AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › Official Ceton Echo Extender Info Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Official Ceton Echo Extender Info Thread - Page 68

post #2011 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by mariob33 View Post

It does not show up. I asked in the beta forum and learned that its up to the plugin developer to decide if its available on a extender or not. And for things which it's just launching the web client it is not possible.
Now, having said that I do recall ceton having some statement around potential web access via the echo.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
mariob33

So does that mean arcsoft could possibly make TMT available for bluray playback?
post #2012 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by skybolt View Post

This is the type of spec we need from Ceton ... It would save alot of cyber paper and confusion.

Motz was very nice to point me to this link in over on TGB. Looks like I spoke too soon.

http://cetoncorp.com/blog/more-details-on-ceton-echo/

Thanks Ceton, Thanks Motz!
post #2013 of 7572
from that blog post, it doesn't seem like dts will ever be supported.
post #2014 of 7572
Yup, doesn't sound like it will ever be any more than a standard MCX. It was nice hope while it lasted. And I now concur with the initial thoughts that this should be more like $79 than $179.
post #2015 of 7572
That blog post refuses to load for me but that's probalby a function of the crappy slow network bogged down with McAfee here at work..
post #2016 of 7572
blog post:
Quote:
Let's Talk About the Ceton Echo
We’ve now kicked off the Ceton Echo Beta program and the first wave of beta units have been sent out to testers. Every day we’re getting closer to commercial launch in November!

It’s clear from all the comments in the various forums, news and social media sites online that excitement for the Echo is high, which is awesome. It’s also clear that people still have questions about the Echo and are confused about some things. This blog post will hopefully answer those questions and clear up the confusion.

Goals for the Beta
First of all, it’s important for people to understand that the beta program is for testing. It is not a preview program. It is not a special sale. It is not a way to get an Echo before it’s finished.

It is designed to help ensure that the Echo is a great product when it launches in November. The beta will put the Echo through its paces in real-world homes, with real-world users, working with a myriad of configurations and networks, in a variety of markets around the world.

By definition, a beta product is not a finished product. There will be bugs. There will be features that aren’t working well, or aren’t yet working at all. Companies do beta tests in order to find and fix those things. Anyone who is not comfortable working with beta quality software should not participate in the beta program and should instead wait until the Echo launches in November.

When it comes to Media Center, people have all kinds of non-standard apps, plugins and configurations they use. Many of these work just fine with Windows Media Center (WMC), even though they’re not supported by Microsoft and you’ll never see them listed as a feature of WMC on any WMC datasheet or brochure. The same is true with the Echo. Echo will support many things natively out of the box. Other things will work with the Echo but we can’t guarantee they’ll always work, or support you if they don’t work, since we have no control over them.

Echo Features
So let’s talk about what the Echo is and is not.

Echo is Windows Media Center Extender (MCX) first and foremost. It’s based on the MCX code we have licensed from Microsoft and the main thing it does is extend the WMC experience from your media center PC to secondary TV sets in the home. We’re adding some additional capabilities where we can like a browser, and will continue to add features and capabilities over time, but please don’t confuse the Echo for a streaming media receiver or an Xbox, as it is neither today.

The Echo beta is not feature complete right now. For example, while you can play higher bitrate video, the Echo will only display up to 720p at the moment. We expect to have full 1080p by launch. Some codecs are not yet there but will be by launch. Internet browsing isn’t there yet but is planned for launch. The feature set and technical specs that Echo will support when it’s launched in November are explained on the Echo pages on our website. If something you’re looking for is not there, please assume the Echo will not support it in November, at least not natively. As you’ll read in the rest of this post, some of those things might be possible with third-party tools however.

So, let’s get to some specifics …

MKV Support
As a Windows Media Center Extender, the Echo is limited to containers that Windows Media Center can handle. In fact, a Windows Media Center Extender doesn't deal with containers at all, which is why they have not been included in our specification list. Out of the box, Windows Media Center does not support the MKV container; however, there are several third-party solutions available that add support to WMC for the MKV container. We’ve provided a list of codecs that the Echo will support at launch on the Echo product page. If your Windows Media Center PC has been configured to handle the MKV container, and the codecs within the container are also supported by the Echo, it should be possible to play that content back on the Echo.

VIDEO_TS Folder Support
Much like MKV containers, WMC doesn’t natively support sending VIDEO_TS to the Echo. There are third-party solutions which will automatically transcode the VIDEO_TS on-the-fly for playback, which should work with the Echo.

DTS Support
Currently the Echo does not support DTS and is not expected to support it at launch. We hope to add DTS support in the future but we can’t say yet when that will be.

Internet Streaming Services
We plan to add a web browser to the Echo by launch, though it is not enabled the current beta build. The browser will support HTML5, which means you can use it with online media sites that use HTML5. We hoped to support Flash as well; however, once Adobe announced they were no longer supporting Flash on ARM-based systems, we obviously weren’t able to do so.

Netflix, Hulu, etc.
Most of the major streaming media sites are moving to HTML5. As those services become available in HTML5 you’ll be able to use them with an Echo. At launch we do not expect you’ll be able to use the Echo with Netflix, which a lot of people have asked about specifically.

