or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Blu-ray Software › Drive
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Drive - Page 10

post #271 of 310
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alkaline View Post


Not currently. Was itchin for some Thief the other day after reactivating my streaming account following a three month hold and saw it's unavailable (though I thought I'd remembered seeing it before)

It is on the UK side, my bad I have both running
post #272 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by dvdmike007 View Post

It is on the UK side, my bad I have both running

Nope my bad - totally forgot UK now has Netflix streaming.
post #273 of 310
Just watched The Ides of March, which I rented primarily because I wanted to see Ryan Gosling's performance and ended up thinking he was marvelous. I am now convinced that my dislike of Gosling's performance in Drive was caused far more by how the Driver role was written and how Refn directed than it was by any weakness in Gosling's performance. Those toothpicks, gaggh!
post #274 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by gwsat View Post

Those toothpicks, gaggh!

I'm not sure what the heck because the Internet can be a strange place, but here is "something" about Gosling's use of toothpicks in Drive: http://pictorialgosling.net/Tentries...toothpick.html
post #275 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by gwsat View Post

I am now convinced that my dislike of Gosling's performance in Drive was caused far more by how the Driver role was written and how Refn directed than it was by any weakness in Gosling's performance.

Yup.
post #276 of 310
have it reserved on redbox. will be watching it tonight.
post #277 of 310
Some information on the French Steelbook BD:

- it is the Sony transfer, not filtered
- it is zoomed in very slightly (only noticable in direct screenshot comparison)
- Bitrate is around 26-27 Mbps
- French subs are forced with the English language track
- Audio is only 16Bit DTS-HD MA 5.1
- It has by far the best cover art
post #278 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by mr. wally View Post

have it reserved on redbox. will be watching it tonight.

Did you like it?
post #279 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rathbone View Post

Some information on the French Steelbook BD:

- it is the Sony transfer, not filtered
- it is zoomed in very slightly (only noticable in direct screenshot comparison)
- Bitrate is around 26-27 Mbps
- French subs are forced with the English language track
- Audio is only 16Bit DTS-HD MA 5.1
- It has by far the best cover art


Slightly zoomed? compared to what version? The US or UK? If it's the Sony transfer, then I would think it's slightly zoomed in when compared to the US version.

Also, if the bitrate is only 26-27 Mbps, then at least from what I've read, it can't be from the Sony transfer since the US version is above 30 Mbps.
post #280 of 310
Comparative ITA USA
ITA VERSION 25,889,603.584 bytes


USA VERSION 35,594,592,522 bytes

post #281 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

Did you like it?

I hated it. Was really boring. Even the Wife hated it. Glad I rented it first.
post #282 of 310
Thread Starter 
Looks like the UK version
post #283 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

Slightly zoomed? compared to what version? The US or UK? If it's the Sony transfer, then I would think it's slightly zoomed in when compared to the US version.

Also, if the bitrate is only 26-27 Mbps, then at least from what I've read, it can't be from the Sony transfer since the US version is above 30 Mbps.

Could be Sony and UK utilized two different masters as their basis (hence slight color variation etc), in addition to being two different encodes? And maybe the French is a different encode of the Sony master?

Also, has anyone heard anything concrete transfer/BDinfo wise about the Canadian? I sort of assumed a direct port of the Sony, at least in terms of video/audio, if not total disc content
post #284 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

Slightly zoomed? compared to what version? The US or UK? If it's the Sony transfer, then I would think it's slightly zoomed in when compared to the US version.

Also, if the bitrate is only 26-27 Mbps, then at least from what I've read, it can't be from the Sony transfer since the US version is above 30 Mbps.

You're conflating transfers and encodes. Two releases could use the exact same transfer, but differences in encoding for Blu-ray would result in the varying bitrates.
post #285 of 310
I've done direct comparisons between the two. I don't know what "ITA" stands for, however...

After copying and viewing each of the same images of each version by rapidly switching back and forth...

There is no difference in color

However...

There is slightly more "brightness" in the US version. This brightness is not a good thing as it tends to "soften" the contrast. Another words, the slight increase in brightness (density...) makes the US version look a touch more soft.

I couldn't detect any differences in resolution or detail between either of the images.

In the case of the image of him taking a drink, the (ITS) version is slightly cropped ONLY from the top of the image (When compared to the US version.)

And the image in the garage, there are no differences in the crop.



I would have to ask, what caused the difference in contrast? Was it from the way it was copied and posted onto this thread? Or does it have everything to do with actual differences between the "ITA" and US version?


The ITA version looked "better" at least on my calibrated monitor. The slightly darker more realistic "black" from the ITS samples simply made the images look more solid and realistic (when compared to the US version.)


So now I have to ask,

1. What is the "ITA" version?

2. Why is the US version have slightly less contrast? Is that the cause of the actual transfer? Or, was it caused from the software used to make the copy for this thread?

