AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › 4-digit channel numbers
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

4-digit channel numbers

post #1 of 29
Thread Starter 
With many cable companies going to 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) for ClearQAM channels, I was wondering if any make/model HDTV sets are incapable of tuning 4-digit channels.

Please list your make/model TV and state whether or not it can tune 4-digit channels. Thanks.
post #2 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

With many cable companies going to 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) for ClearQAM channels, I was wondering if any make/model HDTV sets are incapable of tuning 4-digit channels.

Please list your make/model TV and state whether or not it can tune 4-digit channels. Thanks.

Aren't the 4-digit numbers accessed only through the cable boxes (set top boxes)??? Why would your TV need to access 4-digit numbers?
post #3 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

With many cable companies going to 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) for ClearQAM channels, I was wondering if any make/model HDTV sets are incapable of tuning 4-digit channels.

No TV can "tune" any (real) cable channel other than 1-135.

How digital cable channels are mapped depends on how the TV tuner interprets and what the cableco sends in it's PSIP info.

Many (most?) TV tuners will display the cable channel as R.xx
R = real cable channel assignment
xx = sub-channel

As an example:
When using a cable box, the channel would be 1004. Using the TV's internal tuner, the channel may be 129.18 or 31.3

All you can do is scan and see what you get. And you may have to do that quite often as the cableco may shuffle channel assignments frequently.
post #4 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

No TV can "tune" any (real) cable channel other than 1-135.

How digital cable channels are mapped depends on how the TV tuner interprets and what the cableco sends in it's PSIP info.

Many (most?) TV tuners will display the cable channel as R.xx
R = real cable channel assignment
xx = sub-channel

As an example:
When using a cable box, the channel would be 1004. Using the TV's internal tuner, the channel may be 129.18 or 31.3

All you can do is scan and see what you get. And you may have to do that quite often as the cableco may shuffle channel assignments frequently.

Thanks, I appreciate the explanation also. As "they" say, you learn something new every day.
post #5 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BoilerJim View Post

Aren't the 4-digit numbers accessed only through the cable boxes (set top boxes)??? Why would your TV need to access 4-digit numbers?

As explained, Cox and others are transitioning ClearQAM channel numbers (those are the ones you enter directly into your TV - no cable box) to match STB channel numbers. For example, local ABC affiliate KGTV is channel 10 on the analog tier, and it's HD signal is channel 1010 on the STB, and will soon be channel 1010 as ClearQAM on the TV.
post #6 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

No TV can "tune" any (real) cable channel other than 1-135.

How digital cable channels are mapped depends on how the TV tuner interprets and what the cableco sends in it's PSIP info.

Many (most?) TV tuners will display the cable channel as R.xx
R = real cable channel assignment
xx = sub-channel

As an example:
When using a cable box, the channel would be 1004. Using the TV's internal tuner, the channel may be 129.18 or 31.3

If the cable company puts 1010 into the PSIP data, the TV will have to tune 1010. The local affiliate ClearQAM channel numbers have been 705, 706, 707, 708, 709, 710, and 711 for two years. The same as the STBs. I haven't had to enter a "." in a ClearQAM channel for years. Now they are transitioning from the 7xx range to the 1xxx range.

Funny that instead of answering the posted question you instead argue its validity. So, I'll ask it again:

Can your TV (make/model) tune 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) ?
post #7 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

As explained, Cox and others are transitioning ClearQAM channel numbers (those are the ones you enter directly into your TV - no cable box) to match STB channel numbers. For example, local ABC affiliate KGTV is channel 10 on the analog tier, and it's HD signal is channel 1010 on the STB, and will soon be channel 1010 as ClearQAM on the TV.

Cox in CT has transitioned the HD cable channels to 1xxx as you stated but ... the ClearQAM are mapped to the actual OTA channel. For example, FOX-CT SD is channel 6 on the STB, the HD channel is 1006, but the ClearQAM channel is 61.1 on the TV, the same as FOX's OTA channel.
post #8 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

If the cable company puts 1010 into the PSIP data, the TV will have to tune 1010. The local affiliate ClearQAM channel numbers have been 705, 706, 707, 708, 709, 710, and 711 for two years. The same as the STBs. I haven't had to enter a "." in a ClearQAM channel for years. Now they are transitioning from the 7xx range to the 1xxx range.

