issues to not offend anyone or distract from their important issues/discussions.
post #679 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josh Z View Post

In previous canon, the Borg originated from the complete opposite end of the galaxy and had no knowledge of Earth until Q introduced them to the Enterprise. They could not have been a Federation science experiment.

Of course, the JJ'verse has thrown most canon out the window already, so who can say how this will be ret-conned?
Apparently the Borg were familiar with Earth 200 yrs before Enterprise & crew on the tv series of the same name, Enterprise. A science research station found a crashed sphere & put a couple of drones on thaw inside only to have them regenerate & then send the star coordinates all the way back to the Delta quadrant via subspace before Jonathan Archer & crew destroyed the fleeing Borg. That was 2002 or thereabouts.
post #680 of 682

One of my favorites films

post #681 of 682
I'm late to the game concerning this movie. I didn't see it when it came out. I've just been readings reviews in the meantime. Anyway-I bought the BR disc of this yesterday and watched it. I really enjoyed it. I think I liked it as much as the first one, but for different reasons. Just my $.02 about this. No complaints at all.
post #682 of 682
Quote:
Originally Posted by tenthplanet View Post

Exactly. The Borg always struck me as something based on an humanoids with tech adaptations. How they came about would be interesting, was it evolution or an experiment that went wrong.

Well, gee...why doesn't JJ Abrahms just reboot Battlestar Galactica franchise while he's at it? tongue.gif
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home