or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › Smash on NBC HDTV
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Smash on NBC HDTV - Page 7

post #181 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charles R View Post

Quote:
It's good to finally have a decent drama from NBC... after so many recent failures.

Calling it decent might be a little optimistic.

I was thinking of "The Cape Awake Event"
post #182 of 397
Thread Starter 
I'm willing to go with the flow on this show and enjoy the ride, but tonight it really rock ed the boat and not in a good way. The Ivy/Dev -DevI ?- thing was way too out of character and way too soapy for even me to buy.

i did enjoy the music, "September Song" was a nice touch -especially since it was her grandfather that introduced the song in a 1938 play "Knickerbocker Holiday". His version is on You tube and the lyrics are a bit different than I've ever heard.
post #183 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt L View Post

i did enjoy the music, "September Song" was a nice touch -especially since it was her grandfather that introduced the song in a 1938 play "Knickerbocker Holiday". His version is on You tube and the lyrics are a bit different than I've ever heard.

I loved what Huston did with this wondeful, iconic song. Her "stage voice" delivery was just right. Nice touch having Marc Shaiman playing the piano and his life partner and lyricist Scott Wittman in the crowd. It was also great to see Mark Kudish in the two Darryl F. Zanuck numbers. The new one "Smash" was a real showcase for the ensemble women. I'm still laughing over Derek's "explanation" to Ivy about how he was shtupping Rebecca to get the best performance out of her..HAH!

In regard to Rebecca's peanut spiked smoothie, I have two theories. Either her personal assistant (who is delendent on Rebecca for her income) did it to get Rebecca out of the show after the disasterous finale (nothing says Broadway musical like a drug OD suicide ending ) or Rebecca did it herself to get out of the show. Notice how she didn't actually drink the deadly mix until Karen was with her (or anyone else instead) to act as the emergency safety valve. My bet is on the latter. Rebecca clearly was very shaken by what happened and might have wanted to bail out in a way that would avoid a nasty legal fight.
post #184 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cal1981 View Post

In regard to Rebecca's peanut spiked smoothie, I have two theories. Either her personal assistant (...) or Rebecca did it (...)

Not Ivy? Not evil Ellis?
post #185 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amnesia View Post

Not Ivy? Not evil Ellis?

Ivy's ambitious but not to the point of a possible homicide. Ellis is a despicable weasel but again, risking a serious criminal charge? I can't see it. Besides, whatever "allegiance" Ellis has to Ivy is probably as strong as a grain of sand in the wind. Long term loyalties are not exactly his strong suit. I still think that Rebecca did herself in when she knew that someone was there who could get immediate medical help.
post #186 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cal1981 View Post

Besides, whatever "allegiance" Ellis has to Ivy is probably as strong as a grain of sand in the wind. Long term loyalties are not exactly his strong suit.

Except loyalty to himself.

Perhaps he wanted to get Rebecca sick (not dead, but sick) so that she'd quit the show. After all, she's pretty bad and he's the one who brought her to the project...
post #187 of 397
I have now watched the latest episode and loved it, despite how preposterous it often was. My positive reaction may well have been partly caused by Smash withdrawal. NBC's OKC affiliate preempted last week's show because the weather guys were covering a bunch of storms around the state. Disappointing but still pretty hard to complain about.

I thought the singing and dancing this week were uniformly wonderful. Mark Kudisch was funny and effective in the Zanuck numbers and Angelica Huston's rendition of September Song was lovely. I also liked the music in the church. As usual, Karen was terrific but the dancing-boy who is Tom's current squeeze really knocked it out of the park. The guy can REALLY sing!

The bottom line is, I am still enjoying the show and look forward to it each week.
post #188 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cal1981 View Post

I still think that Rebecca did herself in when she knew that someone was there who could get immediate medical help.

I think you've nailed it there... could be wrong though, but that seems most plausible.

Quote:
Originally Posted by gwsat View Post

... affiliate preempted last week's show because the weather guys were covering a bunch of storms around the state.

Happens here in the mid-west fairly often.
post #189 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by gwsat View Post

II thought the singing and dancing this week were uniformly wonderful. Mark Kudisch was funny and effective in the Zanuck numbers and Angelica Huston's rendition of September Song was lovely. I also liked the music in the church. As usual, Karen was terrific but the dancing-boy who is Tom's current squeeze really knocked it out of the park. The guy can REALLY sing!

The bottom line is, I am still enjoying the show and look forward to it each week.