Funny that instead of answering the posted question you instead argue its validity. So, I'll ask it again:

Can your TV (make/model) tune 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) ?

Funny... as I explained, no TV's "tune" channels above 135.

Do you have a TV that "tunes" to the 700's with no cable box? Is so, what is the make/model? If it works for you now, why anticipate a problem?

Not arguing, but providing reality (or validity). It all depends on the TV's tuner and how the cableco sends compatible info that your TV's tuner recognizes/supports.

Why the hostility Hoss?

Post #7 is accurate (for most cases).
post #9 of 29
My HDTV doesn't show the cable box channel numbers at all for the clear QAM channels, instead it uses the PSIP data from the original source channel apparently. Like 6-1 or 10-1, instead of on the cable box its 706 or 710.
post #10 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by apaulct View Post

Cox in CT has transitioned the HD cable channels to 1xxx as you stated but ... the ClearQAM are mapped to the actual OTA channel. For example, FOX-CT SD is channel 6 on the STB, the HD channel is 1006, but the ClearQAM channel is 61.1 on the TV, the same as FOX's OTA channel.

It used to be that way in San Diego as well, but about 2 years ago Cox transitioned ClearQAM channel assignments to the same as on STBs. KGTV-DT went from being 10.1 on ClearQAM and 710 on the STB to being 710 on both ClearQAM and the STB. And before the end of November, the 7xx numbers will be replaced by 1xxx numbers. That's what drove my question, which nobody seems to want to answer: Can your TV (make/model) tune 4-digit channel numbers?
post #11 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Funny... as I explained, no TV's "tune" channels above 135.

Do you have a TV that "tunes" to the 700's with no cable box? Is so, what is the make/model? If it works for you now, why anticipate a problem?

As explained much earlier, I must "tune" to 705 on my Sony Bravia KDL40S3000 to "tune" to KSWB-DT my local Fox affiliate, I must "tune" to 707 for KNSD-DT my local NBC affiliate, and so on. I anticipate a problem not on my set, but on other make/model sets. Hence my (still unanswered) question. Many sets will tune 3-digit channel numbers (7xx), but not 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx.) Complaints arose when Cox Phoenix made the same transition a few months ago.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Not arguing, but providing reality (or validity). It all depends on the TV's tuner and how the cableco sends compatible info that your TV's tuner recognizes/supports.

Why the hostility Hoss?

No hostility, but continued wonderment as to why you challenge the validity of the question instead of simply answering it. I've been entering 705, 707, etc., into my TV's remote control for a couple of years now. No, I don't do drugs. Screen-shot available on request.
post #12 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by apaulct View Post

Cox in CT has transitioned the HD cable channels to 1xxx as you stated but ... the ClearQAM are mapped to the actual OTA channel. For example, FOX-CT SD is channel 6 on the STB, the HD channel is 1006, but the ClearQAM channel is 61.1 on the TV, the same as FOX's OTA channel.

I see the same on all of mine sets except it is the CW channel. To clarify, on my HDTVs with the cable connected directly to them (not OTA) the CW channel KASW, SD analog NTSC is on channel 6, The clear QAM HD is on channel 61.1, channel 61 is the NTSC SD History channel, and the clear QAM SD CW channel is on 80.4. On the STB the clear QAM SD channel is on channel 6 and the HD channel is on channel 1006. IMO this will be true on at least 90% of the HDTV sets. I would be interested to know if there are any reports of an HDTV without a cable card that would find the CW HD channel on 1006. One of my sets has a cable card which when installed finds the channels at the same channel numbers as the STB, 6 and 1006.
post #13 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

As explained much earlier, I must "tune" to 705 on my Sony Bravia KDL40S3000 to "tune" to KSWB-DT my local Fox affiliate, I must "tune" to 707 for KNSD-DT my local NBC affiliate, and so on. I anticipate a problem not on my set, but on other make/model sets. Hence my (still unanswered) question. Many sets will tune 3-digit channel numbers (7xx), but not 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx.) Complaints arose when Cox Phoenix made the same transition a few months ago.