Media Center Plugins
In the same way Microsoft can’t support third-party plugins like My Movies, Media Browser and such, we can’t support them in Echo either. That doesn’t mean they won’t work with the Echo, just like it doesn’t mean they won’t work with WMC. One of the things we’ll learn from the beta program is which plugins and apps work well and which do not.

WiFi Support
Echo is designed for wired networks, as we’ve said all along. The reason is that WiFi simply doesn’t have the bandwidth and Quality of Service to consistently deliver reliable HDTV signals today. WiFi is even more problematic when you’re sending multiple streams of HDTV around the home, as will be the case in many Echo user homes. If your home isn’t wired today, you do have options, as you’ll see below.

MoCa & PowerLine
For those unfamiliar with MoCa (Multimedia over Coax), it is a technology that lets you turn your in-house coax network into a high-speed wired Ethernet network and is a great option for people whose homes aren’t wired with Ethernet today. PowerLine (aka HomePlug) is a similar concept except it uses your existing electrical wiring at home instead of coax.

The Echo was never planned to have built-in MoCa. It does however support third-party MoCa adapters like those from Actiontec and Netgear just fine. It also works with PowerLine adapters, however we recommend MoCa over PowerLine since MoCa has higher bandwidth speeds and better QoS.

We do plan to introduce our own MoCa adapters in the future as options for the Echo and other products. They will not be available at launch however.

Wireless Keyboards and Mice
We’re in the midst of testing this as part of the beta. Early indications are that the Echo will work with standard USB wireless keyboards and mice.

Universal Remotes/Harmony Remotes
We’re in the midst of testing these too in the beta and early indications are that the Echo will work with them as well.

Component/Composite Output
The prototype Echo we showed at CES did have Composite output in addition to HDMI. The final Echo design has HDMI only. For people who want to connect Echo to a TV that doesn’t have HDMI input, the Echo will work with an HDMI to Component or Composite converter.

http://cetoncorp.com/blog/more-details-on-ceton-echo/
post #2017 of 7572
Nice, I just paid for my Beta! Very happy. I can't wait to start testing!
post #2018 of 7572
Thread Starter 
I wonder if any thought was made to creating a mode on it that would operate outside of WMC. The HP x280n worked like that - it had a dashboard type menu, and WMC was only one item you could use.

If Netflix, Hulu, Vudu, Pandora, advanced video playback, etc could not be housed inside WMC perhaps they could have been located there. My optimism for this has become very tempered.
post #2019 of 7572
I have decided not to participate in the beta after reading that blog post. this is a far cry from what I thought the system would do. I will stick with my SageTV setup until it dies.
post #2020 of 7572
Quote:
I wonder if any thought was made to creating a mode on it that would operate outside of WMC. The HP x280n worked like that - it had a dashboard type menu, and WMC was only one item you could use.

If Netflix, Hulu, Vudu, Pandora, advanced video playback, etc could not be housed inside WMC perhaps they could have been located there. My optimism for this has become very tempered.

I was thinking the same thing. Most of my TV's either have Netflix built in, or have a device connected to them that can access Netflix. I do have one TV where it would be nice to have Netflix as an option, but it would be even more interesting if they could give the option to load and run XBMC. This would solve most of the codec issues...
post #2021 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by stanger89 View Post

Yup, doesn't sound like it will ever be any more than a standard MCX. It was nice hope while it lasted. And I now concur with the initial thoughts that this should be more like $79 than $179.
This is indeed the crux of the problem - at a sub $100 price it's a good device for the money. For the price and feature set it has, not so much. For a small company like Ceton, it's clear that there's no way they can do an extender that cheap though. Even the bigger ones like HP, D-Link and Linksys weren't that cheap, although 4 years ago is an eternity tech-wise.

The only advantage they have is that they are the only extender on the market if you don't want/need an Xbox.
post #2022 of 7572
I have a Synology Diskstation and it has Plex built in. I am going to try it with a Roku to see how well it works. If things work well then I may just get a whole home dvr setup from Charter or DirecTV.
post #2023 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by nebulink View Post

I have a Synology Diskstation and it has Plex built in. I am going to try it with a Roku to see how well it works. If things work well then I may just get a whole home dvr setup from Charter or DirecTV.

Charter doesn't have a whole home DVR. It is separate DVR/STB's at each TV. For that it is $20/month for up to four DVR's and another $5/month per STB. If you have four it is $40/month. Bump that to five and now it is $65/month.
post #2024 of 7572
It is $159 so at $25/month, I'll make that back in less than 7 months then it's gravey. But the next box is only $5/month so that will take much longer.. 80 months or almost 7 years.

It is streaming mkv though and I'm thinking the browser is a good thing that the Charter STB's don't have.. Nor are they a whole home solution.
post #2025 of 7572
So, what they're saying is as of right now it does absolutely nothing that can't already be done with a 360? That's what it sounds like to me at least.