My feeling is that, in many of the snarkier quarters of the blogosphere, McPhee has unfairly gotten a very bad rap. Is she a great actress? Not yet but as they throw more of the dramatic plot twists her way, she has grown in the acting department. Is she as good a pure singer as Megan Hilty? Probably not. Hilty has a powerful and very clean voice while McPhee's is bit more mannered but they have both been excellent in their showcase numbers as was on display last night in the Smash number. Huston singing the song that her grandfather had introduced in Hollywood's Golden Age was a very generous and touching moment. As far as Michael goes, don't you wonder why Frank or Julia has not told him that if he doesn't cease and desist, his wife can expect a very revealing phone call? Even if they don't have the heart to actually do that kind of damage, it would put Michael squarely on notice that his family could be shattered with a brief conversation. Would Michael be willing to gamble on that? I doubt it.
post #190 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cal1981 View Post

Ivy's ambitious but not to the point of a possible homicide. Ellis is a despicable weasel but again, risking a serious criminal charge? I can't see it. Besides, whatever "allegiance" Ellis has to Ivy is probably as strong as a grain of sand in the wind. Long term loyalties are not exactly his strong suit. I still think that Rebecca did herself in when she knew that someone was there who could get immediate medical help.

Didn't the preview of next week's show hint at Ellis getting fired?
post #191 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 View Post

Didn't the preview of next week's show hint at Ellis getting fired?

Yeah, it sort of implied that the young ferret was really working for someone else. The betting in my house is that it's Jerry, Eileen's husband.
post #192 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amnesia View Post

Perhaps he wanted to get Rebecca sick (not dead, but sick) so that she'd quit the show...

"Somebody has to produce this show."
post #193 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cal1981 View Post

My feeling is that, in many of the snarkier quarters of the blogosphere, McPhee has unfairly gotten a very bad rap. Is she a great actress? Not yet but as they throw more of the dramatic plot twists her way, she has grown in the acting department. Is she as good a pure singer as Megan Hilty? Probably not.

Funny, I much prefer McPhee to Hilty as far as singing goes.
post #194 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by psgcdn View Post

Funny, I much prefer McPhee to Hilty as far as singing goes.

I agree that McPhee's voice is both bigger and more beautiful than Hilty's but Hilty is a more polished performer, it seems to me.
post #195 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by gwsat View Post

I agree that McPhee's voice is both bigger and more beautiful than Hilty's but Hilty is a more polished performer, it seems to me.

Both have chops...Hilty's is obviously Broadway trained and somewhat beefier, but McPhee's is more popcentric and being featured (and processed) for the show. In a real sing off, I give the edge to Hilti. In the show, they are making McPhee's voice sound bigger and richer than maybe it is. I do like her numbers better...probably because they are more popish (and I'm not a fan of pop).
post #196 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by gwsat View Post

I agree that McPhee's voice is both bigger and more beautiful than Hilty's but Hilty is a more polished performer, it seems to me.

I think there is no question that they both have beautiful voices, but I am curious as to what you mean by 'bigger' - as in more powerful?, or bigger range? Either way, we are clearly hearing something different - on my system, Hilty has a much more powerful voice than McPhee (although as I said, they both have great voices).
post #197 of 397
Their voices definitely have a different timbre. IMO Hilty is a bit sharper and piercing or "edgy"
while McPhee's is softer (which does not mean quieter) and smoother.
post #198 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by rsambuca View Post

I think there is no question that they both have beautiful voices, but I am curious as to what you mean by 'bigger' - as in more powerful?, or bigger range? Either way, we are clearly hearing something different - on my system, Hilty has a much more powerful voice than McPhee (although as I said, they both have great voices).

Yes, Hilty's voice is similar to Michelle Lea on 'Glee'. Theater performers have a different training regimen than pop singers. McPhee's voice is clearly benefiting from the fact that they overdub & electronically process the songs on this show. That's not to say she doesn't have a lovely singing voice (or that she looked incredibly hot in that Bollywood outfit. Wow!).

Glad to see the renewal. It's rare that a show I like gets more than one season.
post #199 of 397
I wonder if McPhee is like Pavarotti in later years in that she can only maintain pitch when she is singing loudly. I could hear autotune in one of her song's beginnings.
post #200 of 397
I'm also glad this got renewed. As Glee has plummeted into virtual chaos and (for me) near unwatchability, I continue to enjoy Smash immensely. As for the voices, it is clear that Hilty has the true Broadway resume and voice so true to the part. McPhee has a very good voice, but a pop style. It still works for me as it's being carefully used, especially in the off-Broadway numbers she gets (the church, the Bar Mitzvah, the Times Square scene, etc). It works less in direct comparison to Hilty on stage, but that should be expected given their backgrounds and strengths.
post #201 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shaded Dogfood View Post

I wonder if McPhee is like Pavarotti in later years in that she can only maintain pitch when she is singing loudly. I could hear autotune in one of her song's beginnings.

