AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › 'Survivor: One World' Season 24 on CBS HD
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

'Survivor: One World' Season 24 on CBS HD - Page 30

post #871 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPanther95 View Post

They've gone from casting a bunch of "survivors" with a few quirky personalities thrown in - to casting a bunch of freaks with only a couple people that possess both a desire to win and the minimum common sense required to do so.

They may have gained a few extra soundbites and clashes throughout the season, but they've sacrificed everything that made the show interesting.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

However Kat made her way into the show, she made her way in ..

John McCain picked a running mate with inadequate vetting .. someone slipping into a reality TV show with some issues is likely not that tough ..

Survivor is getting pretty long in the tooth .. I don't know how much longer it will run .. they no longer really try to survive, it's almost becoming a soap opera or a parody of itself ..


Well, let's not kid ourselves - they've more or less casted this way from Season 1, with Greg and his quirks - speaking into the coconut phone at all times, and many other wanting to become stars like Colleen (acting), Gervis, etc.

Now, they may cast even more from CA, but this show has always attracted and casted people who aren't the most grounded.
post #872 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by scowl View Post

Kat not only had a heart condition (she says she'll need another operation soon) but even a rudimentary interview would have shown she was not going to handle being on Survivor thus had absolutely no chance of winning.

No shot at winning? That's not accurate. She certainly had a shot, more so than a lot people this season. She formed a friendship/alliance early that was strong enough not to get her voted out from one early bad team challenge performance. In fact, one of the reasons she was taken out was because she was a threat to win it all with the jury guys' vote.

btw, WOW, to see her last night - stunning. -
post #873 of 1026
So it seems Sabrina was wrong that Tarzan might get the men's vote if they took him to the finals, considering that Mike flipped the bird at Tarzan's exit speech.
post #874 of 1026
Last nights episode reminded my of why this is one of my least favorite seasons of Survivor.Though the producers tried to edit the episode to inject some drama. The women did the expected by voting out Tarzan. Even though neither Kim or Chelsea had immunity Alisha did not make a big move to get rid of either of them.If the vote had been tied she could have forced Kim to vote off Chelsea or go to rocks. Alisha would have been safe from the rocks since she had immunity. Assuming Chelsea and Tarzan were the two targets. Alisha, Tarzan and Chelsea would have been safe. With Kim, Sabrina and Christina having to go to rocks.If Alisha had forced a tie either Chelsea would have gone home on the second vote or Sabrina or Kim could have gone out with the rocks. The only downside for Alisha is if Christina had drawn a rock.Now Kim and her alliance can pick off Alisha and Christina depending on whoever does not get immunity.
post #875 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by HDTVChallenged View Post

Wrong. But apparently you missed my point.



Well, I'm sure that will be a great consolation to the family that gets wiped out when his heart explodes at 70mi/hr and he and his Harley become an uncontrolled missile on the 405 (Theoretically speaking.) But I'm glad that you and he are overcoming your personal challenges. The rest of us will just have to remain hypervigilent.

PS: Did you know that pilots have to pass an annual physical (and probably random drug/alcohol testing depending on commercial vs. private) to retain their licenses? Are we saying that flying is inherently more dangerous than driving on surface highways? Because the statistics don't support that assumption. Are you saying we should let 85yr old recovered stroke victims with afib continue to drive ... indeed, where do we the line. Just saying.

I didn't miss your point at all. Your point was clearly an over reaction to what mgk said. What I was trying to get you to understand is that everything is relative and that not everyone that has had some kind of medical issue is washed up and can no longer function like everyone else or become a "danger to society". That's just hilariously stupid.


Quote:
Originally Posted by edpowers View Post

Are you a former contestant in this game? How would you know if viewers are underestimating the stress? Unless you have played or are somehow closely involved with producing the show, you could just as easily be overestimating the stress. How are you so sure that producers don't look for candidates who will fail? After all, the losers are often times more interesting than the winners.

Quite simple Ed, it's from more than 10 years of reading and watching tons of interviews with ousted contestants who over and over state those very things. Comparing what the contestants themselves have said, to the perception I see stated by a large majority of viewers it's quite clear that most of the viewers don't fully understand what it's really like and fail to factor it in when assessing how players are playing.



Quote:
Originally Posted by djb5f View Post

Well, let's not kid ourselves - they've more or less casted this way from Season 1, with Greg and his quirks - speaking into the coconut phone at all times, and many other wanting to become stars like Colleen (acting), Gervis, etc.

Now, they may cast even more from CA, but this show has always attracted and casted people who aren't the most grounded.