Pretty disappointing.
post #2026 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by jhoff80 View Post

So, what they're saying is as of right now it does absolutely nothing that can't already be done with a 360? That's what it sounds like to me at least.
Pretty disappointing.

I would argue it actually does quite a bit less. No Netflix, no Xfinity, no analog output option, no games, etc, etc, etc. It does use a lot less energy though! smile.gif

In most of those categories I'm not really concerned. I do need another extender for a new TV I setup in one of my rooms, so I'll take a shot and spend the $159 for the beta unit and see if the product grows into something better. I just won't buy 3 more to replace my 2 DMA2100's and 1 Xbox that is only used as an extender unless it ends up offering more features. I'll just put the DMA2100's on the TV's I use the least.
post #2027 of 7572
I guess the logical option would be to pair one of these with a ROKU/Boxee etc type device, because on its own it does not offer the solution many of us were hoping for.
post #2028 of 7572
a roku will just buy you netflix, vudu and amazon. you will still need something to play back dvd and bd rips. frown.gif
post #2029 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by jeonunh View Post

I would argue it actually does quite a bit less. No Netflix, no Xfinity, no analog output option, no games, etc, etc, etc. It does use a lot less energy though! smile.gif
In most of those categories I'm not really concerned. I do need another extender for a new TV I setup in one of my rooms, so I'll take a shot and spend the $159 for the beta unit and see if the product grows into something better. I just won't buy 3 more to replace my 2 DMA2100's and 1 Xbox that is only used as an extender unless it ends up offering more features. I'll just put the DMA2100's on the TV's I use the least.

Does the DMA2100 support H.264 .MP4/.M4V? What about the Echo?

My whole library is encoded with H.264 so it works with the Apple TV3, iPad 3, iPhone 5 and Macs w/ iTunes. If so, the appeal of the Echo is declining. I'll take the beta and probably get a DMA2100 off eBay (if not only because I can only buy one Echo and hate the noise, heat, and limited IR for the Xbox 360).
post #2030 of 7572
I'm still interested to see if they share what Freescale SOC they are using to power the Echo so we can research what the chip is theoretically capable of. Since the hardware is final at this point they should post it under the technical specifications on the website.

Obviously the software features will change, so I understand not posting what they hope to be able to offer, but the hardware is a done deal. If the SOC is not capable of, for example, playing 3D bluray then the people hoping the feature may be added someday can move on.
post #2031 of 7572
The GUI on DMA2100 was too slow that you have to turn off most eye candies in order to get decent performance. IIRC, it does support H.264 but it is quite quirky. Echo should match Xbox 360's performance according to Ceton.
post #2032 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortcut3d View Post

Does the DMA2100 support H.264 .MP4/.M4V? What about the Echo?
My whole library is encoded with H.264 so it works with the Apple TV3, iPad 3, iPhone 5 and Macs w/ iTunes. If so, the appeal of the Echo is declining. I'll take the beta and probably get a DMA2100 off eBay (if not only because I can only buy one Echo and hate the noise, heat, and limited IR for the Xbox 360).

I never try playing movies on my DMA2100's anymore, so I couldn't say what they are capable of. I tried a few times way back when I got them several years ago and had such mixed results that I just don't consider it a viable feature. Some movies played, but the quality was downgraded so much that they were unwatchable. Some looked ok, but would restart from the beginning if you paused them. Most wouldn't allow FF or skip. Just not worth the hassle.
post #2033 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by Derek K. View Post

a roku will just buy you netflix, vudu and amazon. you will still need something to play back dvd and bd rips. frown.gif

Well it does have Plex in there store.

http://plexapp.com/roku/
post #2034 of 7572
yeah, but iirc plex has to transcode everything to play on the roku. I'm not a fan of transcoding.
post #2035 of 7572
Extenders Transcode..
post #2036 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sammy2 View Post

Extenders Transcode..

No, they don't. They decode and play back. Transcode means decode and covert into another video format and streaming out.
post #2037 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by tkole View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by mariob33 View Post

It does not show up. I asked in the beta forum and learned that its up to the plugin developer to decide if its available on a extender or not. And for things which it's just launching the web client it is not possible.
Now, having said that I do recall ceton having some statement around potential web access via the echo.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
mariob33

So does that mean arcsoft could possibly make TMT available for bluray playback?

That's is my understanding and hope. I use TMT5 for my iOS rips and it works fantastic on the HTPC


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
mariob33
post #2038 of 7572
That's what I meant to mean..

The PC transcodes and the extender playsback..

For a second or third TV in a non-HT environment this isn't so bad but if you're wanting to use it in a HT environment then isn't so good.
Edited by Sammy2 - 10/17/12 at 2:22pm
post #2039 of 7572
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sammy2 View Post

The PC transcodes and the extender playsback..

It's my impression that the WMC host PC doesn't transcode either- it just removes the raw streams from the container and sends to the extender.
post #2040 of 7572
I'm not satisfied with transcoding results on any of my TVs. So, I'd avoid transcoding at all cost.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Home Theater Computers
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › Official Ceton Echo Extender Info Thread