AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Technical › Feasibility of indoor antenna?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Feasibility of indoor antenna?

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
Hello avsforum,
I would like to first apologize for my ignorance, I've just recently become interested in using an antenna for HDTV reception. Long story short I'm a student on a fixed income and time warner is the only cable company here, $50/mo is just out of my budge and all I want to do is watch local channels.

I'm hoping for an indoor antenna so I can avoid landlord permission.
I am unable to post my tvfool information due to the spammer deterrent, so my general information is as follows- I'm in Ada, Ohio. 45810, elevation of antenna will probably be about 2 feet. ^_^

I'm particularly interested in the channels that are West/Southwest, ~270degrees due to the proximity and variety from that direction (I'm hoping to be able to avoid rotating the antenna). If there is no way an indoor antenna would pick up those signals my roof peaks at about 17 feet.

I don't know if this is useful, or if antennaweb is to be trusted, but that site suggests I use a Medium Directional Antenna with pre-amp.

Thanks ahead of time for any help you can offer!
post #2 of 9
It's not much help but all you can do is try an indoor antenna. There are a lot of folks who have very good luck with indoors but it all depends on what's around you (other buildings, trees, wall material, etc). TVFool is supposed to be more reliable than antennaweb so I'd use their recommendations. Ideally, a roof-top antenna is your best bet but that sounds like it's not possible in your situation.
post #3 of 9
Clearstream 1 or 2, DB2, 4220, Terk HDTVi/HDTVa, or Mohu are antennas that I have found to work well indoors. They are good versions of basic antenna designs. Other indoor antennas are gimmicky and overpriced, and often produce poor results. But if you are in a good signal area, the basic rabbit ears/loop from RadioShack does work good as well.
post #4 of 9
I started out with radio shack rabbit ears and it worked quite well for the money. I am in a condo facing south and most of my channels are northeast about 20 miles and I can get almost all of them.
post #5 of 9
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the quick replies!
I got a set of RCA rabbit ears and was able to pick up the 2 channels that required a "small multidirectional" antenna.

Sadly, those were not the network stations.

So I guess that leads me to my next question-
Are antennae classified "cumulatively" for lack of a better term? (Would a "large directional with pre-amp" pick up everything a medium directional, small multidirectional, etc. would?)

Thanks again for your continued help!
post #6 of 9
You're somewhat lucky in the sense that in order to get the big 4 networks, you only need to be able to receive two stations - WLIO/channel 8, which, according to Wikipedia, has NBC in HD and Fox in SD, and WOHL/channel 35, airing both ABC and CBS in HD. Just entering your zip code into TV Fool, you look to be close enough to those stations, as well as the PBS station WBGU to the north, that an indoor antenna would be feasible, though, as mentioned, there may be obstacles at your specific location that hinder you. Additionally, and completely out of your control, one of the stations you need to pick up is on the VHF band, and VHF digital stations do not have a good record of working with indoor antennas as well as UHF signals.

Still, I'd throw in another recommendation for the Terk HDTVa antenna. The one I have has had few problems in two different cities/houses in picking up VHF and UHF signals from up to 45 miles away. The only downside is that the cable attached to the antenna is rather short, and since the best results for this, and really any, indoor antenna, is to have the antenna as far away from the TV as possible, you may need to buy some extra coaxial cable and a female-female connector. Fortunately, both are cheap.
post #7 of 9
Thread Starter 
Thanks for all the help!
post #8 of 9
FWIW, you might find a comparatively "flat" outdoor-type antenna with nice, long elements to pick up your VHF station and enough uhf elements to match any indoor antenna for that band. I could almost get consistent reception indoors in Ft. Myers, FL with a Terk HDTVi, but replaced it with an Antennacraft AC-9, stuck on top of a tall cabinet back in a corner (so the long elements in back were extended only to a 90 degree angle, not straight out), high enough no one would poke his eye out on an element. It solved the last of the reception problems there, and cost just 20 bucks before S&H.
post #9 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by poorinohio View Post

...Would a "large directional with pre-amp" pick up everything a medium directional, small multidirectional, etc. would?

It might. Or might not. For example, typically the larger an antenna is, the more gain it has. It is also more directional. So, a larger antenna might not pick up stations off axis from the direction it is aimed. Additionally, preamps are prone to overload. If there are any strong local signals in the path of the antenna, the preamp may over-amplify the signal, resulting in worse reception.

Go ahead and post your TVFool link. The address will truncate, but we can determine the complete URL. For your pricacy, your address will not display on the results page.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HDTV Technical
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Technical › Feasibility of indoor antenna?