If you've seen McPhee in some of the guest artist appearances she's done (with David Foster and Chris Botti among others) you would be dissuaded from that feeling. Look up her duet with Andrea Bocelli on "The Prayer" on Youtube. She does not need any processing or autotuning but they are done routinely on Tv shows. Lea and Amber get tuned on Glee at times and neither girl needs it.
post #202 of 397
NBC has put out a number of teaser video clips for the season finale on Monday night including interviews with the primary cast members. Looks likes it's gonna be fun. They are all on YouTube.
post #203 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by flint350 View Post

I'm also glad this got renewed. As Glee has plummeted into virtual chaos and (for me) near unwatchability, I continue to enjoy Smash immensely. As for the voices, it is clear that Hilty has the true Broadway resume and voice so true to the part. McPhee has a very good voice, but a pop style. It still works for me as it's being carefully used, especially in the off-Broadway numbers she gets (the church, the Bar Mitzvah, the Times Square scene, etc). It works less in direct comparison to Hilty on stage, but that should be expected given their backgrounds and strengths.

True that. it's interesting that Hilty is playing a character whose career track in the exact opposite of her own (Ivy in the ensemble for 10 years and Hilty taking over for Chenoweth as Glinda one year out of school and in Wicked's ensemble). She is a brilliant talent and hopefully, her career will now expand well beyond the Broadway stage.
post #204 of 397
She does not need any processing or autotuning but they are done routinely on Tv shows. Lea and Amber get tuned on Glee at times and neither girl needs it.

Then I wish they would stop it.

As for Glee, it's gone so far off the rails there is little to be done for it. I'm not sure I have what it takes to watch the two-part season finale, and after this year I'm done with it.
post #205 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shaded Dogfood View Post

As for Glee, it's gone so far off the rails there is little to be done for it. I'm not sure I have what it takes to watch the two-part season finale, and after this year I'm done with it.

Seems to me like 'Glee' has climbed back onto the rails. This last part of the season has been more focused on music than moralizing, which is what most of us wanted. It's fun again, at least to me and my wife. YMMV.
post #206 of 397
Thread Starter 
Interesting wrap on the season. A few too many cliche's for my taste, the biggest one being the shot of Ivy at the end with the pills. But the show must go on was the theme and it did, with a show stopper ending.

I had no idea how they were going to pull it off after the disaster of the original close, but this was very well done. Looking forward to see how it progresses next spring.
post #207 of 397
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt L View Post

Interesting wrap on the season. A few too many cliche's for my taste, the biggest one being the shot of Ivy at the end with the pills. But the show must go on was the theme and it did, with a show stopper ending.

I had no idea how they were going to pull it off after the disaster of the original close, but this was very well done. Looking forward to see how it progresses next spring.

We enjoyed the show (although my daughter, a devout "Team Ivy" member hated it). Sure a lot of things happened that never would in the real world (i.e. director blowing off his producer/sole money angel) but it is a fantasy after all. Jack Davenport continues to shine as Derek and McPhee was very good during the show montage playing the lead. The last song was a nice capper as well. You gotta give it to Megan Hilty. She's playing a entirely thankless role but has done it wonderfully. Even with Ivy being a hyper-ambitious, do anything to get the part b*%ch Hilty is so talented that more people still probably want to see her character get the lead. I'm not sure where the series will go next season. A lot of things can go terribly wrong between an out of town run and a Broadway opening but the show runners are going to have be careful not to have something blow up every 10 minutes or the series could deteriorate very quickly into nothing but melodramatic nonsense.
post #208 of 397
I thought the last episode was particularly well-done and McPhee's performance was the best I've seen this season. I'm definately looking forward to it continuing next year. I think this is a good show.
post #209 of 397
Well the obvious solution is the before and after Marilyn story with McPhee as the before innocent Marilyn and Hilty as the after drugged blonde Marilyn. I just kept waiting for that to happen in the finale.
post #210 of 397
Okay, why didn't Eileen call the cops on Ellis after he admitted to "poisoning" Rebecca with the peanuts in her smoothie? I know things can get cutthroat, but attempted murder of the star is not allowable.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HDTV Programming
AVS › AVS Forum › HDTV › HDTV Programming › Smash on NBC HDTV