No hostility, but continued wonderment as to why you challenge the validity of the question instead of simply answering it. I've been entering 705, 707, etc., into my TV's remote control for a couple of years now. No, I don't do drugs. Screen-shot available on request.

As I am attempting to explain, ALL TV tuners can only "tune" real channel frequencies from 1-135. Again... how the cableco assigns virtual channels is their perogative. How or if someone's TV interprets the signal depends on the capability and/or compatibility of the TV's tuner. You are selecting a "virtually assigned" channel... not a "real" channel.

I'm glad that you don't anticipate a problem with your TV and commend you for having a concern for others that may have problems with their TV's.

Personally, I suggest, If someone has a problem selecting 4 digit channel numbers, they should contact their cable provider and kindy request they change/revert back to 3 digit channel assignments for clear QAM channels (which is probably unlikely). The only alternatives would be to rent a cable box or purchase a TV that can select 4 digit channel numbers.

BTW... you probably would be better asking posters to respond only if their set is capable of selecting 4 digit channels.
post #14 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

As I am attempting to explain, ALL TV tuners can only "tune" real channel frequencies from 1-135. Again... how the cableco assigns virtual channels is their perogative. How or if someone's TV interprets the signal depends on the capability and/or compatibility of the TV's tuner. You are selecting a "virtually assigned" channel... not a "real" channel.

You know darn well what we are "discussing" here. From the beginning, I was using the term "tune" to explain what is entered on the TV's remote. On Cox San Diego cable systems (as with other Cox systems, such as Phoenix), the same number is entered on the TV remote to tune the ClearQAM signal as would be entered on the STB remote (if one were being used.) These are whole numbers in the 7xx range (soon to be the 1xxx range), not a xx.x or xx-x type number you insisted must be used. I have heard some complaints that a users TV (or HTPC) would not allow 4-digit channels. So, once more, my question:

Does your TV (make/model) allow you to enter 4-digit channel numbers?

That was my only question. Knowing that a particular cable system still uses xx.x or xx-x type numbers instead of STB identical whole numbers is not really news to me. I am more concerned about what happens on this cable system.
post #15 of 29
Zzzzzz... For what it's worth, I just checked my Samsung B650 and it WILL let me enter up to and including 5 digits. I would guess my A650 will do the same but I'm too lazy to go check.
post #16 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

You know darn well what we are "discussing" here.

Maybe or maybe not. You probably know darned well what I am try to clarify.

Quote:
From the beginning, I was using the term "tune" to explain what is entered on the TV's remote.

You are not "tuning", you are "selecting". I've tried to express this point.

Quote:
On Cox San Diego cable systems (as with other Cox systems, such as Phoenix), the same number is entered on the TV remote to tune the ClearQAM signal as would be entered on the STB remote (if one were being used.) These are whole numbers in the 7xx range (soon to be the 1xxx range), not a xx.x or xx-x type number you insisted must be used. I have heard some complaints that a users TV (or HTPC) would not allow 4-digit channels.

Okay. That's all well and good. You or others may or may not have specific issues with COX and your clear QAM capable TV's in specific locations/areas. There are many cable providers across the country and typically all unencrypted channels are limited to local channels and mapped to closely relate to the OTA channel number. I did not "insist" that xx.x xx-x is the way it works everywhere. If you calmly re-read my previous posts, I was attempting to clarify the difference of terms channel tuning, assignments, selection, real/virtual. And... compatibility/capability of the cableco and the TV's tuner.

Quote:
Does your TV (make/model) allow you to enter 4-digit channel numbers?

It may... but I don't subscribe to Cox cable. And if I did, I'd probably use a cable box (STB) as I would subscribe to more than "limited basic".

Quote:
I am more concerned about what happens on this cable system.

Fair enough. Ask to have the mods edit the thread title to reflect "Cox Cable" or ask to have this thread cleaned and moved to the Cox Cable forum.