Quote:
Originally Posted by djb5f View Post

No shot at winning? That's not accurate. She certainly had a shot, more so than a lot people this season. She formed a friendship/alliance early that was strong enough not to get her voted out from one early bad team challenge performance. In fact, one of the reasons she was taken out was because she was a threat to win it all with the jury guys' vote.

btw, WOW, to see her last night - stunning. -

Aaaahh, it's good to see that some people can still look at the show with a little objectivity . The fact is that things are never as black and white as a lot of people seem to like to make them out to be. It seems to be the MO of the internet age I guess. The show may not be as good as some of it's best years but it's nowhere near as bad as some like to paint it. And some of it may depend on exactly why a person watches too. If you're the kind of person who watches solely for supreme gameplay, you're probably not as happy as you could be. But if you watch for other reasons there's just as much reason as ever to tune in. Personally, I like it for various reasons but the biggest one is to watch how the individual contestants handle and react to the situation they are placed in. The sociological aspect of it.

It was quite fun watching Kim just outright own Alicia last night. The girl has got some skills. A fairly interesting interview of Tarzan from Rob Cesternino today where he does a pretty good job of explaining what his thinking was and how some of the stuff went down compared to how it looked on TV:

http://robhasawebsite.com/survivor-o...reg-smith.html


ron
post #876 of 1026
so what are your predictions for final 3?

i see kim and christina making it with great uncertainty over the 3rd member. christina is no threat and kim has an idol and will likely win one of the challenges left. i think chelsea is probably the least likely to make it. tough call between alicia and sabrina. if kim gets her way (which she mostly has), alicia will make it to the final three. i think chelsea's best and maybe only shot to make it is by winning the next two immunity challenges.
post #877 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mac The Knife View Post

So it seems Sabrina was wrong that Tarzan might get the men's vote if they took him to the finals, considering that Mike flipped the bird at Tarzan's exit speech.

Compare that to the warm reception he actually got when he reached Ponderosa and you might not say the same thing. It's also interesting that Tarzan actually was intending to piss the guys off at tribal and provide them reason not to want to give him votes, in an attempt to get the girls to keep him (as his talks about in the Rob C interview).

Quote:
Originally Posted by Foxy7 View Post

Last nights episode reminded my of why this is one of my least favorite seasons of Survivor.Though the producers tried to edit the episode to inject some drama. The women did the expected by voting out Tarzan. Even though neither Kim or Chelsea had immunity Alisha did not make a big move to get rid of either of them.If the vote had been tied she could have forced Kim to vote off Chelsea or go to rocks. Alisha would have been safe from the rocks since she had immunity. Assuming Chelsea and Tarzan were the two targets. Alisha, Tarzan and Chelsea would have been safe. With Kim, Sabrina and Christina having to go to rocks.If Alisha had forced a tie either Chelsea would have gone home on the second vote or Sabrina or Kim could have gone out with the rocks. The only downside for Alisha is if Christina had drawn a rock.Now Kim and her alliance can pick off Alisha and Christina depending on whoever does not get immunity.

The only reason Alicia decided to not insist on Chelsea was because Kim completely bamboozled her into wanting to vote Tarzan instead. The drama was in the game play of how that went down, not in the vote at the end.


ron
post #878 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by R11 View Post

Compare that to the warm reception he actually got when he reached Ponderosa and you might not say the same thing. It's also interesting that Tarzan actually was intending to piss the guys off at tribal and provide them reason not to want to give him votes, in an attempt to get the girls to keep him (as his talks about in the Rob C interview).

The only reason Alicia decided to not insist on Chelsea was because Kim completely bamboozled her into wanting to vote Tarzan instead. The drama was in the game play of how that went down, not in the vote at the end.


ron

yep. that was awesome. kim knows how to play the game.
post #879 of 1026
Yeah, the last few episodes, Kim has been absolutely masterful in how she has been manipulating everyone to vote more or less how she wants. She is just planting little seeds and letting the ideas germinate in the other players heads. Fantastic stuff.
post #880 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by grubadub View Post

so what are your predictions for final 3?

i see kim and christina making it with great uncertainty over the 3rd member. christina is no threat and kim has an idol and will likely win one of the challenges left. i think chelsea is probably the least likely to make it. tough call between alicia and sabrina. if kim gets her way (which she mostly has), alicia will make it to the final three. i think chelsea's best and maybe only shot to make it is by winning the next two immunity challenges.

Anyone but Alicia! That's not a prediction, just wishful thinking.
post #881 of 1026
Christina looking really sexy. I cant wait to see her on Sunday on the live/not live show.



post #882 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by R11 View Post

I didn't miss your point at all. Your point was clearly an over reaction to what mgk said. What I was trying to get you to understand is that everything is relative and that not everyone that has had some kind of medical issue is washed up and can no longer function like everyone else or become a "danger to society".

I didn't say he could "no longer function." All I ask is that after one has supposedly "recovered," that they should stop and consider if their "need for speed and freedom," is really worth the risks to those around them.