3. Why is there a slight crop from the top of the ITS version of the still frame of him taking a drink. Is it that way on the disc or wrongly cropped when placed on this thread?


Final conclusion, if it was not for a slight difference in contrast, the two versions would be exactly the same...(minus an odd crop on one of the images.) At the same time, the US version does look a touch brighter.

Note...I'm assuming the two bottom images are the US version.
post #286 of 310
Thread Starter 
Italian
post #287 of 310
As a Blu-ray label you can do whatever you want when you get the Hard Drive or HDCAM with the transfer/master. Reframe, change colors, filter etc. But in the end you'll have to do your own encode for the disc. I guess all (UK, FR, ITA, US ...) have the same source available. What they make of it is the difference. The French and the US seem to have encoded the source quite unmolested whereas the UK has been additionally processed.
post #288 of 310
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rathbone View Post

As a Blu-ray label you can do whatever you want when you get the Hard Drive or HDCAM with the transfer/master. Reframe, change colors, filter etc. But in the end you'll have to do your own encode for the disc. I guess all (UK, FR, ITA, US ...) have the same source available. What they make of it is the difference. The French and the US seem to have encoded the source quite unmolested whereas the UK has been additionally processed.

I disagree, I think the UK is just starved of bitrate
post #289 of 310
So if you live in Region B land, the Italian one is the one to go for?
post #290 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

Final conclusion, if it was not for a slight difference in contrast, the two versions would be exactly the same...

Not at all. The Italian release copes badly with the video noise. In the shot with Driver holding the glass, the red wall on the left clearly isn't handled as well as in the US release. The Italian release also suffers from some really bad blocking compression artifacts. Most easily seen in Driver's denim jacket. I noticed such blocking quite a few times as well while viewing the UK release (I own the US release & the UK steelbook).

I made a comparison pic, blown up 3x but otherwise completely lossless from those posted screenshots. Italian release on the left, US on the right:

post #291 of 310
Off topic: Anyone know where I can trade blu-rays to others?
Example: I would like to trade Rise of the Planet of the Apes for Drive.
post #292 of 310
Thread Starter 
BAFTA snubbed then
post #293 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by _crs_ View Post

Not at all. The Italian release copes badly with the video noise. In the shot with Driver holding the glass, the red wall on the left clearly isn't handled as well as in the US release. The Italian release also suffers from some really bad blocking compression artifacts. Most easily seen in Driver's denim jacket. I noticed such blocking quite a few times as well while viewing the UK release (I own the US release & the UK steelbook).

I made a comparison pic, blown up 3x but otherwise completely lossless from those posted screenshots. Italian release on the left, US on the right:


Thank you, I didn't even notice that. Considering the compression artifacts from the Italian version, I think the US version is the best AND, it's it very slightly brighter (less contrasty) that "might" look better on some displays.
post #294 of 310
Just got my Canada FutureShop exclusive disc this morning...Canadian disc has a higher bitrate and more/different extras.
LL
post #295 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by hsinnott View Post

Just got my Canada FutureShop exclusive disc this morning...Canadian disc has a higher bitrate and more/different extras.

A higher bit rate than what verson?

What is the bitrate?
post #296 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

Did you like it?

it was ok. goessling's laconic performance didn't help with this mediocre plot, but as expected, the driving scenes were a lot of fun.
post #297 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

A higher bit rate than what verson?

What is the bitrate?


Sorry, bigger disc size on Canada disc...

UK Disc Size 35.59 GB US 48.32 GB Canada 49.95 GB
UK Track Size 25.25 GB US 30.37 GB Canada 33.18 GB


Having touble running c'squid on my PC right now so will get back later with bitrates for video/audio etc...
post #298 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thebarnman View Post

I couldn't detect any differences in resolution or detail between either of the images.

Compare the lines in Driver's forehead in the garage shots. I definitely see a bit more fine detail in the bottom (U.S.?) version.
post #299 of 310
Quote:
Originally Posted by hsinnott View Post

Sorry, bigger disc size on Canada disc...

UK Disc Size 35.59 GB US 48.32 GB Canada 49.95 GB
UK Track Size 25.25 GB US 30.37 GB Canada 33.18 GB


Having touble running c'squid on my PC right now so will get back later with bitrates for video/audio etc...

I'm guessing the difference in total disc and feature size over the U.S. version is due to the Alliance release's different (more?) extras, and possibly additional dub/subtitle options. I'd be very surprised if the video/audio bitrate is actually higher.

Edit: A member in the thread for the Canadian Futureshop exclusive over at blu-ray.com insists extras are identical between US/CA, and the only real difference is the omission of the Spanish subs and different start up trailers on the CA.
post #300 of 310
Is the Canadian disc region locked?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Blu-ray Software
AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Blu-ray Software › Drive