Your opening post, IMHO, is very general. To make the point:
Quote:
With many cable companies going to 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) for ClearQAM channels,

Many?? or... Cox predominantly?
Quote:
I was wondering if any make/model HDTV sets are incapable of tuning 4-digit channels.

Probably the majority.
post #17 of 29
Nice, thorough answer but I doubt if he'll be satisfied until every member punches in as many numbers as he/she can and reports back with the number entered and make/model of the TV.

Update: I checked my Samsung A650 and it will only let me "enter" 4 digits as opposed to 5 for my B650.
post #18 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by BoilerJim View Post

Nice, thorough answer but I doubt if he'll be satisfied until every member punches in as many numbers as he/she can and reports back with the number entered and make/model of the TV.

Thanks... I've tried. After 24+ hours, not many have provided info, so either no one cares or it's in the wrong forum.
post #19 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Thanks... I've tried. After 24+ hours, not many have provided info, so either no one cares or it's in the wrong forum.

I think you hit the nail on the head... probably no one cares.

Many threads continue forever because they are important to so many people.

Conversely, other people have issues that are unique pretty much only to them and if they don't get enough responses in total or enough responses that satisfy them, then they bump their threads, get ticked off at members who don't reply, or get ticked off even more when they get a reply they don't like, don't feel comfortable with, or that doesn't fit into the little slot that they have in their minds that gives them the exact information they feel they need.

And, that's fine also as long as they understand when it's time take a deep breath and accept what they get or don't get.
post #20 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Maybe or maybe not. You probably know darned well what I am try to clarify.

You are not "tuning", you are "selecting". I've tried to express this point.

But not once did you bring up the subject of "physical channel." Thus, I find your falling back on my use of the word "tuning" instead of "selecting" as using semantics as a cop-out. So be it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Fair enough. Ask to have the mods edit the thread title to reflect "Cox Cable" or ask to have this thread cleaned and moved to the Cox Cable forum.

The question was solely TV related - how many digits one can enter when selecting a channel. Not only should it not be a Cox-only thread (there may be no Cox readers with a limited selection, but a caveat from a non-Cox subscriber might help someone shopping for a TV), but an OTA sub-channel of four digits (39.11) might also cause trouble. It was a TV related question until "someone" decided to turn it into a cable TV question.
post #21 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BoilerJim View Post

Nice, thorough answer but I doubt if he'll be satisfied until every member punches in as many numbers as he/she can and reports back with the number entered and make/model of the TV.

...or leave the semantics arguments where they belong. ["Tuning" instead of "selecting"? Geez...I guess I should have asked "How many buttons can you push on your remote when changing channels before it enters them automatically?"]

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoilerJim View Post

Update: I checked my Samsung A650 and it will only let me "enter" 4 digits as opposed to 5 for my B650.

Thanks. And I have learned of at least one HTPC tuner card that has 999 as an upper limit. Trying to verify make/model of the card.
post #22 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BoilerJim View Post

I think you hit the nail on the head... probably no one cares.

And then there are those that, instead of going to the next thread if they don't care about this one, change the direction of the thread away from the original question. Don't care about the question? Don't answer!
post #23 of 29
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

But not once did you bring up the subject of "physical channel." Thus, I find your falling back on my use of the word "tuning" instead of "selecting" as using semantics as a cop-out. So be it.

Talk about semantics? This was my quote in post #3...
"No TV can "tune" any (real) cable channel other than 1-135."
How more concise can one be? So... if said "physical" instead of "real", you would have agreed?

Quote:


... but an OTA sub-channel of four digits (39.11) might also cause trouble. It was a TV related question until "someone" decided to turn it into a cable TV question.

Nice sidestep. This is your opening post:
"With many cable companies going to 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) for ClearQAM channels, I was wondering if any make/model HDTV sets are incapable of tuning 4-digit channels."

Sure seems like a question specific to cable TV to me.
post #24 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Talk about semantics? This was my quote in post #3...
"No TV can "tune" any (real) cable channel other than 1-135."
How more concise can one be? So... if said "physical" instead of "real", you would have agreed?