And more importantly that one probably shouldn't be "shocked" at the reaction when one states the equivalent of, 'I just drank a six-pack ... I'm fine to drive, really I am.'
post #883 of 1026
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by HDTVChallenged View Post

I didn't say he could "no longer function." All I ask is that after one has supposedly "recovered," that they should stop and consider if their "need for speed and freedom," is really worth the risks to those around them.

And more importantly that one probably shouldn't be "shocked" at the reaction when one states the equivalent of, 'I just drank a six-pack ... I'm fine to drive, really I am.'

Right .. and I am absolutely convinced that you'd restrict yourself given the same circumstances .. I maintain an every six months extensive medical examination and although I am 65, am considered by my cardiologist to be in better shape than most 40 year olds ..
post #884 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by R11 View Post

Compare that to the warm reception he actually got when he reached Ponderosa and you might not say the same thing. It's also interesting that Tarzan actually was intending to piss the guys off at tribal and provide them reason not to want to give him votes, in an attempt to get the girls to keep him (as his talks about in the Rob C interview).

The only reason Alicia decided to not insist on Chelsea was because Kim completely bamboozled her into wanting to vote Tarzan instead. The drama was in the game play of how that went down, not in the vote at the end.


ron

I do not think Kim got one over on Alicia. It is a hard choice on who you bring to the final. Tarzan is the easiest to target since he could be the only guy at the final with a jury full of angry dudes. We have the advantage/disadvantage of seeing the producers trying to paint Kim as the mastermind. She is not that good, but she is an intelligent player. Alicia has been fairly consistent. If she sees you as a threat at the final she removes you.
post #885 of 1026
Thread Starter 
Alicia is dilusional .. Kim has played her completely ..
post #886 of 1026
Isn't it obvious that this is Kim's to lose?
post #887 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

I make it a point to not be an armchair shrink .. it's reality TV after all ..

Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

Alicia is dilusional .. Kim has played her completely ..

post #888 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by biker19 View Post

Isn't it obvious that this is Kim's to lose?

I guess, at the reunion, Jeff will say "Thank you all for the most boring season". Where we all knew from episode 8 the winner and who would be voted out every time.
post #889 of 1026
Like clockwork at the reunion show, Jeff will state that this has been one of the best, most unique seasons ever.
post #890 of 1026
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by edpowers View Post


touché .. .. I should have said "living in a dream World" ..
post #891 of 1026
Just think, we get to see Colton again.
post #892 of 1026
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by WaTaGuMp View Post

Just think, we get to see Colton again.

Let me guess .. he will say something like "Oh, it was all just a big act .. I'm not really like that in real life .. I love all of you and treasure my time on Survivor more than life itself .. "
post #893 of 1026
And Tarzan will say "The game is no longer afoot."
post #894 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgkdragn View Post

Let me guess .. he will say something like "Oh, it was all just a big act .. I'm not really like that in real life .. I love all of you and treasure my time on Survivor more than life itself .. "

Most likely we will see something between Bill and him, I am expecting either fake apologies from Colton, or Bill just taking the high road.
post #895 of 1026
After Sunday's two-hour finale of Survivor: One World, with the "Reunion" special, I look forward to whether there is any addressing -- or whether there is deliberate glossing over -- the hateful and racist Colton.
post #896 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by 33idolfinder View Post

I guess, at the reunion, Jeff will say "Thank you all for the most boring season".

That was so-o-o-o one year and two Redemption Islands ago!
post #897 of 1026
I think Kim will win the 100k fan vote, at the very least.
post #898 of 1026
I have thrown away my toothbrush and toothpaste and I use only sticks from my back yard!

Now, when I smile at night my teeth can be seen from space!!
post #899 of 1026
Quote:
Originally Posted by WaTaGuMp View Post

Just think, we get to see Colton again.

And my prediction is for a non-jury member, he will get the most air time ever at one of these reunion shows. Then, as WaTaGuMp referenced and like with all shows that had a nasty confrontation, Jeff will ask Bill and Colton if they are friends now.


I gotta say, I think they need to start making this show tougher in regards to food. I swear, looking at Alicia when the show started and now, it looks like she's gained weight.

Speaking of, I am stumped at the Alicia-Christina relationship. In the beginning they hated each other. Then that mellowed out and they were cordial. Then the tribes switched and Alicia was back to attacking Christina (with Colton's nudging of course). Now, they are back to talking and are actually allies. Very strange love-hate relationship going on there.

Oh, and to concur with what others have said about Christina, I think she may actually have a better body than Chelsea, which I wouldn't have said early on in the show.
post #900 of 1026
The reunion shows are always disappointing. They tease about conflict or resolution, but only gives 30 seconds to the matter and gloss over stuff.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HDTV Programming
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › 'Survivor: One World' Season 24 on CBS HD