Tune is correct. Look in your dictionary:

tune
 [toon, tyoon] noun, verb, tuned, tun·ing.

Radio and Television .
c. to adjust (a receiving apparatus) so as to receive the signals of a particular transmitting station.

So when I instruct my TV to "tune" to channel 707, I am telling it to "adjust" to receive channel 707, which it does by going to 531MHz per the PSIP instructions.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Nice sidestep. This is your opening post:
"With many cable companies going to 4-digit channel numbers (1xxx) for ClearQAM channels, I was wondering if any make/model HDTV sets are incapable of tuning 4-digit channels."

Sure seems like a question specific to cable TV to me.

Hardly. The fact that cable companies have begun the practice of 4-digit ClearQAM channels doesn't mean that they are the only ones using 4-digit channer numbers. The question, which I've highlighted in red applied to TVs, not to a transmission method.
post #25 of 29
post #26 of 29
So much controversy!!

I think maybe the OP originally just wanted to know how many digits could be entered on various makes/models of tv. In my case with a Sony KDL46EX710 I can go up to 5 digits when pressing the tuner number buttons. That's last years model but Sonys are pretty consistent so I think it would be safe to assume that any Sony over the last couple of years should do the same.

The difficulty seems to be that what with different channel mapping, psip data, etc. there's no way of knowing which or how many numbers to press to get a particular clear qam channel on a particular set on a particular cable system.

It's entirely possible (I've seen this on Comcast here in Fresno) for a given channel to be at, say, 704 on a cable box, and the same channel to require one to punch 24.1 on a clear qam tv set. Then there are the cable companies that try to sell boxes by reassigning channels all the time requiring clear qam users to rescan while box users see no difference.

Taking this into account it would be pretty impossible for anyone not in his area using his cable system to go beyond telling how many digits can be pressed--he still wouldn't know specifically how to get the channels he wants to watch.

May I gently suggest he go to the local HD reception forum

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/forum...aysprune=&f=45

do a search for his particular town, and post an inquiry there to find out just what others in his same situation are encountering as far as getting desired channels with clear qam tuners on their particular make/model sets?

Alternatively there's also the option of popping for a box or, in many situations, using an antenna.

Hope this doesn't offend anyone.
post #27 of 29
Not at all...
Explanations/clarifications/suggestions have been attempted.

Simply... the OP's topic should be, "Can your TV/remote manually select channels with 4 digits?"
post #28 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve S View Post

So much controversy!!

I think maybe the OP originally just wanted to know how many digits could be entered on various makes/models of tv. In my case with a Sony KDL46EX710 I can go up to 5 digits when pressing the tuner number buttons.

It was a simple question, really, but morphed into something complex by another for reasons unknown. Thanks for your input. My Sony S3000 series will also accept 5 digits.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve S View Post

It's entirely possible (I've seen this on Comcast here in Fresno) for a given channel to be at, say, 704 on a cable box, and the same channel to require one to punch 24.1 on a clear qam tv set.

That's the way it used to be here. The local NBC affiliate's HD signal was 707 on the STB and 39.1 for ClearQAM. Since all of the online guides and Cox's own website only listed 707, Cox changed the ClearQAM channel to 707 as well. Soon, it will transition to 1007 for STBs and for ClearQAM.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve S View Post

May I gently suggest he go to the local HD reception forum

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/forum...aysprune=&f=45

do a search for his particular town, and post an inquiry there to find out just what others in his same situation are encountering as far as getting desired channels with clear qam tuners on their particular make/model sets?

I considered this but Phoenix, San Diego, and at least one other Cox franchise (that I know of) are changing to the 4-digit format. Plus, if a reader in BF Iowa has a TV that has a 3-digit limit, he might want to inform Phoenix and San Diego readers of that limitation.
post #29 of 29
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ratman View Post

Not at all...

Simply... the OP's topic should be, "Can your TV/remote manually select channels with 4 digits?"

Yeah, that's so much different than my "I was wondering if any make/model HDTV sets are incapable of tuning 4-digit channels."
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: LCD Flat Panel Displays
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › 4-digit channel numbers